Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate it when major national charities don't actually do anything but boast about signposting ? ?

84 replies

koalakate999 · 06/06/2022 19:39

I really like the idea of supporting a charity.

But for goodness sake, you need to have an actual purpose.

E.g the Samaritans may not be perfect, but they provide a 24/7 phone line for lonely people to actually chat/ share worries/ get human contact, ( could be pretty useful at 3.00am on xmas day if feeling very low).

But so many of the other "big ones, " e.g. Age U.K, Macmillan, Mind etc seem to take a lot of money just to "signpost," people to local services they likely already knew about, e.g their local Citizen's Advice.

In fact, a lot of them all just seem to signpost to each other !?

Am I unreasonable in thinking the big charities should actually help individuals more, e.g. grants, services etc.

If anyone could suggest big charities that are providing tangible help I'd be very grateful.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user1497207191 · 10/06/2022 10:58

5128gap · 09/06/2022 15:31

This is not correct. Charities do not exist to make money. Charities are 'not for profit' organisations. They do however, obviously need to acquire sufficient funds to carry out their charitable aims, as their work has a cost, and typically this cost is not covered by the service user.

Just semantics. They exist to "make" money, it's just that they don't make "profits" as the money they make should be ploughed into service provision rather than shareholder pockets. They need to "make" money to pay for the staffing, management, premises, and other overheads.

5128gap · 09/06/2022 15:31

Dotjones · 09/06/2022 13:32

Charities are just a form of business. Like any business they exist to make money. As with any business, some charities provide a more valuable service than others. Some have more integrity than others.

This is not correct. Charities do not exist to make money. Charities are 'not for profit' organisations. They do however, obviously need to acquire sufficient funds to carry out their charitable aims, as their work has a cost, and typically this cost is not covered by the service user.

Dotjones · 09/06/2022 13:32

Charities are just a form of business. Like any business they exist to make money. As with any business, some charities provide a more valuable service than others. Some have more integrity than others.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 09/06/2022 13:14

OK, so rather than turning on the OP, maybe consider WHY this is the view they have of those charities?

I agree. I think if charities are doing more than signposting or raising awareness then they need to be more effective in communicating exactly what they deliver and how much it costs to deliver it, and what proportion of that cost comes from donations as opposed to central grants.

I still don't really know what the NSPCC does. Maybe amazing stuff! But they haven't told me.

FreddyVoorhees · 09/06/2022 13:07

Thatswhyimacat · 09/06/2022 12:13

Why shouldn't senior executives of a charity be given fair compensation for their work? The vast majority would earn tons more in the private sector. You say you want to help people, do you not think providing an attractive package to recruit experienced leaders is going to help do that? Or should charities just be run by whichever random bleeding heart volunteer you can manage to get to run an entire organisation on a pittance?

If you wouldn't work for below your market rate, don't expect charity workers to do so (although they mostly do).

Just looking at Scope's accounts. Don't think it's an issue for the chief exec to be paid £150k when it's a £40 million turnover company with over 2,000 staff.

Only looked at Scope as it really winds me up that they really do appear to have put as much distance between themselves and people with cerebral palsy as they possibly could. Campaigning being a damned sight easier than providing physical support I guess.

Anyway, I've got no problem with the top people earning a half decent amount especially in the larger charities as frankly you put people in charge who haven't got a clue of running multi million pound organisations you may as well burn money.

However, I do have a problem with expansion for expansions sake and you're spending more on the bureaucracy than the operational delivery.

The shift to retail empires also annoys me because the proliferation of charity shops is not helping the high street one bit.

PuppyFeet · 09/06/2022 12:39

I don't completely agree with the OP. I have found Macmillan to be fabulous, not just signposting. Their support lines have been a major source of help for me during my cancer journey either as a friendly listening ear when I haven't felt able to vent to my family any more or when they helped me during a job application process and how to broach the subject of cancer. Each time they checked if I needed any additional support i.e. financial advice or medical advice.

Bettethebuilder · 09/06/2022 12:33

I’m a bit confused about the comments about Macmillan. You can phone them for support at any time 8-8. I wouldn’t expect to see someone in person - they are a phone or email or online organisation. Are people talking about something different? Why would you expect to see a real person, or have someone turn up at your house?

5128gap · 09/06/2022 12:24

I have never seen a charity 'boast about signposting' so don't know what you're actually referring to. However, no one is obliged to support any charity. But equally there's no need to justify it by trying to damage their reputation on flimsy anecdotal 'evidence' of the odd poor experience; or worse, supposition based in ignorance.
Large charities are typically subject to rigorous monitoring by regulatory bodies, so its unlikely any serious or ongoing failure to fulfil their duties would pass unnoticed until flagged up in a thread on MN.

Thatswhyimacat · 09/06/2022 12:13

Why shouldn't senior executives of a charity be given fair compensation for their work? The vast majority would earn tons more in the private sector. You say you want to help people, do you not think providing an attractive package to recruit experienced leaders is going to help do that? Or should charities just be run by whichever random bleeding heart volunteer you can manage to get to run an entire organisation on a pittance?

If you wouldn't work for below your market rate, don't expect charity workers to do so (although they mostly do).

ApplesandBunions · 09/06/2022 11:38

RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 08/06/2022 21:54

I've worked in the third sector since 2002. Most of it in fundraising. I also have 10 years experience of grant making.

I've come to the personal conclusion that there is a perfect size of charity (different for every cause and region) where they are big enough to be professional, efficient, effective, small enough to care and be close enough to the beneficiaries.

BUT

Not so big that they are effectively a fundraising machine (CRUK) or so small that they don't have that professionalism and aren't at risk for safeguarding etc etc

In the main I would say that a turnover of up to £2 million and a cohort of paid staff is a good indicator. I donate to charities with a turnover of over £400,000 and at least 2 part-time staff.

One of my previous jobs was with a national charity (national in the Scottish sense) and the amount of work that went into ensuring our signposting was relevant and accurate was something else. It needed a full time staff member but we only had funding for part time hours.

I'd broadly agree. Have worked extensively in both private and charity sectors, though never for anything quite as big as the Cancer Research style setups.

spongedog · 09/06/2022 01:10

drspouse · 08/06/2022 13:19

Our DS has ADHD and challenging behaviour. We have almost never found a charity, or frankly a professional apart from school (and they are variable), who does anything other than signpost to other organisations, which they haven't bothered to properly research; we already know about the organisations, have tried them and they won't work with DS or they are just parent support groups where we end up talking other parents through how to apply for an EHCP.

One exception is IPSEA who supported us through a tribunal; their volunteer was an actual barrister doing it pro bono.

It almost seems to be a circular arrangement. The SW pointed us to the local parent carer forum who tell us to get support from a SW. The SW then tell us off for not engaging with their suggestions (which we'd already heard of, and tried, and were useless for us).

Oh yes this. There is no real help for children and young people with special needs. Nearly all of it is signposting. Or multiple meetings of adults (perhaps 1 hr meeting with 6-8 adults, perhaps 3 times) - the support finally offered to the young person is 6 sessions of 30 mins.

And some of the larger charities mentioned above - similar. A lot of money is wasted in the charity sector.

Supersimkin2 · 09/06/2022 00:38

No one wants the truth - the very word ‘charity’ gives us all a warm glow of hope for many good things.

Until you’ve worked in one - the main cause many of these wasteful, useless orgs so tenderly support is themselves.

RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 08/06/2022 21:54

I've worked in the third sector since 2002. Most of it in fundraising. I also have 10 years experience of grant making.

I've come to the personal conclusion that there is a perfect size of charity (different for every cause and region) where they are big enough to be professional, efficient, effective, small enough to care and be close enough to the beneficiaries.

BUT

Not so big that they are effectively a fundraising machine (CRUK) or so small that they don't have that professionalism and aren't at risk for safeguarding etc etc

In the main I would say that a turnover of up to £2 million and a cohort of paid staff is a good indicator. I donate to charities with a turnover of over £400,000 and at least 2 part-time staff.

One of my previous jobs was with a national charity (national in the Scottish sense) and the amount of work that went into ensuring our signposting was relevant and accurate was something else. It needed a full time staff member but we only had funding for part time hours.

ApplesandBunions · 08/06/2022 20:24

NumberTheory · 08/06/2022 15:54

Yes. I worked for years for a local charity affiliated to a big national. I did plenty of “getting my hands dirty”. We would not have been nearly as successful in our mission without the national organization. They did a huge amount of lobbying that directly impacted us and developed relationships with companies that enabled us to get significant in kind donations. We also benefitted from the branding that made fundraising more effective and from the networking and annual conference that made it easy to share experience and learn from each other rather than reinventing the wheel.

I went on to work for a charity in the US that provided IT support to small charities. Again, I was working for a local organization doing hands on work. While I was there we joined together with several similar charities to try to provide national support for organizations like us - because it’s hugely useful if you want to be really impactful in your work.

I was also on the board of a local, all volunteer, professional organization for people working in the charitable sector. Again, we worked to develop a national umbrella group to try to coordinate efforts, increase our reach and improve our performance.

People don't want to hear how charities are actually run effectively. They prefer to remain emotionally attached to naive ideas. As demonstrated only a couple of posts below yours.

CulturePigeon · 08/06/2022 20:05

I agree, OP. I haven't got wide experience of charities, but the 2 I did ask for help were useless, and it has made me a) reluctant to give to those 2 and b) wonder how widespread the problem is with other charities.

Age UK were totally useless when my mum was declining. I only wanted advice, but OMG, it was like getting blood out of a stone and it all turned out to be useless anyway. All they wanted to do was to come and sell my mum an expensive alarm which involved making changes to her electrical supply etc, even when neither she nor I wanted this.

RSPCA: once, when I worked full time and lived in the wilds, I came home after a long and tiring day to find a huge dog on my doorstep. No identifying mark, and it didn't belong to any neighbours. I fed it and phoned the RSPCA. They basically said "Can't you keep it?" NO! I work long hours and I don't want a dog. Took me ages to get them to come and collect it, poor thing. I love animals, but the RSPCA isn't my charity of choice any more now when it comes to animal welfare. Donkey sanctuaries etc will get my money!

I've never investigated whether the public can access the spending of these massive charities - it may be possible? I'd love to know where all the money goes. It makes me angry when their senior people get huge salaries.

XenoBitch · 08/06/2022 19:47

Mind might seem like that at a national level, but the local branches can be pretty good.
My local one has it's own crisis service, several social and support groups, help with volunteering/job seeking, life skills, counselling, regular contact with a key worker etc. They can also help with referrals to other MH charities too. They don't get any funding from national Mind.
They have been a life line to many people with poor mental health, particularly those who fall in the gap between GP and CMHT (too ill for primary, not ill enough for secondary).

Overthewine · 08/06/2022 19:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Ownedbymycats · 08/06/2022 19:32

At work (local government) **we get constant referrals from charities. I can only assume that they need to prove in their quarterly returns that they make a certain amount of referrals.They're very often inappropriate and waste a great deal of our time Often it's for equipment which the person might already have or which they just don't want.
I made 4 visits to one referred household recently and eventually they said they didn't need our help. I reported this back to the referring charity who said they were happy the person was now fully informed and aware of what was available.

Somuchgoo · 08/06/2022 17:43

We have stayed for many weeks in the Ronald McDonald House at our local hospital - now there is the ultimate in practical support. A suite of rooms where parents can stay when their child is in hospital for long periods of time. With a kitchen, freezer space, baths, laundry facilities, and family support workers ready to listen. Rooms where you can just go for a few hours when life on the ward is too much. Where the whole family can stay when the hospital is miles from home. Where there’s food donated so you don’t have to spend a fortune on hospital canteen stuff.

Yes!
We've stayed there for many weeks also, and it's been a complete lifeline.

If anyone wants to donate to a charity that has a very practical side, then I fully recommend Ronald McDonald.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 08/06/2022 17:12

The Nurse Specialists funded by Macmillan were very helpful to my friend when her husband was dying of cancer. I think that this is partly because the funding was being spent in a controlled medical environment. They have a real, useful role in treatment, unlike the ‘ advisors’.

when my father was dying from lung cancer, the Macmillan ‘nurse’ who visited him twice in six months encouraged him to sign a form leaving his body to science. This ridiculous action may have been consoling to him, but it caused my mother and I immense extra grief as the body was of course rejected and we had to get the burial certificate changed etc etc. It still makes me angry after 20 years.

One of my friends who used to volunteer for the Citizens Advice Bureau used to vent regularly about the number of referrals ( aka ‘palming off’ in his words) from charities, especially since the charity then recorded any successful outcome as down to their intervention and referral.

Kowloondairy · 08/06/2022 17:10

Not sure where in the country you are, but that doesn’t happen nationwide. We approached Macmillan when my husband was first diagnosed and all we were offered was leaflets, no offer of any practice or emotional support whatsoever. The Macmillan nurse who was paid for in the oncology department had one 5 minute meeting with. Told us to contact here with any problems, I had to ring her once when my husband was really struggling with pain etc, left numerous messages on her answerphone requesting a call back. That was in September. Still waiting.when we took him to a &e and explained that we had tried to get some advice from Macmillan first the doctors reply to me was “I’m afraid that’s par for the course with them”.

Beetie1 · 08/06/2022 17:06

Thebeastofsleep · 08/06/2022 14:44

The nspcc is a huge one for this. They have a phone line and it's often suggested on here that you call them instead of social services. ALL they do is take inaccurate and incomplete information and pass the substandard referral on to children's social services. And they don't provide details of the actual referrer so we can't contact them and get the information we actually need meaning we can't act on lots of their referrals. Fucks me right off. I hope in the years since I worked in that area it's improved.

I can confirm that no - I have had recent referrals come via NSPCC just as you describe. How much they must spent on marketing and running their phone line just to email the little info they get to local authorities....

apintortwo · 08/06/2022 16:51

they focused on policy and societal change. I appreciate this is important. but surely they could do a bit of both? - and their requests for funding definitely don't imply they prioritise lobbying!

A great number of charities (large and small) appear to be powerful political machines nowadays. It's unpalatable, besides there's a legal requirement for them to remain neutral.

I had good experiences when I sought out help from a few charities whose remit was very specific and focused on providing information (as opposed to lobbying for social causes, etc)

user1497207191 · 08/06/2022 16:46

Yep, not impressed with McMillan. My Mum had cancer and tried phoning the McMillan nurses several times over a number of weeks. Kept getting an answerphone and left messages, but very rarely got a call back and never actually saw a McMillan nurse - their standard response was phone your GP or phone the oncology dept. All she actually got were leaflets!

ByTheSea · 08/06/2022 16:45

SunflowerGardens · 06/06/2022 20:18

Barnardos doesn't just signpost. They do lots of work with vulnerable young people, can give families grants and still run children's homes in some areas too.

They were appalling awful and made our situation so much worse when they got involved when my oldest DS was having issues some years ago. The damage this woman (his key worker) did was long- lasting and serious and I'll never forgive them TBH.

Swipe left for the next trending thread