Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disturbed by this comment from DM?

414 replies

greenvelvetcouch · 06/06/2022 11:56

My sister had a baby last year, and due to covid-reasons and a pretty lengthy stay in NICU my DM didn’t meet her baby until she was 37 days old.

I was discussing my Dsis with DM at the weekend and she said to me that my sister was fine and had dealt with it all brilliantly (I disagree - I think she is very damaged by the experience and her husband and I both want her to talk to someone about it all), but DM was still “traumatised” by the experience because it’s not natural for a baby to be kept from its grandmother for so long.

I didn’t call her out on it at the time, but I found this comment so disturbing and it made me worry about the level of entitlement my DM seems to have towards her grandchild. I don’t think grandparents have any “right” to their grandchildren, and I wouldn’t want her acting like that at all when I have my baby. I’ve never had much cause to worry about her beyond her being a bit of an obsessed granny/slightly lonely widow who loves her family but I can’t cope with her being suffocating about seeing my child/ren. I was expecting to ban any visits for 2-3 weeks at least when I have my baby and this would include her.

Is this comment a worrying sign of what’s to come? Do you agree with her?

OP posts:
godmum56 · 06/06/2022 15:37

Thistooshallpsss · 06/06/2022 14:37

Op just take into account the primal fear your mother might go through especially if your Labour is difficult. I practically climbed over the cot to reach my precious daughter who was still quite poorly. I needed to hug her and see that she was ok.

but again you are making this about you and not about your daughter

FabFitFifties · 06/06/2022 15:33

Congratulations by the way! I hope everything works out well for you all.

greyinganddecaying · 06/06/2022 15:31

@greenvelvetcouch - fwiw I seem to be reading your OP completely differently to everyone else.

I read that your mum is dismissing your sister's trauma (by saying she's fine) but highlighting (possibly exaggerating) how she (your mum) feels - I read that and felt that she was being very over dramatic and may have the tendency to make other similar situations all about her (instead of the people directly involved).

(I had a baby on NICU and whilst I appreciated other people were affected by this, I found it really unhelpful when they expected us to emotionally support them - we were only just holding it together as it was).

When I had a baby I saw very few people for 2-3 weeks as I really struggled (traumatic labour/birth, medical complications afterwards etc etc). I had 2 visitors in hospital who stayed for 30 minutes, then saw no one else until we were ready. The idea of having someone who would come along and make it all about them (as I wonder if your mum would), or even someone who wanted to be there with us all the time (as your mum might if she lives some distance away) would have horrified me and I would have found it suffocating too.

FabFitFifties · 06/06/2022 15:31

In my experience, the new mother's who struggle the most emotionally, are those who feel they must control things, and have set plans of how things should be. This includes rigid birth plans too. I honestly think, given your family norms and geography don't make frequent visits likely, that allowing a very early visit, would avoid a lot of problems and upset. You are much more likely to get your calm bonding time this way. GM will be hopefully be happy, and go home, knowing she can visit again in a few weeks,and maybe get some whatsapp/telephone updates to keep her going. Don't cut your nose off to spite your face. People care.

SaySomethingMan · 06/06/2022 15:27

Chickenmicken · 06/06/2022 12:06

I wouldn't 'ban' visits. You are not royalty. You 'ban' visits for 3 weeks and I wouldn't visit you again. Say you are too tired whenever someone wants to come round. No need to make yourself unpopular.

I agree with this. You’re coming across as very dramatic.
it’s a baby.
Do what you want.
I feel sorry for DGPs whose children suddenly become dramatic without good reason.

You’ll have a newborn. That’s not exactly a calm situation. Fair enough that you won’t be feeling or looking your best but banning your own DM for three weeks for no reason?

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 06/06/2022 15:24

There is research showing that people laugh at jokes more when other people are around - if you watch a standup bit on Netflix by yourself, you can find it amusing, but you’re more likely to find it truly hilarious if you’re watching it with friends. Laughing is possible alone, but it is primarily social.

I’ve found parenting (especially babies and not-yet-very-verbal toddlers) to be similar. Yes, the moments bonding alone can be lovely, but the greatest, most uplifting joy always came from watching my babies alongside my parents. I swear, they were cuter when the GPs were around. 😝

All that aside, as many PPs have pointed out, new parenthood can be totally overwhelming. My midwife always said “a newborn is a three person job”. I thought she was a bit OTT until I was faced with trying to complete my first post-labour bowel movement. I was crying on the toilet and trying to do all the same controlled breathing as in labour. I ended up nearly passing out from the pain. I needed my DH to come help me stay upright, and get me back to bed. Meanwhile the baby was SHRIEKING in her bassinet. Had my mum not been there to pick her up, our options would have been a) letting a 3-day-old “cry-it-out” for 20 minutes, or b) having my DH tend to the baby while I lay crumpled on the bathroom floor, covered in blood. Yup… 3 person job!!!

EnterACloud · 06/06/2022 15:22

greenvelvetcouch · 06/06/2022 15:16

@EnterACloud I love a bit of a amateur psychology, I often dabble myself!

I think there’s some truth to some of your takes on my Dad and my relationship with my Mum. I’ll think on those. It’s obviously impossible to ever know things for sure but I am very certain he wouldn’t have minded respecting our boundaries, but that’s not that important.

I’ll think about a balance. I might try and have a discussion with my sister or sister in law about their takes on it to be honest and see if they think mothers should get a short visit in the first week or so. My sister is usually very honest with me!

This sounds like a plan. I'd also think about it in terms of a long-term cost/benefit analysis for everyone.

Pros of your mum having a short visit early on:


  • she gets to meet the baby, potentially a nice experience for all

  • prevents her complaining for the next umpteen years about being kept away

  • could be practical help for you even if it's only holding the baby while you have a shower for example

  • you get a hug from your mum after a hugely stressful experience

  • gets the grandparent/parent/child relationship off to a positive start

  • some (albeit short) disruption to your bonding/routine

  • potential for her to upset you with some melodrama

  • not sure what else but you'll know what you fear happening

KimikosNightmare · 06/06/2022 15:22

Smogtopia · 06/06/2022 15:20

I get so much joy from watching the close bond my children have with aunts, uncles and grandparents. They gain so much from these loving adults in their lives. Why you'd deny that is baffling to me

Because people are different. Families are different. What is so difficult to understand about that? Not everyone lives in your cosy little world.

Smogtopia · 06/06/2022 15:20

I get so much joy from watching the close bond my children have with aunts, uncles and grandparents. They gain so much from these loving adults in their lives. Why you'd deny that is baffling to me

Fearneyox · 06/06/2022 15:17

Poor baby. You’re coming across very naive and controlling OP. There is no prize for being stubbornly independent and restrictive. You are clearly not close to your Mum, or there is some underlying issue you are not fully addressing. Nobody who is close to their mother would treat them like this. Setting strict rules before you’ve even had your child and know what it takes to raise one is just silly, you are making a rod for your own back. When you need help - which you will - don’t expect people to come running if this is how you treat them.

Parenting is hard. I am very independent and have so far loved the newborn journey but I wouldn’t be having half as much fun if it weren’t for the support of my friends and family. Love doesn’t dilute if shared around - so surround your baby with as much love as possible, not just yours.

greenvelvetcouch · 06/06/2022 15:16

OutsideLookingOut · 06/06/2022 15:01

I don't have much to add but that it is wonderful that you are so clear on your boundaries and so calm i your responses. We are all different afterall. You may change your mind, you may not but I love a woman who won't be bullied into things she doesn't want to do and who can follow her own mind. Good luck with everything!

I really appreciate this, thank you!

OP posts:
greenvelvetcouch · 06/06/2022 15:16

@EnterACloud I love a bit of a amateur psychology, I often dabble myself!

I think there’s some truth to some of your takes on my Dad and my relationship with my Mum. I’ll think on those. It’s obviously impossible to ever know things for sure but I am very certain he wouldn’t have minded respecting our boundaries, but that’s not that important.

I’ll think about a balance. I might try and have a discussion with my sister or sister in law about their takes on it to be honest and see if they think mothers should get a short visit in the first week or so. My sister is usually very honest with me!

OP posts:
Wouldyabeguilty · 06/06/2022 15:13

greenvelvetcouch · 06/06/2022 14:53

I know that so many things can go dramatically wrong in labour and there are no “plans” and that we might need a lot more practical help and support than we expect, but we are having the most planned labour possible. We know the date our baby will be born, my DH has a very generous 6 weeks off work. The plan is this won’t be so dramatic, although recovery will presumably be tricky and arduous and I understand many, many things can go wrong. I guess I’m just saying from our POV we have a very clear picture of what to expect, much more so than a lot of other labours.

(I know this is going to make lots of people say I’m naive again and, perhaps, but I promise we do know what we’re talking about and have taken medical advice.)

Ha ha ha ha famous last words. You have no clue what to expect, take off your rose tinted glasses and cop on. Banning visits for 3 weeks and grandparents have no right to their grandchildren, you sound very very very cold and a little bit weird to be honest.

Be interesting to see how it all pans out.

greenvelvetcouch · 06/06/2022 15:12

@momtoboys A lot of people on Mumsnet (and I’ve had comments on this thread) like to say “when you need childcare you’ll regret this!” etc. so I was just confirming that we don’t have that need, so people don’t need to think we’re taking advantage. And yet people still said it!

OP posts:
xogossipgirlxo · 06/06/2022 15:09

Disturbed is too big word for this situation. She's just being silly with saying that baby is traumatised. She is. Ignore it and don't make any serious decisions before you're actually pregnant. It might turn out you are going to need your mum to help you out while your husband is back to work. No point being so strict. If you feel like banning visits for 2-3 weeks, I am sure you can work out some gentle way of saying it.

momtoboys · 06/06/2022 15:08

"We aren’t expecting any childcare or practical help from our extended families so it’s not a case of having to keep them on side."

I don't understand this part of your posts?

ivykaty44 · 06/06/2022 15:08

You’re thinking of banning grandparents from seeing your newborn for 2/3 weeks

this makes me appreciate my daughter wanting me around and her MIL to help and get to meet baby

EnterACloud · 06/06/2022 15:06

Amateur psychologist here, sounds like you're missing your dad a lot still and idolising him/trying to emulate him as far as possible. His way was "the right way" and anyone else is wrong/weak/less good. Unfortunately he's not here so you can't see how he'd actually react to this (rather than how you imagine/think he'd react). But with your mum having a habit of making things all about her (I have one, it's tedious at times i know) I can see why you take refuge in trying to be more like the other parent.

The fact is though (sorry to say this as I know you know) you don't know how your dad would react to knowing you were having a baby, or the prospect of not seeing it for the first few irreplaceable weeks. Maybe he would be a lot more fussed than you think and his drive to make you "independent" wouldn't go as far as encouraging you to isolate yourselves during this period.

I agree with others that you do sound quite unusual (especially saying things like "I’ll be very excited to introduce our baby to our families when we’re ready, not as a desperate attempt to make them feel important." Do you do much for other people?) but I think in this case you'll be best off in the long run striking a balance. How would you feel about e.g. having pop-in visitors a few days after you come home, and then inviting your mum for a proper visit (ideally staying elsewhere if that's what you want) after 3 weeks. I think that's very reasonable. It's the "first sight" that seems to be an issue here so if you can get that out of the way fairly soon after so she can picture the baby and knows you're ok, I think you've then struck a balance and can happily have the next couple of weeks alone if that's what you want.

PersonaNonGarter · 06/06/2022 15:05

DropYourSword · 06/06/2022 11:58

I was expecting to ban any visits for 2-3 weeks at least when I have my baby and this would include her

I disagree with her comment but I also find this very full on!

Yeah this^.

I agree about your DM being a bit OTT but it might just be her way of dealing with it.

OTOH you sound like you might have Co trol issues. And you will definitely want to show your newborn off before three weeks old.

NewYorkLassie · 06/06/2022 15:04

I don’t see what having visits from extended family would bring us?

You class your own mother as extended family? You sound painful. What exactly is wrong with you and your partner that makes you think anyone else meeting your baby within the first 2-3 weeks will disrupt your bonding? Why do you think a visit from Granny will stop you bonding?

Marvellousmadness · 06/06/2022 15:04

Why is everyone jumping on op if she wants people to stay away from her and her new baby for 2-3 weeks?

Fuck visitors. They can wait. The first few weeks are the best. No one is entitled to see the baby. Not even grandparents. They can wait. Its not about them.

ladybugcatnoir1 · 06/06/2022 15:03

You're clearly not close to your mum even though you say you are. The way you talk about her is crazy to me, as someone who is definitely close to my mum.
I've had 2 children, my mum was right there next to me both times. My sister had a baby this week and my mum was there for her too.
I can't even fathom not wanting my mum to meet my baby as soon as humanly possible. I can't wrap my head around it.
Obviously people have different relationships with parents but to say you're close with her but don't want her there for 3 weeks just don't compute.

I personally would have found 3 weeks alone just me, DH and our new baby so bloody boring! And I love my family and wanted to share our joy with them.

If my sister now had said I couldn't have met my beautiful niece for 3 weeks I would have been devastated. They were in hospital for 2 days with no visitors and that was hard enough.

GCRich · 06/06/2022 15:02

TaranThePigKeeper · Today 14:33

That works two ways - it would be a sad thing to permanently fall out with your mother over, wouldn’t it?

I OPs mum can't respect her daughter's desire for a few weeks of rest and recovery with her hubby and baby without a permanant fall out then it's probably best to go NC right now.

Lovelydovey · 06/06/2022 15:02

I think I’d be disappointed at not meeting a grandchild for 5 weeks - probably more upset than traumatised. I think I could forgive her language here. Though it sounds like she may be underestimating the impact on your DSis.

I couldn’t wait to introduce my children to my parents and MiL. They were equally excited about the addition to the family. Both times my parents visited within the first 24 hours while I was still in hospital. And MIL visited for 2 weeks when DS1 was 2 weeks old, and visited for 3 weeks when DS2 was born (she actually picked us up from hospital). I was fortunate that they all just chipped in with what was necessary and I had no shame in going to bed during the day if needed or breastfeeding in front of them. I think it all contributed to a very strong relationship with between grandparents and grandchildren - despite a 500 mile distance from MIL. Neither my DPs or MIL are with us now and I look back at those times with fondness and gratitude that they got to have time with my children as newborns.

OutsideLookingOut · 06/06/2022 15:01

I don't have much to add but that it is wonderful that you are so clear on your boundaries and so calm i your responses. We are all different afterall. You may change your mind, you may not but I love a woman who won't be bullied into things she doesn't want to do and who can follow her own mind. Good luck with everything!