Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why we can't train more doctors?

136 replies

Turmerictolly · 08/06/2022 08:55

The NHS is desperately short of GP's and other doctors and the system is at breaking point. I look on the regular threads on here about not being able to physically see a GP any longer and my own experience of having cancelled hospital appts which are leading to worsening health. I then look at the Medicine threads where there seem to be so many bright and promising young people willing to train but not enough spaces on the courses.

It seems like some sort of dystopian catch 22. How on earth is this going to be fixed?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 23/11/2022 13:28

So, we need to train more pharmacists too!

Universities train more than enough pharmacists. Again, there's a bottleneck post graduation (the pre-registration year), and many pharmacists fairly quickly realise it's a crap job for those who don't rise to senior & management positions and they therefore leave to do something else.

Badbadbunny · 23/11/2022 10:15

BornBlonde · 12/06/2022 07:45

An I ask for opinions on the idea of pharmacists providing fit notes to free up appointments. My local pharmacy has long opening hours and is incredibly busy at all times of day. I cannot see how they could accommodate that?

However the idea of midwives/physios/surgeons being able to provide notes for patients already under their care seems sensible

Our village pharmacy struggles to get a pharmacist at all, they've not had a "permanent" one for a couple of years now, and rely on locums every day. Probably 1 or 2 days per week on average, they can't get a locum, so it has to stay closed. It's not just GPs that we're short of now, there is apparently a shortage of pharmacists too!

Apparently, they can't issue prescriptions without a pharmacist present, even if a pharmacist has already prepared/signed off the prescription, so there's no point in them opening! The other staff continue to "pick" and label the drugs for prescriptions in the absence of a pharmacist, making huge stacks of "baskets" for a pharmacist to sign off when they get one!

Because of this, our pharmacy stopped doing things like flu and covid jabs as when they get a locum for the day, they're busy catching up with issuing the prescriptions backlog from previous days without a pharmacist, so don't have time for jabs etc.

So, we need to train more pharmacists too!

Featheryboa · 22/11/2022 20:37

I don't mind GPs working part time if it means they avoid burn out, or breakdown.

That said, my current gp is pt and is on long term sick leave.
I've also contacted a consultant for a private consultation and they are also on medical leave until the new year.

Its a stressful job and its bound to take its toll.

Middmary · 12/06/2022 09:59

100% agree! Nothing bothers me more than when people say GPs are hiding away. I just did a GP rotation and it was 1000x worse than the hospital. You work 8-6:30, with way less days off. You work mon-fri plus out of hours clinics. You see way more patients and make way more decisions in shorter amount of time. You get a lot of abuse for things not in your control. How is it my fault 200 patients rang today for 20 appointments. And that they arent more GPs. literally people booked appointments just to tell me off that gps aren’t working. Wht a waste of an appointment!

people saying we do nothing because if we are worried we send patients to hospital. Well thats the whole point. Its emergency care for urgent testing! We dont have those facilities in GP as its not the purpose of a GP. If we did, we would basically be an a&e and we woulsnt be able to see anywhere near as many ptients and wait times would suffer further. Gp is for minor non life threatening illnesses, not requiring hospital admission, that can be treated from home. As well as management of chronic conditions. Not emergencies

We all work from within the practise itself. No one works from home unless a very good reason for it.

GPs are responsible for running their own practise and have a given budget. Then you have to pay whatever the expected wage is for a partner/nurse/doctor/manager/receptionist/admin etc. and ensure they have enough for supplies and bills and council tax. They also have to make sure they meet minimums and see certain patients yearly as needed. For example patients with copd or diabetes etc. 10% of patients take up 90% of a GPs time. All this extra work is done during your own time. You have to make sure staff meet training requirements unlike in hospital where you can focus on the medicine mostly and someone else takes care of all the extra running. Almost everyday my supervisor was doing all this extra work at home after surgery was over.

BornBlonde · 12/06/2022 07:45

An I ask for opinions on the idea of pharmacists providing fit notes to free up appointments. My local pharmacy has long opening hours and is incredibly busy at all times of day. I cannot see how they could accommodate that?

However the idea of midwives/physios/surgeons being able to provide notes for patients already under their care seems sensible

Discodreams · 11/06/2022 18:26

I’ve not read the full thread, but one thing I’ve noted - when I moved into my town in 2001 it had a population of 103,000. In 2022 it now us a population of 130,000 (as of 2018). In the last 20 years, there have been numerous housing developments expanding the town in every direction, thousands upon thousands of new homes. Yet not one of these new developments has a GP surgery on it. Not one. There are the same number of GP surgeries having to serve an extra 30,000+ people. No wonder they are struggling to see everyone, the infrastructure just isn’t there.
Shockingly, we have more nail bars then GPs 🤷‍♀️

Lordofmyflies · 11/06/2022 16:43

Retention is the main problem. Medical schools are recruiting smart, empathic, top grade students, med students are spending £45,000, just to train for 5 years, then work very long hours, in an unpleasant situation, with inadequate supplies and structure. Funnily enough, a huge number of docs at the age of 30-40 get disillusioned. Most tradesmen are on a better hourly rate than mid band doctors!

InTheShadeOfTheOakTree · 11/06/2022 16:34

That's a really interesting woody. Going further back, I think a lot of the dissatisfaction began with the introduction of the EWTD (under the old contract). It fundamentally changed patient care. Shift work became the norm and firm structures were destroyed at a stroke.

Doctors, especially the most junior, never saw the team they were part of, didn't see patients through their care pathway and couldn't get feedback from consultants they hardly saw because of the working patterns. Annual leave began to be allocated in advance to avoid falling foul of the regulations, which is dissatisfying and demotivating.

chaoscanbehappy · 11/06/2022 16:17

I'm a hospital consultant. The problem is not that simple. It is more about retaining doctors who are already here than more into med school..All doctors come out of medical school & do a 2 year period of 'foundation training'. This is usually a combination of hospital & community posts and these posts are generally plentiful & full of doctors. It's persuading these doctors to stay in the NHS/UK that is the problem. Do you remember the strike & the new contract? As predicted it's had very significant adverse effects on staffing & working hours. Junior doctors now have random days off in the week to cover weekends (this was the Hunt agenda: '7 day NHS with no more staff to cover 7 days') thus much more antisocial hours & much less continuity of care, this reduces them to 'doing jobs' on the ward rather than building relationships with & following the recovery of patients 'like in the old days'. Most of them spend these years unable to attend weekend events with friends and families & being posted randomly to hospitals in wide geographical areas making things like relationships & sending kids to school or childcare very challenging. Rotas are changed at the last minute, locum pay for filling in these at the last minute is inadequate & generally conditions make working life pretty challenging..They earn around 30k, I don't know enough about other postgrad jobs with simillar hours to know how this compares. When they finish these 2 years , continuing in the NHS to train as a GP does not look very appealing, particularly when you consider the difficulty in looking after patients without secondary care input due to covid related delays & the incredible amount of abuse they face from the general public, generated partly due to their understandable frustration with a broken system too & partly due to the media spin on what is actually happening in surgeries.
There are many other problems eg Brexit meaning less well trained European doctors who come in at a senior level, these docs used to fill gaps at the senior level but no longer feel welcome & years & years of government cuts making provision of care more & more challenging. I feel very reluctant indeed to allow my children to go into a career in medicine in these circumstances even though I love being a hospital consultant & feel very privileged to be here. Bottom line is that we need to vote for a more socialist government who cares about provision of high quality health care for all regardless of their means. Then we need to focus on addressing the problems that make medical training so challenging so that more doctors stay.

woody87 · 10/06/2022 22:31

Topgub · 10/06/2022 09:18

Its not just doctors

The whole if the nhs is in crisis.

And yet going by a recent thread on nurses lots of people seem to think its an over paid easy job.

Weird how we cant recruit or retain staff then isn't it?

Have you got the link to this thread?

Motorina · 10/06/2022 22:25

AndSoFinally · 08/06/2022 12:40

A friend who's a doctor is part of a group looking at this. The issues are cost (he reckons it costs about £250,000 to train a doctor in the UK, mostly funded by the government) and a lack of training places - you need people, hospitals etc. to train that many doctors.

I hear this figure a lot, but have no idea where it comes from. I am a doctor and I teach at the medical school. I lead one weeks teaching a year and help out for the odd lecture on other peoples weeks, as they help out on mine. For this, I get £10k a year. There are around 80 students on my course. £250k to train a doctor would be £50k a year, so £4 million per year for the 80 on my course. The teaching at £10k a week would be roughly £400k a year. The students are paying £720k per year in tuition fees between them. Obviously there are staff expenses other than teaching, as well as exam entry/costs, and other costs, but I doubt these amount to £4.3 million pounds a year. The clinical placements are all provided by hospital consultants, and we don't get paid any money for providing these. We also don't miss any clinical time as the students basically tag along to whatever we're doing and learn as they go.

I genuinely cannot see how training 80 students costs £4.72 million pounds a year?! If anyone knows I'd be very interested

There's a breakdown at assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/600835/Medical_expansion_rev_A.pdf#page=22

But, yes, it's a misleading figure.

MedSchoolRat · 10/06/2022 22:18

Each medical school has a limited capacity for places and can't expand easily

Mmmm... I'm not sure that's true. The impression I get (Med School where I work), we could physically find a way to double the current intake. If we were paid to do it. Lecturers need to be paid. There's equipment costs, too. Pay us & we could figure out a way to squeeze 'em in.

selecting Med students differently these days. ... I would argue that a black belt in Karate and a job working behind a bar in a rough part of town are far more useful attributes than Grade 8 piano, but we still insist on choosing students with the latter

I don't, or didn't, anyway. I'm not aware of any point in our recruitment process where those exC things would carry much weight. The karate is good for conflict resolution skills & the bar work is obvious customer service, fair enough if those things came up in interview. I wouldn't know what relevance is musical talent. Maybe there are clinics with piano playing to soothe patients so those hospital trusts recruit accordingly.

passport123 · 10/06/2022 21:53

QuebecBagnet · 10/06/2022 18:58

I have definitely seen doctor colleagues be refused leave for their own wedding. Normally for something so important another doctor will cover for them, for the actual wedding, not for a honeymoon!

and forget being able to go to relatives weddings, funerals, festivals, etc unless you happen to be off on that date.

Can't remember if I've said this in this thread but I was refused leave for my own wedding.

QuebecBagnet · 10/06/2022 18:58

I have definitely seen doctor colleagues be refused leave for their own wedding. Normally for something so important another doctor will cover for them, for the actual wedding, not for a honeymoon!

and forget being able to go to relatives weddings, funerals, festivals, etc unless you happen to be off on that date.

Badbadbunny · 10/06/2022 18:54

Tagliatellme · 10/06/2022 14:28

But they didn't.

Any restriction on numbers cannot be put at the door of the BMA.

So what was the point in the BMA balloting their members if they (and their members) have no control in the number of training places/medical schools???

mbosnz · 10/06/2022 18:13

My daughter has a conditional offer for medicine. I'm shitting twinkies reading this.

crosstalk · 10/06/2022 18:01

I wonder whether this will make it to the Daily Mail with all the considered responses. Or whether they will just pick up on wedding and MIL problems again.

junebirthdaygirl · 10/06/2022 17:58

In lreland we train lots of doctors. Very high points to get in so very bright students. There are no fees for college here so all free. Then they head off to Australia. Recently my ds's friend went and 80 doctors were on the same flight out. Its heartbreaking to see them go as we are relying on other countries and we are not even sure what their training is like. Some come back but most don't. I find it very worrying going forward

Psychonabike · 10/06/2022 17:30

I've been a hospital consultant for nearly 15 years. UK medical school, all UK training. I wouldn't want my kids to go into medicine.

The problems as I see it are:

It's a long university course with no special financial support. Yet, it's an intense university course with no real down time and it's difficult to have a part-time job on the side. Graduates are often burnt out before they've even begun. Supporting struggling doctors in Year 1 is common...

It's a highly competitive course that takes the top 5% of academic achievers from school but the salary doesn't compete with other professions taken up by that group. This has been the case for a long time, but there used to be more in the way of non-monetary rewards. Now we have a devalued job that feels less of a profession, and the hourly rate looks bad...

After 5/6 years of medical school, Doctors in training still have a ~10-15 year route to becoming a consultant, longer if they take any maternity leave or work part-time. Those years are really tough, and work out at ridiculously low hourly rates of pay. The system for training doctors, residency, was designed by someone who barely slept and abused cocaine. Google Halsted Cocaine Residency, if you are interested. Yet this remains usual practice in western medicine. A lot is dictated to these "juniors" for those years (actually adults usually 25-35 years old); where they work, where they live, they get rotas with leave that is fixed and dictated, they will be under constant pressure to cover ever present rota gaps, and be expected to undertake the post graduate study required for their chosen specialty while working a variety of antisocial shift patterns. Throughout my time training, seeing people in tears over rota issues was common, people who just wanted to attend a grandparents funeral, their own wedding, see a loved one who was dying, have a honeymoon, take paternity leave when their wife when into labour etc...throughout the NHS there is a computer says no attitude to these normal life events accompanied by the outdated and erroneous idea that the rewards of being a doctor outweigh these losses. Retention, as you can imagine, is poor. Better conditions are to be found elsewhere, people burn out and take time out, many will be put off becoming consultants after this experience, many go part-time even before kids and family life might call for this.

The NHS is a really challenging work environment -most consultants are working at their absolute capacity and more. Training junior staff is ill thought out and relies on the goodwill of each consultant to do "extra". Personally I find that very hard to do -like anyone else I have kids to be home for or to collect by a certain time. There is always a conflict between finishing the pressing work of the day, ignoring the trainee in the room, getting out somewhere close to finishing time and actually doing some training/teaching. I'm sure most people can guess what happens to training in that environment. Trainees will vote with their feet and disappear to NZ/Aus. As an individual I can't change that. I would need another 0.5 of me for the same workload to actually have any meaningful time to train someone. Imagine that number for every consultant working in the NHS right now.

Complaints are really tough. Looking at complaints when they come in, its really rare that a complaint is really about the doctor as an individual. They are almost always about the system. You think the doctor had a bad attitude? Every time I've been tasked with investigating this, I've found a doctor who was over-worked or under-trained/under supported in some way. They got something wrong? Same. You had to wait too long? The whole system, not the doctor. The doctor cancelled your appointment? Lack of flexibility/cover in the system. Apart from rare cases, like Shipman, it's always the system. But when you make a complaint, the individual is made to sweat, not the system. The GMC focuses too much on individuals rather than the corporate and governmental failings...and the real underlying problems are not addressed; the system just loses another doctor.

Overall, I think there is a huge amount of work to be done on retention before simply thinking about expanding the workforce. Or at least alongside.

Absolutely45 · 10/06/2022 16:51

Govt imposed the cap not the BMA, they don't run the NHS, could have been lifted and funded at any time over the last few years.
www.gponline.com/9000-medical-school-places-available-2021-cap-lifted/article/1724173#:~:text=A%20record%209%2C000%20English%20medical,Department%20for%20Education%20has%20announced.

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 10/06/2022 15:39

Is that the cap that the BMA themselves voted for?

No.

FreddyVoorhees · 10/06/2022 14:43

Qwertyfudge · 08/06/2022 09:45

We have a cap on the number of students that can study medicine. A number of universities have called for this cap to be lifted. The government have increased the cap but not enough to have a significant impact in coming years. They also need to increase the funding for universities and the nhs to support additional placements.

Is that the cap that the BMA themselves voted for?

AndSoFinally · 10/06/2022 14:33

@missingmiddle what industry do you work in? Asking for a friend.... 😁

Tagliatellme · 10/06/2022 14:30

The BMA can't restrict the offer of training places either, the Deaneries (or whatever they might be called now) do that. Nothing to do with the BMA.

Tagliatellme · 10/06/2022 14:28

Badbadbunny · 09/06/2022 20:34

But their members, i.e. the doctors themselves, can decide not to offer themselves up for training, offering training places, working in the medical schools, mentoring etc., i.e. a kind of "work to rule" or "strike" to support their trade union should the government of the day go ahead and increase medical schools/places against the BMA's wishes!

But they didn't.

Any restriction on numbers cannot be put at the door of the BMA.