Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have a no gift policy for my DC's third birthday?

235 replies

dillydally24 · 07/06/2022 09:23

Just that really. My DC is having a third birthday party which 25 other children will attend. Is it ok to ask that no gifts be given by the other children? My DC will be given a couple of significant presents by me and my DH. I find the flood of gifts for birthdays and Xmas these days completely overwhelming and I don't want it to become the norm for my DC. We already have so much.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DuesToTheDirt · 20/06/2022 20:59

Nanny0gg · 18/06/2022 13:07

I assume you decline gifts for your birthday too?

I can't answer for Julzz, but speaking for myself,
a) I generally ask for experiences (e.g. dinner out) rather than stuff, or charity donations
b) I like most other adults, am never in the position of getting 30+ presents. The child will get presents from their parents, relatives etc. They just don't need such a massive pile of stuff from their classmates.

Nanny0gg · 18/06/2022 13:07

Julezz778 · 12/06/2022 13:45

Absolutely not unreasonable! I've had several parties where I requested no gifts. She's 3, she's just going to be excited for a party! I absolutely agree that it's overwhelming for kids with large amounts of gifts. There's also the kids who's parents can't afford to send a gift and then they're left out of the fun, and that's just heartbreaking to me. I have in the past said gifts aren't necessary, but to make a donation to a charity that was selected on behalf of the birthday child (they adore animals, so make a donation to a local animal shelter.) I applaud you for teaching your child there is more importance than materialistic things. She's gonna be an amazing asset to this world. ❤️

I assume you decline gifts for your birthday too?

PrairiegirlS · 18/06/2022 01:58

You are not being unreasonable. How many toys does a child actually need? We are such a throwaway society based on commercialism. My friend group adopted the No gift policy very early. None of the children missed out and had a great time at the parties. Additionally you should think about those parents who might not be able to afford 25 presents in a group throughout the year.

Johnny956 · 18/06/2022 01:44

Not being unreasonable and it’s pretty common. My daughter I think is going to her 7th birthday party this year and majority of them have no gifts policy on the invitations

Julezz778 · 12/06/2022 13:45

Absolutely not unreasonable! I've had several parties where I requested no gifts. She's 3, she's just going to be excited for a party! I absolutely agree that it's overwhelming for kids with large amounts of gifts. There's also the kids who's parents can't afford to send a gift and then they're left out of the fun, and that's just heartbreaking to me. I have in the past said gifts aren't necessary, but to make a donation to a charity that was selected on behalf of the birthday child (they adore animals, so make a donation to a local animal shelter.) I applaud you for teaching your child there is more importance than materialistic things. She's gonna be an amazing asset to this world. ❤️

FriendshipBunny · 10/06/2022 08:01

You are not being unreasonable. I share a son with my ex, who married into a large and close-knit family. My son usually gets upward of 40 presents for his birthday, and it's become a huge problem. He has stacks and stacks of unopened gifts from years upon years ago. The things he has opened, he barely touches. Its bad for the environment, my son doesn't enjoy unwrapping gifts for so long (abd my son is 8, not 3), he doesn't appreciate gifts as much. Like, nothing about it is good. People are saying you can donate them. That's like saying it's okay for someone to break into your house and rummage around, because you can just clean it later. It's very difficult to get a child to agree to donate his toys, even though he doesnt play with them, and getting to a thrift store is an extra burden you don't need. I ask people to take my son on an outing instead, buy tickets to a movie for him or donate to a college fund. something like that. A card with a nice letter. You're going to have to haul 25 gifts home, then find a sneaky way to get them out of your home. Its best to just avoid it. Not to mention, it teaches a bad lesson about consumerism.

Mlew1 · 10/06/2022 03:58

I just did this for my 6 year oldest birthday last week. He knew ahead of time that his friends weren't bringing gifts and he was more excited that everyone invited was able to attend. We gave him some toys that he has wanted for a while and loves. No one questioned the decision not to have gifts. Instead, several of the kids gave him hand written cards that he loved.

dillydally24 · 09/06/2022 22:47

100% agree @Mumof3FSE

OP posts:
dillydally24 · 09/06/2022 22:46

Thank you, @woody87 and @NurseSalt. Good advice. x

OP posts:
Mumof3FSE · 09/06/2022 21:12

I dont think you're being unreasonable at all. Often gifts are token/cheap and fill your house with more things that really aren't needed. We recently went to a joint 6yrs old birthday and it was written on the invite no gift please but donation to Ukraine unicef appeal or Water Aid instead pls. I thought that was such a lovely idea. A 3 Yr old really won't be so worried about gifts, they will be far too excited to see and play with their friends.

NurseSalt · 09/06/2022 19:47

I don't think you are being unreasonable at all! Some parents will send gifts anyway. Honestly, he's 3 and probably will not notice, especially if he has your gifts to open at the party.
I know my opinion is unpopular, but this is not unusual where I live. We are also moving away from over the top goody bags and parties. All the over the top parties seem to be more about the parents competing than the kids having fun. Kids need to know how to make their own fun. Pizza, games and a jumpy are the best parties. For those saying it's not about you, in my experience, the kids are too distracted by the sight of the gifts to have fun. The party is about him having fun with his friends. Keep it simple.

woody87 · 09/06/2022 19:33

Can't vote as on the app but YANBU and everyone on this thread saying that you are being mean to your child are idiots, he is 3 ffs.

Why on Earth would anyone want to receive 25 individual gifts for a 3 year old, which will more than likely be plastic shite from B&M.

I know exactly how you feel because I like to be as minimalist as possible and feel completely overwhelmed by the amount of presents that people buy my kids at Christmas and birthdays. Luckily my own DF listens to my requests for clothes vouchers etc but FIL is terrible for buying as much crap as possible.

Every Christmas and birthday I screen most of my toddlers presents and then donate them, if you have a bit of storage space then my advice is to put them away and then wait for the Christmas toy appeals, they really appreciate the donations, particularly when the toys are still in the packaging, I would much rather give the toys to families who literally can't afford anything (even more pertinent at the moment given the cost of living crisis)

Johnnysgirl · 09/06/2022 19:13

Needmorelego · 08/06/2022 21:04

Rather amusingly I am getting ads for Build a Bear Parties on this thread

They're the greatest con going.
Dd went to one years ago, and the "party" consisted of the children being escorted by staff round the shelves choosing the accessories (and being egged on to choose right up to the parent's agreed budget Hmm), queuing to get the bear stuffed, and posing for a group photo with the bears.
I think they sang Happy Birthday too, but the shop was obviously open to all other customers as well so it was total chaos.
The child's parents were rightly rooked, IMO.

laurajayneinkent · 09/06/2022 19:03

My friend did a bday party for her son and each child was asked to bring a wrapped book with them, these were then given out to all the children at the end - a lovely idea!! And no flood of presents for the birthday child (I agree it's overwhelming, our kids have too much STUFF these days!!!) :)

MrsR2018 · 09/06/2022 19:02

@dillydally24 we did this in April for my DS’s 3rd birthday. I put a note on the invitations as a little poem at the bottom. He still ended up with SO MUCH STUFF 🤣🥴
I definitely think it’s acceptable and did a sigh of relief when a couple of invites we got said the same thing.

HistoricMoment · 09/06/2022 06:41

SleepingStandingUp · 09/06/2022 00:30

DD's school has a rule that if having a party in Reception and Y1, it must be a whole class party. I feel it is fair as avoids all bad feelings at this young age where friendships are transient but of course, it means hosting for up to 30 once siblings are added in. They have all been soft play/bouncy castle/entertainer party and usually hosted by more than one family where birthdays are close together.
Do you live in an affluent area @prescribingmum ?@prescribingmum ? This seems ludicrous to me. You can only have a party with school friends if you can afford to pay hundreds? My friend looked into booking soft play party for the whole class, at nearly £400. DS wanted to go bowling for him. At £10 a head. He got to invite 7 school friends.

I agree. I couldn't afford a party for the whole class. Quite apart from the stress and work involved in hosting dozens of kids, and the responsibility of looking after them!
I also wouldn't want my children to attend 20+ parties a year.
I am glad parties are usually small where we live. DC1 once didn't get invited to a party of a boy he was friends with and was quite disappointed. I felt very sad for him but we both got over it.

SleepingStandingUp · 09/06/2022 00:30

DD's school has a rule that if having a party in Reception and Y1, it must be a whole class party. I feel it is fair as avoids all bad feelings at this young age where friendships are transient but of course, it means hosting for up to 30 once siblings are added in. They have all been soft play/bouncy castle/entertainer party and usually hosted by more than one family where birthdays are close together.
Do you live in an affluent area @prescribingmum ?@prescribingmum ? This seems ludicrous to me. You can only have a party with school friends if you can afford to pay hundreds? My friend looked into booking soft play party for the whole class, at nearly £400. DS wanted to go bowling for him. At £10 a head. He got to invite 7 school friends.

Ridingoutthewaves · 08/06/2022 21:06

I think it’s a great idea , and much better for the planet to have less plastic crap bought. 3 is far to young to care or even have an interest in opening that many gifts. We have done similar 😊

Needmorelego · 08/06/2022 21:04

Rather amusingly I am getting ads for Build a Bear Parties on this thread

MRex · 08/06/2022 20:42

Turnthatoff · 08/06/2022 17:16

I’m in favour of a no gift policy. I did it a couple of times. When my kids were invited to a no-gift party I’d get them to draw a picture or something. The last time was for a 6th birthday party.

I love this for full class parties! Instead of card and present, every child must draw a picture / sticker art / playdo character / whatever for the birthday child and put their name on it, plus group birthday child parties. I'm going to be suggesting this to the YR class group before September!

Needmorelego · 08/06/2022 19:39

@prescribingmum I am very curious what the school can possibly think they can do though if they found out a child had a party with just half a dozen classmates?
Expel the child? Ban the parents from sports day? Say the child can't go to the Christmas disco?
Seriously.... it's none of their beeswax.

prescribingmum · 08/06/2022 19:20

I'm making assumptions here as the policy was in place before we joined. I can only assume it exists because of incident(s) in the past, especially if it is so unusual.

I've heard of parents retaliating and not inviting at other schools on the grapevine, again it's not first hand experience.

Fortunately parents of DD's classmates have been lovely so far and we've had no issues. The policy doesn't bother me, it applies for first 2 years only and we hosted a joint party in reception for the class. The next will be a smaller party for close friends after Y2

Johnnysgirl · 08/06/2022 19:11

Fair enough, so. There must be some right arses at your school, though, for such a policy to be needed.
No school in my experience has ever had parents retaliating against a child by dropping them from the guest list of their own child's party.
It doesn't mean all kids go to all parties, they just invite their friends.

prescribingmum · 08/06/2022 19:02

@Johnnysgirl I assure you there is absolutely no room for misinterpretation. It is not hidden in a policy but was written in black and white in the paperwork given when starting reception (alongside uniform info, daily routine etc).

I read it as subject to common sense and didn't realise it was so unusual. I have heard on grapevine of cases where parents don't invite children in retaliation at other schools (no firsthand experience).

It's not come up as topic of contention on our parents groups or any meet ups either

Johnnysgirl · 08/06/2022 18:46

prescribingmum · 08/06/2022 18:08

Of course there are playdates with just a few children and I have no doubt some will fall on birthdays and include a little cake. DD has a nursery friend in school with an Aug birthday so when they had a little get together over the summer with nursery friends, just DD was there and no others from school. School doesn't care about that

It is clear the aim of the rule is to avoid someone having a big party and avoid inviting just 2-3 children in the class which causes bad feeling all round. The school succeeds in this so there is no resistance from parents

DD has a nursery friend in school with an Aug birthday so when they had a little get together over the summer with nursery friends, just DD was there and no others from school. School doesn't care about that
Confused. I should bloody well hope they don't!
Not calling you a liar, but I'm still convinced you've misinterpreted some sort of guideline.

Swipe left for the next trending thread