Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have a no gift policy for my DC's third birthday?

235 replies

dillydally24 · 07/06/2022 09:23

Just that really. My DC is having a third birthday party which 25 other children will attend. Is it ok to ask that no gifts be given by the other children? My DC will be given a couple of significant presents by me and my DH. I find the flood of gifts for birthdays and Xmas these days completely overwhelming and I don't want it to become the norm for my DC. We already have so much.

OP posts:
Barkingmadhouse · 07/06/2022 13:16

Awful idea - you child will realise he gives presents to his friends on their birthday yet has received nothing back. My 3 year old would realise it is odd to turn up to a party without a gift and probably would say something to the party child about them having no presents.

Dinoteeth · 07/06/2022 13:15

Nanny0gg · 07/06/2022 13:07

If your child wants to donate. They're not your presents

Most kids will want to keep everything or at least open it first.

I'd not be putting the decision into a 3 yos hands over what is kept and what if anything is getting moved on. Hes not in charge of the cupboards or organising the toy storage, Doubles, too similar to what he has move it on in the best condition for the charity shop to sell it.

Divebar2021 · 07/06/2022 13:15

I read on here about kids parties in Canada called “ Two-sies” where guests don’t bring a present but give $2 each towards a bigger present ( or savings i imagine). They had a box near the door where the money could be posted. I thought it was a great idea and the child still gets the pleasure of choosing a nice toy / experience

Apologies to any Canadians if any of that is incorrect.

PelicansPandasandPuppiesOhmy · 07/06/2022 13:12

*Your wedding, your choice.

His birthday, his choice*

The child is getting a party with 25 of his friends, with entertainment and I imagine decorations etc, he's not paying for it and not exactly hard done by!

MRex · 07/06/2022 13:12

It's a tricky one, I'm with you on disliking the huge amounts of stuff we have. OTOH it's nice for gift givers; DS is 4 and always quite sure of what a friend wants, and so far he's been correct (feelings are obvious at this age). There is also one child who finds it important to personally give a gift and watch it be opened, because that's the process.

No presents feels mean for attendees and child, but 25 is ridiculous, especially at only 3yo. In an ideal world, it would be nice if the kids could group together to get a few thoughtful gifts, say 5 instead of 25! If you know the parents well, could you suggest to some groups of friends that they group together to choose a small gift?
You can definitely say "no gift required, but if your child wants to give something small...", then direct ideas to something small and say secondhand is fine. I would say to give different suggestions to different people when it's so many, unless it's something that must be small when low cost such as Lego. You could suggest things that have a natural home e.g. a book / art supplies / jigsaw 25 - 50 piece / clothing age 3 / hair accessories / etc.

VestaTilley · 07/06/2022 13:11

I think this is really mean.

Let your child enjoy being a child - life is miserable enough without depriving them of gifts, and joyous moments like the innocence of children's birthday parties.

Most of the gifts will be nice and your DC may really like them - donate any to charity if you or DC don’t like them. Your child won’t grow up spoilt because they get some birthday presents. Give the poor kid a break.

Nanny0gg · 07/06/2022 13:10

dillydally24 · 07/06/2022 10:29

@Amelion my thoughts exactly. I grew up in a family where we received one or two thoughtful presents which ended up being much treasured. I can't bear the torrent of stuff we don't need. We did the same for our wedding - no gifts, just optional charitable donations - and I felt so happy we made that decision.

Your wedding, your choice.

His birthday, his choice

Nanny0gg · 07/06/2022 13:07

dillydally24 · 07/06/2022 09:30

That's not a bad idea. I'd have to donate a bit further from home as I wouldn't want the parents to see them in the local charity shop.

If your child wants to donate. They're not your presents

Nanny0gg · 07/06/2022 13:06

dillydally24 · 07/06/2022 09:27

I don't think he will feel hard done by given the presents he will receive from me and my DH, but maybe that's wrong. It just doesn't sit right with me. We don't need loads more stuff. He will be delighted with the 2 presents my DH and I have bought for him.

Still not about you.

My kids enjoyed choosing presents and loved opening their own.

And maybe some will just put money in a card.

Let it be

(Oh, and a lot of parents will ignore you anyway)

SnowWhitesMum · 07/06/2022 13:04

I have two sets of twins. Parties I always say optional gifts especially as we have a large family who give gifts to. No one opens gifts at our parties. We're always overwhelmed as people as so kind. Any duplicates or things I know they'd maybe not care for all go in my pile for FIND for charity donations at Christmas. Just donate to places or people if it's to much but don't subtlety so your child doesn't notice of course ☺️

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 07/06/2022 13:04

I completely agree with you OP and all those who say about the child being disappointed are instilling the value of mindless giving into their children.

Complete nonsense. I was a normal child who got presents and loved getting presents. I equally loved choosing presents for my friends.

Deny your kids presents if you like, but don't pretend it's for their own good and not yours.

prescribingmum · 07/06/2022 13:01

InChocolateWeTrust · 07/06/2022 12:57

If you are hiring soft play/hall and entertainer, it makes little environmental difference whether you have 10 or 20 children, just extra food to cater for.

The point being you dont need to hire (and heat!!) A soft play or hall.

You can just have 5 or 6 little children to tea/in the garden at home.

It's all so bloody ott with kids parties now, and it's mainly about the parents who want to throw a party

Everyone does not have a home that is suitable for hosting parties or the time to prepare.

A soft play is a local business which is open regardless, paying them entry and food cost for 20 children, the parent is spending locally and the children are entertained.

FusionChefGeoff · 07/06/2022 13:00

We keep a present box in the garage - gets used either for other family birthdays / Christmas / other kids parties or raided in emergency wet day / kids doing my head in type circumstances

InChocolateWeTrust · 07/06/2022 12:57

If you are hiring soft play/hall and entertainer, it makes little environmental difference whether you have 10 or 20 children, just extra food to cater for.

The point being you dont need to hire (and heat!!) A soft play or hall.

You can just have 5 or 6 little children to tea/in the garden at home.

It's all so bloody ott with kids parties now, and it's mainly about the parents who want to throw a party

prescribingmum · 07/06/2022 12:57

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 07/06/2022 12:38

But truly, the amount of threads I have read on here where people say they usually spend around £5 (definitely less than £10) on birthday presents for classmates unless they are best friends is so numerous

Children don't understand or care about the value of presents though. The fun is in recieving them, opening them, and having something new and shiny. That's why it's so mean for a parent to ask for no presents because they find them annoying to deal with, or because they consider them "tat".

And why are we encouraging them to have fun in something new and shiny which is usually forgotten in a few days? Surely it is our responsibility to teach them that these things do not have value and fun with friends is the part to enjoy.

Parents who succumb to the 'having something to open' are to blame

Cantanka · 07/06/2022 12:55

dillydally24 · 07/06/2022 11:42

For people suggesting IABU, what about the environmental implications? I think the next generation is going to grow up judging us harshly on issues like this. I wonder if my DC will be appalled by the sheer amount of stuff bought for birthdays/Xmas etc. when older.

Consumerism is a big issue for the environment admittedly but the balloon garlands and throwaway party decorations/plates/cups etc are far worse as they are single use whereas if you give your gifts away someone will use them.

Children’s parties aren’t good for the environment generally sadly (although some are worse than others!)

prescribingmum · 07/06/2022 12:52

I completely agree with you OP and all those who say about the child being disappointed are instilling the value of mindless giving into their children.

Having a party is about hosting and having fun with their friends, not about the gifts they will receive. DD had parties for her 3rd and 5th birthdays. We did not write no gifts because the parties were both joint with another child and did not want to enforce it on anyone else. She did not care about the pile of gifts either time. Her 5th party was 2 weeks before her actual birthday so we did not open the gifts until the day. She had forgotten by the day of her birthday about the pile from the party. As much fun as she had ripping off the paper, most of the gifts sit unopened in a box 4 months on and she will be donating them to childrens' ward of the local hospital this Christmas

I personally do not feel smaller parties is the answer but the mindless giving is to blame. If you are hiring soft play/hall and entertainer, it makes little environmental difference whether you have 10 or 20 children, just extra food to cater for. 10 needless gifts, wrapping paper, plastic to have to offload are a bigger pain than feeding 10 more mouths

Steelesauce · 07/06/2022 12:50

You can put no gifts but you're likely to get gifts. And if you want to donate them, donate them wherever. The parents aren't going to notice them in the charity shop. Its mostly b&m toys/books given anyway that the parents have grabbed quickly. I have a box of cheapo toys in my wardrobe I just grab out of for birthday presents for the younger ones party invites. I wouldn't even be able to remember what I've given!

badg3r · 07/06/2022 12:50

If you say gifts are optional people will take that to mean they can buy something very small.

badg3r · 07/06/2022 12:47

The trick here is to ask for stuff you would buy anyway, if the parents ask what they like. Drawing stuff, clothes, arts and crafts things, toys for the beach, colouring books/paper, water bottle, gift card to the zoo, maybe a picture of your kid with their friend in a frame, face paints, board games. Those sorts of things.

I hear you about the environmental impact and the relentless stuff. The good news is that it gets much easier quite quickly! My oldest is eight and it has already subsided a lot.

Indoorcamping · 07/06/2022 12:45

Part of the fun of a birthday at that age is opening the presents. Just sift through later and put some aside for regifting. Pop a postit on each saying who they're from so you don't give them back to the giver.

MrsMiddleMother · 07/06/2022 12:44

Yanbu! They don't need 20 gifts and it's one less worry for the other parents, especially considering the cost of living crisis. Personally I'd write on the invite, please no gifts but a handmade picture/card would be perfect

MammyZ · 07/06/2022 12:42

I think of course YANBU but from the range of replies here you’re going to have to try to figure out which side of the fence most it your peer group fall - height of rudeness(!) or perfectly fine to request presents?!

I can actually think of nothing more unreasonable than 25 presents likely from Flying Tiger or somewhere equally plasticky.

One of my favourite traditions from our school is that since the start one parent added the request for no-presents but if you really wanted to then to throw a fiver a card. This has filtered through all years and younger siblings and takes a lot of stress and waste out of parties.

I know this approach is sacrilege to some, and it’s not a hard and fast rule, some still give gifts (I suspect they are actually regifts lol), but I think it works really well.

And one of the nicest aspects I’ve found in our school is that the tradition evolved to also include a handmade card by the kids. This was never requested it just kind of evolved that way. So if my DD is going to a party for group in her class (it’s all joint parties here too!) our prep is a few fivers, and she sits down an hour before and makes some lovely cards. I recently bought a plain white card-making kit, but could also be A4 page folded over….

But obv it’s going to depend on how
you think your group will feel about it!

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 07/06/2022 12:38

But truly, the amount of threads I have read on here where people say they usually spend around £5 (definitely less than £10) on birthday presents for classmates unless they are best friends is so numerous

Children don't understand or care about the value of presents though. The fun is in recieving them, opening them, and having something new and shiny. That's why it's so mean for a parent to ask for no presents because they find them annoying to deal with, or because they consider them "tat".

Winter2020 · 07/06/2022 12:34

Hi OP,

When my son had a joint party with another boy (whole class invited) I was worried parents might resent buying two gifts or decide not to come because of gifts. We put a note on a little slip of paper in the invitation

There’s no need to bring a present,
We just want you to come along,
but if at all,
please keep it small,
’cause our party is all about fun!

I think it worked well as some came with just a card/ nothing and we had a mix of presents and some were small such as a bag of sweets or a small amount of £ in a card (e.g. £3).

It would be nice in the current climate to take the pressure off gift buying but I wouldn’t ban them completely. I think your child might feel that is unfair.

Swipe left for the next trending thread