Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Difference between being tight and being unable to afford stuff

79 replies

Zoooooom · 07/06/2022 06:21

Sometimes I feel like it's not always clear, especially when you have friends on higher salaries, it's easy to come across as stingy but it's different when you genuinely can't afford the same things.
A guy in the past used to call me a cheapskate just because I liked charity shops etc. However I was only on 17k a year.
I do worry about this sometimes

OP posts:
Bluevelvetsofa · 07/06/2022 09:13

I think that there’s a fine line between being frugal and being tight.

I worked with someone who would join in with a group meal at a restaurant, but would always choose the least expensive option on the menu, only ever drank tap water and worked out his portion of the bill to the last penny. I know that there were no financial constraints to prevent him choosing more expensive options, so it was a question of always spending the least amount of money. It seemed joyless to me.

I understand that people don’t want to be subsidising others, if you don’t drink and everyone else is buying bottles etc, but to always go for the cheapest option is certainly frugal.

rookiemere · 07/06/2022 09:02

@gannett I hate taking taxis too unless there's no other option. My friends laugh at me but it means I get extra steps and save a minimum of £10 per trip.

gannett · 07/06/2022 08:59

IMO people who quickly label others as "tight" are showing themselves in a worse light. It's judgmental and often entitled. They usually don't really know the other person's financial affairs or priorities and often it's in the context of "why hasn't my BFF splashed out on MY present" or "why hasn't this man on a first date splashed out on ME".

I'm comfortably off but I've been broke and having to get through weeks with nothing in my bank account. Certain frugal habits stick with you and that's a good thing. I walk and take public transport rather than take a taxi, I don't shop for leisure, I shop in charity shops, I refuse to pay anything that I don't perceive to be worth it.

I don't have any issues spending money on things that I prioritise - food is one, hosting friends is another, supporting activist campaigns that are close to my heart is another.

But opting out of consumerism and materialism often makes people who don't do that judge you as tight.

Sswhinesthebest · 07/06/2022 08:57

for example if a friend asked me for a drink and it was a tight month, I’d still go and buy a single pint of cider and make it last, and the friend would probably buy me another drink or two as if they were skint, I’d do the same.

Thats ok and not tight because it’s reciprocal. Being tight would be accepting all the drinks but never doing the same back, even if you can afford it at other times. Nothing wrong with going and nursing a single drink all night if you don’t intend to reciprocate. And also nothing wrong accepting if you genuinely can’t afford to reciprocate.

My old group of friends and I are still smarting from years ago when we frequently bought drinks for our skint friend. We didn’t mind until she went on a round the world trip and we realised we’d part paid for that, with all her free drinks!

Greenfinch7 · 07/06/2022 08:45

My father was what you would consider tight. Heating low, never bought takeaway coffees, would walk to avoid paying for parking, steamed stamps off envelopes, etc. He was also incredibly generous- gave away very large sums of money both to charity and to struggling friends/acquaintances, and did it with no hint of a string attached.

His priorities were for paying for what he considered important: education, certain cultural things, caring for people who were in trouble. He hated wasting money on things he considered unimportant. I don't find that tight.

MistyFuckingQuigley · 07/06/2022 08:34

Fritilleries · 07/06/2022 08:13

If you read my post you'd have seen I save a chunk on payday so anything left at the END of the month is pocket money which I choose either to spend or save. Not hard is it?

*Being tight is having money left over from bills etc and not spending it.

Being unable to afford anything is having no money left or a stonking big overdraft/debt that you have to use.

I like charity shops cos I like my money, hope this helps. I'm similarly frugal.*

I was responding to this post dear. You don't mention anything about saving.

Farawayfromhere · 07/06/2022 08:33

I think being ‘tight’ means being unkind with money. Eg always letting other people buy you things and not buying back. (But not explaining at the start that you cannot buy back, and allowing them to choose whether to spend anyway.)

It shouldn’t ever be tight to chose not to spend money on something because you are sensible and either don’t want it or want to spend the money elsewhere or save it. Or because you can’t afford it.

I hate when people are made to feel tight.
Insisting people spend is like forcing people to eat or to drink alcohol when they say they don’t want to.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 07/06/2022 08:29

Another example is we didn’t get new furniture for our baby’s room. In fact it’s not finished - we have ikea Kallax in flat pack (ok so that was new but about £30!) still to assemble and a second hand wardrobe I got free, sanded painted and up cycled. I enjoyed the process of painting it, changing the handles etc and would do it again! Plus it only cost about £12 for materials. We haven’t got a cot or a changing table, baby sleeps in a next to me bed and I change her on the floor where she won’t accidentally roll off! However a friend was talking about how they are due their baby in September and are having to forgo their planned weekend away in summer as they’ve spent a fortune on the nursery. To them that’s what you do - you are having a baby, you go to John Lewis and buy the whole furniture set, everything matches and it’s unthinkable to not have the nursery ‘done’. To me it’s not a priority and I’d rather have the money to go away for a few days! Or in our case we have used that money we didn’t spend on a new dishwasher. Whether this makes me terrible I don’t know but another example of different levels of not being the same in priorities. Truly skint is not being able to even afford the tin of paint to paint a free wardrobe because you wouldn’t have the money for the electric meter that week if you bought it.

LoudingVoice · 07/06/2022 08:29

DurhamDurham · 07/06/2022 08:20

I think there is a difference but it sometimes overlaps. If you can't afford an outing or a meal out and arrive expecting or hoping other people will pay for you that can be seen as being 'tight'. If you can't afford it you shouldn't go. People who don't pay for their round at the bar are the worst.
Nothing wrong with charity shops and there's been a definite shift in the last few years, it's recognised as being environmentally friendly to shop there.

Yes I agree, knowing something is out of your budget and declining and invite is sensible/understandable.

rookiemere · 07/06/2022 08:26

I probably do a few things that would be considered tight on here - but then thankfully so do my friends.

For example I've read here that if you book something and it has say a £5 per head deposit, it's tight to ask for that money back from a friend. But I'd always do that unless I was treating.

Also on holiday with friends we now use splitwise so all drinks etc end up
Getting shared out cost wise - tight - maybe but very fair.

PinkSyCo · 07/06/2022 08:25

Your ex is an idiot. As well as being ethical shopping from charity shops can be fun. And being frugal is sensible, whereas being tight is miserly and mean. Two completely different things.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 07/06/2022 08:24

I do sometimes think people prioritize different things and others can’t see the perspective

for example if a friend asked me for a drink and it was a tight month, I’d still go and buy a single pint of cider and make it last, and the friend would probably buy me another drink or two as if they were skint, I’d do the same. And the £3/4 or whatever I’d just have to knock off the budget for that month - probably come off the food shop. To me that isn’t the difference between eating and not eating but to some people I know it is.

however lots of people would think going to the pub for a pint with a friend is a waste of £3 or whatever and it could be saved or whatever, and would say no I can’t come out, I’ve not saved any money this month. To me that’s not skint that’s just not prioritizing people - that pint and a chat could be the thing that saves a friends mental health or gets them through a tough time, but that’s my own perspective and priorities not someone else’s

LoudingVoice · 07/06/2022 08:22

Fritilleries · 07/06/2022 06:40

Being tight is having money left over from bills etc and not spending it.

Being unable to afford anything is having no money left or a stonking big overdraft/debt that you have to use.

I like charity shops cos I like my money, hope this helps. I'm similarly frugal.

I don’t think it’s necessarily tight to have money left over and not spend it, saving money rather than just frittering it away because you’ve got some left at the end of the month is just sensible.

I think being tight is having the money but expecting other people to foot your bill, despite being able to afford it.

I love a charity shop too by the way and buy loads of things second hand, it makes my money go further and it’s more environmentally friendly too.

DurhamDurham · 07/06/2022 08:20

I think there is a difference but it sometimes overlaps. If you can't afford an outing or a meal out and arrive expecting or hoping other people will pay for you that can be seen as being 'tight'. If you can't afford it you shouldn't go. People who don't pay for their round at the bar are the worst.
Nothing wrong with charity shops and there's been a definite shift in the last few years, it's recognised as being environmentally friendly to shop there.

mubarak86 · 07/06/2022 08:19

I have a limited amount of money and make sure I allocate it for what us best for my family. I've been called tight before, but I don't care. I refuse to go away on hen weekends, don't like going out for dinner, don't have recent tech to name a few. I have friends that would prioritise the hen weekend because that is their thing. It's horses for courses really.

MiddleParking · 07/06/2022 08:17

ChiselandBits · 07/06/2022 07:00

as others have said its a relative thing. My favourite example though is DP, when I first met him, would take me out for a meal, cocktails etc and always pick up the bill but park much further out of town than he needed too cos it was free instead of a couple of quid to park. I gently took the mick until he got the hint because I actually found it really unattractive - like he wanted to be seen to be really generous and gentlemanly in the bar/ restaurant but didn't care about me walking in the rain or heels or whatever. He worked it out after a few times of me absolutely insisting we park closer and paying for the car park if it was a problem. Tight is inconveniencing or scabbing off someone else when you could but won't pay.

See, I agree with your last sentence generally, but I don’t think he’s being ‘tight’ in that specific scenario, especially if he’s picking up the whole dinner bill. It’s just different priorities again. I think food and drink is worth spending money on and paying for parking to avoid a walk isn’t (unless it’s monsoon weather).

Ragwort · 07/06/2022 08:15

There's a big difference between being tight and being frugal as others say; I am pretty frugal and love charity shops (I manage one Grin), wouldn't dream of buying clothes 'new' and don't 'eat out' just for the sake of it regularly. There was a thread on here a couple of weeks ago when a mumsnetters was taking a picnic on a day out and had no idea what a 'picnic' was.

But being tight would be not sharing a round, refusing to treat a friend to a coffee, insisting on a picnic on a freezing cold day in the park. If you have a choice (and I fully appreciate that not everyone does) it comes down to what you perceive as 'value for money'. I am a competent cook and can easily recreate restaurant quality food at home, I don't want or need to pay for 'entertainment' (concerts, theatre etc) but we paid off our mortgage in our 40s, DH retired early and I can afford to work part time.

people might think us 'tight' if we don't want to go to an expensive restaurant or holiday but generally who cares what other people think, if you have confidence in your own choices then it really doesn't matter.

Fritilleries · 07/06/2022 08:13

MistyFuckingQuigley · 07/06/2022 07:57

*Fritilleries · Today 06:40

Being tight is having money left over from bills etc and not spending it.*

No dear that's called saving

If you read my post you'd have seen I save a chunk on payday so anything left at the END of the month is pocket money which I choose either to spend or save. Not hard is it?

ItoldyouIwastrouble · 07/06/2022 08:11

Could they sell it to a friend cheap, then split the difference.? So say, sell to friend for 300+admin, then he pays your daughter 150. So they are just out of pocket 150 each, friend gets a bargain holiday and it's more likely to sell.

Sswhinesthebest · 07/06/2022 08:05

I think it’s ok to say you don’t want to spend money on this, that or the other, as you are saving for something etc , but it’s not ok to keep accepting someone else saying they’ll buy it. Occasionally yes, frequently, no! That’s tight. Just don’t accept unless you pay back in some other non monetary way.

If you genuinely have no money at all, then that is a different matter! I don’t think people mind helping out then.

MistyFuckingQuigley · 07/06/2022 07:57

*Fritilleries · Today 06:40

Being tight is having money left over from bills etc and not spending it.*

No dear that's called saving

Onionpatch · 07/06/2022 07:56

To me tight is more about how you treat others, so going out for coffeee but not taking your turn paying even though you can, or leaving before your round, or buying gifts for people in charity shops when you wouldnt dream of buying something for yourself from there, or turning up empty handed at a pot luck supper - even though you could easily afford to make a dish.

Buying things for yourself from a charity shop is just spending the money you have in the best way you can to me.

thecatsthecats · 07/06/2022 07:51

Frugal is when you make financial decisions that only affect you.

Tight is when you enforce that on other people, and always aim to have the upper hand of not "being had" when no one is trying to "have" you.

But then I turned down a meet up with a friend because I spent my fun money for the month, I need new tyres etc - but mainly because I treat my pension overpayment as a bill I can't afford not to pay. Some people would call that tight.

Trisolaris · 07/06/2022 07:49

For me being tight is about a lack of generosity not how frugal you are.

eg you spend loads on yourself but get cheap gifts for your friends - tight

you are hard up and spend hardly anything on yourself but still get a cheap gift for your friend for their birthday - not tight.

you are trying to save money and have a good income so economise where you can but still always bring a gift for the host - not tight

you have a good income and are trying to save money so decide to do this by not buying any gifts for anyone at all (but happy to accept) - tight

BarbaraofSeville · 07/06/2022 07:49

I don't object to buying nice food on days out, even if it's a bit expensive. But what I do object to is paying attraction prices for nasty fast food or fridge cold factory sandwiches. That's not something that adds to a day out, its a punishment.