Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I6 year old caring for 2 year old

112 replies

Rosebel · 07/06/2022 10:09

I have been offered a new job which I really want. I have childcare in place 4 days a week but nursery has no space on Thursday until late August.
My job starts in July by which time my eldest will have finished her GCSEs and I'm thinking of asking her to take care of toddler on Thursday until nursery has space.
She absolutely loves her little brother and he adores her but is it asking too much? It would be a long day from about 7:15 to around 4:30.
Once her sister (14)finishes school she'd be able to help too but is it too much to ask?
I know my sister used to look after me during the holidays when our parents were working but I wasn't 2.
YABU it's too much to ask
YANBU it's fine

OP posts:
SmartCarDriver · 08/06/2022 07:01

MisguidedSheep · 07/06/2022 19:17

@SmartCarDriver - lol! Maybe read my post again I simply point out the drawbacks and state an opinion. Just like your obviously opposing one it is perfectly valid.

I am allowed to think that teenagers should be allowed to be teenagers and kickback and relax after the intensity of exams (and especially after the last couple of years). You think differently....that's fine, maybe next time try and be a little more polite.

I think 9 hours a week means they can still be a teenager and "kick back and relax"!

It it was 3/4 days a week I might agree, but really?

Sunnytwobridges · 08/06/2022 01:39

I think this would be fine as long as the two year old isn’t a handful. I don’t care how many people had babies at 16 that doesn’t mean everyone is prepared to watch a two year old. Esp one that’s a handful and not their own. Definitely pay her fairly.

Kanaloa · 08/06/2022 01:07

Bless her 😂 she needs to learn a bit about the art of negotiation! To be fair I can see why she’d jump at the chance. Looking after your own baby brother in your house with the option to stick him in the pram and go out a walk/chill at home/have a friend over is cushty compared to a job earning pennies and working super hard in a shop or cafe or hotel or similar. And she’ll have a bit of extra pocket money and be in mum’s good books next time she wants a favour. Win win really.

R1408 · 07/06/2022 22:37

I pay a 16 year old babysitter to look after my 4 year old.

Luredbyapomegranate · 07/06/2022 22:34

I don’t see why not - as long as she is genuinely up for it, and you are happy she’s sensible enough. It’s great life and work experience and will build their relationship.

Do some settling in days with her, make sure she knows what to do in an emergency and does a basic first aid course. It’s a long day so if there’s an activity group she can go to.

If it’s for more than a few weeks she should be paid though as it’s time she could be using to earn money.

HappyDays40 · 07/06/2022 22:26

At 14 I used to collect my sister (12) and cousins 9, 7 and 4 from a local primary school 5 days per week. I made their tea and looked after them till their mum got home. I loved doing it she will be perfectly capable. Ask her and offer to pay her. 😁

Rosebel · 07/06/2022 22:19

Tbf she hasn't looked for a job and has decided she's going to look for one in September /October as then she'll know her college schedule and thinks they'll be more opportunities as the uni students will be back by then.
Anyway I asked her tonight and she was really happy about it, although we're still going to do a trial run. She offered to do it for £10 a day!! Don't worry she'll be getting more than that.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 07/06/2022 21:03

I think she should be paid more than NMW because it reduces opportunities for other full time jobs (she'd have to find one that guarantees the same day off every week when employers often demand absolute flexibility & eliminates Mon-Fri jobs altogether). Just because it's legal to pay a 16 year fuck all, that doesn't mean that it's right. And you will still be receiving Child Benefit for her, so it's not as if you're paying £22 of it out of your own pocket.

It's over 9 hours without a break. I think that's worth £6 ph. Especially as that's less than a childminder (most of whom will probably be on holiday at some point over the summer so wouldn't be available for a one day a week child even if they were willing and had space for one compared to a 3-5 place).

GreenCat44 · 07/06/2022 20:45

My mum worked nights and i looked after my youngest sister (same age gap? There's 14 yrs between us) once I'd left school. Also babysat for the same age kids during the day while their mum worked. I think if she doesn't mind and you think she'll be ok, go for it.

minutesturntohours · 07/06/2022 20:37

No.

An evening, yes.

Not a full day.

MisguidedSheep · 07/06/2022 19:17

@SmartCarDriver - lol! Maybe read my post again I simply point out the drawbacks and state an opinion. Just like your obviously opposing one it is perfectly valid.

I am allowed to think that teenagers should be allowed to be teenagers and kickback and relax after the intensity of exams (and especially after the last couple of years). You think differently....that's fine, maybe next time try and be a little more polite.

Saracen · 07/06/2022 16:10

It isn't unreasonable to ask, but she should be rewarded in a significant way. It's a long day to look after a toddler. Either pay her properly or offer her something else she wants very much.

The exception would be if you were very hard up and at the end of your rope, in which case she just has to muck in so the family can survive, though it isn't ideal. This is the situation in many families.

RedSoloCup · 07/06/2022 13:35

I just asked my 16yo (home on GCSE study leave) and she'd be more than happy to do this

2bazookas · 07/06/2022 13:26

I was perfectly capable of that at age 16 and eager to earn money doing a real job. If she is a sensible reliable girl that would be a great solution ( and an excellent addition to her CV).

Glitternails1 · 07/06/2022 13:17

@Rosebel as long as you pay her at least £45 (minimum wage for 16 yo) then that’s fine. I wouldn’t pay your 14 yo because by the time she comes home from school, there’s probably only an hour max until you’re home.

NotQuiteUsual · 07/06/2022 12:53

I wouldn't inflict my two year old on anyone regardless of age because she's intense, unpredictable and an absolute liability even in the house. But my older two would of been fine at this age with a responsible 16 year old. Unless your two year old has managed to pull light fittings off the ceiling and dug a hole through the plaster so deep you thought you'd come through to next door like mine, I'd say you're good.

Vikinga · 07/06/2022 12:51

1 day a week and getting paid for it is absolutely fine. I spent the summer helping a family with their 5 year old when I was 15 and loved it. My 16 year old would also enjoy it, and even better if she was getting paid. My eldest at 15/16 used to look after a friend's children many times - picking them up from school and waking them home and staying with them until their parents came home. Usually only 2-3 hours but a couple of times it was 6-7 hours. He thought it was easy money!

Swayingpalmtrees · 07/06/2022 12:44

I wouldn't be comfortable with her friends coming over - and they get distracted etc, she would need to approach it as a paid job and take good care of him.

Swayingpalmtrees · 07/06/2022 12:42

Its is one day a week, I think she will be fine. I would ask them to stay at home, as I would worry about the 2yr old being out and running off. Definitely pay her and leave a picnic behind so they can sit outside in the garden. I don't see a problem at all, especially if she is a sensible girl and enjoys spending time with him anyway.

Steelesauce · 07/06/2022 12:36

Its fine. My friends teenagers babysit regularly for me. Her eldest started at 16 (at the time my children were 7, 4 and 2) and has just turned 18. She likes to go out herself now so when she's unable to babysit, her 15 year old sister helps me out. I actually used to sign things and write statements for the oldest teens college course (child care) so it was beneficial for both of us.

Highfivemum · 07/06/2022 12:34

It is all down to how you know ur DD. If you do decide to go for it then make sure she has a list of numbers to contact in emergency. Also is there anyone close by that could also be an emergency. ?

doing a trail run is a good idea

RB68 · 07/06/2022 12:33

Of course its fine if she agrees, sounds like they have a lovely relationship. I was 16 when my youngest brother was born I was No 1 and he was no 6, I was always looking after one or other of them and perfectly capable of doing so.

Pennyhill22 · 07/06/2022 12:33

It's absolutely fine for 16 year old to help out one day a week. I would pay her though. Our DD14 babysits our DD12 and DS10 about once a month and we pay her.

Kanaloa · 07/06/2022 12:27

I had my own baby at that age! So I think it’s silly to act like she’s be incapable of it. It’s more about if she’s willing. I think it very much depends on how she feels about it. If it was me I’d present it very much as not an expectation and offer some money as a payment for her services, and if she accepts I’d make it very clear how completely grateful you are.

Graphista · 07/06/2022 12:17

16 is old enough to be married and have a child of their own!

I was babysitting from the age of 14 inc overnights and weekend days and was absolutely fine.

If she is comfortable with it (when you ask make sure she knows she can say no) then I don't see a problem

My daughter (now 21) also did a lot of babysitting as a teen and looked after cousins etc

I've also a lot of experience with teens in voluntary roles she'll very likely be absolutely fine.

Honestly the infantilising of teens and young adults these days drives me nuts! It's not doing them or society any favours!