Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disturbed by this comment from DM?

414 replies

greenvelvetcouch · 06/06/2022 11:56

My sister had a baby last year, and due to covid-reasons and a pretty lengthy stay in NICU my DM didn’t meet her baby until she was 37 days old.

I was discussing my Dsis with DM at the weekend and she said to me that my sister was fine and had dealt with it all brilliantly (I disagree - I think she is very damaged by the experience and her husband and I both want her to talk to someone about it all), but DM was still “traumatised” by the experience because it’s not natural for a baby to be kept from its grandmother for so long.

I didn’t call her out on it at the time, but I found this comment so disturbing and it made me worry about the level of entitlement my DM seems to have towards her grandchild. I don’t think grandparents have any “right” to their grandchildren, and I wouldn’t want her acting like that at all when I have my baby. I’ve never had much cause to worry about her beyond her being a bit of an obsessed granny/slightly lonely widow who loves her family but I can’t cope with her being suffocating about seeing my child/ren. I was expecting to ban any visits for 2-3 weeks at least when I have my baby and this would include her.

Is this comment a worrying sign of what’s to come? Do you agree with her?

OP posts:
Moodycow78 · 06/06/2022 13:38

greenvelvetcouch · 06/06/2022 12:03

I want the first weeks of my baby’s life to be as calm as possible for me and my husband, with just a focus on our family and learning to be parents and bond. I don’t see what having visits from extended family would bring us? As a previous reply said, a baby won’t know if it’s Granny or Uncle is visiting. I know I felt SO intrusive visiting my SIL and my brother when they had their newborns, despite being invited.

We aren’t expecting any childcare or practical help from our extended families so it’s not a case of having to keep them on side.

The best advice I can give is don't plan too much or be too rigid in your expectations for those first few weeks. Every birth is different and you have no idea how you'll react. You may want to be left alone but you really might value having your mum or sister with you, time will tell 💐

MelvinThePenguin · 06/06/2022 13:35

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

SomePosters · 06/06/2022 13:34

I don’t know what you’ve been ‘researching’ but the more people who love and invest in a child the better their long term outcomes

no one can stop you closing down your family unit if that’s what you choose but I can tell you that once my baby was here I really wanted to people who will feature in her life to meet her and start implanting their smell and voice in her memories so they feel comfortable and familiar to her.

no one knows what the future holds.
were something to happen to you and dh your children will need their ‘extended’ family to fall back on. Laying down solid foundations for those relationships is very valuable.

Xmasbaby11 · 06/06/2022 13:33

It's so extreme to ban visits from close family when you get on well. The days and nights can be long and boring with a new baby. You really don't need to be alone with your baby 24 hours a day in order to bond, that's very intense. I was desperate to see people after a couple of days, and of course it's so special seeing your DP meet the baby for the first time. Of course they are excited and want to meet them! It doesn't make any difference to the baby, sure, but to be fair, it's months before babies 'care' where they are or who they are with - it doesn't mean we don't do anything with them.

37 days will have felt a very long time to your DM if the baby was in NICU. I was in hospital with DD for a week due to minor problems, and it felt like forever. I'm sure my mum was worrying even though she had been to visit.

SayMyNameNotMyName · 06/06/2022 13:32

But I still have a feeling that she doesn’t want to connect with the emotional complexities of her children, and I don’t want her to do the same thing when I have my baby

I have similar issues with my DM. I would gently suggest that you might want to talk through with your therapist whether a 3 week 'ban', and treating your DM like any other visitor, is really setting a boundary, or tips over into a punishment

Abraxan · 06/06/2022 13:31

I do, however, think your mum was being over dramatic with her response about being traumatised over not seeing your sister's baby so soon, especially as the little one was in hospital and it was covid. She sounds dismissive of your sister's trauma and someone should have spoken to her about that.

saraclara · 06/06/2022 13:28

ItsLisaLou · 06/06/2022 13:23

Can you explain your last sentence a bit more to those of us who’ve never had grandkids? What is it about allowing a few weeks of private time for your DD that would be so heartbreaking, if you’re all going to meet eventually anyway? Especially assuming your DD would also be heartbroken at having her wishes for privacy dismissed/discounted by her own mother?

I don't know about @Badger1970 but I'm quote a bit from my previous post

Your daughter giving birth is a massive thing. I didn't realise quite how massive, until mine went into labour, to be honest. I was so anxious for her and the baby (and I'm not normally like that).

While I'd never say anything, and I'd have to respect it, if she'd said that I couldn't see her and the baby for three weeks, I'd have found it incredibly hard. On a really primal level, I needed to see them both and know that they were okay.

Golightly133 · 06/06/2022 13:28

I didn’t have any visits from my side of the family till my babies were weeks old they all live abroad and couldn’t get back, I hated it I would have given anything to share my little family with my mum and dad and siblings. You sound a joy & very precious. The apple didn’t fall far from the over the top tree did it 😂

Abraxan · 06/06/2022 13:28

This!

One of my dearest memories of DD's early days was being able to introduce her to my closest family and then friends. I'd had a CS after a long induction and my mum was so supportive it really helped, esp when DH had to go to work (paternity leave wasn't the norm then.) She traveled for ages on public transport to come and spend the day with me, cooking, cleaning, giving me time to sleep and - when other family visited - being the one who made the tea and coffee and checking when I wanted them to leave.

My parents and sister visited me the very next day in hospital, MIL the day after. II have photographs of my parents, my siblings and PILs/BIL all with DD in her first week or two and they are a pleasure to look back on and see that unconditional love from them being directed to DD. FIL was in hospital when she was born and didn't see her for 5 days as a result - he was over the moon to be sent pictures in hospital and he asked to visit the day he was released from the ward.

She was the first grandchild on both sides and she'd been a long time coming after difficulties with fertility and a miscarry They were all so keen
to see her and, although would have abided by any restrictions/ban if I'd has asked, would have also been upset and hurt by it I am quite sure.

I can't imagine shutting out my family especially from those first few days. I was desperate to 'show her off' to those that would love her the most, after me and DH.

The whole banning visitors is something I have only known on Mumsnet. I heard one colleague suggest it when she was pregnant but by the time she was due to give birth she had changed her mind entirely.

Confusion101 · 06/06/2022 13:27

I am pregnant too OP and cannot understand your POV at all! It seems very extreme. 2 - 3 weeks is a long time. I know my family and in laws would be very hurt if I tried to do this, but anyway I don't want to. I need our close family to help and do the jobs like cook, make tea, take the dog for a quick run, so me and DH can focus on bonding with baby (also find it very weird you consider your own mother to be extended family)... The only thing I want is the first night I come home from hosp to ourselves but even at that I know we might not get it.

TheOrigRights · 06/06/2022 13:26

I think you're coming at it from a slightly different POV than most people.

Most people want to show their new baby to their Mothers. The moment my Mum saw my first son (also the first grandchild) is one that remains close to my heart. She didn't want to take over, or tell me what to do, she just wanted to see me and her grandchild.

Wifwolf · 06/06/2022 13:25

My mum came to stay when my first was born. It was brilliantly reassuring at a time when I was doing something I’d never done before, and she (by definition) had.

I was discharged from hospital within 8 hours of baby number 2 and we went straight to the in-laws, who had been looking after our then toddler. I was so happy to share my joy with people I loved.

The idea of pushing close family away at such a time seems very strange. I’d also say that it’s good not to get fixed ideas of “how it’s going to be” before you’re actually doing it. If you have a very set mindset and something prevents it from being that way (quite likely) then you are setting yourself up for disappointment about something that should be precious, whatever happens. Nothing wrong with having some idea about how you want it to be, but allow yourself the realization that it might go completely differently.

greenvelvetcouch · 06/06/2022 13:25

@Mischance I’m so sorry to hear you lost your husband. I really really feel for you. Your post was really poignant and interesting, I appreciate it. Food for thought.

OP posts:
KimikosNightmare · 06/06/2022 13:24

ItsLisaLou · 06/06/2022 13:23

Can you explain your last sentence a bit more to those of us who’ve never had grandkids? What is it about allowing a few weeks of private time for your DD that would be so heartbreaking, if you’re all going to meet eventually anyway? Especially assuming your DD would also be heartbroken at having her wishes for privacy dismissed/discounted by her own mother?

Yes. I don't understand that either.

ItsLisaLou · 06/06/2022 13:23

Badger1970 · 06/06/2022 13:17

I've got 4 grandchildren, was there when the 1st was born and met the others within hours of their birth. DD came home to our house after coming home from hospital rather than to her own home, and I have such cherished memories of each single time. DD jokes that she knew I'd look after her far better than her DH would have done. I've got such a bond with all of them - and in some ways that bond is even more special than with my DC.

To have been kept away from them for weeks would honestly have broken my heart.

Can you explain your last sentence a bit more to those of us who’ve never had grandkids? What is it about allowing a few weeks of private time for your DD that would be so heartbreaking, if you’re all going to meet eventually anyway? Especially assuming your DD would also be heartbroken at having her wishes for privacy dismissed/discounted by her own mother?

saraclara · 06/06/2022 13:23

@Mischance , you could be me. Thank you for expressing the viewpoint from our position so beautifully.

famagusta · 06/06/2022 13:22

The apple doesn’t fall far from the tree

KimikosNightmare · 06/06/2022 13:22

Badger1970 · 06/06/2022 13:17

I've got 4 grandchildren, was there when the 1st was born and met the others within hours of their birth. DD came home to our house after coming home from hospital rather than to her own home, and I have such cherished memories of each single time. DD jokes that she knew I'd look after her far better than her DH would have done. I've got such a bond with all of them - and in some ways that bond is even more special than with my DC.

To have been kept away from them for weeks would honestly have broken my heart.

Well good for you. Do you understand not one size fits all? I can't think of anything I'd have wanted less than my mother and mother-in-law turning up within hours of my giving birth.

greenvelvetcouch · 06/06/2022 13:21

@NetflixAndSauvignonBlanc I really appreciate your insight, thank you! Your time with your first born sounds really special. I hope you get the same with your second!

OP posts:
washingwakeup · 06/06/2022 13:20

(I also wonder if I’d said this was DH’s Mum rather than my own people would react differently, as I’ve seen previously on Mumsnet.)

I wouldn't have reacted differently, and I actually went back to check if you were writing about your DSIL and DMIL before I replied, so that replied properly.

I would have felt just as sorry for your DH's mum being kept away from her grandchild for three weeks.

KimikosNightmare · 06/06/2022 13:19

OP's mother is entitled to her view that babies need involved hand-on grandparents and it is 'unnatural' and 'traumatic' to keep them apart, but her opinions do not trump OP's wishes about how she wants her own home and family to be. OP describes her mother dismissing/invalidating her sister's trauma and making it all about herself. I'd have concerns and want to put some boundaries in place too

I agree. OP's mother's reaction is completely OTT.

Badger1970 · 06/06/2022 13:17

I've got 4 grandchildren, was there when the 1st was born and met the others within hours of their birth. DD came home to our house after coming home from hospital rather than to her own home, and I have such cherished memories of each single time. DD jokes that she knew I'd look after her far better than her DH would have done. I've got such a bond with all of them - and in some ways that bond is even more special than with my DC.

To have been kept away from them for weeks would honestly have broken my heart.

Mischance · 06/06/2022 13:17

As I commented, your Mum is being a bit dramatic; but I do not think it would do any harm for you to have some care and compassion towards her; as indeed you will be hoping your own child might towards you in years to come. This is something that you will teach him/her by example, so might be good to start from the beginning.

I am a widow; I have grandchildren. I respect their needs, and they respect mine. I have filled my life with worthwhile activities for the specific purposes of being of some use in my community and not being burdensome to my AC.

Things to think about:


  • how it might feel to lose your life's partner - it hurts, believe me; it is like having a limb wrenched off.

  • how it might feel to be the widow of someone whom you (as her daughter) clearly idolised.

  • how it feels to have lost the central roles from your life, and how hard it is to fill those gaps when you are grieving.

  • there will only be a few people in your child's life who will love him/her unconditionally - your mother is one of them - they are precious people.

  • there will only be a few people around when you are bringing your child up who will be like a rock - who you can rely on.

  • parents bond with their babies (unless there is some major problem) as a matter of course, and a caring grandparent visiting is not going to stop that happening.

I had a difficult upbringing, and realise that when my children were small I did not include my parents as much as I could have, as I was still harbouring resentments. It is one of the few things in my life that I truly regret. One day you will be your Mum - so, unless she truly is a cruel or unpleasant person, do unto her as you hope your own children will do unto you when you reach this stage of life.

NetflixAndSauvignonBlanc · 06/06/2022 13:16

@greenvelvetcouch I understand you wanting to have time to yourselves after the birth and I feel the same way! We had our first child just as the first wave of Covid hit and so the lockdown rules at the time meant we had a good few weeks to ourselves before anyone (including grandparents) even met the baby. Looking back I really value the time we got to bond as a little family of three and how my husband and I learned how to look after our little one without being in the gaze of anyone else.

Now we're expecting number two and are discussing how we can create a similar environment to bond our family of four once the new baby arrives. We will probably make some compromises so the grandparents don't feel totally shut out but we will safeguard our bubble and do what's right for us.

I know lots of people want to show off their babies and that's great for them, but everyone is different and you need to do what's right for your family.

mam0918 · 06/06/2022 13:15

Not to be rude but you sound naive... life doesnt stop when you have a baby, if anything you need more help than ever.

2-3 weeks of not seeing anyone is honestly a bit ridiculous and completely impractical.

As for her comments, sounds like a lot of grandmothers I know... Ironically the least involved grandmothers tend to talk the most like that, like if they talk up their involvement people will believe it when its not true.

As for think they are traumatised and need help. I had a medically traumatic birth (where we both died for a bit) it was by far in my point of view my easiest birth I had, the 'trauma' was entirely on others watching it happen not me and my DS.

I HATED people constantly telling me how depressed and traumatised I should be and that I need help to 'deal with it' or was in denial or should try 'meds'. Its 14 years later and there was nothing to deal with and they MAJORLY overstepped the mark trying to push their assumptions of how I should handle it on me.