Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to think that most people live near family?

166 replies

ImplementingTheDennisSystem · 06/06/2022 20:09

DH and I moved 4 years ago to a beautiful little town in an area we love, and have worked hard to establish a great social network here. We have no links to the area and our family are all scattered and hours away from us. There is no central family 'hub' for us to move to.

But I'm having a wobble having had the realisation that most people I know - both here and elsewhere - live near family. Family is the focus of activity for so many friends and forms a key part of their social lives (and obligations). I'm feeling a bit dislocated and worried that friendships are potentially a bit fleeting compared to the solidity of family. People will understandably always prioritise their family, so will that leave me feeling continually sidelined?

Have you successfully built a life nowhere near family? If so, how do you feel about this and does your situation feel 'solid'?

OP posts:
Sceptre86 · 07/06/2022 14:11

We love 4 hours away from my family but 10 minutes away from dh's mum and brother. We still only see hos brother once a week or fortnight because he had kids too and is busy. Just because people live near family doesn't mean they spend much time together.

Zpoa · 07/06/2022 14:08

I don't stay in London because my parents are here, I stay because all my friends are here. I don't 'need' to be near my parents, it just so happens that I do.

Crankley · 07/06/2022 14:00

No, I think the reverse is true.

ThreeRingCircus · 07/06/2022 13:47

namechangetheworld · 07/06/2022 10:05

We live within 20 miles of both my parents and the in-laws, and that seems fairly common around here (South Lincolnshire). We moved closer when I was pregnant with our eldest. We're not a 'close' family per se, certainly not living in each others pockets, but both sets of parents help out with childcare when needed and we meet up for days out once every few months. We could afford a bigger house further afield but I would feel incredibly selfish moving away now - the grandparents have a lovely relationship with their grandchildren, and I also worry about them getting older and us not being around to help out. Also (selfishly) life is much easier with people around you know you can depend on - my Dad can pop round to wait for the plumber if I'm stuck at work, my in-laws can give us lifts to the train station, etc. My husband regularly does little bits of DIY at my brother's house. I don't think you can rely on friends the same way you can rely on family. Blood is thicker than water and all that. My NDN is the only person I know who has no local family (through choice) and she seems to really struggle with no support network, constantly having to call on favours from other neighbours or co-workers. I couldn't live like that.

Reading posts like this do make me feel sad that we don't live close to family (200 miles away) as these are all the positive things I think we miss out on. However it does seem an alien concept to me to self-limit where you live out your life because you happen to have been born in Lincolnshire, or Lancashire or Liverpool etc.

In the area where I grew up it's very rural so there are limited job prospects and hence I didn't move back after I went away to University. I moved to a city instead and I love the place I've chosen to live, it's broadened my horizons but I do feel sad my parents will never have my DDs for a sleepover, or my sister isn't round the corner to pop in for a cuppa.

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/06/2022 13:40

ihatethefuckingmuffin · 07/06/2022 13:35

The whole blood is thicker crap is for some just to put up with disfunction and abuse. It puts unnecessary guilt on people who want to escape toxic environments but stay because well it’s family.

I totally agree. There are some obvious benefits to having family around but this idea of guilting people who move away and making them feel that they can only really trust family is really backwards and sinister. No thank you.

ihatethefuckingmuffin · 07/06/2022 13:35

The whole blood is thicker crap is for some just to put up with disfunction and abuse. It puts unnecessary guilt on people who want to escape toxic environments but stay because well it’s family.

ImplementingTheDennisSystem · 07/06/2022 12:25

*tootiredtospeak · Today 10:35

You have told me about your parents but what about you. When people plan for the future I dont think they give enough consideration to this, not enough thought. It's fine to be far away from family and not close but then you need to plan for your old age the same as retirement. What do you want to happen and how will you pay for that. Everyone is talking about parents and siblings. What about your own children do you really want them moving away from you to see them once or twice a year. I would never ever stop mine but would be pleased if they wanted to stay close to me. I love them they are the most important things in my life why wouldn't I want them close.*

DH and I have planned for our futures. We will downsize from our 4-bed detached house to a small, town centre flat when we are approx 60. We've seen my mum and both inlaws NOT do this and then deal with the constant uphill struggle of trying to maintain their properties in older age.
We will then, as with millions of others up and down the country, use paid care support in our homes if needed, and may eventually go into a care home - maybe cared for my robots by then, who knows! (...I'm only half joking).
That's not what this thread was supposed to be about though. There is an 'elderly parents' forum on here where people often discuss these sorts of arrangements.

OP posts:
Livpool · 07/06/2022 11:34

Most people I know live near their families - but whatever works for you

Echobelly · 07/06/2022 10:45

I think it's quite unusal. Most of my family and DH's live nearby but that's relatively unusual and also to some extent because we're Jewish. Jewish families tend to either live near one another or on different continents! But I think British families are less likely to.

Airyfairy03 · 07/06/2022 10:44

I live in an area where everyone still lives near their families, it's really uncommon for people to not have all their family around them and most people like the OP says, are busy with their families at weekends etc.

I grew up here, moved away and then moved back, my sibling lives 20 mins away and my parents 15 mins away. Inlaws live 3 hours away. To be honest though, I'm not family orientated, I don't have anything in common with my family really and we're not particularly close. I see my sibling once every couple of months and my parents once a week/ every 2 weeks. We all get together for a day/ meal out/ BBQ once every few months and obviously do Christmas and stuff but that's about it.

Put it this way, I'm never not available for my friends at the weekends because I'm hanging out with my family, I'd rather see friends as they're the family I choose.

Stellaris22 · 07/06/2022 10:43

We have one child and I would be sad when she moves away as an adult, but i'd also be happy that they were confident and independent enough to realise thay are capable of doing things by themselves. Of course it would be sad, but i'd know i'd done my job as a parent to help them make friends and lifelong companions.

tootiredtospeak · 07/06/2022 10:35

You have told me about your parents but what about you. When people plan for the future I dont think they give enough consideration to this, not enough thought. It's fine to be far away from family and not close but then you need to plan for your old age the same as retirement. What do you want to happen and how will you pay for that. Everyone is talking about parents and siblings. What about your own children do you really want them moving away from you to see them once or twice a year. I would never ever stop mine but would be pleased if they wanted to stay close to me. I love them they are the most important things in my life why wouldn't I want them close.

JudgeJ · 07/06/2022 10:33

I think the days of family living very close together are generally gone, the population has to be far more mobile for work. In my family during my mother's youth you left school on Friday and on Monday you were in the mill or down the pit, little other choice. In the 1921 Census in a street of 56 houses, 18 of them were in some way related to my mother, even in the 1960s I recall many of thise houses were Uncle/Auntie to me.
When we had our children we were living abroad so had no-one close by, the best thing in my opinion, we made all decisions!

Choopi · 07/06/2022 10:29

Not where I grew up. I grew up in the countryside and pretty much everyone moved for uni then never moved back. There isn't many jobs so it wouldn't make sense to live there. I live 2.5hours away from where I grew. All 3 of my siblings have moved between 2 and 5 hours away.

Where I live now lots of the kids school friends parents went to the same school as the kids so not the same amount of moving at all. I think it just depends in the area you grew up in and what it has to offer.

Aussiegirl123456 · 07/06/2022 10:24

24 hour flight away from our nearest and dearest. We like it like this!

Hardbackwriter · 07/06/2022 10:22

MojoMoon · 07/06/2022 09:04

It's a class/education level divide - if you go off to a competitive university course and then a fairly high paying profession, it will likely involve leaving home at 18 and then living in a city for several years as you climb the first rungs of the career ladder. It also might involve stints abroad.
It then also means you are more likely to meet a partner/spouse from another area or country while through work/city living/city friends. You are also more likely only to settle down in a relationship or marriage in your late 20s or early 30s by which time you have established a friendship group and life independent of your home town and family

If you leave education at 18 in a small town and get a job locally while living with your parents, you will likely date locally, marry locally and earlier and therefore be less likely to live further away from family.

If you are in a small town where a lot of people did that, then yes most people will live near their families. If you moved to a big city, it would be different

I went to Cambridge and loads of my university friends live near their parents because they grew up in London or nearby and that's where they live as adults. I grew up in home counties commuter-ville and none of my school friends lived near there when we were 25 but now we're 35 and lots of us have 'gone back' (including me). Where I live now is absolutely full of people who have 'moved out' from London (it's not affordable for anyone else) but most of them, like me, chose this specific place to come to because they already had a connection to it.

People who grew up in London generally seem quite bemused by the idea that they'd live anywhere else but for some reason that's not seen as limiting and weird in the same way it is if you grew up anywhere else and want to keep living there.

curlydiamond · 07/06/2022 10:19

We didn't live near family when we got married and had our first two children. DH and I met in the city we'd moved to for uni and nearest family were 3 hours away.
I grew up abroad and we visited family in the UK once per year as kids, so I hadn't experienced the extended family childhood thing.
When the kids came along we saw how involved our friends' families were in their children's lives and how positive those relationships were, and realised we wanted that for our kids too. We made the decision to move to near DHs parents when DCs were in primary school, moving from a thriving city to small rural town.
We have no regrets moving closer to family, we had a really strong support network of friends before we moved and we miss not seeing them as often but we've made new friends too and are happy to be near now MIL and FILs health is deteriorating.
My DPs have lived abroad (EU) my entire adult life, I have a very close relationship with my mum. When covid hit it was awful not seeing them, especially my Dad who was very ill with covid and battled on alone for 11 months before his organs finally gave up. Not being able to visit him in hospital, being unable to attend his cremation, it was just awful and I feel very guilty that he spent his last 6months alone.
We can't live for our families, and not everyone has a set up that would be improved by living closer to family, living far away doesn't mean you can't still have a close relationship or that you love them any less. Only you can decide what's going to work best for you.

Chouetted · 07/06/2022 10:13

You have to find the others who have moved away from family. They will be the ones who understand the issues and are more willing to step up and help out with the logistical issues that family would normally cover.

Interestingly, those are the friendships that have remained solid, even where people have moved away agaub - I suppose in a corny way, we became family

ringoutthebells · 07/06/2022 10:12

We don't live near family. Now we have small children it's been hard, not going to lie!

namechangetheworld · 07/06/2022 10:05

We live within 20 miles of both my parents and the in-laws, and that seems fairly common around here (South Lincolnshire). We moved closer when I was pregnant with our eldest. We're not a 'close' family per se, certainly not living in each others pockets, but both sets of parents help out with childcare when needed and we meet up for days out once every few months. We could afford a bigger house further afield but I would feel incredibly selfish moving away now - the grandparents have a lovely relationship with their grandchildren, and I also worry about them getting older and us not being around to help out. Also (selfishly) life is much easier with people around you know you can depend on - my Dad can pop round to wait for the plumber if I'm stuck at work, my in-laws can give us lifts to the train station, etc. My husband regularly does little bits of DIY at my brother's house. I don't think you can rely on friends the same way you can rely on family. Blood is thicker than water and all that. My NDN is the only person I know who has no local family (through choice) and she seems to really struggle with no support network, constantly having to call on favours from other neighbours or co-workers. I couldn't live like that.

ihatethefuckingmuffin · 07/06/2022 10:05

I haven't lived near family for 30+ years. As a child/teen I found their dynamic very weird as their lives revolved around each other. Between 8 siblings and grandparents they had a couple of friends outside their group. Always just walking into each other's houses, not making plans unless it included them and all is kids. Us kids forced to include cousins in our plans. Abhorred it and as soon as I had The chance I left and have never looked back.

once I left I was more in contact with mates from there than I was when I was there as they often left early/ didn't come as they didn't want to hang with my family. Didn't blame them, still don't want anything to do with the racist, sexist arseholes.

when my mum and step dad moved there years ago I told him how life was. As Lee mentioned fine in small doses but once in thei r clutches he realised the massive mistake he made and several months later returned. He fully understood why I would never go back not even for a day as this was weird as he's close to his family but not that close.

Spitescreen · 07/06/2022 09:55

MojoMoon · 07/06/2022 09:04

It's a class/education level divide - if you go off to a competitive university course and then a fairly high paying profession, it will likely involve leaving home at 18 and then living in a city for several years as you climb the first rungs of the career ladder. It also might involve stints abroad.
It then also means you are more likely to meet a partner/spouse from another area or country while through work/city living/city friends. You are also more likely only to settle down in a relationship or marriage in your late 20s or early 30s by which time you have established a friendship group and life independent of your home town and family

If you leave education at 18 in a small town and get a job locally while living with your parents, you will likely date locally, marry locally and earlier and therefore be less likely to live further away from family.

If you are in a small town where a lot of people did that, then yes most people will live near their families. If you moved to a big city, it would be different

Yes, to an extent. But Irish people of my generation emigrated in huge numbers regardless of social class, because unemployment was so high, so a situation like that of my family is pretty normal, with parents living where we grew up and me and all my siblings living overseas longterm in different countries. At one point I was living in France, with one sibling in Tokyo, one in Beijing, one in Istanbul and one in Poland.

When I lived in a village in the (English) Midlands, I did find it quite odd that virtually everyone was living in the immediate vicinity of their family — it seems to me like arbitrarily limiting your own life to where you happened to have been born.

ForestFae · 07/06/2022 09:49

I live about 5 minutes from my parents and we like it that way as they see the kids a lot, but I don’t think everyone does.

jamapop · 07/06/2022 09:45

Tryagain2020 · 07/06/2022 08:46

I don't and nor do most people I know. I am London/SE. Most people I know went to uni and never went back to their home town.

Yes I live in London and we are in the majority I think in not having family nearby.

I didn’t grow up near family either - my parents had both moved away from their parents so when we saw them we always had to spend a few nights. Even then (not London / SE and 30-40 years a go) I don’t think we were particularly unusual as a family in not having wider family living down the road. I was always surprised people who were born and lived their whole lives in the same place.

RedWingBoots · 07/06/2022 09:39

I live near family but I'm another one from an extended family culture so there are very few places in the world I won't find someone I'm related to within a reasonable distance. (That distance varies from country to country.)

It's actually annoying as you happily minding your own business then one of your cousins sees you and remembers you from the last extended family meet up you both went to. They say "Hello" then tell you where they live which is between 2-5 miles of where you do. If you are over about 60 or one of you has children under 10 then you both end up seeing each other more regularly, otherwise you don't tend to step on each other toes.