Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

disappointed in sons decision

114 replies

Twins3007 · 06/06/2022 11:50

My son is now 21 and still lives at home, since leaving school he has been training and just passed certain exams so he practice in his own right. He could have a potential of earning quite a good living if he put his mind to it . He was quite happy in the role then covid hit and he has been wfh since as they shut the office and now only go in once a week even then most don't turn up or go home early. This way of working has certainly changed all dynamics of the job as he has had no mentor and no one to show him how to interact with clients , he is home alone and has no motivation what so ever. All social aspect of the job has gone since wfh , which is such a shame as this did give him confidence and getting to know colleagues.
He has now decided this line of work is not for him and wants some sort of a trade, to re train and do some kind of manual work, I am distraught and have tried to dissuade him but he is adamant, because he still lives at home this is possible, he has been used to living on a low wage while training .

He feels he has wasted 5 years of his life, all his friends have got on and all have trades and earning a respectable wage and he feels he has been left behind.

I worry that he may regret his decision and have told him so but he will not listen, although it is soul destroying to see how lonely he is wfh and lost all motivation, what do I do try to persuade him to stick it out or encourage him to find a new role in life ?

OP posts:
skyeisthelimit · 06/06/2022 14:48

If he has decided that it is not for him , then he does need to find something that he is happy to do.

Life is too short to go to work hating what you do every day

Twins3007 · 06/06/2022 14:44

I have spoken to him about changing to another company and being office based as I said in last post this is not an option, he hates every aspect of the job I'm afraid, I still think bloody covid and changing to wfh has definitely been the cause as I said he has no confidence in his work as has not been in office to get experience.
Hey ho we must move forward and respect him for making his choice , and I would never tell him I am disappointed , of course not,

OP posts:
skyeisthelimit · 06/06/2022 14:43

If he has the qualification then why doesn't he apply for office based jobs, or hybrid working? A lot of employers are now wanting staff to get back to the office, so he should be able to find something.

I am an accountant and while I am self employed so I do work totally from home, I need my employee in here as she is still training on a lot of things. I know that if I had to work from home when I started out, I wouldn't have learned much as there are a lot of questions when you start out.

Ultimately though, it is his life and if he wants to retrain and can afford to, then he should be able to do that with your support. He could do an adult apprenticeship even, to find something that he really wants to do and learn the trade.

Iamthewombat · 06/06/2022 14:33

Hybrid working suits a lot of of employers and employees. Get over it.

Please don’t turn this thread into a rant about why nobody should be expected to, like, go into an office, ever. With added “I’m much more efficient at home, honest!”

Icannever · 06/06/2022 14:32

Ideal combination for running a successful business at some point i would think 😊

JinglingHellsBells · 06/06/2022 14:25

@SleeplessInEngland Hybrid working doesn't mean 1 day in the office (if you can be bothered). It can mean 3 days AND support for younger people.

I don't think you know what hybrid working means. And the impact is has on the young who are at the start of their careers, unlike employees in their 30s, 40s and 50s.

JinglingHellsBells · 06/06/2022 14:24

But it's not that he doesn't like the office.

It's that the office has changed to WFH and he's missing out on contact with other people.

He needs to be logical and see that there are plenty of other roles in finance that are not WFH where he could be happy!

It's throwing the baby out with the bathwater. I can see why- he's young and thinks swapping careers is the answer, but everything has pros and cons.

SleeplessInEngland · 06/06/2022 14:22

FatTum · 06/06/2022 12:52

I personally think it's an absolute disgrace for the younger ones in finance/accountancy that their firms haven't instituted more of a return to the office. All of us, at that age, learnt from being around other people doing the jobs. I'm back in the office 4 days a week so I can make sure we mentor the younger starters. I would advise him to look for another firm first. Some firms are prioritising being in the office to make sure the newer starters are properly trained and mentored.

Hybrid working suits a lot of of employers and employees. Get over it.

as for the thread, sounds like a good decision from your son. He’s still very young, and trades are great career moves.

goldfinchonthelawn · 06/06/2022 14:21

Support him. If he picks the right trade, he'll earn a fortune, never be out of work and never be bored stiff working from home.

He is still very young and it's incredibly brave and wise of him to realise so quickly that he isn;t suiteds to one profession and to choose to train in another. If as PPs have guessed, he trained in accountancy then he'll be very good at keeping on top of his books as a self employed trader.

He sounds multi-talented with a great work ethic. Support him.

JinglingHellsBells · 06/06/2022 14:17

This is why WFH is a disaster for so many young people. They get out of the office, lose mentors, lose motivation, and it all goes belly up.

Has he thought about talking to HR or his boss and explaining how he feels?

OR can he look for another job using his qualifications?

I agree with you that the grass can look greener and he's still very young.

I'd be talking to him and asking him to think about applying for a similar role where he can go into the office and there is support from HR and mentors.

There is nothing wrong with having a trade but it seems a big leap from working towards something for 5 years and ditching it due to the pandemic.

CapMarvel · 06/06/2022 14:06

He's 21 with at least 40-45 years to need to earn a living. That's a long time to be stuck in a job you hate.

You should be encouraging him to find something he is passionate about and loves, and if that means a few wrong turns along the way so be it.

Rhodora · 06/06/2022 14:03

He will be absolutely fine. When my DH was 33 he decided he wanted to go to university and get a degree as a building surveyor after driving HGVs for years. As he already had a degree in architectural technology he got admitted straight into third year (Scotland so four year degree).DH is now a building inspector and he loves it. DF in law was invited to leave school at 15 and so decided to become a joiner. DF in law served his time as an apprentice joiner and once he qualified he became a lecturer at a further education college. DF in law finally got a university degree in his 50s after the college decided they wanted all their lecturers to have one. Your son may decide to go back to accounting later or he may decide that a trade is what he has always wanted to do. Either way he will have skills that will benefit him for life.

cornishcrusader · 06/06/2022 13:58

Please don't worry too much. My own children have made many mistakes, had changes of heart, about turns, wasted periods of their lives doing things they now regret, squandered opportunities. Maybe we all do actually. I think this has taught me to support them on a day to day basis in what they want to do now, and never inflict my opinion or personal beliefs on them. You know what, it usually works out in the end...and if it doesn't then continue to support them through the bad times too. As long as they are healthy and happy nothing else really matters. Hope it all works out for the best, whatever the best is for him personally.

Namechangehereandnow · 06/06/2022 13:56

I think you’re massively over reacting OP.
He’s 21 - he needs to make his own choices, and mistakes.
Be there to support and guide, but let him make his own decisions.

GreenCard · 06/06/2022 13:55

With an accountant background and wanting to do a trade, he will have a great career. An aquaintence went from running a club in central London to being a high end plumber! 40years is a longtime to work if you’re miserable, if he hates it he can always come back to accounting/finance. It sounds like you wanted the prestige if him doing that more than his happiness.

ToppTotty · 06/06/2022 13:52

At 21 he has time to do anything he wants to do. Tradespeople are like gold dust where I live. I wouldn't worry about him.

Iamthewombat · 06/06/2022 13:51

I don't think you need to be as worried as you are given he's 21. Many people at that age take a few years to find their calling and to work out what inspires them. And he has his qualification under his belt, presumably, if he wants to go back

Sorry to rain on your parade but his chances of getting even a semi-decent role requiring an accountancy qualification after leaving the profession to work in a trade are negligible. They just are. The qualification is only the start of it. He’d need to build up his experience, which is what employers and recruiters are really looking for. They want a recent track record.

From the OP’s updates it appears that her son has 90% made his mind up, but I don’t blame her for being sad about it. There’s nothing wrong with working in a trade, and some people do very well from it financially (yes, I know that there is more to life than money but it’s a consideration), but it doesn’t compare to working in a profession at a senior level for compensation and other tangible and intangible benefits.

Twins3007 · 06/06/2022 13:40

notacooldad · Today 13:29
At the age of 23 my son was doing really well with his career that he had since he was 17. The firm had put him through exams and he was getting more and more staffing responsibility. His wage was really good. However he had enough. He had a complete career change and is a 18 months into an apprentice that he is absolutely loving. He has done so well they have given him a bonus and an early wage rise.
This isn't bragging. It is to tell you a career change can lead you to new opportunities and things that you love. There was no point my lad carrying on with a job that had been taken over by a company that didn't have the same values as the original one so he found something else. Your DS will be fine. He is young. Things will work themselves out.

Thankyou for this , this is what i am hoping ,

OP posts:
IrisVersicolor · 06/06/2022 13:40

I agree it makes sense for him to try a new job in a different company in his current profession before throwing in the towel.

He’s very young and has time on his side.

poetryandwine · 06/06/2022 13:37

Good on your DS for knowing his own mind. I do wonder, along with @FatTum and @Aprilx , whether he has thought of changing firms to one where he could have an office based role? But possibly at this point he just wants out of the field.

If that is so, I am very glad that you and his DF are on his side. He is at the best stage for making the change and as PPs have said, he can have a great life in trade.

ChocolateHippo · 06/06/2022 13:37

I don't think you need to be as worried as you are given he's 21. Many people at that age take a few years to find their calling and to work out what inspires them. And he has his qualification under his belt, presumably, if he wants to go back. Career changes are not uncommon at every stage of life but are easiest when you have no real commitments like a mortgage and children.

I have friends from university who left with their degrees and 'bummed around' travelling for a few years, just earning enough to get by and go where they wanted to. Definitely not time wasted in their eyes but the only stage of life where they'd get to do that. One is a teacher now, one has gone back into law and the other has their own business. But they weren't very driven at 21 (at least compared to your DS who sounds like he's got it together) and perhaps their parents worried about them like you are worrying about your DS.

PigletJohn · 06/06/2022 13:36

A grounding in accountancy can be very useful in business, whether running your own firm, or being an employee who rises in seniority.

If he becomes a self-employed plumber, for example, he should be able to glide through keeping his own accounts, dealing with tax, profits, loans, depreciation, allowances and debts.

Lots of people who set up in business on their own have no idea, and sadly fail.

I believe most people in building trades go bust.

Twins3007 · 06/06/2022 13:36

Distraught is rather a strong word , and yes I feel slightly to blame as knew a while ago he was unhappy but kept saying things will get better once back in office and qualified. He could also look at another company that is office based but he has gone so off the job that is not an option he wants to look into.

I am quite happy for him to to re train as I said in previous post my other two sons have trades .

The main thing now is looking for a trade that he can enjoy for hopefully many years to come as we spend a lot of time at work .

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 06/06/2022 13:31

FatTum · 06/06/2022 12:52

I personally think it's an absolute disgrace for the younger ones in finance/accountancy that their firms haven't instituted more of a return to the office. All of us, at that age, learnt from being around other people doing the jobs. I'm back in the office 4 days a week so I can make sure we mentor the younger starters. I would advise him to look for another firm first. Some firms are prioritising being in the office to make sure the newer starters are properly trained and mentored.

This.

I’m going to go against the grain here and suggest that you try one last time to persuade him to give finance another go at a different firm.

I know that it’s difficult to be objective with your own children, but is he clever enough to really make a go of accountancy, and is he at (or could he get into) a decent-sized and prestigious firm? If the answer to both of those questions is “yes”, then I’d be encouraging my kid to stick it out and change employer. The Big Four are under-resourced at the moment, so that’s an opportunity.

It’s all very well for posters to say, “yes, but he’ll never be out of work if he’s a plumber” or, “he’ll be able to do his own books, so his training won’t be wasted”, but the truth is, his training and exams will be wasted if he chucks it in now. Not all accountants earn above average salaries, but if you have a good brain you will earn more than most other jobs and you won’t have your arm down a toilet whilst doing so either. Plus, there are other less obvious benefits: you can comfortably work into your sixties, which you may not want to do if you are fitting solar panels to roofs.

Call me a snob if you like (I can see a few posts berating the OP for ‘caring what other people think’) but as somebody who grew up on a council estate in Manchester and has forged a great career in finance I would 100% encourage kids who are not from privileged backgrounds to choose the professions over trade if they have the option. That’s they key to social mobility, whether we choose to acknowledge it or not. You can bet your life that the people who have privately educated their children and have well-established networks and connections aren’t encouraging their kids into manual roles. That’s why you get so many posh mediocrities in the professions, and in the universities.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 06/06/2022 13:30

I'd agree that he needs to change job.

But if he was getting on well before covid, I'd suggest that he finds somewhere new, somewhere where they go in the office more and have adapted their mentoring to hybrid working rather than just abandoning it. Give it 6 months and if he still hates it then you will fully support his retraining. Surely if it means he will be living at home for longer then you have a say?

Swipe left for the next trending thread