Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate it when major national charities don't actually do anything but boast about signposting ? ?

84 replies

koalakate999 · 06/06/2022 19:39

I really like the idea of supporting a charity.

But for goodness sake, you need to have an actual purpose.

E.g the Samaritans may not be perfect, but they provide a 24/7 phone line for lonely people to actually chat/ share worries/ get human contact, ( could be pretty useful at 3.00am on xmas day if feeling very low).

But so many of the other "big ones, " e.g. Age U.K, Macmillan, Mind etc seem to take a lot of money just to "signpost," people to local services they likely already knew about, e.g their local Citizen's Advice.

In fact, a lot of them all just seem to signpost to each other !?

Am I unreasonable in thinking the big charities should actually help individuals more, e.g. grants, services etc.

If anyone could suggest big charities that are providing tangible help I'd be very grateful.

OP posts:
UpdateStoleMyProfile · 08/06/2022 16:40

Big charities providing practical help - my disabled child is currently having respite in a Barnados run respite care facility. We receive whole family support from The Rainbow Trust, who have family support workers who come alongside and actually help. We have had equipment and advice from NewLife, Cerebra, The Variety Club, Caudwell Children’s, The Family Fund and a wish from MakeAWish.

my child’s school has had funding from Children In Need.

We have stayed for many weeks in the Ronald McDonald House at our local hospital - now there is the ultimate in practical support. A suite of rooms where parents can stay when their child is in hospital for long periods of time. With a kitchen, freezer space, baths, laundry facilities, and family support workers ready to listen. Rooms where you can just go for a few hours when life on the ward is too much. Where the whole family can stay when the hospital is miles from home. Where there’s food donated so you don’t have to spend a fortune on hospital canteen stuff.

Tangsr1neDr3am · 08/06/2022 16:25

The Children’s Society and The Autistic Society have been fab for us.Agree with the op re most others.

SherbetDips · 08/06/2022 16:21

That’s why you support local charities not the big ones.

Mogs43 · 08/06/2022 16:20

I am sure/and glad many people have had great support from charities - unfortunately we haven't been so lucky. My father had a number of disabilities before he died and we reached out for help but were passed from one organisation to another and in the end gave up. It became yet another thing to manage/chase when were were already broken with day to day disability and caring issues.

I do think some of the bigger/well known charities have changed their focus in the past few years - it feels that their priority is now more about lobbying Government than providing practical support to the vulnerable. My Grandmother, for example, was deaf and blind and got great practical support and equipment from some of the big charities, when my father experienced similar disabilities they said they no longer helped with such things.- they focused on policy and societal change. I appreciate this is important. but surely they could do a bit of both? - and their requests for funding definitely don't imply they prioritise lobbying!

I have also heard about significant waste. One of my friends, for example, works in HR/ training for the charity sector. She was handsomely paid to provide diversity training for a children's charity (who do very emotive adverts) , flew business class around the world, stayed in smart hotels and driving a brand new SUV whilst the people we thought our money was going to lived in abject poverty. I am not, in anyway, saying that such training shouldn't be given or workers appropriately paid but am sure, as my friend said, it could have been delivered more cost effectively? Other friends have given many similar examples of financial waste and horrendous HR practices/abuses.

I do think national charities have a really important role to play (and not just as an employer of middle class graduates!) but I think many have taken the decision to provide a different kind of service and may not be being entirely honest in their communications on this- especially not when fundraising!

anniegun · 08/06/2022 16:06

I totally agree. Some of the best know Mental Health charities are all about "raising awareness" and "signposting" and have nothing to offer someone actually needing help. They soak up resources and funding and distract from the few that actually provide a service

mumonthehill · 08/06/2022 16:04

much of what had been said is true. I worked for a charity on a funded project that had very specific boundaries around who could access it. It would often mean that we would have to refer out as service users did not match our criteria that was tied to the funding. It was very frustrating. Interestingly even if we referred out it would count as a contact for our project so the number of people who used our service looked higher than it actually was. I left the project in the end as I hated turning people away.

earsup · 08/06/2022 15:59

Well some need the money for the big fancy offices and luxury cars for the managers....drive down purley way croydon...lots of charity hq buildings...see the cars parked in the managers bays....all top end luxury....bet they dont pay for those...!!!

NumberTheory · 08/06/2022 15:54

Valeriekat · 08/06/2022 09:58

Yes much easier to lobby and swan about at international forums than actually get your hands dirty and help people. I am guessing that you work in the charity sector.

Yes. I worked for years for a local charity affiliated to a big national. I did plenty of “getting my hands dirty”. We would not have been nearly as successful in our mission without the national organization. They did a huge amount of lobbying that directly impacted us and developed relationships with companies that enabled us to get significant in kind donations. We also benefitted from the branding that made fundraising more effective and from the networking and annual conference that made it easy to share experience and learn from each other rather than reinventing the wheel.

I went on to work for a charity in the US that provided IT support to small charities. Again, I was working for a local organization doing hands on work. While I was there we joined together with several similar charities to try to provide national support for organizations like us - because it’s hugely useful if you want to be really impactful in your work.

I was also on the board of a local, all volunteer, professional organization for people working in the charitable sector. Again, we worked to develop a national umbrella group to try to coordinate efforts, increase our reach and improve our performance.

Candleabra · 08/06/2022 15:48

where I live MacMillan are based in the local
hospice and work very closely together with them and the local hospital. I was pleased with the level of support they offered. Aware this is very variable from area to area though.

drspouse · 08/06/2022 15:43

FKATondelayo · 08/06/2022 15:11

I completely agree with you in some cases. The amount of 'youth mental health' charities there are out there - all with their fancy websites and ads and social media teams. But if you need ACTUAL help all you find on there is 'get a CAMHS referral'. Because that's so easy and straightforward.

If I could get a CAMHS referral I wouldn't be googling for help would I?

We actually have quite a good local one that worked with a friend's teen DD who was unwell enough to need hospital at one stage. Her DS is the same age as my DS and is fairly similar to him in that he has ADD and some challenging behaviour at home some of which stems from anxiety. However they would not see my DS though they were very helpful with her DS despite them being the same age because her DS is a sibling of a child they had already seen and my DS wasn't.

TooManyPJs · 08/06/2022 15:13

All of those charities do way more than just signpost people. And as others have and signposting is a bit more complicated anyway than you are imagining.

Macmillan find nursing posts, have a dedicated support line 24/7 365 days a year on which you can get emotional support, access to a medical professional to discuss questions about cancer and a national benefits team plus they fund local teams around the country to provide face-to-face advice. They also fund entire cancer support centres in hospitals. Macmillan have a lot of money as a charity and use it to do way more than signposting!

Mind are less well funded but have information and support lines, advocacy including IMHAs, peer support schemes, support groups.

Age U.K. have benefits advice teams, run home from hospital support, helplines, befriending schemes etc etc etc.

So I would gently say that you don't know what you are talking about.

FKATondelayo · 08/06/2022 15:11

I completely agree with you in some cases. The amount of 'youth mental health' charities there are out there - all with their fancy websites and ads and social media teams. But if you need ACTUAL help all you find on there is 'get a CAMHS referral'. Because that's so easy and straightforward.

If I could get a CAMHS referral I wouldn't be googling for help would I?

Gazelda · 08/06/2022 15:09

If there weren't national charities, how would the people they represent be heard? How would people with dementia (for example) have a say in national strategy? Or housing needs if Shelter didn't have such a high profile?

Local charities can be very effective at responding to the needs of people in their geographical area. They can be agile and flexible. But they need a common strategy to influence spending, investment and planning.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 08/06/2022 15:04

Wanted to add I've heard some bad things about national Mind from a number of sources. Wouldn't touch them with a bargepole, or give them any money.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 08/06/2022 15:00

In areas where it provides counselling and groups, it is commissioned to do this via nhs money. Locally they act like they are doing it via fundraising when actually they won a contract over nhs services and hold all the local funding to do so. They make it seem like it is done from the charity side rather than government contract. In the same way virgin care are running out the goodness of their hearts
^^
Services are put out to tender, Mind are doing nothing wrong here. And at least local Mind organisations are local rather than a national swooping in and hoovering up contracts.

ApplesandBunions · 08/06/2022 14:49

I don't think the nspcc are too popular on here now!

Thebeastofsleep · 08/06/2022 14:44

The nspcc is a huge one for this. They have a phone line and it's often suggested on here that you call them instead of social services. ALL they do is take inaccurate and incomplete information and pass the substandard referral on to children's social services. And they don't provide details of the actual referrer so we can't contact them and get the information we actually need meaning we can't act on lots of their referrals. Fucks me right off. I hope in the years since I worked in that area it's improved.

Overthewine · 08/06/2022 14:06

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

motogirl · 08/06/2022 14:03

MacMillan provide nurses, age U.K. have local groups that provide services, not sure about mind

Overthewine · 08/06/2022 14:01

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Overthewine · 08/06/2022 13:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

twointhemorning · 08/06/2022 13:42

I have cancer and I have used Macmillan services locally and nationally.

The national helpline has been awful, one adviser just hung up on me!

Locally my service has been amazing. From the Clinical Nurse Specialists who advocated for me after I had dreadful treatment on the ward after my cancer operation. The Macmillan benefits adviser who sorted out my applications ensuring the right medical people signed them. Being on the end of the phone when I was anxious about symptoms and then attending my appointment. My local service has a member of staff who has telephoned regularly to check on my wellbeing after surgery and chemo.

Cheeseandlobster · 08/06/2022 13:39

fatfrenchprick · 08/06/2022 13:21

Shelter! Awful charity. It's basically just like a BT operator

Wrong. In my area they offer a housing support service where support workers help vulnerable people to secure housing, apply for benefits, set up utilities etc. They also have a drop in centre for those who need immediate advice. Hardly like BT at all. Please check your facts before you post stuff like this

GlisteningGoldGrasses · 08/06/2022 13:36

In terms of considering who to donate to who actually help people I'd really recommend this website www.givewell.org they assess charities for actual evidence they help people and work out who provides the most help for the money. The research is really interesting when you see what's been proven to work is sometimes the simple, unglamorous option not the big exciting sounding things with lots of PR.

oldtableleg · 08/06/2022 13:36

drspouse that's my experience too - LA & charities have a circular arrangement where they 'signpost' you back and forwards between themselves & consider it job done.

As a parent of disabled & chronically ill children the only charities who've ever actually done anything are IPSEA, Family Fund & CRY.