Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable about well-off women with new Ukrainian women cleaners?

106 replies

Upsizer · 06/06/2022 13:57

A lot of my well off acquaintances have new Ukrainian female cleaners and I feel very uncomfortable about it. They talk quite openly about wanting to support the women but have made no attempt to understand the women’s professional backgrounds and I feel it’s both virtue signalling but also somewhat inappropriate. I know the government has put nothing in place to support these trained professionals back into work but to me this smacks of virtue signalling while using vulnerable people as cash in hand staff. AIBU?

OP posts:
mustlovegin · 06/06/2022 16:45

Far be it for me to actually defend the government, but there are schemes and support for people seeking work

Really? So if you were a lawyer or a CEO who was made redundant the governrment would be involved to ensure you got a job at the same level in the same type of industry? Please stop talking nonsense

RebeccaCloud9 · 06/06/2022 16:42

It's cleaning, not prostitution!

MajorCarolDanvers · 06/06/2022 16:39

What is wrong with being a cleaner? Why do you think it is demeaning?

MsMarch · 06/06/2022 16:35

a long time ago, I was forced out of a highly paid job in the City. At the time, I thought it would be fine because I had a good pay off and a good CV. The problem was that at my level, doing the job I do, there were very few jobs. I was also, I realised later, suffering from some mental health issues as a result of the long-term bullying and gaslighting I'd gone through.

I went out and found work temping locally at pretty much minimum wage. I didn't do it a lot or for long. But I certainly never felt it was beneath me to organise someone's meetings and book travel when a few months before I'd had a PA to do it for me.

And then I started my own business, in my field. And I mostly did the kind of work I was trained for and good at and that paid well. But sometimes, when work was slow, I did a slightly different type of work that was very badly paid and not what I wanted to do. But it helped pay the bills.

In any job - as a private contractor, as a temp doing basic office admin or as a highly paid city executive I only had an issue with people who talked down to me. And that happened in all three roles. People who treated me courtesly and professionally I was fine with.

Surely it's the same with Ukrainian cleaners?

motogirl · 06/06/2022 16:35

There's 3 Ukrainian women just moved here that are advertising as cleaners - one of their hosts has helped them set up a Facebook page etc. I can't see what is wrong, the town has a shortage of cleaners (most have wait lists) and the Ukrainian women are charging the normal rate for the area (£15 an hour) one of host families has accounts knowledge and is helping them keep it legitimate and set up card payments even.

thebabynanny · 06/06/2022 16:34

Upsizer · 06/06/2022 16:31

I’m not blaming “wealthy women” but this is the group that seems to be saying these things! It does feel very Lady of the Manor - I think that’s why it feels very uncomfortable to me.

And my problem with cash in hand is not tax but that this leaves people open to abuse with no insurance, guaranteed pay, protections, security or income. Plus the chance of the benefits system shafting them at some point in the future.

Yes I have worked as a cleaner and also employed a self-employed cleaner in the past.

Wait, are you accusing all these Ukrainian women of tax avoidance now as well?

thebabynanny · 06/06/2022 16:33

Would you feel the same if your friends were giving male refugees work as gardeners or builders?

Upsizer · 06/06/2022 16:31

I’m not blaming “wealthy women” but this is the group that seems to be saying these things! It does feel very Lady of the Manor - I think that’s why it feels very uncomfortable to me.

And my problem with cash in hand is not tax but that this leaves people open to abuse with no insurance, guaranteed pay, protections, security or income. Plus the chance of the benefits system shafting them at some point in the future.

Yes I have worked as a cleaner and also employed a self-employed cleaner in the past.

OP posts:
CapMarvel · 06/06/2022 16:30

mustlovegin · 06/06/2022 16:16

I know the government has put nothing in place to support these trained professionals back into work

The government does not help British citizens back into work either (highly trained or not). Why should anyone else get priority or special treatment?

Far be it for me to actually defend the government, but there are schemes and support for people seeking work.

So really, it's not wanting special treatment at all, just equal treatment. And surely it's not too big a stretch to understand why helping refugees to find work that suits their skills - particularly if there is a shortage of that skill - is a good thing.

Stylishkidintheriot · 06/06/2022 16:30

What’s bothering me here is the general assumption that there is something wrong or shameful about being a cleaner.

S0upertrooper · 06/06/2022 16:28

I'm hosting a Ukrainian woman and her child. She receives UC but has to work/seek work/ train for 16hrs pw to qualify. She is desperate to prove she is doing this so has started cleaning as it fits around school hours. It is NOT cash in hand, she receives cash but she has registered with HMRC and declares her hours to the job centre.

She has effectively started her own business and is enjoying meeting people, improving her English and having a sense of self worth. I doubt she'll be a cleaner forever but who knows, maybe she'll love being her own boss. Another Ukrainian in the area is a qualified lawyer and she is very happily working in a care home.

I don't believe these women are being exploited and I don't believe they think they are. Please don't assume you know how others feel.

newnamethanks · 06/06/2022 16:27

Ridiculous. For the time being it's a reasonable solution, I doubt this government has put anything sensible in place to help them. Having some money in your pocket is very reassuring and helps people feel less vulnerable.

Naunet · 06/06/2022 16:25

Upsizer · 06/06/2022 13:57

A lot of my well off acquaintances have new Ukrainian female cleaners and I feel very uncomfortable about it. They talk quite openly about wanting to support the women but have made no attempt to understand the women’s professional backgrounds and I feel it’s both virtue signalling but also somewhat inappropriate. I know the government has put nothing in place to support these trained professionals back into work but to me this smacks of virtue signalling while using vulnerable people as cash in hand staff. AIBU?

Is it only women that need a cleaner then, not men?

Frenchyfrog · 06/06/2022 16:21

Why are you only concerned about ‘wealthy’ women? Do men not get a say when employing a cleaner? In our household we make decisions jointly, as I imagine most do in a joint household. Seems like you’re laying all the blame at women.

mustlovegin · 06/06/2022 16:16

I know the government has put nothing in place to support these trained professionals back into work

The government does not help British citizens back into work either (highly trained or not). Why should anyone else get priority or special treatment?

NumberTheory · 06/06/2022 16:10

The cash in hand is an issue and the “I’m doing it to help refugees” is facile. But employing these women (or any who want the job) on a living wage is a great thing to do and a really good way for well off people to spend money.

Triffid1 · 06/06/2022 16:08

@HeleenaHandcart I can understand what you're saying here and completely agree that paying massively under the going rate and then claiming it's "support" is ridiculous.

Personally, while I have donated ad hoc to a few appeals, I don't have sufficient spare cash to just support someone long term. Nor do I have space in my home. I can also admit that I am not the kind of person who feels able to invite a stranger to live with me.

However, if I was aware of an Ukrainian woman locally who was looking for cleaning work because her English/visa/qualificatinos aren't currently usable in England and I was in the market for a cleaner, I would be more than happy to employ such a woman. I would also pay her a fair wage and would do what I could to support her. I don't think that makes me a bad person.

GentlemanJay · 06/06/2022 16:06

If they are paying them the going rate then fine.

I can't believe by a coincidence you have various friends who are employing Ukrainian women who have only just arrived in Britain to escape the war.

Fifi0102 · 06/06/2022 16:06

It's virtue signaling I employ British cleaners. I work 12 hours shifts and prefer to chill on my days off . It's employment that fits into school hours , I don't really see the issue .

adlitem · 06/06/2022 16:05

Upsizer · 06/06/2022 14:33

I don’t think there’s anything wrong with being a cleaner. I am uncomfortable when people pay cash in hand for this work. And I am uncomfortable that several of my friends have told me that they are doing this to help refugees - if they really wanted to help shouldn’t they be paying them through an agency or similar?

Why would it be better if they are paid through an agency? It's probably economically better for the women to receive the money directly (rather than pay agency overheads, plus admin for being set up as an employee etc).
I am a little torn on it, but I can understand that many of them would value having something to do and earning some money. Someone might be a Ukrainian lawyer, but that would have very little value in the UK job market (I say that as a UK lawyer).
showing off about it, as though you are somehow mother theresa for doing it, is in really poor taste though.

Chaoslatte · 06/06/2022 16:03

It might not be possible for all professions to automatically transfer over (English skills aside). Lawyers and accountants for example are qualified in their specific countries - eg in English law or U.K. accounting rules. So any Ukrainians from those professions might find themselves needing to re-qualify if they wanted to work here. What’s the problem in taking on some cleaning work while you figure out what to do?

Iwonder08 · 06/06/2022 16:03

What do you expect Ukrainian refugees to do in UK when most don't speak decent level of English? Cleaner is an honest and decent job that can be done without the language knowledge. If your rich friends specifically prioritie Ukrainian cleaners over everyone else they do indeed give them this extra opportunity

DirtyteaCup · 06/06/2022 16:02

A few years ago a Lithuanian guy started at our local shop, spoke very little English. Always wanted to chat to improve his English and asked a lot of questions about everything. Within a couple of years his English was great and he went on to be the store manager (national chain). Then left and now runs a very large business in town (I would guess £50K salary)

Should I have felt sorry for him when he was learning English, he was taking a job that let him learn quickly?

Paq · 06/06/2022 15:56

Why do women get flack for employing cleaners? Why not men? Or does their magical penis suck up all their dirt and mess?

😂😂😂 if only! But it's a good point well made, why is it bad for women to hire cleaners but okay for men?

HeleenaHandcart · 06/06/2022 15:50

I’m Ukrainian and I’ve really struggled to bite my tongue with some friends on this issue.
One has even text me about her ‘support’. She’s got a cheap cleaner basically, who’s forced to undercut others to get work. There’s a shortage locally and otherwise prices are really high in the area for cleaning. A woman who’s fled here, without the support of her husband, alone with 3 kids in a strangers rooms.
Frankly the friend is rich enough to sponsor the family the cleaning amount without it being noticeable at all in her world. That’s support.
Friend otherwise has done nothing, not sent a text otherwise (we were pretty close). I’m had 6 family members over the last few months squeeze in my house, supported many acquaintances through the visa process, supported people through church and generally felt half crazy at times with the stress-including the worry of most my family staying in Ukraine. No one owes me support I know, but it fucks me off to hear nothing but a virtuous message about a new cleaner and nothing else.

Get a cleaner. Whatever. It’s her life. But cut the ‘support’ rubbish unless you are doing more than enjoying a cheap rate cleaner who’s otherwise a professional women with no other option. Paying her a bit extra, helping in other ways- great. Otherwise people need to drop the ‘support’ line. It’s just called getting a new cleaner.