Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

disappointed in sons decision

114 replies

Twins3007 · 06/06/2022 11:50

My son is now 21 and still lives at home, since leaving school he has been training and just passed certain exams so he practice in his own right. He could have a potential of earning quite a good living if he put his mind to it . He was quite happy in the role then covid hit and he has been wfh since as they shut the office and now only go in once a week even then most don't turn up or go home early. This way of working has certainly changed all dynamics of the job as he has had no mentor and no one to show him how to interact with clients , he is home alone and has no motivation what so ever. All social aspect of the job has gone since wfh , which is such a shame as this did give him confidence and getting to know colleagues.
He has now decided this line of work is not for him and wants some sort of a trade, to re train and do some kind of manual work, I am distraught and have tried to dissuade him but he is adamant, because he still lives at home this is possible, he has been used to living on a low wage while training .

He feels he has wasted 5 years of his life, all his friends have got on and all have trades and earning a respectable wage and he feels he has been left behind.

I worry that he may regret his decision and have told him so but he will not listen, although it is soul destroying to see how lonely he is wfh and lost all motivation, what do I do try to persuade him to stick it out or encourage him to find a new role in life ?

OP posts:
fyn · 06/06/2022 17:17

@Iamthewombat well my husbands uncle set up a building company, now retired in 50s and is flown about in his helicopter because getting about by car isn’t worth his time. Two of my friends parents started as builders and set up their own firms, both also millionaires.

Sure there are a lot of people who stick at being a bricklayer but if you have drive and ambition you can do really well in the building trade. I worked in a builders yard doing admin from 18-21, most of them are still there but one got his apprenticeship and went to Australia. Did well and saved, he moved back here five years later and did now buys houses at auction, does them up and sells them on. He’s hired other people and flips lots now. I know a lot more wealthy tradespeople than I do wealthy accountants.

Iamthewombat · 06/06/2022 17:08

JulyDreams · 06/06/2022 16:51

You are 'distraught' because he wants to learn a trade?

I'm insulted. Do you know how 'skilled' you have to be do learn and DO manual work? It's not easy. I'm fed up of the stereotypes around builders and labourers. Without them you would have your houses shops and supermarkets. My family run their own labourer and 'trade' company and are very successful.

No, she’s upset because (1) her son is making a life changing decision influenced by circumstances beyond his control and (2) she worries that he may regret that decision after spending five years training and sitting exams.

The OP explicitly tells us that her two other sons work in trades, that she is happy about that, and that she will support her son whatever he chooses. Don’t let that stop you kicking her when she is down, though.

alwayslearning789 · 06/06/2022 16:54

A little time outside the profession may be just what he needs to appreciate the breadth of opportunities within it.

I had a similar experience, started and finished a 5 year accounts apprenticeship from 18, then took some time out doing something totally different for a much needed 'break' which really refreshed and focused my aims going forward. Picked up a seperate strand of the profession and been flying since.

(Incidentally, this is another reason why I advise against early apprenticeship in this particular field.) Although the zero uni fees is initially attractive, there's sometimes a bit of unspoken burnout for some of the early starters and then having to compete with the uni students when they come in at higher tiers with wider experiences)

21 is young, time is on his side for exploring and who knows... it may lead to some further amazing opportunities with his existing qualification as others have pointed out.

Try not to worry OP, he has a good qualification and base to find his way long term. Best Wishes

JulyDreams · 06/06/2022 16:51

You are 'distraught' because he wants to learn a trade?

I'm insulted. Do you know how 'skilled' you have to be do learn and DO manual work? It's not easy. I'm fed up of the stereotypes around builders and labourers. Without them you would have your houses shops and supermarkets. My family run their own labourer and 'trade' company and are very successful.

poetryandwine · 06/06/2022 16:49

I think PPs are expecting us to read with common sense. I don’t live in an expensive area of the country and I reckon my plumber makes about the same salary as someone on one of the lower salary bands for Senior Lecturer or Reader ( Reader is the rank just below Professor) at our major Russell Group University. Good on him, I say.

Iamthewombat · 06/06/2022 16:39

If he trains in electrical or plumbing he can more or less write his own pay check.

Don’t be silly. Write his own pay cheque? What if someone quoted you £10k to unblock a loo? What would you say then? Go ahead and charge whatever you want? Of course not.

Iamthewombat · 06/06/2022 16:36

fyn · 06/06/2022 16:17

I retrained at 21 for a new career despite having qualifications, it was the best decision.

My Dad is an electrician and specialised in a specific type. He is semi retired in his 50s, lives at his lake house in America for half the year and spends the rest of the year on his yacht or messing about with his classic car collection. He’s much better off and has a better quality of life than any accountant I know!

With respect, how many tradespeople are going to end up with a lake house in the USA, a classic car collection and a yacht? That’s just daft talk. A bit like when Michael Caine used to boast that his father wanted him to become an accountant and “now I employ three of them”. Forgetting that he was one of the very few, amongst hundreds of thousands of jobbing or aspiring actors, to be in that fortunate position.

The thing with an economy is, it abhors a vacuum. So when news circulates about a skilled trade that the majority of people could enter if they learned the skills and which pays well through scarcity, what happens then? Oh yes, lots of people enter it and supply increases, so prices reduce. It would be foolish to expect that tradesmen will remain scarce. Any current shortage around here is due to the Polish tradesmen thinking, sod you after Brexit and going home. I doubt that our area is unique. As soon as the new crop of tradespeople come through, the financial advantage is lost.

As for him being better off than any accountant you have ever met: I’m surmising that you haven’t met many. There are accountants earning average salaries. There are also CFOs and partners making huge amounts. There’s a reason why middle class kids are pushed into the professions. What do you think that reason is?

Thinkingblonde · 06/06/2022 16:23

If he trains in electrical or plumbing he can more or less write his own pay check. There’s a shortage of skilled tradesmen,/women, especially in Electrical, school leavers were encouraged to apply for university rather than go into trade this causing this lack of skilled trades personnel.
My DH, a retired Electrician in the oil and gas industry has only ever been out of work once, and that was for two months in a 44 year career. He more less left one contract and started another the following day.

fyn · 06/06/2022 16:17

I retrained at 21 for a new career despite having qualifications, it was the best decision.

My Dad is an electrician and specialised in a specific type. He is semi retired in his 50s, lives at his lake house in America for half the year and spends the rest of the year on his yacht or messing about with his classic car collection. He’s much better off and has a better quality of life than any accountant I know!

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 06/06/2022 16:06

He could set up as a tradie, do his own books, and do self employed books for his tradie mates.

User3568975431146 · 06/06/2022 16:05

Good on him. Not sure what you're problem is.

godmum56 · 06/06/2022 16:03

Twins3007 · 06/06/2022 12:25

of course I do not want him to pursue a career he is unhappy in like you say he has many years of work ahead of him ,I have had a few people say to me " omg how can he give up his career after getting his qualifications , tbh I think he disliked the job before passing his exams but hoped it would get better which it hasn't.

Both his brothers have trades and yes I am proud of him that he has made this brave decision and keep my fingers it works out for him .

so are you disappointed or not?

Thehonestybox · 06/06/2022 16:02

He sounds really sensible. Any job that can be WFH is precarious now. A manual trade is for life, and people make really good livings out of it where they can eventually build up a business to run itself, if they want that.

All my friends who learned a trade are years ahead of me financially, and my sector feels like its always at risk

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 06/06/2022 15:56

He is only 21 so this is the time to change careers.

My stepson changed from an office job to becoming a great carpenter at around that age.

BorisJohnsonsvomitbucket · 06/06/2022 15:55

I pursued a nursing career back in the late 90s and after three years jacked it in because I wasn't cut out for it. I got a job in a department store before someone suggested applying to work on the Underground. I'm still on the Tube now having progressed a bit up the chain, and have much more earning power than I would ever have as a nurse. (Nurses should get paid more than me because it's a much harder job and I don't earn my money unless there's an incident)

Plenty of people I work with come from "prestigious" jobs but for one reason or another (the pandemic being one) they've ended up on the Tube. And are happier for it. Sometimes it's not worth ploughing on with something which just isn't working out. You have to break and find something else, and be happy doing it.

goldfinchonthelawn · 06/06/2022 15:46

I certainly wouldn;t suggest teaching over plumbing. He'l make far more from trade and be his own boss.

Mumwithbaggage · 06/06/2022 15:41

My dd1 got a great law degree from a top RG university then aced her Masters (best thesis, top student etc) but is now doing something entirely unrelated. Main thing is she's happy. Ds did tree surgery - now building and doing pretty well for himself. Again, he's happy. Dd2 doesn't love her job but she's only 26. Things are different these days. Wish I'd had the courage to jump careers at that age rather than stick to something I'm good at but don't really enjoy.

Welshrarebit75 · 06/06/2022 15:31

I’m in the retrain camp but he should keep paying his professional fees so that he continues to have it as a back up.

If he goes into a trade he’ll be able to do his own books! Win, win.

ChickenBurgers · 06/06/2022 15:24

nothing wrong with getting a trade. Grandad lives next door to a plumber and I can tell you he is not short of cash. Always going to need tradesmen!

OkyDoke · 06/06/2022 15:14

My husband did similar, accountancy training etc and quit when he was about 20 as he was depressed; he was made for practicality and a trade. He never got the chance to train though and always resents that. Be on his side.

dropthevipers · 06/06/2022 15:13

Sounds like you are aghast at the notion of him going into Trade, of all things rather than him hanging onto a nice professional middle class career. Heaven forfend!

erinaceus · 06/06/2022 15:10

I know of two formerly unhappy accountants who retrained as maths teachers and became much happier, just a suggestion in case he has not thought of options other than trades. And one lawyer who became a plumber and did well.

As another poster said, if he has accountancy qualifications he will find the financial side of being self-employed more straightforward than most.

notsoskinny · 06/06/2022 14:57

As a fellow accountant, please tell your son to first try another field. The roles are SO different.

It isn't for everyone. My best friend retrained as a teacher despite being the top scorer in one of the ACA exams. She just loves Maths. She is much happier, but I now earn 3x her salary and ultimately, the money + wfh benefits + corporate gains are all I need.

ChairP0se9to5 · 06/06/2022 14:53

He's only 21 so he can afford to ''waste'' five years. A lot of apprentices are paid well and they pay while you train so it's not like he'd be straight back to day one with no training and no pay again.

If he met really good people in his last job, they can catch up when he has news.

I think that 21 is so young. IF he wants to go back to the first job after 6 months then at least he'll know now that the first job isn't so bad.

Ponderingwindow · 06/06/2022 14:49

Before he spends time retraining, it would be smart to try a job with a different company. When he interviews he should be honest and say that he is looking for a place that has found a way to maintain a more connected company culture.

Swipe left for the next trending thread