Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dog tried to bite my baby

116 replies

UserICantThinkOfAUsername · 06/06/2022 08:48

Morning all. So I've never had dogs, don't know much about them, never really trusted them either.

Yesterday at my PIL house one of the dogs tried to bite my 11 month olds nose in a completely unprovoked attack (she was just crawling next to the dog). Luckily my partner was quick and stopped the dog but she almost bit our LG nose. I didn't allow the dog near her the rest of the day. Previously, said dog has been very protective of my baby and gets upset when she cries etc so we are shocked she's tried biting her. But obviously now I do not trust the dog at all... I am also due our 3rd baby in September who PIL are the default childcare if I go into hospital (planning a homebirth). It's a very close family and we regularly go to their house for gatherings. AIBU to say I will not be going to their home anymore with children if said dog is there?

OP posts:
Trinacham · 06/06/2022 09:42

@livelyredjellybean you don't wait for that one incident though, to say that the dog can't be trusted. The incident that happened within my family - the dog had never shown aggression before. The child was not a baby. The child wasn't bothering the dog. Dog was sleeping. Child accidentally touched the dog with a toy. Dog startled. Reflex was to bite whatever had startled him awake. This dog has lived with children for years and was a very docile dog and a breed that is often said to be a wonderful choice to have around children.

saraclara · 06/06/2022 09:41

The anthropomorphisation of dogs that is rife these days, is so dangerous.

The dog wasn't being 'protective' when it got upset at the baby crying. It was anxious and stressed at the noise. And it was a clear sign that it was likely to react unpredictably to the child at some point.

People need to stop attributing positive human emotions to animals, and anyways err on the cautious side.

Staryflight445 · 06/06/2022 09:37

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 06/06/2022 09:07

Reading previous behaviour as 'protective' is usually incorrect. Sounds like no one in the family actually understands dogs, notices discomfort/anxiety cues and have inadvertently forced the you, your child and the dog into a terrible situation. You are right to fully protect your child. As a pp said, I'd not allow crawling around ANY dog. Keep them totally separate.

I agree with all of this.

I also hope in the future people won’t be able to have dogs unless they’ve been on specific courses that teach all of this basic stuff.

LeeMucklowesCurtains · 06/06/2022 09:37

As dog owners, they should know better.

I had the two most loving, docile, genital golden retrievers you would ever meet, but I never had them in the same room as someone else’s small
child and my own children were never left alone with them for a second and always closely supervised so they were acting appropriately around the dogs.

I wouldn’t leave my children with a dog owner who couldn’t keep both the child and the dog safe.

Mythril · 06/06/2022 09:35

I think how you proceed depends on PIL response to the incident. Are they acknowledging the now apparent risk and making plans to keep dog and baby seperate? Or are they playing it down?

I think YABU to require the dog not be at the house (where would it go??)

ComDummings · 06/06/2022 09:29

I would be finding alternative childcare for when you go into hospital.

hassletassle · 06/06/2022 09:28

There is absolutely no way I would let my baby go to that house while the dog is there. If they are the default childcare, can't one of them come to your house to look after your child while you're in hospital?

Belephant · 06/06/2022 09:27

Yep - I've spent my whole life around dogs, as well as wild animals and livestock. I've seen enough beautiful, loving, docile dogs turn and snap because they're spooked, stressed, or scared to make me certain that I don't want dogs around my baby. And for various reasons, babies and small children can be a trigger for these things.

I'm really not trying to be all "well you shouldn't have done XYZ in the first place", OP, this is just a learning moment and I'm so happy your lovely dc was unharmed - obviously mostly for your DC's sake but also the dog's. It makes me very sad when dogs are put in situations that can lead to them being put down because they were stressed and reacted as their instincts tell them.

You are NOT overreacting, your mum-instinct to keep your baby away from this dog are totally valid and the right thing to do imo.

What did your PIL's do after the incident? How does your partner feel?

livelyredjellybean · 06/06/2022 09:26

There’s a difference between a child “crawling near a dog” which my kids do all the time with my own dogs, and a child crawling all over a dog. Obviously the latter is an absolute no-no, and it’s up to the parent to prevent the child from doing this.

From the OP’s post, the dog hasn’t ever shown aggression - if it has in any circumstances, this changes things entirely! But I see absolutely no concern with allowing a child to crawl around “the same space” as a dog who previously has shown no behavioural concerns!

UserICantThinkOfAUsername · 06/06/2022 09:25

Okay thanks everyone. As I said I don't know much about dogs, never had one myself, my partners family always have had dogs, so I trusted their judgement.
I'd never seen problems with this dog previously with other family children so saw no issue with a baby crawling near it (much like their family didn't) I won't allow baby and dog to be together again and will make this clear to PIL and BIL

OP posts:
NwNmOldFace · 06/06/2022 09:23

The dog has been telling you all for quite some time that they find small people stressful. Between you, nobody has picked up on those signs. Babies and children should not be crawling around near dogs no matter how well they have previously appeared to get along. Your DH needs to speak to PiL to work this out going forward. My suggestion would be that the dog is kept in a safe space where they feel comfortable, maybe a bedroom or conservatory - somewhere there doesn't have to be heavy traffic but where the dog can be checked regularly, let out to toilet etc... and you all take responsibility for ensuring there are no careless oops moments. I'm sorry if I seem harsh OP but I've spent the last twenty five years of my life rehabbing dogs who have a bad reputation as "aggressive" - I have yet to meet one that actually was. What I have met is scores of anxious, depressed, shut down dogs who have given up on life and have reacted badly in a moment of highest anxiety, now their world has been torn apart as have the lives of those who love them.

lostintheglowofmotherhood · 06/06/2022 09:23

YANBU in being concerned about the dog.
We have a dog which was adopted when our eldest was 9 years of age, he's always been great with her, but it has become apparent he doesn't like children.
We've had a new baby and we've had to put controls in place to ensure the babies safety.
Tbh it seems like your moat reasonable option is to make your home the place for the family get togethers.

Nit sure if its helpful but these are things we do.
When DS first came home DDog was put on his lead if he was too excitable.
Dog isn't allowed too close to baby, certainly not up against him etc
If baby is crying dog is out of the room.
Dog is now trained to leave the room with me if I have to leave whilst baby is in his cot.
Baby is worn in a carrier a lot around the house.

6 weeks in, he's largely unbothered by my son, doesn't take an interest when he cries (when he first came home, Dog tried to barge me out of the way to get to the baby who was whimpering.

ZekeZeke · 06/06/2022 09:22

How your PIL reacted would be key to making any decision on them looking after your child/ren.

If they brushed it off then you have your answer and you cannot be sure they will keep the dog separate to the DC. Even if they say they will.

growandhope · 06/06/2022 09:22

UserICantThinkOfAUsername · 06/06/2022 09:02

I don't think this is really fair, it's a family dog that has been around the other children for around 3 years, including my older son who was only a baby when dog was brought home. If I ever thought there was a chance this dog could do this I wouldn't have allowed it, but plenty of families have dogs ?

This is the best advice and you have picked this posters advice out and rejected it.@livelyredjellybean is talking absolute crap.The dog did not behave in an 'unusual way', a vet check and a behavioural session is not required and not going to do much when it is not your dog. You are not going to be able to train someone else's dog. You have had your warning OP, heed it.

carefullycourageous · 06/06/2022 09:19

The dog should never be allowed in the room with the baby after this. I would not take my baby to the house if proper measures were not taken.

People are ridiculously trusting around dogs. I do not understand the modern approach of acting like dogs have soft teeth and rational thought processes. I grew up in a dog family, they were loved but they were accepted to be dogs - so we were careful.

NoSquirrels · 06/06/2022 09:18

livelyredjellybean · 06/06/2022 09:09

OP, ignore Pp overreacting about “you shouldn’t have let your baby crawl near a dog”; that’s absolutely ridiculous when the dog has shown no previous negative behaviour towards your kids.
Going forward you definitely shouldn’t allow your PIL to watch the kids unless the dog is elsewhere. They should also investigate why the dog behaved in such an unusual way, starting with a vet check. They could follow up with a behavioural session after if no obvious cause is found at the vet check. But it will be completely up to you whether you ever trust this dog again.
I really hope you do better than I have with my own parents and their dog; I’ve never taken my kids to their house as I don’t trust their dog (and I say this as a qualified dog behaviour consultant!) yet they still won’t crate the dog when we ask to visit.

I’m very surprised a trained dog behaviour consultant would advise it’s OK for a crawling baby to be in the same space as a dog.

NoSquirrels · 06/06/2022 09:16

And the dog having previously been ‘good’ around children doesn’t mean it will continue to be ‘good’ forever in all circumstances. A young dog coping with one baby/toddler could be fine, then as more kids come along and everything gets more chaotic (you mention the day was ‘hectic’) the dog can get its stress triggers stacked up and that’s when problems occur. But definitely dogs cannot be near crawling babies, and should be closely, closely supervised with toddlers and young children, and everyone should follow rules to give space and keep everyone happy and safe.

StooOrangeyForCrows · 06/06/2022 09:15

Even closely monitored doesn't cut it. A dog can snap in a tenth of a second and remove a piece of tissue that needs skin grafts and eight surgeries.

Mommabear20 · 06/06/2022 09:15

We have 2 dogs, and even though I have full trust in them, both dogs and toddlers are unpredictable! We keep ours separated using a baby gate, so they can all see each other and interact but everyone has the option to move away if they want to. We only have small dogs so the very worst that could happen is one of them bites DC hand if they stick in through the gate. Still a worry but knowing it could never end in a serious attack and hurt any of them, dog or child, gives me so much peace of mind.
YANBU to be upset by the incident, but I don't like it when dogs are shut into a separate room which is out of the norm for them in their own home. I'd say just don't take DC to their house, have them come to you from now on.

StooOrangeyForCrows · 06/06/2022 09:13

In my day job I have seen the result of dog bites on children and babies.

Please stop putting children and dogs together unless the dog is muzzled or dead.

I have worked with dogs my whole life and was raised around them but they have an inner narrative too and putting them in a position where they can end up dead at the vets because of a decision by humans and your DC can have life long facial scars and all for no reason at all, is crazy - genuinely.

londonlass71 · 06/06/2022 09:12

Dogs and babies should always be monitored closely - I wouldn't have let the baby crawl near the dog like that in the first place. Was there a toy nearby? Or food? Or something the dog found valuable? Does the baby grab at the dog? These things can all play a part. I am not saying it is right or ok what has happened, I am just pointing out there are many facets to dog behaviour.

I would be mindful of using the word "attacked" it wasn't an attack at all.

This was caused by bad management on your part I'm afraid OP and yes you need to take steps in the future to ensure it doesn't happen again. You say the dog previous "got upset if the baby cried" (or words to that effect). How do you know the baby wasn't stressing the dog our as opposed to the animal being upset? You don't.

Always err on the side of caution. As much as it pains me to say this it is your fault not the dog's. We as a society expect dogs to tolerate so much and of course they have limits.

livelyredjellybean · 06/06/2022 09:09

OP, ignore Pp overreacting about “you shouldn’t have let your baby crawl near a dog”; that’s absolutely ridiculous when the dog has shown no previous negative behaviour towards your kids.
Going forward you definitely shouldn’t allow your PIL to watch the kids unless the dog is elsewhere. They should also investigate why the dog behaved in such an unusual way, starting with a vet check. They could follow up with a behavioural session after if no obvious cause is found at the vet check. But it will be completely up to you whether you ever trust this dog again.
I really hope you do better than I have with my own parents and their dog; I’ve never taken my kids to their house as I don’t trust their dog (and I say this as a qualified dog behaviour consultant!) yet they still won’t crate the dog when we ask to visit.

stuntbubbles · 06/06/2022 09:09

Mischance · 06/06/2022 08:59

I would rate your concern about seeming "too precious" as bottom of the list in comparison with the risk of your child being bitten.

Do not ever leave your child in the unsupervised care of your PIL.

Anyone who has a visiting child or baby and does not put their dog in a separate room is irresponsible.

This. I’d be the most precious and difficult person in the world to keep my child safe from a dog bite.

It’s absolutely imperative to enforce child/dog separation, especially now you’ve witnessed an incident: that’s strike one. Can you get alternative childcare for when the new baby arrives?

Ponoka7 · 06/06/2022 09:09

To the dog it wouldn't have been unprovoked, your baby was crawling, the dog might have been giving warnings which wasn't noticed and so snapped. The dog snapped, it didn't bite, that's a warning. For whatever reason, jealously or fear, the dog must be away until the children can be taught how to behave around dogs. Realistically the dog can't be out of the house, in all weathers. You can get crates large enough for every breed, which might be a solution. The dog should be given tasty treats/chew sticks when in there so it doesn't see the crate as a punishment.

NoSquirrels · 06/06/2022 09:09

Dogs shouldn’t be near crawling babies. So there should be a way to separate them - gates etc - and everyone should do that as standard from now on. What did your in-laws do/say/suggest when this happened? Responsible dog owners would already be thinking of how to separate dogs and children if this happened.

I’d give the benefit of the doubt once i.e. go over again with the expectation that measures had been put into place to separate the dogs and kids, and if they hadn’t or your in-laws don’t seem to be taking it seriously then I’d not take my DC there or allow them to mind DC with dogs present - they could leave dogs behind and look after your DC at your house when you’re in labour.

Don’t let anyone tell you you’re overreacting.

Previously, said dog has been very protective of my baby and gets upset when she cries

This is a misunderstanding of what the dog was trying to communicate. It was stressed by the presence of the baby. Stress - if ignored - eventually leads to a reaction like biting. Have a read up on dog signals of stress (licking lips, turning head away, whining, staring). Dogs only snap or bite as last line of defence/communication- the dog will 100% have been trying to tell you all that it was unhappy, it won’t have come out of the blue, even if it seems that way to you. It’s just the first warning signs were missed - lots of people don’t recognise when dogs are trying to communicate stress.

Swipe left for the next trending thread