Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do you cope with being rejected by a family member?

114 replies

TalkSomeSense1 · 06/06/2022 14:38

Posting here for traffic. Sorry

Just that, really. What coping strategy do you have in place to enable you to deal with the pain it's caused/causing? It's something I'm going through at the moment and I need to take back the power and learn to live with it.

OP posts:
Whitesapphire · 07/06/2022 12:26

I’ve read all your responses but I’m just asking have you ever sincerely apologised for YOUR actions? Never mind there being two sides to everything.

TalkSomeSense1 · 07/06/2022 11:57

Whitesapphire · 07/06/2022 11:01

Have you ever sincerely apologised and taken responsibility for your actions though? Or have you repeatedly tried to make the other person as culpable as you, even though they are not.

How do you know I'm culpable though? Just because I'm the one on the outs doesn't necessarily mean I'm entirely in the wrong, does it?

And if you haven't already read my responses to previous posters then you ought to as I have said several times I'm fully aware there are two sides to everything.

OP posts:
TalkSomeSense1 · 07/06/2022 11:53

Livpool · 07/06/2022 11:22

Sorry you are going through this @TalkSomeSense1

My brother did this years ago and my mother was devastated. She had some therapy.

A few years he reappeared and wonders why most of the family are LC with him. We all made our peace with him gong NC

But if that person does reappear do you need them to be remorseful/take SOME accountability or do you slowly slot back into life and leave the elephant in the room? Hypothetical question I know as you have already have it happen! Are you afraid of raising the 'problem' in case you lose that person again? It's such a minefield.

OP posts:
TalkSomeSense1 · 07/06/2022 11:50

BSky · 07/06/2022 11:32

My views may not be relevant to others scenarios particularly people where abuse is involved or there is a clear breach of acceptable behaviour. Hope that makes sense.

Some of these are complex situations where blame/who is culpable maintain the injustice and negative feelings. There has to be empathy and respect for others' viewpoints for an apology to bd given or accepted. There are different ways of seeing situations which the OP has acknowledged but to move on/reconcile there needs to be an acceptance and willingness from both/all involved. It is not necessarily about agreeing the same version of events but being able to have an understanding that others feelings are valid.

You have summed up my thoughts in a nutshell. Thank you! I've not been able to properly articulate this - there does have to be an acceptance/willingness from both sides to want to have a proper talk but the attempt to do this has been met with increasing hostility.

It is complex and won't be unpicked in a hurry. But the suggestion of finding someone professional to talk to to get, hopefully, some clarity and ability to let the situation go for however long I need to (perhaps forever!) is something I am looking at. I have a couple of recommendations of good therapists so will follow those up today.

Thank you again to everyone for their considered responses.

OP posts:
BSky · 07/06/2022 11:32

My views may not be relevant to others scenarios particularly people where abuse is involved or there is a clear breach of acceptable behaviour. Hope that makes sense.

Some of these are complex situations where blame/who is culpable maintain the injustice and negative feelings. There has to be empathy and respect for others' viewpoints for an apology to bd given or accepted. There are different ways of seeing situations which the OP has acknowledged but to move on/reconcile there needs to be an acceptance and willingness from both/all involved. It is not necessarily about agreeing the same version of events but being able to have an understanding that others feelings are valid.

Sparklybutold · 07/06/2022 11:23

@TalkSomeSense1

I think your attempt illustrates that unless the family member makes a conscious effort to change/be remorseful, any attempt by you will always be futile. I completely empathise with how hard this is to then make the decision to let go.

Livpool · 07/06/2022 11:22

Sorry you are going through this @TalkSomeSense1

My brother did this years ago and my mother was devastated. She had some therapy.

A few years he reappeared and wonders why most of the family are LC with him. We all made our peace with him gong NC

Sparklybutold · 07/06/2022 11:20

This reply has been withdrawn

Message withdrawn - duplicate post.

Sparklybutold · 07/06/2022 11:20

@Whitesapphire

Beyond knowing why the OP has decided to go NC, this assertion peretuates the myth that in going NC occurs because the person instigting the NC is at guilt. Sometimes - families are so toxic that no honest remediation will ever occur. As we don't know the reasons - suggesting this can be extremely damaging to the estranged family member.

Whitesapphire · 07/06/2022 11:01

Have you ever sincerely apologised and taken responsibility for your actions though? Or have you repeatedly tried to make the other person as culpable as you, even though they are not.

TalkSomeSense1 · 07/06/2022 10:42

Swayingpalmtrees · 07/06/2022 08:53

You need to have a hard look at what they have said/what has happened and be honest with yourself, do they have a point? Could you have done things differently? Could there be an apology or acknowledgement that is owed to the other party?

Are you actually asking how to do you live with yourself, knowing you have hurt another and lost them?

Or how do you move on?

They are very different. If you know you have hurt someone else, and it has ended badly there is always time to try and put it right. Taking action to repair and heal a situation in the best way you can should make you feel better, you will know in your heart you have done your best to fix it, now the onus is on them to come back when they are ready.

If an apology is not required because you have genuinely done nothing to warrant giving one, then your conscience should be entirely clear. There should not be a nagging feeling, but simply respecting the other person's decision to step back is all that can be done, whilst making it clear you are there for them at all times in the future. You don't know if there are other reasons for their strong feelings, and allowing them the time and space to work out how they feel is the best thing to do.

Nothing has to be so final, so dramatic. It can simply be space and time to think things through, or it may be permanent if the other person feels they can not move past what has happened.

You talk about splitting people into camps, and that you have many on your side. I have to say that rang lots of alarm bells, why on earth are you gathering a side against someone you supposedly love? Surely the best thing to do is keep everyone else out of the equation so you can focus on a possible solution?
It won't endear you to anyone by doing this, and can across as bullying.

I would stop making things worse, and start by being respectful. It is the foundation of any relationship, and you won't get anywhere without it.

Thank you for taking the time to write all of this. It's hard to get context from what is a very limited idea of what has gone on and I'm sorry for that. I don't think rehashing all of the whys and wherefores is good for me but what I will say is that I have always, ALWAYS been open to reconcilliation and the chance to move forwards but this has been met with nothing less than awful, awful responses. I have looked and looked at things that have happened, trust me when I say it has occupied many conversations and space in my head. I can hand on heart say that there is nothing that I have said that can be taken as anything less than considered and polite and an obvious attempt to try to see a positive way out of this for everyone. I know this makes me sound saintly and having put no foot wrong! :-(

I don't think I mentioned splitting people into camps? If I did then it wasn't meant to be taken the way you have inferred. I have friends and people who sit completely removed from the situation and have nothing to do with anyone else involved other than me. That's not me being divisive in any way, it's just friendships I have - and people who are supportive but would pull me up on mistakes I might have made. I am able to realise there are two sides which is why I will always be open to a conversation and jump to help in a heartbeat.

Thank you to everyone who has taken the time to write such considered responses to my ask for advice. I have read all of them and will spend some time thinking about all that has happened.

OP posts:
BSky · 07/06/2022 09:32

I'm also dealing with an estrangement - the advice of @KarmaStar is helpful.
I think estrangement is like a grief and being kind and compassionate to yourself can help. It sounds trite but gratitude is a comfort - when the pain/anger/hurt/sadness of the estrangement hits I try to think of the things I'm grateful for. Especially the small things

I do also think recognising that estrangement/NC can be positive and empowering - as people who've had traumatic/abusive relationships. It's important to recognise how we deserve to be treated in life, to allow ourselves to heal from hurt and to surround ourselves with people/situations that are caring and nurturing.

Swayingpalmtrees · 07/06/2022 08:53

You need to have a hard look at what they have said/what has happened and be honest with yourself, do they have a point? Could you have done things differently? Could there be an apology or acknowledgement that is owed to the other party?

Are you actually asking how to do you live with yourself, knowing you have hurt another and lost them?

Or how do you move on?

They are very different. If you know you have hurt someone else, and it has ended badly there is always time to try and put it right. Taking action to repair and heal a situation in the best way you can should make you feel better, you will know in your heart you have done your best to fix it, now the onus is on them to come back when they are ready.

If an apology is not required because you have genuinely done nothing to warrant giving one, then your conscience should be entirely clear. There should not be a nagging feeling, but simply respecting the other person's decision to step back is all that can be done, whilst making it clear you are there for them at all times in the future. You don't know if there are other reasons for their strong feelings, and allowing them the time and space to work out how they feel is the best thing to do.

Nothing has to be so final, so dramatic. It can simply be space and time to think things through, or it may be permanent if the other person feels they can not move past what has happened.

You talk about splitting people into camps, and that you have many on your side. I have to say that rang lots of alarm bells, why on earth are you gathering a side against someone you supposedly love? Surely the best thing to do is keep everyone else out of the equation so you can focus on a possible solution?
It won't endear you to anyone by doing this, and can across as bullying.

I would stop making things worse, and start by being respectful. It is the foundation of any relationship, and you won't get anywhere without it.

LifeInsideMyhead · 07/06/2022 08:25

Im not sure I agree with half of these.

Usually when someone has got to thenpoint of minimising or reducing contact there is a reason (as we can see on this thread and others.)

Often of the guilty party just acknowledged their hand in whatever it was it would make the world of differene. "Im sorry I didnt stand up for you enough as a child/ im sorry I didnt believe you as a child... i do now what can we do to move on?"

The fact the guilty party just leaves with a grump is part of the problem.

I dont think advising op just yo accept it is necessarily right. I e if it is a child who is hurt then there is way you can acknowledge and apologise and see if there is a way forwards.

I went lower contact with a family member after counselling and honestly if they were to just apologise or seem interested in me life would be different. The fact they've made no effort speaks volumes and I fear it would for you too.

LakieLady · 07/06/2022 08:10

Accept it, draw a line under it, and move on.

Dwelling on it will make it much harder to get over.

SleeplessInEngland · 07/06/2022 08:07

Sorry, but need more info to give advice. How close was this kin? How/why did the estrangement start? Can it be salvaged? Etc etc.

Don’t fly off the handle because people want to know the context or you’ll make them think ‘no wonder this family member wants nothing to do with you.’

Dacquoise · 07/06/2022 08:01

@TalkSomeSense1 , the Stately Homes thread in Relationships might be a good place for advice on this one. Non judgemental safe place to discuss family estrangement.

I am NC with my entire family which was my decision after a lifetime of abuse as the family scapegoat. Time, grieving the relationships I didn't really have and a good therapist have really helped.💐

Londonnight · 07/06/2022 07:45

You learn to live with it. I had counselling which really helped put things into perspective.
I hope at some point in the future we can put this behind us and be together again, but for now I have to accept what is happening and to get on with my own life otherwise it would drive me mad constantly thinking about it.

PurassicJark · 07/06/2022 07:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 07/06/2022 00:42

I'm the one who did the cutting off but I think the thought process can help both sides

Just because fate joined you in some random way by sharing a bunch of genetic material doesn't mean you have got to be in each other's lives

You are individual with different minds and Experiences. If it was a colleague Or random there wouldn't be such strife.

Blood doesn't mean you will get along.

milkyaqua · 06/06/2022 23:55

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 06/06/2022 23:53

And from others @milkyaqua

After her outburst, which to my mind was informative.

bottleofbeer · 06/06/2022 23:54

Yeah, being written out is my experience. It absolutely blindsided me. I didn't see it coming and so I couldn't prepare for it.

I was lied about, abused mentally and even with absolute proof in the form of texts (I will destroy you and see you with nothing as one example) which were still brushed off, I just have to live with it.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 06/06/2022 23:53

And from others @milkyaqua

Bouledeneige · 06/06/2022 23:49

I find it very hard to accept. I love them with all my heart and would give my life for them. So all I can do is indicate that I'm always here and just hope that one day our lives will come together again.

Most of the time I just keep myself busy and try to enjoy the other important relationships and pleasures in my life. I have a lot of lovely friends and very loving kind people around. But at certain points it surfaces again - when I go on family trips, when there's a bereavement, old shared jokes and laughs surface. That's hard.

I'm not a bad person. I'm a kind loving person but I've been written out.

bottleofbeer · 06/06/2022 23:47

Massively long story so I won't go into it. I lost an entire side of my family. It hurt and I have totally examined my own part in it (I'm not a baby who assumes everything is somebody else's fault) but I am satisfied that it wasn't anything I did.

How do I deal with it? Accept I can't change opinions, accept that they are entitled to that opinion and focus on those that love me. I believe they are wrong. They believe they are right. I would absolutely rage at what I saw as injustice and could not believe others could not see it. But ultimately, they were never going to stand up and say that this shit wasn't right. That was hard to take.

It will probably always upset me, but this is just how it is. I just have to let it go.

Swipe left for the next trending thread