Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have a no gift policy for my DC's third birthday?

235 replies

dillydally24 · 07/06/2022 09:23

Just that really. My DC is having a third birthday party which 25 other children will attend. Is it ok to ask that no gifts be given by the other children? My DC will be given a couple of significant presents by me and my DH. I find the flood of gifts for birthdays and Xmas these days completely overwhelming and I don't want it to become the norm for my DC. We already have so much.

OP posts:
MotherWol · 07/06/2022 15:58

YANBU at all, but this is Mumsnet where you’ll be told you’re depriving your child of a giant pile of generic stuff they don’t need. Most of the whole class parties DD gets invited to say ‘no gifts’ on the invite, it’s fine and the kids still have a great time.

Wor · 07/06/2022 15:48

I have a friend like you. She finds the presents overwhelming and dislikes the waste and consumerism.

Her children don’t feel that way. Her DH doesn’t feel that way. The grandparents and friends do not feel that way. She triumphantly insists that her child may only have two presents for Christmas and congratulates herself on her ethical living. She does not see how sad this makes her child and those around them.

You find the flood of presents overwhelming. But that doesn’t mean you get to dictate to those around you.

YABU.

GADDay · 07/06/2022 15:28

Agree with you OP. I think it's fine to ask for no gifts.

No child needs 25 gifts - wrong on every level.

motogirl · 07/06/2022 15:22

Our local food bank takes gifts suitable for children to give to struggling families for birthdays, ask if yours does

DogsAndGin · 07/06/2022 15:10

I completely agree with you. It’s a huge pile of wasteful, plastic tat, all made in China, and doesn’t teach the child anything at all.

But, I just don’t think it’s feasible to reasonably request no presents. Maybe don’t invite as many children next time. Or, put all the presents on a table when people come in, and clear most of them away before DC sees them.

mrssunshinexxx · 07/06/2022 15:07

How old is he @dillydally24 can you explain about asking for donations for a chosen charity instead?

GarageGalore · 07/06/2022 15:02

Because people have different days/times at nursery, at 3 was definitely not having a full 'class' party had about 10-12 kids and had to ask staff which children they played with (I knew a couple but not 10 of them). For the first few years I gave mine secondhand presents, if it is what I thought they would like/enjoy, they wouldn't notice/care and saved me money and recycling.

You lot must be minted the amount of brand new stuff you give to charity. I don't get why you wouldn't regift, saves money. (I still give stuff to charity, it has just been used)
I did two or 3 years of full class parties reception/yr1 (possibly yr2) when dc were frequently changing friendship groups.

Maybe you could ask for recycled presents, would ease your concern about being green/affordability/give 3 yo a present (at 3 they won't know)

Cartoonmom · 07/06/2022 14:50

No gifts is pretty typical at my kid's school (US, east coast). The invitation normally says something like your presence is the best present - no gifts please. Most people listen. Kids who don't bring a gift will normally bring a card though.

GlitteryGreen · 07/06/2022 14:41

I just think there has to surely be a new solution now that children are often having (and encouraged to have) whole class parties, which was not the norm previously?

I am surprised at how many people here don't think 20+ presents just from friends alone is excessive, especially when it's multiplied by each child in a class. That's so many and so much waste!

It must be such a pain in the arse for buying parents too...I'd much rather there was some kind of dedicated birthday parties site that everyone used where you could gift a few pounds for each birthday...so much easier and the birthday boy/girl can put it towards something they really would like. On top of getting gifts from close friends and family of course, so they'd still have 'proper' gifts to open.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 07/06/2022 14:30

Most parties we’ve been to form 3-6 year olds have said no presents, or someone collects a donation and they get one more expensive present

I would hate my kids to get 25 presents

GlitteryGreen · 07/06/2022 14:23

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 07/06/2022 12:38

But truly, the amount of threads I have read on here where people say they usually spend around £5 (definitely less than £10) on birthday presents for classmates unless they are best friends is so numerous

Children don't understand or care about the value of presents though. The fun is in recieving them, opening them, and having something new and shiny. That's why it's so mean for a parent to ask for no presents because they find them annoying to deal with, or because they consider them "tat".

But surely it is our job as parents to guide them away from that expectation then? I don't want my child to only be happy if they have a mound of gifts to open, regardless of what they are.

As I said, I am not anti presents at all and I think a suggestion of books (for example) as a gift still gives a lot of scope for smaller spend for those who struggle to afford all these gifts for parties, and the birthday child gets to open lots of gifts and feel special.

If parties with 20+ kids is the new norm, there has to be a middle ground somewhere when it comes to gifts.

SallyWD · 07/06/2022 14:02

He's only 3 and I don't think 2 gifts sounds like a lot. Even if they're really expensive gifts he won't realise at that age. I do completely understand your view that it's wasteful and you don't want too much stuff but I do think he'd absolutely love opening gifts on the day. I think I'd just accept the gifts, keep a few of the best ones and give the remaining gifts to charity or a children's hospital. You could also keep them to give to other children for their birthdays (keep a note of who gave what so you don't give the same gift back!). We've done that lots of times!

prescribingmum · 07/06/2022 14:01

Your wedding, your choice.

His birthday, his choice

I absolutely despise these comments as the child would not be receiving the presents if the parents were not holding the party in the first place 🙄
Many young children will get excited and want to keep it all when they open, then swiftly forget. Many families also do not have space for so many things in their home

I would never dream of choosing what happens to a gift given by a grandparent/immediate family on their behalf. That is entirely the child's choice but when hosting a big party and receiving so many gifts, it is my place as the parent to step in and consider how much we can realistically keep. Fortunately my children have little interest in the gifts and party bags but they are the minority

Arthursmom · 07/06/2022 13:52

Or alternatively we have asked for books in a certain series that he doesn't have any in e.g. he's starting to get into Mo Willems so any of the Elephant and Piggy etc I think people feel odd not giving a gift but if it's something he actually needs / will use then I feel comfortable enough to give people a little direction

UseOfWeapons · 07/06/2022 13:51

YANBU. Why not? We all have too much STUFF we don't need. Much better for your son, and for the planet. He’ll have a special day anyway, although so many children for a party seems a bit overwhelming, but they’re your nerves!😊
I don’t agree with donating or regifting in the manner suggested by some, better that people don’t spend money on tat in the first place….giving away a gift that someone has spent time and money on selecting, knowing you were going to regift it immediately, doesn’t sit right with me.

Arthursmom · 07/06/2022 13:47

For my sons birthday is asked people to gift him things for outdoor play-conkers, pinecones, shells, stones etc. he's got enough plastic fantastic stuff and loves all the above mentioned things / considers them 'treasures' so it's a win win. We've got him a mud kitchen and a few bits for the garden so he can use all his new 'toys' out there and his wee pals can collect these things on their own too.

NerrSnerr · 07/06/2022 13:47

You won't get 25 rubbish presents though. You'll get some books, some puzzles, some parents will text to see what you'd like.

When both mine were 3 it was mainly books, clothes, one big study plastic truck that is still played with years later, crafts and my eldest got a lunch box from an NCT friend at 3 she still uses and she's almost 8!

The thing I love about gifts from nursery/ school friends are the things I wouldn't have considered buying like when someone got Hama beads when my daughter was 4- I hadn't thought about them as a toy and she still plays with them now (although we've bought her more since).

Occasionally we keep things aside to regift/ use for a raffle or give to charity. I wouldn't worry about parents spotting stuff in the charity shop. How likely is it they'll see it and have bought you something so unique that they know it's the one they bought you?

prescribingmum · 07/06/2022 13:44

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 07/06/2022 13:04

I completely agree with you OP and all those who say about the child being disappointed are instilling the value of mindless giving into their children.

Complete nonsense. I was a normal child who got presents and loved getting presents. I equally loved choosing presents for my friends.

Deny your kids presents if you like, but don't pretend it's for their own good and not yours.

My child loves receiving presents but values receiving a few things she loves.

She gets overwhelmed and uninterested with 25 presents which consist of plastic bracelets, hairbands, low quality puzzles, toy kits where things quickly fall apart, felt tips which run out etc

She also loves choosing and giving presents to her close friends - all 25 children at the party would not fit into this category

dillydally24 · 07/06/2022 13:39

@VestaTilley

Let your child enjoy being a child - life is miserable enough without depriving them of gifts, and joyous moments like the innocence of children's birthday parties.

Err, what a weird comment. I am not depriving him of gifts or a birthday party. He will get some really love gifts from me, DH and close family (e.g., grandparents). And he'll get a birthday party which 25 of his nursery and playgroup friends will attend. They will have a fabulous time. All I'm suggesting is that I curtail the number of presents he receives as 25 is a huge amount and (in my view) completely overwhelming and unnecessary.

OP posts:
Blueeyedgirl21 · 07/06/2022 13:34

You could maybe do a request for a book for his party, I have friends who asked for ‘you don’t need to bring a gift just yourself, but if you’d like to bring one a book would be lovely’ and it went down well, for a christening and one friend did it for her little ones 2nd birthday. Or say craft stuff - put in a big storage box and eek it out over the year for rainy days!

FannyCann · 07/06/2022 13:33

I hope you start a new trend OP with parents of your child's friends following suit. The waste is appalling and 25 presents is far too many for a 3 year old (or anyone really).

The family of my DD's (24) boyfriend don't do Christmas presents, they give to charity. They are all really involved with environmental/sustainability issues.
Since being with him DD has hardly bought any new clothes, preferring charity shops, though I note she still likes to get some Christmas presents from us. I do give him something small too, like a book, it feels too mean not to, but usually wrapped in pre-used paper!

So start as you mean to go on, you won't regret it.

Just be prepared for sticking to your guns about not giving your child's friends presents when going to their parties.

I used to insist on my children making the birthday card for their friends - half an hour or so keeping them occupied, saving on money and waste and making them think about their friend.
They still mostly make cards for family Christmas/birthdays. I have a huge stash DH refuses to throw away.

Maytodecember · 07/06/2022 13:29

Perfectly reasonable. And admirable. I don’t think a 3 year old will remember previous birthdays and expect gifts.
The huge amount of stuff I’ve seen at dgc parties has made me weep. So much plastic, and most of it made in China.

dillydally24 · 07/06/2022 13:24

Nanny0gg · 07/06/2022 13:10

Your wedding, your choice.

His birthday, his choice

Don't be ridiculous! He's three years old and doesn't have a choice. I am his parent and it's my responsibility to make his choices for him. That's the main job of a parent. Should I also let him choose what he eats for dinner, where he goes to school, what television he gets to watch? Silliest comment on the thread.

OP posts:
Dutch1e · 07/06/2022 13:22

YANBU, the waste is awful and it's so easy to teach a child that their party IS a gift, especially after a lovely morning with family opening one or two special presents.

The only thing is that you will have to suggest a cheap & easy alternative on the invitation, as it's too uncomfortable to arrive empty-handed.

Dinoteeth · 07/06/2022 13:19

Op depending on the charity shops some who are chains move stuff around anyway. They may also put toys into storage to put out nearer Christmas time so wouldn't worry about going futher afield.

Swipe left for the next trending thread