Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad for Prince Harry

417 replies

OldManRivers · 06/06/2022 12:07

Have been looking at the photos today of Harry in the car being driven from the airport in America back to his home. He looks so sad. It must be very difficult for him to attend a huge family occasion like that with his role drastically changed, and to see all of his family but now he's on the sidelines popping in so very sporadically.

Also I can't help but think he must feel sad to think his children won't grow up around their cousins, and extended family. Meghan doesn't have any family except her mother so they don't have any in America either.

Originally he and Meghan wanted to carry on being part of the royal machine and do appearances etc but also have some independence so it's not as though this life was their original plan, where it seems like they're sidelined and alienated. AIBU to think regardless of what's gone on it must be very hard for him to be in another country, away from his ailing grandmother who he is very close to, and feel like a bit of an outcast?

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 08/06/2022 09:57

I am sure Meghan and Harry can easily take the Mail and any other rag to court if the claim is UNTRUE puzzled they have had no problem at all spraying court orders all over the place, so I can't see them letting it go. Of course it is true, and is in many other papers this morning as well.

DFOD · 07/06/2022 16:37

JemimaPuddlegoose · 07/06/2022 14:07

It will be the truth, from impeccable sources, checked and double checked.

LOL I did not have "the Daily Mail is the impeccable gospel truth" on my Meghan hater bingo card for today. GrinGrinGrin

Obviously you've never worked in the press, like I have. Or been featured in the Daily Mail (again, like I have).

So if the Mail is this renowned vessel of verisimilitude, who is the trusted high-up person inside the RF who's ringing up the Daily Mail to tell them all about private royal children's parties.

Either it's all lies and the Palace isn't acting on lies; OR the RF is actively authorising leaks and violating the Queen's privacy in order to deliberately smear the Queen's grandchild; OR someone high-up in the Palace is betraying the RF by leaking private conversations and things that happened during royal children's private birthday parties to the tabloids.

None of those three options exactly leave the Palace looking good, do they?

Well your first option leaves the RF with clean hands?

Also how does it square that HMQ loves her grandson Harry so much but personally as the head of the organisation sanctions 24/7 blitz of negative press that wrecks his MH? Or facilitates and sanctions it indirectly via grey suits leaking and smearing? It’s not adding up for me.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 07/06/2022 15:34

It will be the truth, from impeccable sources, checked and double checked

In the Mail? Hmmm ... Hmm

In fairness to them - though it chokes me - what they are skilled at is wrapping their editorial in "quotes from sources" to enable just enough to insinuate something without coming out and saying it directly

And of course they can't be forced to reveal their "sources" except for a court order very rarely granted - something their platoons of lawyers will know perfectly well

JemimaPuddlegoose · 07/06/2022 14:07

It will be the truth, from impeccable sources, checked and double checked.

LOL I did not have "the Daily Mail is the impeccable gospel truth" on my Meghan hater bingo card for today. GrinGrinGrin

Obviously you've never worked in the press, like I have. Or been featured in the Daily Mail (again, like I have).

So if the Mail is this renowned vessel of verisimilitude, who is the trusted high-up person inside the RF who's ringing up the Daily Mail to tell them all about private royal children's parties.

Either it's all lies and the Palace isn't acting on lies; OR the RF is actively authorising leaks and violating the Queen's privacy in order to deliberately smear the Queen's grandchild; OR someone high-up in the Palace is betraying the RF by leaking private conversations and things that happened during royal children's private birthday parties to the tabloids.

None of those three options exactly leave the Palace looking good, do they?

JemimaPuddlegoose · 07/06/2022 13:53

Another day, another article on Horrid Harry and Mean Meghan. What better decoy for preserving the rest of that family's image?

Yes, well said.

To add to that, the Royals and the tabloid press and the government all engage in quid pro quos. You scratch my back and I'll scratch yours.

The tabloids press demand scandal and coverage. One tabloid paparazzo is on record as saying the reason he hates Meghan is that her leaving the UK has cost him hundreds of thousands of pounds in predicted earnings and that he'd expected to put his children through school and retire early off the back of selling photos of Meghan and her children.

The tabloid press is a machine that needs to be constantly fed, and they demand scandal. Sweet photos of Kate baking cupcakes with her kids doesn't feed that demand. That's why for all of modern royal history at least one royal has been the scandalous 'bad' one who's always in the press. Diana, Fergie, the York sisters, Kate, someone has to play that role and they either tolerate it or they get out and thus get smeared. Even before that, Princess Margaret was the tabloid 'wild child' who created scandal. It's pretty clear the press are preparing for Charlotte and Louis to be the next generation sacrificial scandalambs, and no doubt a lot of the anger at Harry and Meghan at leaving is because they and their children aren't around to be put in that role anymore.

The RF's willingness to make their own sacrificial lambs gives them a certain amount of power to protect the royals whose images need to be protected at all costs, which basically means the monarch and direct heirs. Look how Diana was completely trashed and smeared to protect Charles' reputation. And how aggressively they've protected William over the unsavoury rumours (and the alleged deals made with the press that the press won't cover anything bad about William in exchange for being given stories about Harry). Compare the coverage of Queen's favourite Andrew with the coverage of Harry. The tabloids went far easier on Andrew for hanging out with convicted pedos and paying off a sex trafficking survivor who accused him of rape, than Harry who's only crime was protecting his beloved wife and doing a moany interview.

The tabloid press are right wing and in the pocket of the Tory government. How often has the RF benefited from government influence (the RF being given an exemption from laws banning racial hiring discrimination, all the dodgy financial stuff, William's secret meetings with politicians in Scotland which resulted in C4 overtly accusing Kensington Palace of lies and harassment). And how many times has some negative Tory story like Matt Hancock being found to have acted unlawfully been bumped off the front page because the RF conveniently released a negative story about Meghan?

DFOD · 07/06/2022 13:42

JemimaPuddlegoose · 07/06/2022 13:24

Personally I think it's a lie. No one knows anything that happened during the private birthday party because it was private. It's only Meghan haters who come running to these threads to repeat everything the Daily Mail says as though it's gospel.

The Queen and Harry obviously love each other and get along well. Most likely they had a lovely time at a private birthday party, and either the tabloids were so incensed not to have any gossip from the party they just made up lies, or some
courtier or perhaps someone who wasn't invited leaked a fake story designed to paint Harry and Meghan in a bad light.

The palace smear campaign against Harry and Meghan is exactly the same as the smear campaign against Diana. Married-in royals are always thrown to the wolves and only protected once they've proven their "loyalty" (ie willingness to silently tolerate any amount of abuse and lies from the press, willing to have bad stories released about them when a more important royal needs protecting).

Anyone who steps out of line or is non-compliant gets smeared. Diana was the mother of the future King but she still got a despicable smear campaign intended to portray her as mentally unstable and to gaslight her, for standing up to them and refusing to accept infidelity and emotional abuse. Harry and Meghan were thrown under a bus to protect more important royals and are now being smeared for standing up for themselves and their children by leaving. The Jason Knauf scandal alone shows how corrupt the Firm is. And it's not necessarily the royals themselves, but the courtiers, the famous little grey men, who have so much power.

This makes some sense - that it’s the firm/grey suits that are pulling the strings (to keep the institution intact and themselves in a job) - although it would require approval (even if it’s a blind eye) by the RF leadership - do we believe that HMQ sanctioned the Diana stuff in the past and is now responsible for sanctioning the smear/lies/leaks around her grandson Harry and his wife? I find it hard to compute!

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 07/06/2022 13:38

@JemimaPuddlegoose, that's the crux. There is a constant repetition in the media that the Windsors have no power. (They do. They've always had far too much power over what appears about them in the media, and the media has a huge degree of power over public opinion). There seems to be an unwritten rule that if a member of the public speaks to a Windsor, the content of that conversation must not be divulged on any pretext. The Queen has a meeting with our elected PM weekly, the contents of which we are not allowed to know. Their PR machine is about the most powerful there is.

The second PR drive is that the British public universally loves them and thinks themselves lucky to have them, all bar a minority of flaky republicans. True? Just ask around a few people you know (MN isn't a representative sample). Hell, even the establishment-living Mail readers, when there isn't a Jubilee celebration ongoing, are exasperated with their antics.

I'd be against the hereditary system of this constitution (that includes the Lords) on political grounds were the Windsors the most benign, caring, wonderful bunch of people ever to walk these green and pleasant lands. But this lot are particularly poor custodians of their very great, unelected privilege.

Swayingpalmtrees · 07/06/2022 13:35

Personally I think it's a lie

It is not going to be a lie, of that we do know, because Harry and Meghan are very fond of taking all and sundry to court!

It will be the truth, from impeccable sources, checked and double checked.

It was the right call not to have cameras etc, the Queen does want to be soiled with their latest money making fodder. They were there to get as much out of it as they could, and everyone knows it. Pure self interest.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 07/06/2022 13:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ameliarosethistle · 07/06/2022 13:30

Maybe a little but he's a multi-millionaire, living in a great house, lovely location, with a wife, kids and can basically go anywhere or do anything that he likes so of all of the people to feel sorry for in this world, I don't really feel it for Harry.

It might be a bit sad for their kids that they only regularly see one of their grandparents but I'm sure they have other people that they are close to as a family.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 07/06/2022 13:24

Personally I think it's a lie. No one knows anything that happened during the private birthday party because it was private. It's only Meghan haters who come running to these threads to repeat everything the Daily Mail says as though it's gospel.

The Queen and Harry obviously love each other and get along well. Most likely they had a lovely time at a private birthday party, and either the tabloids were so incensed not to have any gossip from the party they just made up lies, or some
courtier or perhaps someone who wasn't invited leaked a fake story designed to paint Harry and Meghan in a bad light.

The palace smear campaign against Harry and Meghan is exactly the same as the smear campaign against Diana. Married-in royals are always thrown to the wolves and only protected once they've proven their "loyalty" (ie willingness to silently tolerate any amount of abuse and lies from the press, willing to have bad stories released about them when a more important royal needs protecting).

Anyone who steps out of line or is non-compliant gets smeared. Diana was the mother of the future King but she still got a despicable smear campaign intended to portray her as mentally unstable and to gaslight her, for standing up to them and refusing to accept infidelity and emotional abuse. Harry and Meghan were thrown under a bus to protect more important royals and are now being smeared for standing up for themselves and their children by leaving. The Jason Knauf scandal alone shows how corrupt the Firm is. And it's not necessarily the royals themselves, but the courtiers, the famous little grey men, who have so much power.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 07/06/2022 13:20

what people do you mean - ie inside the RF? Do you think it started there and the RF or the RF machine stirred up the press with negative stories about H&M deliberately?

Also leaving the racism issue aside. Yes, I do believe this. Reading between the lines it's difficult to come to any other conclusion. Someone very close to the inside of that dynamic was leaking like a basket, at one stage on an almost daily basis. The stories were practically all to Meghan's detriment. Even allowing for the fact that Harry isn't the sharpest, no one in their right senses would efficiently stage-manage media smear campaign against themselves, calculated to show them up in the worst light possible. This just would not happen.

Rebekah Vardy isn't the brightest, either, but her case highlights how these campaigns of leaking operate, and what's involved in these mutually beneficial dynamics set up between individuals and the media, no doubt in return for glowing coverage of themselves. It's not unfeasible that this is what's happened here. The reason Markle is so widely loathed, IMO, is that few stand a chance against such a slick PR machine as the Windsors'. Their advisors, if not themselves, are not as dim as Vardy.

I can’t see how the RF as individuals and family - siblings / father / grandmother would benefit from doing this?

There are several ways. A schism had opened up within the family and someone, for whatever reason, believed Harry and Meghan needed putting back into their box. The reasons are a matter of speculation: all we can see is what was going in the media. Certain family members were receiving a poor press for laziness. Meghan, unlike most Windsors including her husband, is smart and articulate. The DM venerated the Cambridges to such an extent that their readers started sarcastically referring to her as Saint Kate. Rumour was rife in the overseas media that William was in the throes of an affair with his Norfolk neighbour. (Immediately, a counter-rumour went around that someone admitted the story was made-up. They didn't. They merely said they had no real evidence it was going on - a different thing entirely). Then, of course, there was Andrew. His misdemeanors are far graver, but he hasn't been subject to the same censure.

Another day, another article on Horrid Harry and Mean Meghan. What better decoy for preserving the rest of that family's image?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 07/06/2022 13:15

No link offered to the alleged Daily Mail headline I see - I wonder if that was another thing that was made up?

DFOD we'll probably never know how the RF responded to any complaints Harry may have made from the start. On current form he might well claim nobody cared, and they'd probably revert to the famous "recollections may differ"
So that leaves some to fill the blanks with "facts" of their choice, and fill them in they certainly will

DFOD · 07/06/2022 12:55

JemimaPuddlegoose · 07/06/2022 12:34

I'm not surprised nobody wants to talk to them really, they must be terrified of everything they say being repeated, out of context, to the media. All this from people who are desperate for privacy...

The RF leak stuff to the media ten times more than Harry and Meghan ever did. The RF are the ones that leak constantly. The RF are the ones who planted a spy in Harry and Meghan's house - someone who got rewarded with a cushy CEO job when he'd been breaking his NDA by giving stories about his royal bosses to the press for months.

Look at the Daily Mail story about the photographer, who do you think leaked that? Certainly not Harry and Meghan. It's either a lie, or someone on the royal side leaked it in order to attack Harry and Meghan. Again.

No wonder Harry and Meghan don't trust Harry's family when they constantly go running to the press to spill everything Harry does. Poor Harry, not being able to trust his own backstabbing family.

I suspect going to Hollywood to get out of the limelight and live a quiet life isn't all it's cracked up to be.

They don't live anywhere near Hollywood. They don't even live close to LA. At least get the basic facts right.

Lets face it, she's cut off from all her family apart from her mother

The only person she's cut off was her dad, and he's the one who ghosted her, not the other way around! Just lies and hate for no reason.

“Look at the Daily Mail story about the photographer, who do you think leaked that? Certainly not Harry and Meghan. It's either a lie, or someone on the royal side leaked it in order to attack Harry and Meghan. Again.”

@JemimaPuddlegoose what do you think is the reality here - separately both in terms of what actually happened with photos and then what is the origin of the story - a lie or a leak and what is the purpose of a leak? Why do the RF want to attack H&M? Surely they all want a quiet life and to focus on HMQ? Leaking doesn’t achieve this.

  1. HMQ and PC had loads of family snaps taken with their DGGD and DGD at her first birthday party but have asked H&M that they remain personal and private and H&M agree. Mail made it up - so it's a lie.
  1. HMQ and PC had loads of family snaps taken asked for them to remain private. H&M reluctantly comply. The Mail are briefed this - why?
  1. HMQ and PC insisted that no family snaps were taken.
  1. HMQ and PC have not met their grand daughter.
JemimaPuddlegoose · 07/06/2022 12:41

People came to dislike her because she and Harry seemed to be taking the piss, mainly.

I would also like to know what Meghan did wrong prior to the wedding that caused the extreme and non-stop hate and abuse that existed in the press and online during the engagement.

People claiming that Meghan was greeted warmly and that public opinion changed only after they left are trying to re-write history.

In reality, the hate and abuse was at its height during two periods, the engagement, and her first pregnancy.

The hate towards Meghan here on MN was certainly at its height during the engagement. And many of the Meghan-bashing threads (often half a dozen a day) were deleted for containing overt racism and racial slurs.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 07/06/2022 12:34

I'm not surprised nobody wants to talk to them really, they must be terrified of everything they say being repeated, out of context, to the media. All this from people who are desperate for privacy...

The RF leak stuff to the media ten times more than Harry and Meghan ever did. The RF are the ones that leak constantly. The RF are the ones who planted a spy in Harry and Meghan's house - someone who got rewarded with a cushy CEO job when he'd been breaking his NDA by giving stories about his royal bosses to the press for months.

Look at the Daily Mail story about the photographer, who do you think leaked that? Certainly not Harry and Meghan. It's either a lie, or someone on the royal side leaked it in order to attack Harry and Meghan. Again.

No wonder Harry and Meghan don't trust Harry's family when they constantly go running to the press to spill everything Harry does. Poor Harry, not being able to trust his own backstabbing family.

I suspect going to Hollywood to get out of the limelight and live a quiet life isn't all it's cracked up to be.

They don't live anywhere near Hollywood. They don't even live close to LA. At least get the basic facts right.

Lets face it, she's cut off from all her family apart from her mother

The only person she's cut off was her dad, and he's the one who ghosted her, not the other way around! Just lies and hate for no reason.

DFOD · 07/06/2022 12:33

MangyInseam · 07/06/2022 12:00

People came to dislike her because she and Harry seemed to be taking the piss, mainly.

But it doesn't really matter, there are all kinds of royals the press have not liked, sometimes quite unfairly. Racism is hardly the only explanation.

OK let’s leave the racism to one side for a moment - what incidents do you think Harry and Meghan were taking the piss that led people to dislike them?

And what people do you mean - ie inside the RF? Do you think it started there and the RF or the RF machine stirred up the press with negative stories about H&M deliberately?

I can’t see how the RF as individuals and family - siblings / father / grandmother would benefit from doing this? What would their goal have been? I suspect the opposite that relationships became tense within the family but that they would try to keep a neutral public face as this would be in the RF interests.

Insertusername123 · 07/06/2022 12:25

I have never warmed to MM because she reminds me very much of someone I know. And I think this maybe the same for others.

Yes this is from media reports,and their own interviews,not for personal experiences but I think others have come to the same conclusion.

This person used me,and others for their own gain. Once I saw through her and stood up to her she never spoke to me again,yet from the outside she had friends. These people were similar to her,or were scared of her.

I think we all went to school with a women like MM,we've all worked with a women like her and we have all seen the fallout to someone we care about when a women like her turns.

Its nothing to do with the skin colour of her father or where she was born,she just doesn't come across as a nice person and maybe the public are protective of Harry after his mothers death.

SeriaIBreeder · 07/06/2022 12:13

MangyInseam · 07/06/2022 12:00

People came to dislike her because she and Harry seemed to be taking the piss, mainly.

But it doesn't really matter, there are all kinds of royals the press have not liked, sometimes quite unfairly. Racism is hardly the only explanation.

I don't know what alternative there is to the irrational hate - the people who actually follow people they hate (more than people who like them!). Not everyone is, but out of all of the people who hate her I'd guess racism plays a role.

Definitely those who deny the racism accusations. Whether or not you like Meghan, you don't have to snip and poke holes in everything she does.

SeriaIBreeder · 07/06/2022 12:08

JudgeJ · 07/06/2022 11:31

It is racist to speculate on the colour of someone else's baby

Then I know lots of people who are in families of different heritage who you could throw that accusation against! When a baby is expected parents to be, families, friends often debate characteristics, a Ghanaian friend married to a Japanese woman is having some real fun at the moment. It's not nasty, it's normal behaviour.

@JudgeJ No. another family member who is asking whether the baby will be too dark is racism. Black people are NOT exempt from colourism either, it's very common for people to check babies' ears at birth to see the colour.

It is not normal to question how dark another persons baby is. It IS normal to wonder what you're baby will look like. We're not stupid, nor is Meghan.

MangyInseam · 07/06/2022 12:00

People came to dislike her because she and Harry seemed to be taking the piss, mainly.

But it doesn't really matter, there are all kinds of royals the press have not liked, sometimes quite unfairly. Racism is hardly the only explanation.

DFOD · 07/06/2022 11:57

MangyInseam · 06/06/2022 23:55

No, the press was never over the top racist and 99% of it wasn't even a little bit. THat Oprah interview they did had to pull headlines from totally different countries, or edit them, to get anything like that.

Most people were very positive and seemed quite pleased about the whole thing, including in the press. The tone changed because people came to dislike her. Which may not have been fair but it wasn't a race thing.

When and why did people come to dislike her @MangyInseam?

And what people are you referring to - the immediate RF (C&C, W&K?), the broader RF firm “men in grey suits”, the press or the public?

Wheresthebeach · 07/06/2022 11:56

@thebellagio I think you've made some good points. I wonder if he didn't brief her fully because the others had walked away.

Their behaviour has been very spoilt - complete public fits when they didn't get what they wanted. Combined with a bizarre level of helplessness - if Meighan was suffering why didn't he get help? Why was it the palaces job? He'd been in therapy so it's not like he couldn't pick up the phone easily enough.

It comes across like everything wrong is someone else's fault, they are victims, and it's all unfair so I'm going to throw my toys out of my pram. In public so everyone understand how hard done I am. It's like complaining about being 'cut off' financially, in your thirties, when you've £34 mil in the bank. I don't get why people weren't outraged by the entitlement.

Dinoteeth · 07/06/2022 11:54

They could easily have had a life like the Yorks and Phillips.
The Wessex are full working Royals but guard their privacy and their children few people would recognise their kids in the street.

But they seemed to wants the glam bits of being royal without the mundane opening community centers.
And they desperately wanted to trade of the Royal name and connections. It never worked for Edward either.

My predictions for the future is he and Meg will split and he'll slowly work his way back into the Royal fold.

DFOD · 07/06/2022 11:49

JemimaPuddlegoose · 06/06/2022 22:08

Was the MM racism always there in the press from day one? I don’t read the red tops (maybe it was also there in the broadsheets) - was it bubbling under subtly and then gathered a head of steam? Can anyone pinpoint an event / timeline when the either the tide turned or was it a slow build?

From the tabloids, yes I think so. The "Straight Outta Compton" Daily Mail headline was from 2016, and was the first headline to overtly reference a racist stereotype, and the same year the Mail published an article referring to Doria's "exotic DNA."

Harry's statement against the racist bullying in the press was all the way back in November 2016, and the statement claimed they'd been dealing with defamatory articles on a daily basis, as well as having to call the police over pap break-ins. So even in the very early stages of their relationship, it was evidently pretty bad.

The Daily Mail responded to the engagement news in 2017 by publishing a headline saying "Yes, they're in love. So why do I have niggles about the engagement photo" where the word NIGGLES was right over her face. And before people start complaining that niggles is a perfectly ordinary, non-racist word; yes it is. Of course the word niggles is not inherently racist, and people use it every day in non-racist contexts. But context does matter. Niggles is an odd word choice to use in this context, and it seems pretty obvious that plastering a word that's one letter different from a racial slur all over Meghan's face was a goady dog whistle.

The following year the Daily Mail published a headline reading, "Meghan's seed will taint our Royal Family" - the headline was actually a quote from a text that the girlfriend of a UKIP MP had sent, which had resulted in her being suspended from UKIP. But the Mail initially chose to use just that as their headline, and later edited it to read "UKIP leader's girlfriend suspended over racist texts.

A lot of it was subtle, dog whistles and things with racist undertones, rather than very overt racism. This can actually be more problematic and insidious than overt racism, since it leads to black women being gaslighted and told they're being oversensitive, or that they're imagining racism.

Regardless of the racial component, there was certainly an extraordinary amount of abuse and hostility towards Meghan in the press, pretty much from the start.

That's really interesting that the racist British press were at it from the beginning in an underhand way that not everyone could see so overtly. They obviously know that this sells papers and as PP has said is a covert dog whistle to the public who overtly post racist comments.

How did the rest of the RF respond in 2016? Did they support Harry's complaints from the top and from the start?

If not how would it have benefited the firm/RF to collude or allow this to happen?

My personal experience was one of sensing positivity through their relationship, engagement, wedding, trips abroad and birth of Archie etc - maybe I was just in a different echo chamber. I am not denying this was happening as it clearly did just can't fathom what the RF role in it was?