Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sis in law drama advice

84 replies

Lagertha6 · 06/06/2022 11:55

My DH has 2 brothers and one sister who all have partners/babies/young children.

I'm in process of arranging an afternoon tea for the girls which will include my mum in law.

One of our sister in laws (call her Sadie) is very, very, very hard work. Walk on eggshell types and she becomes annoyed if you say something she doesn't agree with.

Sadie has been rude to mum in law in the past to the point of tears. She's from another country so has no family or barely any friends here. My mum in law encourages my friendship with Sadie, which is fine but everytime I see her I'm on edge.

My sis in law (DH sister) dislikes her for various reasons. I can understand why she doesn't like Sadie and I know Sadie is really hard work.

Also Sadie doesn't like my sis in law and is resentful of my mum in law. Sadie told me this and I've never repeated it to anyone.

I've just told my sis in law that I have asked Sadie to come for afternoon tea and she isn't happy about it. My sis in law (call her Katie) has two babies (newborn and 18 months) so doesn't ever get a break.

Katie has told me that she doesn't want to spend a rare day off on edge and anxious. But if I hadn't had invited her then Sadie would be upset and my mum in law wouldn't be pleased.

What do I do? Feel like just cancelling whole thing. I can't be bothered going out where people don't like each other and I have to spend the day placating everyone. But I love my family so I'm stuck.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
declutteringmymind · 06/06/2022 19:35

Yes just say she needed a few things and you took her shopping and whoops they had a walk in table for 2 for afternoon tea.

Lagertha6 · 06/06/2022 19:34

StageRage · 06/06/2022 18:05

ah, fair point, but I was working within the context of the OP’s starting point: a really party.

Personally I would suggest some wild swimming followed by a pint.

At least I didn’t suggest a ‘Spa Day’ 😉

Or a shopping day ;)

OP posts:
neonjumper · 06/06/2022 18:17

I think you are the problem in all of this and you are making the whole situation worse.

You know there is tension between Katie/ mil and Sadie but you insist on trying to draw them together.

See them separately, stop putting your own needs ahead of other peoples feelings, you need to accept this is not going to work .

StageRage · 06/06/2022 18:05

Herejustforthisone · 06/06/2022 12:29

Gardens or river trip or something

Separate issue but what is with these ‘girl-approved’ days out? Teas? Gardens? Lovely little river cruises?

Women, know your limits.

ah, fair point, but I was working within the context of the OP’s starting point: a really party.

Personally I would suggest some wild swimming followed by a pint.

At least I didn’t suggest a ‘Spa Day’ 😉

Lagertha6 · 06/06/2022 17:48

TheNoodlesIncident · 06/06/2022 16:46

I appreciate you say you invited Sadie out of a feeling of duty and guilt, but I think you would all be happier if you suppress that and don't invite her to events like this. She will ruin it for your MIL and Katie as well as you!

My two sisters-in-law are lovely and I would enjoy afternoon tea with them, but if I had one who was as awkward and unpleasant as Sadie I just wouldn't invite her. I wouldn't post photos on FB or otherwise let her know she was being excluded, that would be mean, but actions have consequences and people not wanting her presence is the natural outcome of her behaviour. Why should you feel guilty about that, if you don't otherwise rub her nose in it? I'd be frankly pissed off with her carping about her MIL when her MIL is very good and helpful to her, I don't blame you for commenting on that and good for you, sticking up for your MIL.

In short, I'd tell Sadie the tea was cancelled and just do it without her. She's an adult who needs to make an effort to get on with people and make friends where she is, wherever that happens to be. It's not down to other people to fill the gap if she's not prepared to be nice!

I know. I really wish none of us where in this situation because it just makes everything so much more hard work. When it was the funeral she sat away from us all inc me and this was before I'd annoyed her. She even sat away from her partner.

Katie really needs some time for herself and MIL needs it too. She's up the wall with grandchildren and had own health probs.

Think have my answer. Thanks everyone xxx

OP posts:
Lagertha6 · 06/06/2022 17:44

EnterACloud · 06/06/2022 15:30

has barely spoken to me since

Honestly this sounds like a result. Cancel the plans, book something else sans Sadie as long as you can trust the others to be discreet (sounds like you can). Have a nice time Flowers

Thanks very much. It is a result but then when family events come up everyone's always uptight about upsetting her rather than us all being together enjoying ourselves.

Just going to give her wide berth x

OP posts:
TheNoodlesIncident · 06/06/2022 16:46

I appreciate you say you invited Sadie out of a feeling of duty and guilt, but I think you would all be happier if you suppress that and don't invite her to events like this. She will ruin it for your MIL and Katie as well as you!

My two sisters-in-law are lovely and I would enjoy afternoon tea with them, but if I had one who was as awkward and unpleasant as Sadie I just wouldn't invite her. I wouldn't post photos on FB or otherwise let her know she was being excluded, that would be mean, but actions have consequences and people not wanting her presence is the natural outcome of her behaviour. Why should you feel guilty about that, if you don't otherwise rub her nose in it? I'd be frankly pissed off with her carping about her MIL when her MIL is very good and helpful to her, I don't blame you for commenting on that and good for you, sticking up for your MIL.

In short, I'd tell Sadie the tea was cancelled and just do it without her. She's an adult who needs to make an effort to get on with people and make friends where she is, wherever that happens to be. It's not down to other people to fill the gap if she's not prepared to be nice!

Teapot13 · 06/06/2022 16:13

This is your husband's family. Why are you arranging a tea for people that don't like to spend time together?

EnterACloud · 06/06/2022 15:30

has barely spoken to me since

Honestly this sounds like a result. Cancel the plans, book something else sans Sadie as long as you can trust the others to be discreet (sounds like you can). Have a nice time Flowers

Lagertha6 · 06/06/2022 15:24

WhereYouLeftIt · 06/06/2022 15:07

No, you don't all get on. Sadie rubs everybody up the wrong way. That's not 'getting on', at best it's you and MIL sweeping reality under the carpet.

I actually really agree with this, we do. Alot of phrases are uses "just do this/that otherwise Sadie will get annoyed." We do sweep alot under the carpet. My MIL knows that Katie dislikes Sadie and tbh I think my MIL does although she won't ever say that. She just wants to keep her DS happy (Sadies fiancee.) Whenever there is aggro or Sadie throws a strop, I try to agree with Katie's POV but my MIL asks me to remain neutral.

But Katie has really been struggling with the both babies (her husband should help more) and she just wanted her Mum this one day as the babies had to be rushed to hospital.

That weekend I had lunch with Sadie and Sadie was annoyed my MIL wasn't available to babysit. I explained due to babies being in hosp, Sadie replied she doesn't get any help so why should Katie. I then replied MIL has yours 4 days a week, which she didn't like an has barely spoken to me since.

I personally don't like her. She does treat my MIL like garbage.

OP posts:
Lagertha6 · 06/06/2022 15:15

SleepingStandingUp · 06/06/2022 14:10

Cancel it OP and book something similar but slightly different with you, MIL, her daughter and the other SIL. Don't tell Sadie.

Also if you quote the posts you're replying to, it'll make it easier for people to follow your replies.

Ok thanks very much for your help. Still new on here xxxx

OP posts:
fallfallfall · 06/06/2022 15:14

Another one who suggests cancelling and rebooking in a different format…one without Sadie.
Do something else with Sadie, which includes letting her know her challenges.

declutteringmymind · 06/06/2022 15:13

Just organise something with your MIL.

don't feed the drama.

Lagertha6 · 06/06/2022 15:13

Thank you. I said that to her at the lunch an she didn't speak to me. She doesn't like it when you disagree.

OP posts:
WhereYouLeftIt · 06/06/2022 15:07

Lagertha6 · 06/06/2022 13:11

We all get on. It's Sadie who doesn't get on with anyone except me and my DH. It was meant to be a nice thing for my MIL. Do you not socialise with your family?

No, you don't all get on. Sadie rubs everybody up the wrong way. That's not 'getting on', at best it's you and MIL sweeping reality under the carpet.

MargosKaftan · 06/06/2022 15:00

Cancel. Arrange to just take MIL out and offer to watch Katies kids so she can go out with her mum another time. Invite 3rd SIL that you do like for another thing, or her and her dh to yours for dinner.

Family events dont need to involve all family members, you can see just one or two of the couples. You can quietly stop arranging anything with Sadie. DH can meet up with his brother married to Sadie without wives.

Sadie has no friends. Sadie isn't making much effort to have a close family relationship. This is who she is. Stop trying. If she wants a close family relationship, she can put the work in.

TheEponymousGrub · 06/06/2022 14:59

What do you do? How about this:

Have a quiet word with Sadie, explaining that you all want to include her in the gig but you all need her to behave in a certain way, i.e., NOT doing X, Y, Z (the type of thing she's got form for - and have specific examples ready in case she denies it.) Be super duper nice about it and if she accepts it and comes along (admittedly unlikely), well things may improve; but if she is outraged at you all "ganging up on" her and doesn't come, well that's OK too.
However - this would require agreement in advance from the other SILs and maybe the MIL too, because it depends on you taking the position that you're being perfectly nice and reasonable in explaining what you all need from her. Maybe you/your husband could even run it by her husband beforehand because the best outcome would be for her to see that her behaviour is found unacceptable by everyone else.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 06/06/2022 14:58

I'd just ask them but leave them all to it.

A few years ago DB was married to a complete bitch, whenever she came round we had to bite our tongues and be nice to her (we all liked her at first) but then after a while she showed her true colours. There was when memorable time when she visited, I was upstairs, and she was screeching that she'd fight me! Shock Then she ostracised my DB from his family. Luckily the marriage didn't last and they divorced.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 06/06/2022 14:52

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 06/06/2022 14:44

The person causing drama is you, by inviting "Sadie" to an event when you know it will cause friction and upset.

There is something in that.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 06/06/2022 14:44

The person causing drama is you, by inviting "Sadie" to an event when you know it will cause friction and upset.

rnsaslkih · 06/06/2022 14:37

Christ on a bike
I'd send a group message saying bookings fucked up and postpone indefinitely

I can't be fucked with drama

EnterACloud · 06/06/2022 14:23

The question is do you want your MIL and Katie to have a nice time or a shit one? If you get them and Sadie together they will have a shit one. She also doesn't like them. Cancel and rearrange.

Also you sound like a kind and patient person who's tried to see the best in Sadie, and give her a chance - but honestly, she sounds horrible. Maybe she moved countries because she'd already pissed off everyone in her home country. She'd rude, ungrateful to MIL, unkind and not pleasant to be around. I'd limit your interactions with her to family occasions, you don't HAVE to see her more often.

SleepingStandingUp · 06/06/2022 14:10

Cancel it OP and book something similar but slightly different with you, MIL, her daughter and the other SIL. Don't tell Sadie.

Also if you quote the posts you're replying to, it'll make it easier for people to follow your replies.

Dishwashersaurous · 06/06/2022 14:09

Why would you organise any optional social event with attendees that you know don't like each other?

sleepygal · 06/06/2022 13:57

carry on with the event, invite all family ladies and DO NOT get involved in any drama. Leave it to the people who create the drama, don't get involved, don't get involved, don't get involved.