Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

4-day working week: would it be extended to schools?

140 replies

Anothernameforallthis · 06/06/2022 11:19

Just reading in the Guardian about a big UK project to trial a 4-day working week in a whole range of different businesses / places of employment. The benefits are expected to be clear: “The four-day week is generally considered to be a triple-dividend policy – helping employees, companies, and the climate. Our research efforts will be digging into all of this.”

If it is a great success, wouldn't we want to extend these benefits to school children and teachers? Give them a less stressful life, benefit the environment (one less day a week of the school run), more time to develop interests / hobbies / skills away from the classroom?

OP posts:
orwellwasright · 06/06/2022 17:14

Or the kids who are vulnerable and safeguarded, who’s parents barely brought them in during lockdown because they don’t give two shiny shits about their children

We saw this at my school during the lockdowns. Despite being the first to receive a guaranteed bubble place not one of our vulnerable children were brought into school because school wasn't mandatory so the parents couldn't be arsed.

All of these children suffered hugely and are still struggling to catch up with their peers. Heartbreaking.

Schools don't bang on about attendance because they want to spoil your fun holiday, or insist your dangerously ill child crawls on bloody stumps into lessons. They stress its importance because they know only too well how poor attendance impacts children.

GooglyEyeballs · 06/06/2022 17:12

Holiday not jiday!!

GooglyEyeballs · 06/06/2022 17:11

Tbh students have so much jiday and time off anyway I don't think they need anymore and parents could probably do with that extra day off 😂

GreatCuppa · 06/06/2022 17:08

TheKeatingFive · 06/06/2022 17:02

Also who's providing this subsidised childcare? There isn't enough childcare provision as it is.

The childcare fairies! With their magic fucking wands of course!

And let’s not even start thinking about where the SEN kids or children with complex needs are going to go!

DelphiniumBlue · 06/06/2022 17:05

It won't happen, but really there's no reason why it shouldn't. You could have schools open for 5 days but teachers doing overlapping days of 4 days a week each. If the will was there it could be done, but it isn't.

TheKeatingFive · 06/06/2022 17:02

Also who's providing this subsidised childcare? There isn't enough childcare provision as it is.

GreatCuppa · 06/06/2022 17:01

They could access subsidised childcare on the extra day off.

People that can’t afford to feed their kids and rely on free school meals can’t afford subsidised childcare, when previously they weren’t paying for it. They certainly can’t afford ‘enriching’ activities.

People that don’t give a shit about their children aren’t going to take them or pay for subsidised childcare. They didn’t take them to school during lockdown.

My kids are not going to enjoy any activities if I can’t afford them because I’m shelling out on extra childcare I hadn’t factored in.

Caspianberg · 06/06/2022 16:58

@Sleepingsatellite1 - Austria.
School holidays are also long. this summer it’s July 1st- September 12th in most states. Ie 10 week summer holiday

Slinkymalinky03 · 06/06/2022 16:57

Burgerqueenbee · 06/06/2022 12:45

It isn't compressed hours, it is literally just working 4 normal days and getting paid for 5.

I don't think you've understood this correctly. It's all about productivity.

Sleepingsatellite1 · 06/06/2022 16:53

Caspianberg · 06/06/2022 12:09

Yes it would be good.

dh and I shifted to 4 day weeks a while ago. It means you get less burn out and actually some time to do stuff as the weekend was always lost with chores, diy etc.

if your working 4 days, then it wouldnt matter if children only did 4 days either.

Although tbh school isn’t childcare. School where I live is 8am-11.30am, has been forever. So no one of any age has school in the afternoons. It’s plenty.

Wow, where’s that 😊

Anothernameforallthis · 06/06/2022 16:51

I don't understand why the UK has never introduced decent, state-funded childcare, which is common in most of Europe. Here in France, school starts at 3 and is free for all from that point. Before that there are a huge number of different crèches, from fully state-run to semi-private to parentale (where parents get together to set one up) to fully private. Within the state system, the costs are means-tested, with the lowest income families paying maybe 50€ a month for a full-time place, with cost rising depending on how much you earn. There are also multitudes of nannies and childminders, with the costs subsidised in some way for most families. I don't know anyone here who needs to take the cost of childcare into account when making these decisions. Yes, it can sometimes be difficult to find a place but the restrictions are not down to cost.

OP posts:
coffeecupsandfairylights · 06/06/2022 16:36

I won’t be earning any extra to cover the £100+ cost of childcare for two DC every week. Wherever this magical childcare is. How should I cover this cost?

But equally, it WILL benefit loads of families who can save on childcare and spend more time together. Should everyone miss out because there are some families who won't benefit?

And what about the children who get free school meals? I guess they shouldn’t eat one day a week. Maybe we should introduce ‘starving Wednesdays’. Or the kids who are vulnerable and safeguarded, who’s parents barely brought them in during lockdown because they don’t give two shiny shits about their children.

They could access subsidised childcare on the extra day off.

Our admissions of abused, bruised children went up after lockdown. Because they weren’t physically seen. But no, let’s just live in an idealistic unrealistic bubble where all children’s lives will be enriched by going swimming and doing outdoor activities one day a week.

It's obviously horrendous that some children suffered through lockdown, but reducing the school week to four days doesn't mean the same thing will happen again. There will obviously have to be systems put in place to support working parents and these things take time, but it can definitely happen. After all, it works in other countries, so why shouldn't it work here?

adlitem · 06/06/2022 16:35

I won’t be earning any extra to cover the £100+ cost of childcare for two DC every week. Wherever this magical childcare is. How should I cover this cost?

Clearly the 4 day week scenario would require more than just changing some working hours if it was to be roled out on a societal level. It's not inconscievable that such a change would factor in other things, such as better wrap around care.

I don't think schools should be 4 days - because it would be logisically difficult, but mainly because I don't think it benefits the children. However, e.g. a shorter day could be accomdated by good wrap around care and clubs.

GreatCuppa · 06/06/2022 16:31

Because school isn't childcare, it's education.

Many parents pay for childcare around school hours already - how would this be any different?

Well, obviously. And I do, already.

I won’t be earning any extra to cover the £100+ cost of childcare for two DC every week. Wherever this magical childcare is. How should I cover this cost?

And what about the children who get free school meals? I guess they shouldn’t eat one day a week. Maybe we should introduce ‘starving Wednesdays’. Or the kids who are vulnerable and safeguarded, who’s parents barely brought them in during lockdown because they don’t give two shiny shits about their children.

Our admissions of abused, bruised children went up after lockdown. Because they weren’t physically seen.

But no, let’s just live in an idealistic unrealistic bubble where all children’s lives will be enriched by going swimming and doing outdoor activities one day a week.

I can only assume that people either don't have school-aged children or are sahps with misty-eyed fantasies about enriching days out and #sourdoughbreadmakingwithmytinies

This.

MajorCarolDanvers · 06/06/2022 16:30

LoopyGremlin · 06/06/2022 11:27

Edinburgh and the surrounds do a 4.5 day week in schools and have done for decades. Finish at lunchtime on a Friday. Works well for teachers and kids, not so sure for parents.

The kids are in school for the same length of time - just in 4.5 longer days. I am in Fife and we have this with our high schools too.

When it was brought in it was supposed to replace in service days but the teachers are out of the schools on Friday lunchtimes liked greased lightening (don't blame them I would too) and so there was no change to in service days.

The pupils and teachers seem pretty happy with it.

As it is high school you don't have a knock on effect with parents as no childcare needed but it would be a nightmare if this was introduced for primary.

MarshaBradyo · 06/06/2022 16:19

I’d prefer not if thinking of dc first, but these things tend to favour some sections of society over others - as happened with the bigger closures

the gap between top and bottom widens

adlitem · 06/06/2022 16:16

orwellwasright · 06/06/2022 16:08

That may be a problem. Who knows. It may not.

The solution, however, isn't to rediuce the time children are in school because the consequences of that to both children and working parents would be devastating.

The solution would be to recruit more PT teaching staff.

Agreed. The priority in education should be about what is best for the pupils. Not what is best for the teachers in terms of employment. The whole concept of the 4 day week is not only that it's best for employees but that it's best for business as people work more efficiently on that basis. Obviously that doesn't mean teachers should be given a bad deal but there are other ways to compensate for not everything being equal everywhere (as is the case in all other differentials of employment). This might be better wages, shorter days (see below), longer holidays, better pensions, better job security, etc etc etc
My view is that shorter week/ longer days doesn't benefit learning. Perhaps shorter days equally a 4 day working week in hours would be the way to go in an ideal world. With appropriate wrap around care in place.
Holidays shouldn't be cut either. It's well proven that the benefits of a siginifcant amount of time once in a while can't be compensated by odd days.
I don't think that education should be structured around childcare requirements of parents, then rather good quality wrap around care should be provided/ available.
The above isnt "I'm alright, sod everything else!" at all.

Simonjt · 06/06/2022 16:16

Personally I would rather we had a smaller curriculum so children could actually learn, rather than memorising (especially in secondary), if schools remained 5 days it would be nice if a smaller curriculum meant more enrichment activities.

Four days would be awkward as everything else would be open for the same time, so some parents would always work a friday for example, but school is now closed then so they would need childcare. There aren’t enough childminders around (are they on four days, doubtful as pay is poor) for all the primary school children with a parent at work on the fifth day of the week.

orwellwasright · 06/06/2022 16:12

TheKeatingFive · 06/06/2022 16:07

Because school isn't childcare

This is such a facile phrase. It IS childcare, among other things. We've based working patterns and benefits around that fact.

It's quite obviously not going to be acceptable to reduce schools to 4 days and expecting parents having to work 5 to suck that up. I've no idea why anyone would think it is.

100%.

I can only assume that people either don't have school-aged children or are sahps with misty-eyed fantasies about enriching days out and #sourdoughbreadmakingwithmytinies

artisanbread · 06/06/2022 16:09

Most schools actively dislike recruiting part-time staff. I know from experience.

orwellwasright · 06/06/2022 16:08

artisanbread · 06/06/2022 16:03

Watch all the (remaining) teachers, healthca e staff, hospitality workers leave for jobs they can all do in a 4 day week then. It's hard enough to recruit in these areas anyway, especially after Covid, so let's make the jobs even less attractive!

That may be a problem. Who knows. It may not.

The solution, however, isn't to rediuce the time children are in school because the consequences of that to both children and working parents would be devastating.

The solution would be to recruit more PT teaching staff.

TheKeatingFive · 06/06/2022 16:07

Because school isn't childcare

This is such a facile phrase. It IS childcare, among other things. We've based working patterns and benefits around that fact.

It's quite obviously not going to be acceptable to reduce schools to 4 days and expecting parents having to work 5 to suck that up. I've no idea why anyone would think it is.

orwellwasright · 06/06/2022 16:06

adlitem · 06/06/2022 15:52

Holidays should not be shortened. That's a terrible idea!

I think the summer one should. But not the total. But I think we should lose two weeks from summer, instead distributing the time amongst the other holidays.

Way better for kids from poorer families who often spend the first few weeks in September catching up. In fact, the IoW has just shortened its summer holiday by a week and increased the October half term.

artisanbread · 06/06/2022 16:03

Watch all the (remaining) teachers, healthca e staff, hospitality workers leave for jobs they can all do in a 4 day week then. It's hard enough to recruit in these areas anyway, especially after Covid, so let's make the jobs even less attractive!

orwellwasright · 06/06/2022 16:01

coffeecupsandfairylights · 06/06/2022 15:52

Because school isn't childcare, it's education.

Many parents pay for childcare around school hours already - how would this be any different?

Because each child would need childcare costing around £2k per year. I've based this on parents needing a full day's care each week during term time. Obviously there will be cheaper arrangements.

So two kids at primary? You need to earn an extra £4k net pa. Where's this money coming from?

It's too facile to say education isn't childcare. Of course it's education but it still allows parents to work on those days. You need to factor in childcare, its cost and availability, before you blithely change school hours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread