Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dog tried to bite my baby

116 replies

UserICantThinkOfAUsername · 06/06/2022 08:48

Morning all. So I've never had dogs, don't know much about them, never really trusted them either.

Yesterday at my PIL house one of the dogs tried to bite my 11 month olds nose in a completely unprovoked attack (she was just crawling next to the dog). Luckily my partner was quick and stopped the dog but she almost bit our LG nose. I didn't allow the dog near her the rest of the day. Previously, said dog has been very protective of my baby and gets upset when she cries etc so we are shocked she's tried biting her. But obviously now I do not trust the dog at all... I am also due our 3rd baby in September who PIL are the default childcare if I go into hospital (planning a homebirth). It's a very close family and we regularly go to their house for gatherings. AIBU to say I will not be going to their home anymore with children if said dog is there?

OP posts:
Ownedbymycats · 06/06/2022 10:18

Sorry, agree that you're under reacting.
I know a professional middle aged person who recently had to have their nose reattached after working with a family pet who had no history of biting. They face years of surgery and the cosmetic side is only part of the problem.
Don't trust your children with these dogs and never allow them to crawl into the dogs territory.

BemoreDerek · 06/06/2022 10:17

I love dogs, have two of my own but you are not overreacting to say you don't want your DC around this dog ever again, it's just not worth the risk. I have a 2 year old DGC, my dogs go in their crate when he's here despite being lovely, sociable and much loved pets and never having shown any aggression to anyone. I genuinely don't understand anyone who doesn't do the same with visiting children, the consequences of my dogs hurting someone, especially a child, are just too awful to contemplate doing anything else.

Ownedbymycats · 06/06/2022 10:15

I've a 2 inch scar on my arm from my mother's toy poodle biting me about 15 years ago.
I agree that you're

SleepSleepRaveAsleep · 06/06/2022 10:14

Once a dog does that they are no longer safe, really they should be having that dog pts, are you going to wait until it bites one of your children's faces off? I would not be visiting them whilst they still have the dog, they can come to you. My brother has dogs, one bit my husband on the leg (before we had children) our children have never been round their house because of the dog. If the dog had done that to one of our children I'd have reported it. I get the dog is a family pet but once a dog bites they should be put down. Too many cases of poor children being mauled to death in the news.

growandhope · 06/06/2022 10:09

@livelyredjellybean stick to walking the dogs; you do not WAIT to see aggression

MagnoliaTaint · 06/06/2022 10:04

NoSquirrels · 06/06/2022 09:16

And the dog having previously been ‘good’ around children doesn’t mean it will continue to be ‘good’ forever in all circumstances. A young dog coping with one baby/toddler could be fine, then as more kids come along and everything gets more chaotic (you mention the day was ‘hectic’) the dog can get its stress triggers stacked up and that’s when problems occur. But definitely dogs cannot be near crawling babies, and should be closely, closely supervised with toddlers and young children, and everyone should follow rules to give space and keep everyone happy and safe.

Yep.

There is no such thing as a dog that is 'unprovokable'. Any dog can be startled or provoked, and sometimes their reactions are hard to predict. If a dog is tired, or ill, or has been stressed the previous day, their tolerance level may be compromised.

I would keep any child under about 8 in close supervision or separate. Babies and toddlers only when I am in direct close supervision and dog on lead, and only for a very short period (come and clap it and say hello, okay, no more than that - and my dog is super friendly).

So YANBU, OP. Hope you can discuss amicably, but I think it's sensible & reasonable to say that the dog needs to be kep separated from your children. You could shift the focus onto keeping the baby away from the dog if that is easier?

GlitteryGreen · 06/06/2022 10:03

I don't think you can expect their dog not to be in the house when you visit, but you can certainly make sure it's always separated from your child/on a lead when your child is there.

Laiste · 06/06/2022 10:01

Aug12 · 06/06/2022 09:56

You are absolutely right to be concerned and not trust the dog. However, can’t the dog just not be in the same room? Kept in the utility or kitchen or something with door closed whilst your kids are there?

Trouble with this comes when having to trust other people totally to do this in your absence.

Once there's a seed of doubt - what do you do?

Fixyourself · 06/06/2022 10:00

Dogs are unpredictable- surely all the news stories show this? Your child should not be crawling near the dog. Don’t blame your in-laws when you were there.
A stair gate separating the dog while your child is crawling around would be best.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 06/06/2022 09:58

Why on earth aren't people more responsible with their dogs? There is no way I'd allow a dog in the same room as a baby.
My cat was a biter she would just attack visitors so if I had people over the cat would be firmly and comfortably locked in my bedroom until they left and there is no way I'd have trusted her with children.

Aug12 · 06/06/2022 09:56

You are absolutely right to be concerned and not trust the dog. However, can’t the dog just not be in the same room? Kept in the utility or kitchen or something with door closed whilst your kids are there?

theremustonlybeone · 06/06/2022 09:56

i am a bit lost...why wasnt there a conversation with your PIL after the incident? If you have not made a big issue out of it or made it clear at the time of the seriousness they may be oblivious. It seems you and your DP didnt respond in a way that would have triggered a discussion with his parents there and then, I would have been horrified if that happened to my DC and immediately spoken to the owners and made clear that the dog was not to be around my DC. You needed to see their response as that will help guide you whether they can be trusted. The fact you dont know how they feel just seems mad...if they minimise the incident and dont take it seriously then you cant leave your DC with them when you have your baby

Laiste · 06/06/2022 09:56

@UserICantThinkOfAUsername - ''...my partners family always have had dogs, so I trusted their judgement.''

Don't.

Don't automatically trust the judgement of people who have always had dogs OP. Always having had dogs doesn't make people knowlegable or sensible. In fact it can make them overly sentimental and cloud the clear judgement that you yourself have right now actually.

Read the news. All these awful dog attacks - they're nearly always in a family setting and everyone is always ''surprised and horrified'' that the animal attacked. None of them will be saying ''oh yeah we knew Rover was a badun'' .... Think about it.

Read a few bits about dog behaviour. There's a dog in the family so you need to educate yourself now and make your own mind up.

''I won't allow baby and dog to be together again and will make this clear to PIL and BIL.''

Good for you - but you might meet A LOT of opposition, so prepare yourself for it. Stay calm and stick to your guns. Good luck.

MummyGummy · 06/06/2022 09:56

Dogs should never, ever be trusted around babies & young children. Either the dog needs to be shut away when you go round or you meet somewhere else & the dog is left at home/with a sitter. And I think you’ll have to find alternative childcare for during your birth, there’s no way I would risk my baby being in the same house as a dog for an extended period of time, they won’t be able to keep them separate the whole time or PIL might not follow instructions to do so.

ThisisMax · 06/06/2022 09:54

UserICantThinkOfAUsername · 06/06/2022 09:02

I don't think this is really fair, it's a family dog that has been around the other children for around 3 years, including my older son who was only a baby when dog was brought home. If I ever thought there was a chance this dog could do this I wouldn't have allowed it, but plenty of families have dogs ?

But its always a 'family dog' that bites kids on the face. You do not have young babies and a dog together, ever. I have a GSD who gets crated if we have visitors. He is super, great temprament, loving etc but he is also a dog.

bridgetreilly · 06/06/2022 09:53

Babies should never be left unsupervised with dogs. That mean that if there is a dog in the room, you supervise. Keep the baby well away from the dog, on your lap if necessary.

SirSniffsAlot · 06/06/2022 09:53

As others have pointed out, my thoughts would be that the previous "protective" behaviour was actually this dog trying very hard to communicate distress or anxiety around your baby and that your ILs have not been able to recognise this as such and take it as the warning it should be. With that in mind, it is possible that the dog gave similar warnings for all the previous children before but circumstances meant it was never pushed to go futher. Or the dog is losing patience with age which also happens.

FWIW dogs may use a forward snapping motion, as if to bite, but without the intention to follow through futher than skin contact without pressure - as a futher escalation of the warnings they have already been giving. I suspect this is what has happened, because a bite that is meant as a bite is very quick and it would be a super human who could get a baby out the way in time.

Of course, even the snapping warning is not something anyone wants to see or something that should be dismissed. This dog is unhappy around your baby and you are very sensible to take the warnings it has given seriously. However the dog has been in the past, the dog is now uncomfortable around your baby and should not be put in a situation where a bite is possible.

Worth noting that if this is truly a change in the dog's behaviour then a vet check is essential to rule out medical causes, which can play a factor here.

diddl · 06/06/2022 09:52

If you don't trust your ILs to keep the dogs & kids separate then you need to be looking for other childcare for if you need to go to hospital.

What's your husband's take on it all?

NoSquirrels · 06/06/2022 09:52

livelyredjellybean · 06/06/2022 09:26

There’s a difference between a child “crawling near a dog” which my kids do all the time with my own dogs, and a child crawling all over a dog. Obviously the latter is an absolute no-no, and it’s up to the parent to prevent the child from doing this.

From the OP’s post, the dog hasn’t ever shown aggression - if it has in any circumstances, this changes things entirely! But I see absolutely no concern with allowing a child to crawl around “the same space” as a dog who previously has shown no behavioural concerns!

We’ll agree to disagree, I guess. I wouldn’t have any crawling baby in the same room as a dog, supervised or not, and regardless of how ‘good’ the dog is.

I say this as the owner of an extremely tolerant, docile dog, who children who are otherwise scared of dogs love - we’ve had a couple come to meet her specifically to help them. She’d be a brilliant PAT dog if I had the time. But I still wouldn’t have her near a crawling baby. Primarily because would be unfair to her. If I put her in that situation it wouldn’t be for her benefit or the baby’s benefit, and it could result in unwanted stress for everyone.

I’m much less hardline about older children with correct supervision but crawling babies - nope.

CaptSkippy · 06/06/2022 09:51

It may not have been intended as an attack, but a correction. Adult dogs do the same with puppies.

However, while a puppy may be fine after being nipped, a baby might need stitches, so it's a good idea to keep the baby away from the dog as neither understand each other very well.

LeeMucklowesCurtains · 06/06/2022 09:49

*gentle.
Not genital 😳

WiddlinDiddlin · 06/06/2022 09:46

I suspect this dog has NOT actually been 'fine' and 'good' with previous babies, I suspect they've struggled and have no further tolerance.

I can pretty safely state however that the dog did not 'try to bite' - dogs move far faster than us, if the dog intended to land a bite, the dog would have landed a bite unless there is extra information such as the dog is blind - dogs don't miss.

The significance of that is.. this dog IS still communicating their discomfort without actually biting.

Likely an air snap (often interpreted as 'tried to bite but I pulled them away in time').

That means theres time to improve this!

Separate dog and baby - the dog is NOT comfortable with a crawling baby and tbh, very few dogs are - its scary, babies are unpredictable, grabby, smacky, wobbly, prone to strong smells and loud noises, and they DO NOT respond to the polite dog-language communications to back off, give the dog space, leave me alone (stare, freeze, lip curl, growl, air snap etc).. Instead.. they keep coming, which is rude and confrontational!

So the safest kindest thing you can do for both is - well ideally, don't go round there, but if you must - separate them.

If this were YOUR dog, id recommend you reward the heck out of the dog for moving away from the baby and ensure the baby can never approach the dog or trap them. Dogs often forget they can move away, another misunderstanding - people think 'well if he didn't like it... (being smacked, hit, grabbed, climbed on, approached)... he'd move away'.

It doesn't work like that - worried or anxious dogs (and people do this too!) often freeze and forget that moving away is an option.

If we can encourage moving away and reward it by chucking treats so the dog wants to follow them... away from the baby, great!

I suspect it isn't practical to do this with the dog being someone elses - do you know what they have done in the past, have they rewarded the dog for being gentle around babies/ignoring babies, or have they told the dog off for freezing/lip curling/growling (if they have this will make it worse and tbh that would mean I would NOT let my baby go near the dog again. Punishing communication like that is what results in dogs who 'bite without warning'.)

Whatever you decide to do re their dog, I would make a strong point of distracting your baby from any other dog and rewarding them for that - all too often people make a BIG deal about approaching doggies, touching doggies etc when actually what would be far safer is teaching children 'yes the doggy is nice we can look at him from HERE and NOT go and touch/hug/fuss' until they are old enough to understand how to touch nicely, that a growly face is NOT a smile etc etc.

WhatTheWhoTheWhatThe · 06/06/2022 09:44

UserICantThinkOfAUsername · 06/06/2022 09:02

I don't think this is really fair, it's a family dog that has been around the other children for around 3 years, including my older son who was only a baby when dog was brought home. If I ever thought there was a chance this dog could do this I wouldn't have allowed it, but plenty of families have dogs ?

It’s not unfair at all the fact you think it is just shows you have very little understanding of dogs and is even more reason for you to keep you children separate from them.

I have a family and I have a dog. He’s never snapped at anyone but he does give very clear (to me) stress signals so I am hyper vigilant and never let him unsupervised around children. He knows and loves the neighbours children but I never let them pet him unsupervised. He’s a great dog but he has a slightly nervous nature so although he’s never bitten and only ever seems happy to see people I’m always cautious both for his benefit and other people’s.

You’re not wrong to be upset about the incident but you do need to take some responsibility for your own ignorance about keeping your child safe around dogs.

Belephant · 06/06/2022 09:44

@Staryflight445 I also hope in the future people won’t be able to have dogs unless they’ve been on specific courses that teach all of this basic stuff.

I completely agree! Yes OP didn't read the dog's behaviour but she doesn't bloomin have a dog so why would she?! Her PIL's should have known better as the owners of the dog.

And I also agree with everything @saraclara said. Animals are animals, let's respect them as such!

user2234534 · 06/06/2022 09:43

Yanbu.

All it takes it 1 time or 1 accident. Isn't worth the risk.

Swipe left for the next trending thread