Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

4-day working week: would it be extended to schools?

140 replies

Anothernameforallthis · 06/06/2022 11:19

Just reading in the Guardian about a big UK project to trial a 4-day working week in a whole range of different businesses / places of employment. The benefits are expected to be clear: “The four-day week is generally considered to be a triple-dividend policy – helping employees, companies, and the climate. Our research efforts will be digging into all of this.”

If it is a great success, wouldn't we want to extend these benefits to school children and teachers? Give them a less stressful life, benefit the environment (one less day a week of the school run), more time to develop interests / hobbies / skills away from the classroom?

OP posts:
Summerstink · 06/06/2022 16:01

orwellwasright · 06/06/2022 14:58

I'd take a 4 day week and would most definitely include schools in that. A 3 day weekend, such as happens over a bank holiday weekend now, is so good for the soul in terms of rest, seeing family/ friends and spending more time on interests and leisure

Not if your family hasn't got a pot to piss in. Or your mum spends her days taking crack. Or your dad wallops you continually. It's such a middle class privilege to see family and leisure time as unadulterated joy.

Schools aren't there to solve society's problems but effectively that's what they do. They hugely mitigate the negative effects that poverty, substance abuse and domestic abuse has on children.

Children from poorer backgrounds do far better in school than out.

Nothing exclusively middle class about enjoying time with family. And yes it is privilege.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 06/06/2022 16:00

It's really not about saying some industries can't do it, so others shouldn't. It's about having the sense to look at the significant wider ramifications of expecting some people to work longer hours than the norm and pay higher childcare costs (if indeed childcare can be found). It would be very, very silly to just think 'I'm alright so sod everyone else' and not think that might come back and bite you - and a whole bunch of other people.

Musicalmistress · 06/06/2022 15:54

underneathleaf · 06/06/2022 12:46

In Edinburgh, the teachers' PPA (or whatever it is called in Scotland) is Fri afternoon but the school doesn't need to pay for cover teachers and in many cases doesn't pay to keep the building open. Staff are still doing a 5 day week (lots of teachers take their half day PPA from home in other areas, but the class is covered by eg an HLTA).

Not how it works in all authorities - ours do longer hours Mon-Thu to cover the Fri afternoon and teacher's no -contact (PPA) time is during the time children are in school. Our schools used to start later & allow an hour for lunch, both have been shaved by about 10/15mins so not immediately obvious that the time in school is longer. In our authority teachers are required to be in school for a small number of Fri afternoons across the year as part of collegiate work/professional learning sessions but most Fridays are their own.

adlitem · 06/06/2022 15:52

Holidays should not be shortened. That's a terrible idea!

coffeecupsandfairylights · 06/06/2022 15:52

GreatCuppa · 06/06/2022 15:50

Childcare?

What childcare? For school aged children.

So I should pay out for childcare that I don’t currently need, because my children are at school.

Because school isn't childcare, it's education.

Many parents pay for childcare around school hours already - how would this be any different?

GreatCuppa · 06/06/2022 15:50

Childcare?

What childcare? For school aged children.

So I should pay out for childcare that I don’t currently need, because my children are at school.

Dinoteeth · 06/06/2022 15:43

Those suggesting shorter holidays are forgetting that will push the price of holidays up, you cut the tourist season by two weeks the tourist businesses still need to make money.

And many workplaces only allow a few staff off each week which is manageable over a 6 or 7 week summer. But if everyone wants the same over 4 weeks it means people taking holidays when their kids are in school or their partner can't get the same two weeks off.

I really think it will be a nightmare for parents to manage.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 06/06/2022 15:31

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 06/06/2022 14:54

So because it doesn't work for some industries it shouldn't be trialled for any?

Isn't that like saying "well I can't work from home so you shouldn't either"?

Pretty much.

I've noticed that a lot on MN though - lots of "I can't do xyz so you shouldn't be able to do it either".

adlitem · 06/06/2022 15:28

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 06/06/2022 14:54

So because it doesn't work for some industries it shouldn't be trialled for any?

Isn't that like saying "well I can't work from home so you shouldn't either"?

Inclined to agree with this.
And then sectors where it didn't work, it was treated as unsociable hours and therefore remunerated better.
Lots of things aren't standard over all industries, but that doesn't mean they aren't a good idea. And maybe if the 4 day week became the norm, it would be easier to see how it could be applied more widely.
Alternatively shorter working days would be a good idea. I believe I have seen that the UK has one of the longest working weeks in Europe and is one of the countries with least productivity. More hours does not = more work.

fallfallfall · 06/06/2022 15:27

Those who mention nursing
i work in BC where our contract is for 36 hours a week full time.
all this means is a variety of rotations not that business is limited to 36 hrs of operation.
means more staff though so government would initially have to pay to train more people.

ahwobabob · 06/06/2022 15:26

No.

Fizbosshoes · 06/06/2022 15:25

In France we have:

2 weeks in October
2 weeks at Christmas
2 weeks in February (for skiing)
2 weeks at Easter / springtime
A 4-day weekend over Ascension
7-8 weeks of summer holidays.

So it is do-able. The summer holidays are loooooong though!

Wow. That's a lot of holiday to cover for working parents!

coffeecupsandfairylights · 06/06/2022 15:24

GreatCuppa · 06/06/2022 15:01

So because it doesn't work for some industries it shouldn't be trialled for any?

Where are my kids going to go when I’m at work?

Childcare?

Nobody's saying it's going to start immediately and work flawlessly right away, but it's obviously possible - it just needs some working out first.

WhateverIdo · 06/06/2022 15:23

Unless the entire country goes to a four day week being classed as full-time for the same pay, not pay that is sneakily reduced over time then it won't work... Why would anyone in the public sector choose to work a 5 day week, more hours for less than someone in a call centre enjoying a work life balance. Makes no sense and the public sectors will haemorrhage staff more than they are currently

coffeecupsandfairylights · 06/06/2022 15:21

GreatCuppa · 06/06/2022 14:47

Pretty sure all midwives and drs don't currently work 7 days a week, every week, although I imagine it does happen.

No but if you’re expecting a school to have the same day off every week that means I have to have the same day off every week, and nurses, doctors and midwives work a rotation of shifts. Unless we just close the hospital on a Friday…

I'm pretty sure not all midwives, doctors and nurses have small children who need childcare, though...

robinkombucha · 06/06/2022 15:17

I agree it would be fairly unworkable in schools BUT it will only make the teacher recruitment and retention crisis much much worse if teachers had to work a 5 day week while we gone else had 4, inspite of the holidays.

GreatCuppa · 06/06/2022 15:01

So because it doesn't work for some industries it shouldn't be trialled for any?

Where are my kids going to go when I’m at work?

orwellwasright · 06/06/2022 15:01

I also feel hugely for single parents. Do people even realise how exhausting school holidays can be if it's just you? A three day weekend, every weekend would break lots of struggling single parents.

orwellwasright · 06/06/2022 14:58

I'd take a 4 day week and would most definitely include schools in that. A 3 day weekend, such as happens over a bank holiday weekend now, is so good for the soul in terms of rest, seeing family/ friends and spending more time on interests and leisure

Not if your family hasn't got a pot to piss in. Or your mum spends her days taking crack. Or your dad wallops you continually. It's such a middle class privilege to see family and leisure time as unadulterated joy.

Schools aren't there to solve society's problems but effectively that's what they do. They hugely mitigate the negative effects that poverty, substance abuse and domestic abuse has on children.

Children from poorer backgrounds do far better in school than out.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 06/06/2022 14:54

So because it doesn't work for some industries it shouldn't be trialled for any?

Isn't that like saying "well I can't work from home so you shouldn't either"?

orwellwasright · 06/06/2022 14:53

Yes there is the wider issue of the impact of an extra day on vulnerable children and I don't have the answers here

Until there are genuine solutions to this, it's a non starter.

Schools are under enormous, continued pressure to close the attainment gap. I have been grilled by Ofsted on this repeatedly.

So introducing a national policy that would widen the gap would be nonsensical. Unless the govt and Ofsted just gives up caring. Which would be really shit for society. But, hey, the rich kids get an extra day each week doing enriching fun things so that's ok.

GreatCuppa · 06/06/2022 14:47

Pretty sure all midwives and drs don't currently work 7 days a week, every week, although I imagine it does happen.

No but if you’re expecting a school to have the same day off every week that means I have to have the same day off every week, and nurses, doctors and midwives work a rotation of shifts. Unless we just close the hospital on a Friday…

Anothernameforallthis · 06/06/2022 14:47

While I'm here, I'd also like two 2-week half terms in May/ June and Oct (before the clocks go back) and only a 4 week summer holiday. Please.

In France we have:

2 weeks in October
2 weeks at Christmas
2 weeks in February (for skiing)
2 weeks at Easter / springtime
A 4-day weekend over Ascension
7-8 weeks of summer holidays.

So it is do-able. The summer holidays are loooooong though!

OP posts:
Cleangreenbean · 06/06/2022 14:43

I'd take a 4 day week and would most definitely include schools in that. A 3 day weekend, such as happens over a bank holiday weekend now, is so good for the soul in terms of rest, seeing family/ friends and spending more time on interests and leisure.

While I'm here, I'd also like two 2-week half terms in May/ June and Oct (before the clocks go back) and a only a 4 week summer holiday. Please.

And my kids liked it when, during the tail end of Covid, the school had half the kids in the class for the first part of the week and then the other half in for the second part. Their learning came on brilliantly with only 15 kids in the class, as opposed to 30. Must be how private schools do so well?

Lastly, what happened to that report on how the education system can help kids recover from Covid? Buried under sodding partygate??? Kids deserve better. Come on.

IsItMeOrThemBeingKnobs · 06/06/2022 14:28

I think this article sums it up well in their drawbacks bit: theantiburnoutclub.com/4-day-work-week-benefits-drawbacks-detail/

“During the study in Iceland, the government had to hire more healthcare workers to cover the changing shift patterns at a cost of £24.2 million per year. If the UK decided to make four day working weeks the norm, the expense needed to cover an increase in healthcare workers would likely be eye-wateringly high.

For sectors that are already facing staff shortages, such as schools and healthcare, it would be practically impossible to introduce a four day work week without a huge recruitment drive. Workers in hospitality, emergency services, carers, business owners and many others would unlikely reap the benefits of a UK-wide shift in working days. Could this create animosity and inequality in the long run?”

Swipe left for the next trending thread