Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of sister and BIL dictating everything on holiday?

113 replies

Imontopoftheworld · 07/06/2022 16:14

Every single family holiday.

My BIL will turn his music on and god forbid anyone else can play theirs. So this weekend I was stuck listening to loud opera.

They decide what we eat and cook it. Im happy to cook but it’s not even an option. I was going to make a side dish to their dinner and it got questioned half to death by my sister I couldn’t be bothered

They and our parents sort all the meals and good out beforehand - I try and get involved but they do it when I’m not there. I contribute money to the food but apparently I’m not even trusted to buy any type of food.

I’m just sick of it. Because I’m not married or have children then they treat me like a baby and sit there and moan loudly about laziness being a horrible trait.

OP posts:
stepuporshutup · 07/06/2022 21:06

This

Lunificent · 07/06/2022 21:05

Don’t go on any holiday involving your BIL. He’s quietly bullying you really.
See your father at other times.

IssaBaby · 07/06/2022 21:00

Life is too short to force yourself to do things you don't want.
Either don't go or just put your music on and do some cooking and be honest if they object and say its your holiday too.

I'd have stopped going by now...

Lollypop701 · 07/06/2022 20:54

I’m with the making your own lovely food and telling them you would have made it for them…but I’d make sure I offered up front so you could point out they said no. If everyone else likes opera and it’s just you who doesn’t then think you will have to suck it up.. if your df likes something else, change it and smile and say oh df likes x so we’re listening to this. Ds and bil are infantilising you because, well children can’t have their own house and fab job. So I’d point out you are tired after your latest project/ busy work period etc but it’s great as it’s paid for new car etc. lots of smiles, but do what you want basically

altiara · 07/06/2022 20:37

I’d speak to your parents and say you’re fed up of being treated this way, you want to be able to join in more rather than be treated like a child.

Glitterspy · 07/06/2022 20:28

My god, lie back and enjoy it. If I had a family who organised, booked and paid for holidays, laid on food without me having to lift a finger, and all I had to do was pay my share of the food bill? Sounds absolutely amazing to me, I’m not sure I’ve understood what the problem is!

Porcupineintherough · 07/06/2022 20:08

Just don't go - it really is that easy. See your parents some other time. Or go and advocate for yourself. Stand your ground.

BiasedBinding · 07/06/2022 20:05

The snide remarks about laziness are totally unacceptable, absolutely no need for that

Aprilx · 07/06/2022 20:02

Imontopoftheworld · 07/06/2022 16:29

Sorry I didn’t make it clear in my OP - it’s a holiday that my parents organise and pay for. They won’t accept contributions. We just contribute with the food etc

They don’t tie you up and make you go though do they. I voted you are being unreasonable, not because I think you are being unreasonable on holiday, but only because there is such a simple solution!

Labpictures · 07/06/2022 20:00

Sirzy · 07/06/2022 16:33

Just because they pay doesn’t make it compulsory to attend.

at the end of the day the only way anything will change is if you speak up.

This.

so address it - next phone call - can I address some things that happened on holiday? For the smoothness of the next time we go

  1. we take turns in cooking end of
  2. opera all weekend was just too much - can we take it in turns
  3. adults are treated like adults - equal decision making etc
BiasedBinding · 07/06/2022 19:52

It sounds awful. If you want things to change then you have to say something or just not go.

But I see it from the other side too - we do holidays with parents and my siblings and if I waited for those without children to decide to do things or cook things then we would get out of the house too late for my toddlers and/or they would be getting hungrier and hungrier for food. Im not saying you would do it that way OP, you sound considerate and would understand I am sure, but I can see how my siblings without children might see me as overbearing when in fact it’s just the case that the buck stops with me when it comes to dealing with fractious children and I will act early to avoid it.

Luredbyapomegranate · 07/06/2022 19:42

I think there will have to be a break period for them to see you as an adult, right now it seems they think you are a teen who doesn’t get a vote because they are paying.

People take people for granted if they are always available.

If you want to spend time w your Dad, then perhaps just go for less time. It also might help to frame it it your mind that you are being treated as the honorary boy rather than child (if that is conceivable). This might give you license to reframe yourself as the cool single aunt who has better things to do than go to the supermarchet

It might be a good idea to think about how you might have some holiday plans of your own so they start to see you differently. If you don’t have friends who are available for
a holiday, you could look at things like Skyros or yoga holiday or whatever you are into.

Mariposista · 07/06/2022 19:29

They sound like an absolute nightmare - but I can also understand why you want to make the most of time with your elderly parents while they are still able to go on holiday. Why don't you sit down with them, without your brattish sister and BIL around, and tell them how you love spending time with them, and appreciate them taking you all away, but this controlling and belittling behaviour makes you feel inadequate. Quote examples. Maybe they don't realise how it makes you feel.

NumberTheory · 07/06/2022 19:20

If it's making it so you don't enjoy the holiday, I think you need to be a bit more direct about it when it happens:

"[BiL] I'm really sick of opera, we listen to it every holiday and I'm past the point of toleration. How about some x? Or something by y?".

Alternatively, as a starting point, when he puts something on "Not opera again, [BiL]. Please choose something else." or whatever reflects his words when you put on your favourite. This does presume your musical tastes are shared by at least some of the others on the holiday - if everyone else likes opera and hates your taste in music then headphones are the answer.

On the food front:
As soon as the holiday is arranged "Just a heads up, I'm kind of tired of never being involved in planning what we eat or doing the cooking. This time I want to be involved in that. I have a bunch of ideas."

And if they do it without you anyway and ask you for cash towards it then "Hold up. That's really rude. I specifically asked to be included in planning this time. I don't want to be stuck in the same dynamic every holiday." Ideally, include a meal you want to cook, say when you want to cook it and list the ingredients that need to be added to the food list.

GreenCard · 07/06/2022 19:14

Don’t worry about your niece asking if you were an adult. Mine asked this when they were little too and we didn’t have kids. In their head you were either a mummy or a kid as that’s all they knew. So she asked if I had kids, no, then I must live with my mummy.

MummyGummy · 07/06/2022 19:05

Don’t go with them anymore. Arrange a holiday with just you & your parents. Sister & BIL won’t change, and life is too short to be wasting holiday time feeling resentful and miserable.

EllaDuggee · 07/06/2022 19:04

Talk to them about it, but honestly if they don't listen and you don't enjoy these holidays, don't go any more. Plan something else with your Dad.

ThorsBedazzler · 07/06/2022 18:55

Be more proactive. Take control of at least one meal. Play the music you want.

There is literally zero point in feeling wronged when you passively let others take charge.

As for your niece asking if you are grown up, if she is under 10 I would have taken it as either a compliment (you must be fun! Look young!) Or accept that children often just say things without thinking.

But stop feeling sorry for yourself and sitting in the role of no doing anything. Be more proactive.

Onceinawhileuser · 07/06/2022 18:50

Write to them several weeks before the next holiday, saying that you'd like to contribute more so will be making [2 or 3?] full meals for everyone, including buying, cooking and washing up. Ask them to include those meals in the schedule. Don't agree to provide details of what you're cooking - just say it'll be the kind of thing everyone likes. And maybe volunteer to run a games evening or something too. Don't make it easy for them to call you lazy and useless.

Everydaydayisaschoolday · 07/06/2022 18:50

You complain that they are treating you like a baby and it does sound as if they are. But you are acting like a baby as if you are powerless in this whole scenario. It's a fairly typical family dynamic, reverting to childhood behaviour patterns.

You are not a baby anymore. You have choices and autonomy. If it doesn't bring you pleasure don't do it.

Dinosaur975326788900864322456778899900754543 · 07/06/2022 18:42

Surely you just tell them you’re cooking x night and x night and will shop for and coordinate these nights, so they have two less nights to think about. If they ask what you’re cooking tell them it’s a surprise and don’t explain further

Mumontour85 · 07/06/2022 18:38

When arrangements are being made, TELL them what you are going to cook one day for dinner/ brekkie. Don't ask. Don't look for opinions. Just TELL them and then DO IT.

Make sure you take some pics and tag your BIL and everyone else, thanking your parents for the trip, mollifying him trying to take the credit!

If your sister and BiL remain unreasonable then I suggest 'kidnapping' your parents and taking them out for a nice meal, a good way to get some quality time in and thank them for the treat.

Failing all of this, stop going. Take your parents away separately, even just for a weekend. But if you let the cycle continue you can't blame anyone else for nothing changing.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 07/06/2022 18:37

Imontopoftheworld · 07/06/2022 16:58

I’d like to be involved though. They just treat me like I’m a baby.

So if I’ve understood correctly, you’d still like to go if the dynamic was different, right? Well, wishing won’t make it happen. You’ve got to stand up for yourself.

If there’s a holiday coming up, have a full and frank discussion with your family beforehand. Tell them you would like more input into what you all do and are not prepared to just go along with whatever they decide anymore. You need to be very, very firm on this, to the point of obstinance. They WILL argue back. They WILL try the ‘Some young women would be grateful for a free holiday’ routine. They WILL tell you that you’re being stubborn, difficult and other variations on that, and that you’re spoiling it for everyone. You have to be prepared for this.

Stay as calm as you can. Say you have no intention for spoiling things for anyone else - but at the moment, things are being spoiled for you, and that you’re sick of being the one who always falls into line. State calmly - not as a threat - that if things aren’t going to change, perhaps it’s best you don’t come.

You need to be prepared for your mother to turn on the tears; to say she can’t believe you’re ruining things like this and that all she wants is for her family to be together, surely that’s not too much to ask etc. I’m sad to say she may even pull the ultimate ‘We don’t know how many more chances your dad will get to have all his family around him’ emotional blackmail card. But it IS blackmail. It will be incredibly tough - but you have to stand firm.

I get what other posters have said about how ‘It’s not as easy as that’. I really do. The truth is it won’t be easy, and may not work. But you need to try if you want anything to change.

Good luck.

AnnaMagnani · 07/06/2022 18:31

I am not convinced that your family are capable of giving you what you would like.

You would like a family holiday where all adults are treated as equal adults - as you like spending time with your elderly dad.

My hunch is that even if you rocked up with a husband, 3 kids, a senior job and and a 5 bed house they would STILL treat you as the baby as that is the role assigned to you. If you try asserting yourself then YOU will be seen as the problem.

You therefore have to think about achieving what your highest priority is, in a different way. If it is spending time with your dad, then make a way to do it without your sister and ghastly BIL there spoiling things.

Be an adult by spending adult time with him finding about his life one to one, doing things only he and you are interested in, getting your mum to learn about your adult personality instead the role she has you pegged in age 8.

It's time to change things.

madasawethen · 07/06/2022 18:18

Don't go anymore.

If you do continue to go, you're going to have to speak up.

Walk over and turn the opera off. Tell them it gives you the rage.
Or get up and do an interpretive dance.

Any criticisms from your sister, tell her thanks but I've managed to keep myself alive.

Follow each with a tinkly laugh.

Sounds like your BIL and sister like to think of themselves as special.

I had a set like that. My late DHs sister and her husband.

He wouldn't say anything to them but I enjoyed winding them up in subtle ways and he loved me for it.