Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I6 year old caring for 2 year old

112 replies

Rosebel · 07/06/2022 10:09

I have been offered a new job which I really want. I have childcare in place 4 days a week but nursery has no space on Thursday until late August.
My job starts in July by which time my eldest will have finished her GCSEs and I'm thinking of asking her to take care of toddler on Thursday until nursery has space.
She absolutely loves her little brother and he adores her but is it asking too much? It would be a long day from about 7:15 to around 4:30.
Once her sister (14)finishes school she'd be able to help too but is it too much to ask?
I know my sister used to look after me during the holidays when our parents were working but I wasn't 2.
YABU it's too much to ask
YANBU it's fine

OP posts:
LondonQueen · 07/06/2022 10:53

It's fine as long as you pay her. What happens when she wants to go out with friends, what will they do all day etc?

UpdateStoleMyProfile · 07/06/2022 10:53

Absolutely fine to ask her. Personally I’d leave a list of activities especially given you’re paying her. So I’d expect them to go to the park/feed the ducks/pick easy favoured local activity of choice at some point during the day not just tv all day. Make it more of a summer job with expectations beyond keep him alive and fed! But not so onerous she decides not to bother.

And I’d have a discussion about other expectations too - so for eg no taking him for a drive in older friends cars, what are the ground rules for her having friends over at the same time, that sort of thing.

ManateeFair · 07/06/2022 10:49

I think you need to a) give her the choice and make sure she’s definitely comfortable with it and b) offer to pay her as you would a childminder. But I don’t see any reason why a 16-year-old couldn’t look after a toddler. You know your daughter and whether she’s responsible and patient enough for the task.

Dinoteeth · 07/06/2022 10:49

16yo should be fine.

I know of a 16 yo mum who was too young to supervise her own child in a softplay but that is amongst the bonkers inconsistent age rules we have in the UK.

I'd pay her if you can but I don't think you need to pay as much as the NMW for 16yos any more than you'd pay an au-pair the NMW. If she was out working full-time on NMW you'd probably in turn be looking for dig money from her and she'd have expenses getting to and from work and potentially she'd be paying tax on it.

Mariposista · 07/06/2022 10:49

If she is happy with the arrangement and you pay her, then this seems ok.

Rosehugger · 07/06/2022 10:48

It's absolutely fine if she is happy to do it and her little brother would be happy to be with her. Do you have family, friends or neighbours she could reach in an emergency? Also it would be a good idea if she has some knowledge of first aid.

purpleboy · 07/06/2022 10:47

It's fine as long as she is happy with it, good opportunity to earn a bit of cash, spend time with her sibling and help you out.

Findingmypast · 07/06/2022 10:47

As long as you pay her and also please give her emotional support, you haven't shown any reasons why not, other than she may say no thanks Mum.
I was married and raising my own children at that age (without pay or emotional support) and sadly quite a lot of girls I knew thought it must be a great situation to be in. Teenagers seem wiser and better informed now, but giving a responsible girl the opportunity to recognize the choices that have to be made, even when the whole thing's been made easy and can be ended, might not be a bad thing.

Mally100 · 07/06/2022 10:46

RedHelenB · 07/06/2022 10:18

Perfectly fine but definitely there should be some financial.recompense as it's for a full day rather than an hour or so..

This. Absolutely fine, this is how we grew up and we are so close and would still do anything for each other. MN is another universe where you would be accused of exploiting her 🙄. If she is happy to do so, and you compensate her then I see no issue. It's only for a month and a bit.

Hallyup89 · 07/06/2022 10:45

Depends on the child. I wouldn't trust my 18 year old to look after my 3 year old, but I'd trust my 14 year old.

At 16 there are plenty of teenagers with babies themselves. Most cope well. As long as she's willing and rewarded for it, I'd think it'd be ok, but only you know your daughter.

cadburyegg · 07/06/2022 10:44

I think YANBU especially as it's only one day a week and it's only for a few weeks, particularly if they already have a close relationship like you stated

Zpoa · 07/06/2022 10:42

If your DD16 is okay with it, then why not.

EatYourVegetables · 07/06/2022 10:40

Long term I’d say not fair, but we’re talking one day a week for a few weeks (depending how early in July your job starts and how late in Aug can you get the nursery spot)? So, maybe 4 or 6 days? That sounds ok to me.

Mangogogogo · 07/06/2022 10:39

At 16 girls (and boys but yours is a girl) will be going to college to do childcare and will be expected, on placements, to care for children

Candleabra · 07/06/2022 10:38

Just once a week? Not too much to ask.
If your 16 year old is responsible then I think that’s fine.

RollOnWinter · 07/06/2022 10:35

It's not fair to expect or hope your older child to look after a toddler. As you know, 2 yer olds are hard work. I think you should either wait until you're able to get the little one in at nursery, or pay a childminder.

Rosebel · 07/06/2022 10:33

I'd be paying her if she agrees, wouldn't expect her to do it for free. I'd also pay my 14 year old once she breaks up from school.
Food wise I'd either make him a packed lunch or something she can easily heat up. Activity wise he's got lots of things at home arts, building blocks, cars or they can go out. Although he may be so tired from nursery that he'd be happy watching Lion King. She is responsible and mature but I was just worried it might be asking too much. I could get home in 20 minutes if the need arose (DH would be even quicker if he's working locally but sometimes is away).
I'm thinking of giving a short trial to see how she feels after that. Well that's if she agrees to it. Of course she might not in which case I'll have to think again.

OP posts:
FerminaDaza128 · 07/06/2022 10:32

As someone with two much younger siblings, this was normal for me growing up and has led to a much closer bond with sibs in adulthood than I might otherwise have had, so never resented it at all. We still have our own special snack combos and in-jokes when we get together from the time I was looking after them.

Agree with other posters about paying her a set rate (ideally minimum wage if you can afford it) helping her out with suggestions for a daily routine and food prep, and being accepting of her saying no if she so chooses.

She might be very happy with the additional responsibilities and a chance to earn a bit of extra money, and I certainly wouldn’t see anything wrong with the arrangement but it must be her choice. I think 16 is old enough to take it on - you know your daughter so if she’s up for it and she doesn’t feel pressured then you’ve no reason to feel guilty!

Axahooxa · 07/06/2022 10:32

My 13 year olds used to look after their 2 and 4 year old siblings. Maybe ask her to have a friend to help and split some pocket money?

rainbowunicorn · 07/06/2022 10:31

I think it is fine as long as you are paying her at the very least the minimum wage for a 16 year old which is £4.83 and hour. So rounded up £5 an hour minimum which for a 9 hour day is £45. This is a minimum as she could go and get herslf a job paying more than that. Just to put in context my own 16 year old gets paid £10 an hour in their part time job.
Also additional money left so that she can take the toddler out and about to soft play, trip to park and an ice cream etc.

lanthanum · 07/06/2022 10:31

I'd offer pay, on the grounds of it being a full day rather than "looking after him while I go to the supermarket" or for a couple of hours in the evening when he's asleep anyway. Make that distinction clear, so shorter babysits can remain part of "contribution to family life". It's also more of a commitment, in that she absolutely cannot back out if friends turn out to have plans. You'll be paying the childminder once that's an option, so the money is presumably there (and you probably don't need to pay her quite as much - other jobs for 16 year olds won't pay the adult minimum wage).

If you were talking about all day every day, that would be a big ask, but one day a week is entirely reasonable.

TidyDancer · 07/06/2022 10:30

Yeah this is incredibly dependant on the two children involved. I would be fine with it in theory but only if you think your DD would be okay with it. You would need to pay her, have you floated the idea with her?

mbosnz · 07/06/2022 10:29

If the relationship between the two is good, she is asked, and knows she genuinely can say no, without repercussions, and she is being paid for it, then I'd say go for it!

(I say that as one that my siblings did not like me as a two year old, then I didn't like their children when I was a teen, I was given no option, and sweet bugger all pay, lol).

Aussiegirl123456 · 07/06/2022 10:28

I’ve got a 16 year old daughter and a 2 year old daughter. I know my daughter would be fine in that position and would really appreciate the money throughout the summer.

It all depends on your daughter though. Is she mature enough? Are you paying her? How far away is your job if an emergency arises? Is there any other family near by ‘just in case’?

MissBPotter · 07/06/2022 10:27

If she’s happy to do it then go for it. I would definitely pay her and give her money to do things with dc eg buy ice cream or soft play or whatever. Bus money etc as can’t drive. But this long summer can be a bit aimless for kids of that age and so it will be a good little summer job for her and helps you out, plus sibling bonding time.