Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to think that most people live near family?

166 replies

ImplementingTheDennisSystem · 06/06/2022 20:09

DH and I moved 4 years ago to a beautiful little town in an area we love, and have worked hard to establish a great social network here. We have no links to the area and our family are all scattered and hours away from us. There is no central family 'hub' for us to move to.

But I'm having a wobble having had the realisation that most people I know - both here and elsewhere - live near family. Family is the focus of activity for so many friends and forms a key part of their social lives (and obligations). I'm feeling a bit dislocated and worried that friendships are potentially a bit fleeting compared to the solidity of family. People will understandably always prioritise their family, so will that leave me feeling continually sidelined?

Have you successfully built a life nowhere near family? If so, how do you feel about this and does your situation feel 'solid'?

OP posts:
AppleandRhubarbTart · 07/06/2022 09:34

indoorplantqueen · 07/06/2022 09:13

We lived away from family for 15 years in the SE of England. Pandemic really put things into perspective with not being able to fly to see them etc. We moved back 18 months ago and it's the best decision we've ever made. Having family around is great. My dc has cousins and aunts/ uncles/ grandparents and is so much happier. We're an independent nuclear family as we never had support, but it's lovely dc being able to go to parties, christenings, weddings and other things we regularly missed out on. And my parents often gave the grandkids for sleepovers so dh and I have much more couple time.

We had made good friends where we were, and most of them didn't have local families. Now that we moved away we rarely keep in contact with those friends.

It's interesting to read about your experience. I definitely felt incredibly lucky to be close to family during the pandemic and lockdown.

LeeMucklowesCurtains · 07/06/2022 09:34

We didn’t.

Then, we couldn’t afford to live where we were anymore and moved 3 hours to where PIL as it’s pretty much the only affordable to us place where dh could still get to his office twice a month.

Worst thing I ever did. Interfering, racist gits are making me miserable. Didn’t realise how bad they were when I only saw them once every couple of months for two days.

Ive never had any family other than my dad and he followed me wherever I moved to, it was horrendous.

RaspberryChouxBuns · 07/06/2022 09:31

I don't live near my family, we are in separate countries. My siblings who stayed in England are not geographically close to one another, nor my parents. My Grandparents live in another European country and my other Grandparents used to live in Ireland, they're now dead. I think it's incredibly naive to say that most people live near family, it's not been my experience at all.

CharSiu · 07/06/2022 09:27

We live in a small market town and many people are from the area and have always lived here. We are not and chose this town as it was between DH and mine workplaces. It does mean people have established networks.

Our families are dotted all over the world. I’m the child of an immigrant and my Mother whilst born here lived overseas in Africa and also all over the UK. DH grandparents lived in India for a time, his sister lives in Spain and my brothers moved to America. A lot of my family live in Hong Kong.

@MojoMoon is right in that it is a class and education divide.

We have over 20 years established a network and I’m grateful for some great friends but it’s not quite the same as being near family. I saw three lots of friends over the jubilee weekend and it was great but it had to be arranged. When children were little I had no one I could write as local emergency contact.

InChocolateWeTrust · 07/06/2022 09:26

I grew up with parents who lived 200 miles from their own parents. The nearest aunt/uncles were 1.5hrs away.

It was fine, my parents have a great social network in our town, many other people were in similar position.

I also live a long way from parents and in laws. I do think its less common than it was when I was a child as many friends simply cant afford childcare and have had to live near family for financial support. We know a lot of people (south east so £££) who's parents have contributed to their house purchase, and as a result have slightly influenced where they live.

However.... it's fine. I'd like to live nearer my sister but we make the time to visit and we call a lot.

Nitgel · 07/06/2022 09:25

I live close to my family and do think it's important to, especially as they age and need support.

theviewfrommywindow · 07/06/2022 09:23

MojoMoon · 07/06/2022 09:04

It's a class/education level divide - if you go off to a competitive university course and then a fairly high paying profession, it will likely involve leaving home at 18 and then living in a city for several years as you climb the first rungs of the career ladder. It also might involve stints abroad.
It then also means you are more likely to meet a partner/spouse from another area or country while through work/city living/city friends. You are also more likely only to settle down in a relationship or marriage in your late 20s or early 30s by which time you have established a friendship group and life independent of your home town and family

If you leave education at 18 in a small town and get a job locally while living with your parents, you will likely date locally, marry locally and earlier and therefore be less likely to live further away from family.

If you are in a small town where a lot of people did that, then yes most people will live near their families. If you moved to a big city, it would be different

@MojoMoon This is spot on - especially for my family. Although I did break the mould and move back home to my family after living in the 'big city' for many years.

theviewfrommywindow · 07/06/2022 09:20

I have a massive family with lots of us in each generation, we are very close and the main form of socialising for our children is with their cousins.

My husband and I regularly discuss how much we'd like to live in other areas (although we both lived in in numerous other towns and cities when we were single and childless) but at the moment it would not be fair to remove our children from the close network of their cousins. My husband and I plan to relocate when our children have moved out and are settled but until then we enjoy having the big support network of our family (we probably won't end up moving as we'll realise that we love it just as much as our children!) Grin

indoorplantqueen · 07/06/2022 09:13

We lived away from family for 15 years in the SE of England. Pandemic really put things into perspective with not being able to fly to see them etc. We moved back 18 months ago and it's the best decision we've ever made. Having family around is great. My dc has cousins and aunts/ uncles/ grandparents and is so much happier. We're an independent nuclear family as we never had support, but it's lovely dc being able to go to parties, christenings, weddings and other things we regularly missed out on. And my parents often gave the grandkids for sleepovers so dh and I have much more couple time.

We had made good friends where we were, and most of them didn't have local families. Now that we moved away we rarely keep in contact with those friends.

letsnotdothat · 07/06/2022 09:05

Our family is dotted all over the country and FIL spends half of his time in another country entirely so it isn’t the case for us at all. Our closest relative is MIL and she’s about a 20 min drive away.

MojoMoon · 07/06/2022 09:04

It's a class/education level divide - if you go off to a competitive university course and then a fairly high paying profession, it will likely involve leaving home at 18 and then living in a city for several years as you climb the first rungs of the career ladder. It also might involve stints abroad.
It then also means you are more likely to meet a partner/spouse from another area or country while through work/city living/city friends. You are also more likely only to settle down in a relationship or marriage in your late 20s or early 30s by which time you have established a friendship group and life independent of your home town and family

If you leave education at 18 in a small town and get a job locally while living with your parents, you will likely date locally, marry locally and earlier and therefore be less likely to live further away from family.

If you are in a small town where a lot of people did that, then yes most people will live near their families. If you moved to a big city, it would be different

Hbh17 · 07/06/2022 09:02

Err, no..... Never lived near relatives as a child, then moved away from parental home for university 40 years ago & stayed. None of my family or in-laws close by which, to me, is a very healthy way of living & encourages independence. Can't think of many of our friends who live near family either - education & careers mean that most people will move around.

Cheshiresun · 07/06/2022 08:54

No, I don't live near family either side. It's not a problem until you find yourself alone through separation or loss etc, then childcare logistics can be more difficult and require a bit more planning!

We decided to move away as at the time we liked the independence and family not making unannounced visits (they still sometimes did though).

I do think many people, around here anyway, do have family near by. They have their mothers/MILs do childcare.

chchchchch · 07/06/2022 08:54

We lived in a town near my parents and one brother when DD was young. DH and I moved there when we were in our 20s, then my brother followed us because SIL wanted to move there, and then my parents decided to retire there. I started a trend😂

But we then relocated 200 miles for work, although thankfully I am only 15 miles down the road from my other brother so he could always be on call for an emergency. It was a bit tough at first not having my parents around because my mum undertook some childcare, however we got on with it and built a great network of friends in the village we moved to. Life is all good. We would go stay with my parents at bank holidays, Christmas, Easter etc so still spent a lot of quality time with the,.

DH's family live abroad but he's not that close with them. He would hate to live in the same town as them, never mind the same county.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 07/06/2022 08:53

The variation by area within the UK is really significant here. So even if it were the case that the majority of people don't live near family, because you're in an area where that's not the case OP, of course you're going to feel different from the community you live in. You're going to get really different answers from people living in eg nappy valley London to people in eg Northern Ireland.

Fwiw I live near loads of mine, in a city, but I'm from an extended family culture.

Tryagain2020 · 07/06/2022 08:46

I don't and nor do most people I know. I am London/SE. Most people I know went to uni and never went back to their home town.

adlitem · 07/06/2022 08:38

We don't.

I am from an EU country (where the rest of my family still are) and my in laws are 2 hours away. We moved for my husband's job. We are 6 years in in our new area and of course it has chalenges (mainly surrounding help with childcare - a night out for me and DH just isn't possible unless we arrange for grandparents to come stay, and emergencies can be tricky, there's a lot of logisistics required), but overall we love where we live and have - as you say - worked hard to build friendships and a support network.

All that said, it is a factor in why we will probably not have a third child. We had our second here, and I think a third with no regular help might just tip the balance. But this is also influenced by the fact that my husband has a long commute so he is not around at home much.

Hardbackwriter · 07/06/2022 08:32

Stellaris22 · 07/06/2022 08:25

I too find it a bit weird being unable to unlatch yourselves from parents as adults. Having a good relationship is great, but a healthy part of being an adult is being independent and able to live your own life with people your own age. I love my circle of friends (other parents, work friends, dog walking friends) and want my children to have the ability to do that for themselves as well.

Having a 'need' to see parents and adults and talk to them constantly is weird, they are there for when you need them but being able to lean on partners or friends should be the first thing you do.

But this seems to assume that the only reason you'd want to be close to and see a lot of your parents as an adult is because you rely on them. That isn't always the case, and it almost inevitably switches to the opposite at some point as they age. Some families just enjoy being around each other. I don't see why enjoying the company of friends is great and appropriate but enjoying the company of family is somehow pathetic?

Stellaris22 · 07/06/2022 08:25

I too find it a bit weird being unable to unlatch yourselves from parents as adults. Having a good relationship is great, but a healthy part of being an adult is being independent and able to live your own life with people your own age. I love my circle of friends (other parents, work friends, dog walking friends) and want my children to have the ability to do that for themselves as well.

Having a 'need' to see parents and adults and talk to them constantly is weird, they are there for when you need them but being able to lean on partners or friends should be the first thing you do.

Ragwort · 07/06/2022 08:22

Not in my experience, but perhaps people gravitate towards friends who don't have family nearby so they make their own 'support network'. Both DH and I moved away from our home towns after Uni and I fully expect/hope that our DS moves away when he graduates. My own DPs moved away from the area we grew up in when they retired. I find it quite stifling when people don't move away .. we live in quite a small town now and there are a lot of people who have never 'moved away'. My elderly DPs did move closer to us in their 80s so that we were nearer for support and that was quite a good solution.

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/06/2022 07:54

@kitcat15

I don’t get why you wouldn’t want that for your own children

Because I would want my children to define what they want for their lives themselves, rather than having everything dictated by the needs of the extended family.

I would find living in the pocket of my wider family my whole life incredibly stifling and I wouldn’t want it for my DD.

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 07/06/2022 07:54

I hardly know anyone with family nearby. My mum is actually near us, but that's because she moved here to be closer to us, the rest of our family is hundreds of miles away.

I did grow up in a place where everyone lived within a few streets of their family - parents, siblings, cousins, etc all a few minutes walk away - and tbh I found it stifling abd claustrophobic. Part of the reason I'm now hundreds of miles away!

IncompleteSenten · 07/06/2022 07:54

We live nearly 4500 miles away from most of ours.

There's a few live about 30 miles away and a few more about 200 miles away.

zafferana · 07/06/2022 07:49

Depends where you live. In and around London and probably any big city I would disagree. Many people live here, because of work, with their family often being from somewhere completely different, including abroad. DH and I live 100 miles from any of my family and on a different continent to his.

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/06/2022 07:48

I really don’t think it’s most people. Maybe in small, close knit rural communities yes.

Bur most people who go to university move away from their family. That’s half the point of it!

In big cities very few people live that close to their families.

I haven’t lived in the same town as any of my family for over 30 years. I have a good support network but it’s based on friends not family.