Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate it when major national charities don't actually do anything but boast about signposting ? ?

84 replies

koalakate999 · 06/06/2022 19:39

I really like the idea of supporting a charity.

But for goodness sake, you need to have an actual purpose.

E.g the Samaritans may not be perfect, but they provide a 24/7 phone line for lonely people to actually chat/ share worries/ get human contact, ( could be pretty useful at 3.00am on xmas day if feeling very low).

But so many of the other "big ones, " e.g. Age U.K, Macmillan, Mind etc seem to take a lot of money just to "signpost," people to local services they likely already knew about, e.g their local Citizen's Advice.

In fact, a lot of them all just seem to signpost to each other !?

Am I unreasonable in thinking the big charities should actually help individuals more, e.g. grants, services etc.

If anyone could suggest big charities that are providing tangible help I'd be very grateful.

OP posts:
DisgruntledPelican · 06/06/2022 20:22

thecatsthecats · 06/06/2022 20:14

I work for and with a number of small local charities. They all have funding spends of 95%+ on direct support.

And they're all a fucking wasteful shitshow behind the scenes. Some of them it's only a matter of time until a safeguarding issue results in someone's serious injury or death.

I do paid and voluntary work specifically trying to address the weaknesses of small charities and this is rife. They're always well meaning, and always disastrously underskilled.

The signposting thing annoys me too but it's often tied to funding. If someone gave you £10k to support treating individuals with X need in Y location, then they want to hear that you did that or they want their money back.

I only donate to large charities who I have a decent impression of.

This. Charities need to spend money on things that keep the charity running well, brings in more money (trust fundraising, anyone?) and lobbies politicians / influences policy. Smaller charities who spend all their income on services are often not supporting their volunteers or are downright exploiting them.

Georgeskitchen · 06/06/2022 20:22

Local voluntary animal rescues are the ones I support. They seem to do so much more for animals in distress than the great behemoth that is the RSPCA

SunflowerGardens · 06/06/2022 20:18

Barnardos doesn't just signpost. They do lots of work with vulnerable young people, can give families grants and still run children's homes in some areas too.

FuzzyPuffling · 06/06/2022 20:18

Macmillan were absolutely fantastic when my DH had cancer. They gave really good one to one support for both of us, including counselling, physical therapies, endless cups of tea and listening ears and access to specialist information.

thecatsthecats · 06/06/2022 20:14

LimpBiskit · 06/06/2022 19:54

I no longer donate to large charities as they become self serving organisations. Local grass roots charities are much better at supporting people and give much more bang for their buck too.

I work for and with a number of small local charities. They all have funding spends of 95%+ on direct support.

And they're all a fucking wasteful shitshow behind the scenes. Some of them it's only a matter of time until a safeguarding issue results in someone's serious injury or death.

I do paid and voluntary work specifically trying to address the weaknesses of small charities and this is rife. They're always well meaning, and always disastrously underskilled.

The signposting thing annoys me too but it's often tied to funding. If someone gave you £10k to support treating individuals with X need in Y location, then they want to hear that you did that or they want their money back.

I only donate to large charities who I have a decent impression of.

CurbsideProphet · 06/06/2022 20:07

Macmillan give grants but IIRC they are restricted by amount.

Age UK organise activity / support groups, coffee mornings, befriending services etc, as do Alzheimer's Society.
Dementia UK have a helpline and Admiral Nurse service.

Military charities give monetary grants to those who are eligible, usually via specific items eg white /brown goods, carpets, funeral grants, training grants etc, but not cash grants.

Christians Against Poverty provide free debt support and money management courses.

What support do you need and what charity have you tried to get help from?

NumberTheory · 06/06/2022 20:00

You really have no idea what you're talking about.

Firstly, signposting, when done well, is a labour intensive service that involves well trained staff or volunteers talking one on one with users to make sure they understand the situation and can make sure the user gets the right advice from the right people and knows how to access it. It also involves staying up to date as services and legislation changes. None of that is cheap or lacking in value. (When done poorly, unfortunately, it wastes everyone's time.)

Also, the charities you've mentioned don't just do signposting. Age UK, for instance, as well as lobbying politicians and businesses to try and ensure legislation and policy is suited to their users also runs day care centers, adult education, assistance services, etc. MIND run drop-in centers, counseling, training schemes and crisis help-lines. Macmillan provide grants, coaching for people trying to change their lives after a diagnosis, a host of legal and medical advice, etc.

LimpBiskit · 06/06/2022 19:54

I no longer donate to large charities as they become self serving organisations. Local grass roots charities are much better at supporting people and give much more bang for their buck too.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 06/06/2022 19:46

I partially agree. There are a lot of amazing charities, doing brilliant work and providing direct services. However I know what you mean about signposting. Signposting is important, as often people don’t know how to access things that are already available. However I think it needs to be in conjunction to other services.

during the pandemic the charity I work for proposed a phone line, that we would help staff. When I asked what information/support we’d be giving out, it was very woolly. Luckily it didn’t happen in the end.

my major issue with charity….is that any service that is needed by people should be funded and not reliant on charitable hand outs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread