Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have a no gift policy for my DC's third birthday?

235 replies

dillydally24 · 07/06/2022 09:23

Just that really. My DC is having a third birthday party which 25 other children will attend. Is it ok to ask that no gifts be given by the other children? My DC will be given a couple of significant presents by me and my DH. I find the flood of gifts for birthdays and Xmas these days completely overwhelming and I don't want it to become the norm for my DC. We already have so much.

OP posts:
RachelAMpls · 08/06/2022 16:03

The child will be at a PARTY with friends, and probably cake and ice cream. Nothing sad about that. Teaching your child that happiness comes from material objects is sad.

Johnnysgirl · 08/06/2022 15:57

just can't understand why it is then so rude/grabby to say that 'if you are planning to bring a gift, we would much rather a contribution towards...'
Because it's always a bit gauche to try to translate a possible gift into cold hard cash. It's not particularly logical, but it just is.

prescribingmum · 08/06/2022 15:40

@BuenaVistaAntisocialClub this thread indicates how much gift giving is ingrained into us but I just can't understand why it is then so rude/grabby to say that 'if you are planning to bring a gift, we would much rather a contribution towards...'

Personally I would much rather you gave the small bag of sweets as the gift than a cheap toy that will take up space/fall apart quickly.

@Needmorelego DD's school has a rule that if having a party in Reception and Y1, it must be a whole class party. I feel it is fair as avoids all bad feelings at this young age where friendships are transient but of course, it means hosting for up to 30 once siblings are added in. They have all been soft play/bouncy castle/entertainer party and usually hosted by more than one family where birthdays are close together. I personally can't find much to fault in this - even if my child does not play with the birthday child, they are with friends and have fun. I don't view the hosting itself as mass consumerism - it is the decorations (increasingly excessive if social media is anything to go by but this is fortunately not a reflection of the parties we've attended), presents, take home gifts etc which make it crazy. Hosting their friends/class in a running soft play, paying for their meal and giving them a slice of cake is a great birthday celebration for a young child

WishingOnAStar21 · 08/06/2022 15:17

prescribingmum · 08/06/2022 11:20

@StoppinBy this would be the ultimate sin on MN where it is considered extremely grabby to consider asking for what is wanted and needed.

You cannot win, if you specify no gifts, it is rude and no-one wants to come empty handed. According to many PP you are also cruel and denying your child the opportunity to open presents and receive endless stuff that they do not need🙄. If you say money only, you are asking for gifts and that is grabby and rude. If you say nothing, you end up with stuff you need to find a new home for (and usually still ends up in landfill within the next year)....

My personal opinion when hosting (for adults or children) is that the cost of hosting is on me and I do not expect anything in return for doing so. I have invited people because I/my child enjoys their company and that is all I would like. If they feel they must bring something, a consumable item is perfect. When we end up hosting a children's party alone, I will be asking for books or a consumable item

Spot on!

MintJulia · 08/06/2022 14:59

It's a bit joyless and sad isn't it.

my ds always loved choosing presents for his little friends. I'd turn him loose in the market with a budget of £5 and he was very good.

He won't be the hopeless man who sends his wife shopping for own stuff in 20 years time. It's how they learn.

Needmorelego · 08/06/2022 14:17

All these posts about 'to much consumerism' and 'think of the planet dying in a mountain of tat' etc are valid points but really a good change in attitude would be to stop having these ridiculous large parties. No 3 year needs 25 other kids at a party.
I took my daughter to some soft play/rent a church hall type parties a couple of times. Often my daughter never even saw the birthday child or played with them because there was sometimes 40 children there all running around screeching.
Gift was placed on a table (taken home today open later - or going by these posts given to a charity shop) so didn't even get to give the gift to the birthday child.
Thankfully my daughter began to hate these parties so she stopped wanting to go.

Bunnycat101 · 08/06/2022 14:16

It’s a bit tricky if you don’t know the parents but at school there are starting to be more joint gifts at parties so the child gets a bigger toy rather than lots of smaller things. That is working really well and reduces some of the quantity issues while allowing the child to get something they might not have otherwise had.

BuenaVistaAntisocialClub · 08/06/2022 14:01

Requesting no gifts is one of those things that may seem pragmatic and sensible to you but is actually quite a big deal.

When I studied social anthropology there was a big focus on gift-giving in cultures around the world. And how it’s a central social tie, and one of the aspects of virtually every society. To try and change the norms of gift giving in a society can be really disruptive for everyone involved.

There’s a reason gifts are traditionally given and received, and I for one would feel really awkward going to a party for a 3 year old without a gift for them. I’d probably panic at the last minute and buy something cheap, like some sweets or something, in lieu of a proper gif anyway.

dillydally24 · 08/06/2022 13:32

Should have said: @prescribingmum , I am so on your page.

OP posts:
TheRoadToRuin · 08/06/2022 13:19

If he was one or two I would agree. However at three he will know it's the norm to get presents.
Keep them all to the end of the party.
Make sure you note down who gave what.
Put 80% away and let him open the rest.
The remainder you can either re-gift or bring them out when a new toy, reward or distraction is warranted.

dillydally24 · 08/06/2022 13:10

So on your page.

OP posts:
Johnnysgirl · 08/06/2022 12:40

Dear God, a food bank...

thelastshadowpuppet · 08/06/2022 11:34

oh don't do that.

Lollypop701 · 08/06/2022 11:31

set Up a just giving for a Ukrainian childrens charity for donations? Or a local food bank?

prescribingmum · 08/06/2022 11:20

@StoppinBy this would be the ultimate sin on MN where it is considered extremely grabby to consider asking for what is wanted and needed.

You cannot win, if you specify no gifts, it is rude and no-one wants to come empty handed. According to many PP you are also cruel and denying your child the opportunity to open presents and receive endless stuff that they do not need🙄. If you say money only, you are asking for gifts and that is grabby and rude. If you say nothing, you end up with stuff you need to find a new home for (and usually still ends up in landfill within the next year)....

My personal opinion when hosting (for adults or children) is that the cost of hosting is on me and I do not expect anything in return for doing so. I have invited people because I/my child enjoys their company and that is all I would like. If they feel they must bring something, a consumable item is perfect. When we end up hosting a children's party alone, I will be asking for books or a consumable item

StoppinBy · 08/06/2022 05:30

I completely understand where you are coming from BUT would suggest maybe popping on the invites that there is something DS would like and ask people to contribute a small amount towards rather than buying a present.

Then your child gets a present and you get to avoid all the stuff coming in to your house - win/win.

Marvellousmadness · 08/06/2022 05:22

Ive tried it
People ignored the request
So the next birthday party i said on the invitation that all the gifts would be donated to a charity of my choice. So then all the toys went to a good home. It was lovely really .

Sunnytwobridges · 08/06/2022 01:50

I think it’s fine and not rude at all. I think too many kids are focused on stuff and if you teach them young not to always expect to get tons of gifts they will be fine with it. Plus I would be extremely happy not to have to spend money to buy a gift 😂

WishingOnAStar21 · 07/06/2022 23:50

GADDay · 07/06/2022 23:16

I agree with those saying that this thread demonstrates a lot of what is wrong with the world.

Me.Me.MyChild.Me.Me.MyChild.

Fuck the environment, fuck the waste, fuck considering anything but my own selfish "needs".

Can the people who firmly think that little Johnny will be irrevocably damaged by not receiving 25 cheap, irresponsibly manufactured and just not needed gifts, not see the bigger picture?

It's grotesque - this rampant selfish consumerism. Stuff does NOT = happiness, no matter your age.

IMO, a lot of posters are living vicariously through their children. They want to relive the glory days when we were ignorant about the state of the world.

OP - you should start a movement, I would be the first to sign up.

Totally agree @GADDay

It really saddens me that so many people equate happiness to material possessions.

GADDay · 07/06/2022 23:16

I agree with those saying that this thread demonstrates a lot of what is wrong with the world.

Me.Me.MyChild.Me.Me.MyChild.

Fuck the environment, fuck the waste, fuck considering anything but my own selfish "needs".

Can the people who firmly think that little Johnny will be irrevocably damaged by not receiving 25 cheap, irresponsibly manufactured and just not needed gifts, not see the bigger picture?

It's grotesque - this rampant selfish consumerism. Stuff does NOT = happiness, no matter your age.

IMO, a lot of posters are living vicariously through their children. They want to relive the glory days when we were ignorant about the state of the world.

OP - you should start a movement, I would be the first to sign up.

DuesToTheDirt · 07/06/2022 20:37

I did this for my 5 year olds birthday party several years ago now. I was hoping it would start a trend, but I guess I'm not a trend-setter!

SleepingStandingUp · 07/06/2022 20:14

Well I suspect you'll get a load of cash instead tbh @dillydally24 , guests bringing a gift because "they couldn't not", and the rest feeling awkward because they listened to you.

UpInSpace11 · 07/06/2022 20:01

dillydally24 · 07/06/2022 17:13

Except the votes indicate that most people think I am being unreasonable! However the voices out there who say I am not have been persuasive in convincing me that this is the right thing to do. I cannot bear the idea of my 3-year old receiving 25 presents (in addition to those gifted by close family). It's just a bit gross for so many reasons. I am going to request no presents at this party and all future parties. I set the trend with my wedding and I am going to stick with it. I hope others will follow suit.

Op - good for you! 👍😊 Totally agree.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 07/06/2022 19:56

I feel very very sorry for your poor child, what a miserable life he will likely have

seriously, what a mad thing to say!

Youseethethingis1 · 07/06/2022 19:54

I feel very very sorry for your poor child, what a miserable life he will likely have
Interesting point.
One of the saddest things DH ever told me about his childhood was that his mother spent untold fortunes, scraping every penny together, to buy him gifts (which she proudly told me herself she donated most of them in pristine condition to a local creche as he had far too much) and his dad was much more restrained, although he never missed a Christmas or birthday either.So little DH loved his Daddy less. He had been conditioned to believe that his mum loved him more because she spent more money on him.
Wouldn't be so quick to feel sorry for OPs child.
FIL and MIL are now exactly the same with my DS. Mountains of ostentatious shit from MiL taking over the house, a few small gifts and bung for his bank account from FIL. Don't suppose they will ever change.

Swipe left for the next trending thread