Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

London Transport Unions

35 replies

Finallylostit · 06/06/2022 21:19

Today instead of my 10 min walk to the tube and into work - I had to drive 20 mins to a national rail station which was open, pay nearly £20 for parking , an extra £22 on a train ticket to arrive in London.

I then had the choice of joining the queue for the bus- what a joke!
Join the queue for a taxi ha ha 123 in the queue and taxis turning up every 3-4 minutes or walking.
I walked 15234 steps

After standing working in an NHS hospital my 11 hr shift ended and walked 16284 steps back to the train station to catch the train home

An expense I did not need from a bunch of people who have just had a massive pay rise and this is not about safety because if it was - then please tell me when we can see a member of staff on the platform at Harrow on the Hill - helping people with buggies, disabled etc jump from platform to platform as you change them every 5 mins.

The thought of doing it again tomorrow is just depressing.

There is a cost of living crisis, spending an unnecessary £42 today which I can ill afford is not good.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DdraigGoch · 07/06/2022 20:55

Fairisleflora · 07/06/2022 16:44

It takes 6 months to train an underground driver. That’s all. It’s hardly as though their job is remotely tricky. And yet they are paid salaries nurses can only dream of. This strike is a joke!

If it's such an easy and well-remunerated job then why haven't you applied? Have you ever actually driven a train? It's not as easy as you think, anyone can get one moving but stopping steel wheels on steel rails accurately is an art form, especially with a slippery railhead.

Never mind the fact that RMT members are mostly not drivers and therefore are on significantly less money with added aggro (they're more likely to have to deal with drunk/drugged/aggressive passengers than drivers are).

For all of you banging on about automation, forget it. The capex required to automate the tube stretches into billions and you still need a human onboard to supervise because funnily enough sending thousands of people (in whatever state of inebriation) into tunnels with no one on hand if something goes wrong is a recipe for chaos.

If TfL are struggling for funds, perhaps they ought to review some of the Mayor's vanity projects.

Finallylostit · 07/06/2022 18:26

I have no issues with unions am a member of one myself - but striking to the inconvenience of hundreds of thousands of people, endangering peoples lives and livelihoods - no I do not agree with.

Moving with the times and accepting practices change with technology, different ways of working etc - yes I do support

WE are all facing an increase in costs - but to have an additional unnecessary cost thrust on me, by people who may gain something but it will make absolutely no difference to my daily life - es I m entitled to be pissed off about.

If TFL is not getting enough monies from fares, then they need to look at where monies can be saved and part of that is staffing costs,

Still rarely seen a platform assistant on my commute which is where they are needed not sitting in the office!

OP posts:
BorisJohnsonsvomitbucket · 07/06/2022 17:34

Hello everyone. I am a tube station supervisor at a group of tube stations.

I was fortunate to not have to strike yesterday because of a rostered rest day. But If I was rostered on, I would have striked.

I just want to echo others that have knowledge of what's going on. Either as a staff member or partner of a staff member. Everything they are saying is correct.

My wage rise was part of a deal struck three years ago. TfL couldn't have predicted the rise in RPI back then. Unfortunately they preferred multiple-year pay deals. It came back to bite them on the bum. I don't think they will be doing it again.

Whilst my wage has increased over those years, my husband's has not. He's a postal worker. Postal workers have been offered a 2,2% pay rise this year, but to get that they have to work until 8pm, work Sundays and Bank Holidays. Since privatisation, postal workers real-time wages have reduced, whilst Royal Mail have cut staff to the bone. So my wages are now just about keeping us afloat. We live in a tiny flat in South London, mortgaged, and that's all we can afford. But going back to the postal workers, they are heading for strike too. Just like the couriers, airport staff, cabin crew, barristers (I was surprised how poorly paid they are) and of course the incoming national rail strike. Many TfL workers have partners whose wages have stagnated. Including healthcare staff.

I'll tell you how valuable having station staff is. About a month ago, a young woman approached me and said she was being followed. She said she lived a five minute walk away. It was 11.30pm. So I told the relevant people I'd be absent for a bit, opened all the gates, and accompanied her home. If she lived further away, I would have arranged a taxi. She comes back to see me often to say hello. Even her brother has visited to say thank you.

Some of my colleagues speak languages other than English. Vital in an emergency, or when talking about fares, or directions.

We assist people with extra needs. We guide people with visual impairment. We assist mobility impaired customers navigating stations with lifts and escalators. We help those with both obvious and hidden disabilities. We help when people fall ill on trains. We help when people cause hurt and distress to other people. We help when people want to hurt themselves.

We also do various things on and around the track to help keep the service going if needed. We crowd-control. We give information. We act on it too.

Usually I work by myself but have a part-timer at busy times. If I lose those part-timers, I am sunk. I can't manage my ticket hall and pull a sick person from a train at the same time. I can't help with an Oyster query and try and locate a lost suitcase concurrently. Just can't be done. So I'm fighting for their job. And around 600 others. You cannot automate us.

(Train automation requires billions of pounds of investment that TfL doesn't have so if you want to chat about that, we just say, "huh, that old chestnut")

I know what the Government want, and thats to sell off TfL. That's the background battle. But look at what happened after privatisation at Royal Mail. A bloody fire sale.

So in all, I empathise with OP. But if you want things to change, you have to take direct action. Yes, nurses etc need to threaten strikes! The threat of being bloody inconvenient changes things. (Green Park and Euston threatened to strike over a bullying manager during the Jubilee weekend and withdrew when that manager was moved) You have to join a union and you have to take part. There's a union for everyone. Yes, people moan about unions but we don't have anywhere near the same rights as in the 70s (look up anti-union laws brought in by the Tories). You don't even have to strike, but if your job relies on OT, don't do it. If your expected to look at emails and take phone calls after hours, turn off your devices. Being difficult works.

But anyway. I've typed enough. That's my take.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 07/06/2022 17:00

DdraigGoch · 07/06/2022 00:08

I'd like to see how a robot would deal with a train full of Saturday night drunks.

Have you ever seen Robocop? :)

Fairisleflora · 07/06/2022 16:55

Dear god, read your post again! 6 months training is nothing!!! And I’m pretty sure if the tube breaks down the driver doesn’t get out a spanner and get on his hands and knees to fix it. They get 43 days holiday.

And guess what, everyone in employment pays tax and ni! If you earn £30k then tax and NI eats up your salary so you get £24k. Being a tube driver sounds good. I’d apply, but I can’t as apparently TfL and the unions have an agreement that the general public are not allowed to apply for the driver training scheme.

stopringingme · 07/06/2022 16:48

It was station staff on strike not drivers.

I do wish posters would learn about something before posting - drivers are trained for at least six months before being able to drive on their own, they are then retested each year.

They have to be able to fix the train.

They are given their holidays and the only guaranteed day off is Christmas day.

They are also on a rota so very few weekends off.

It is shift work including nights.

The pay rise is swallowed up by the tax/national insurance and everything else, it is not the golden paying job some seem to think. After you take the amount of tax/national insurance paid out of the equation it is not well paid.

Unions are needed by the workers as TFL are always trying to squeeze every last drop out of the workers.

Station staff are needed, and they need more than one at each station for health and safety.

As in all jobs you get good and bad - that is life.

Do not believes everything you read in the newspapers.

Fairisleflora · 07/06/2022 16:46

The basic salary is over £50k. No sympathy whatsoever!

Fairisleflora · 07/06/2022 16:44

It takes 6 months to train an underground driver. That’s all. It’s hardly as though their job is remotely tricky. And yet they are paid salaries nurses can only dream of. This strike is a joke!

dreamingbohemian · 07/06/2022 16:25

How the hell can anyone think driving a train is an unskilled job. And no, we will not have automated tube trains for a very long time, there are considerable safety reasons for that.

Station staff are not just there to provide customer service, they are there to maintain safety especially in case of emergencies. Sadly people do jump in front of trains a lot, there are accidents and fights, all sorts of things happen that people need to manage so everyone else is safe.

There are about 2.5 million tube journeys every day. I don't think people really appreciate what a massive undertaking it is to move that many people around a large city safely. Of course not every TFL employee is amazing, of course you can dispute whether they should be striking or not, but these attitudes that you can rid of most of the staff and they're all unskilled, I mean wtf.

lonelyapple · 07/06/2022 16:18

sst1234 · 06/06/2022 22:17

The sooner their jobs are automated, the better.

This ^.

Fairisleflora · 07/06/2022 16:07

I’m with you OP. Can’t the drivers and staff see that their jobs are unskilled and automation is making their jobs obsolete and that is not a bad thing. Why prop up their employment, fund tfl to keep paying them if their jobs aren’t needs? Why can’t the money that goes on keeping 3 people staffing one station at the same time be reduced to funding one person and the money saved go into bringing down fares? This makes sense. The people made redundant can get other jobs. There are lots going currently.

And why should we pay for tfl to pay their staff final salary pensions when 90% of the rest of us don’t have such a generous benefit?

SherbetDips · 07/06/2022 15:53

I know it’s disgusting, tube drivers have it pretty good and I’m fed up of being held to ransom by them.

londonmummy1966 · 07/06/2022 15:45

The real place to direct your ire OP is successive governments who failed to invest in a decent public transport system. TfL is pretty well bankrupt and the government's advice was to start charging kids. A well run, subsidised public transport system that provided a good service across the whole country would not only be good for the planet but help lots of people out of poverty - being able to access better job prospects/better education etc.

orwellwasright · 07/06/2022 14:54

But as someone said this was going on in the 70s and will continue whilst the unions refuse to move with the times and work in the 21st century

How old are you? If you think unions have the same influence and MO as they did in the 70s then you can't have heard of Thatcher.

orwellwasright · 07/06/2022 14:51

Wouldn't it be good if we had strikes that didn't actually inconvenience anyone. Like teachers striking in the school holidays etc.

Something to think about, no?

Finallylostit · 07/06/2022 14:49

If it was all about my inconvenience then fine - I would not have come to work and 20-30 people needing treatment would not have been seen - I chose to come in and yes it was a nightmare, nothing selfish in my actions

Was it nightmare for the workers, union of tfl staff - absolutely not!

AS to educate my self - I have - job cuts will make no difference to the 5-6 members of staff who sit at the entry gates at harrow on the hill, grunt if you ask question and dare to stop their conversation. Are they down on the platforms helping their customers jump from platform to platform by the bridge or tunnels - are they heck. So cutting staff will make no difference to safety.

Pensions - everyone has seen a fall in their pensions, Why do they feel they are immune
At the end of the day - you are employed to provide a service , as am I and many others who were hugely inconvenienced and lost monies from one groups action. But as someone said this was going on in the 70s and will continue whilst the unions refuse to move with the times and work in the 21st century

OP posts:
Pyewhacket · 07/06/2022 03:41

Lockheart · 06/06/2022 21:23

please tell me when we can see a member of staff on the platform at Harrow on the Hill

Given they were striking against job cuts then I trust you'll be supporting them.

londonist.com/london/transport/tube-strike-6-june-2022

Are you taking the piss ?

Meh2020 · 07/06/2022 02:59

TheHomeContact · 07/06/2022 02:11

They're striking against job cuts and against having their pension taken away.

I get so cross about this assumption, not helped by how certain newspapers bring out the wages thing.

The payrise isn't a lot and has been totally swallowed. I know this because my partner is a tube driver. We rely solely on his income because I'm disabled. The wage isn't actually as much as the papers like to say, but it's not bad.

However. We can't afford to live here. We live in little more than a box. For logistical, practical reasons we cannot move far away to somewhere cheap, for another five years.

Our NHS staff (particularly those who aren't consultants or higher level nurses etc) need to be paid more, the nursing degrees need subsidising properly with bursaries, and there needs to be more staff per shift in most departments across the board.

In order to make this happen, the union for nhs staff needs to action more strikes. There needs to be more effort, more frequently etc.

Just because one vocation has got a decent union who manages to negotiate for basic workers rights, doesn't mean they are then deserving of the utter scorn and rudeness they receive from those in other professions.

Yes the strike was inconvenient. But what use would a strike be if it wasn't. The union for nhs staff needs to make a nuisance of itself with all of your colleagues backing the action. I know it's difficult for departments delivering 24/7 care to those who will die without it but the union with the NHS staff's support should be able to work out what strikes CAN be actioned.

We are literally just on that cusp which means we don't get any benefits etc for my conditions - just my pip. Yet having a tube driver partner doesn't give us holidays, we run one car but don't take it out where possible because of fuel costs, the mortgage on this tiny stupid box is the same as local rent costs, we can't save in order to afford the fees involved in moving.

We don't like to complain because we could be miles worse off. But if they cut my partner's job, we are done - he doesn't have any decent qualifications. If they take their pensions, we are screwed. The minor wage increase was swallowed by an increase in our mortgage payments, making us worse.off than we already were.

Again: it's not ideal you had a bad day because of the strikes. But the union is doing the level of job for its members which all other unions should be doing for theirs.

Excellent post - you’ve articulated really well. It really does feel like a race to the bottom with how some people think.

TheHomeContact · 07/06/2022 02:11

They're striking against job cuts and against having their pension taken away.

I get so cross about this assumption, not helped by how certain newspapers bring out the wages thing.

The payrise isn't a lot and has been totally swallowed. I know this because my partner is a tube driver. We rely solely on his income because I'm disabled. The wage isn't actually as much as the papers like to say, but it's not bad.

However. We can't afford to live here. We live in little more than a box. For logistical, practical reasons we cannot move far away to somewhere cheap, for another five years.

Our NHS staff (particularly those who aren't consultants or higher level nurses etc) need to be paid more, the nursing degrees need subsidising properly with bursaries, and there needs to be more staff per shift in most departments across the board.

In order to make this happen, the union for nhs staff needs to action more strikes. There needs to be more effort, more frequently etc.

Just because one vocation has got a decent union who manages to negotiate for basic workers rights, doesn't mean they are then deserving of the utter scorn and rudeness they receive from those in other professions.

Yes the strike was inconvenient. But what use would a strike be if it wasn't. The union for nhs staff needs to make a nuisance of itself with all of your colleagues backing the action. I know it's difficult for departments delivering 24/7 care to those who will die without it but the union with the NHS staff's support should be able to work out what strikes CAN be actioned.

We are literally just on that cusp which means we don't get any benefits etc for my conditions - just my pip. Yet having a tube driver partner doesn't give us holidays, we run one car but don't take it out where possible because of fuel costs, the mortgage on this tiny stupid box is the same as local rent costs, we can't save in order to afford the fees involved in moving.

We don't like to complain because we could be miles worse off. But if they cut my partner's job, we are done - he doesn't have any decent qualifications. If they take their pensions, we are screwed. The minor wage increase was swallowed by an increase in our mortgage payments, making us worse.off than we already were.

Again: it's not ideal you had a bad day because of the strikes. But the union is doing the level of job for its members which all other unions should be doing for theirs.

dreamingbohemian · 07/06/2022 01:43

Meh2020 · 07/06/2022 01:06

completely off topic but that’s not that far!

That's like 20 minutes 😆

Meh2020 · 07/06/2022 01:06

UrsulaPandress · 06/06/2022 22:22

I remember getting blisters during the tube strikes in the 1980s. Had to walk to Soho from Waterloo

Plus ca change.

completely off topic but that’s not that far!

user1471457751 · 07/06/2022 00:53

Tfl are essentially bankrupt, they are relying on government bailouts. Services are only about 70% of pre-pandemic level. That, coupled with ever-increasing use of contactless cards, means there isn't a demand for staff as there used to be. And as for pensions, they are still offering final salary schemes. I don't agree that taxes should be used to fund final salary pension schemes, they no longer do for nurses, teachers, civil servants etc. So why should TfL staff be any different?

DdraigGoch · 07/06/2022 00:08

sst1234 · 06/06/2022 22:17

The sooner their jobs are automated, the better.

I'd like to see how a robot would deal with a train full of Saturday night drunks.

BorisJohnsonatemyhampster · 06/06/2022 23:13

If more people stood up for themselves and other workers BS like zero hours contracts wouldn’t exist. Unions gave you every right you have, even the right to have a day off. It’s not a race to the bottom.

Definitelymabel · 06/06/2022 22:43

HiJenny35 · 06/06/2022 22:15

You work for the NHS, an organisation whose strike action was massively misconstrue by the media and made to look dreadful for their strike action and yet you take no time to educate yourself about why tfl were striking today and instead write this post to slag off them striking you should be ashamed of yourself. Tfl have like most organisations had their workforce cut, simultaneously some were offered a "raise" to make it appear that they are being unreasonable, this surrounded by lack of job stability and worse unsafe working conditions and changes to pensions . If you are happy, as a female travelling at night, with unmanned stations then great, most of us aren't and I'd hope fully support the strike action.

Here here! Educate yourself OP.