Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable?

279 replies

User2392 · 06/06/2022 08:25

I know you all hate these types of threads but I wanted to keep it as unbiased as I could so apologies!

Olivia has a child with Paul, they are not together and Paul has another younger child with his wife Lizzy.

Olivia and Lizzy have always gotten on well enough, not the best of friends but amicable and as the years have gone on, friendly.

Olivia's child has recently told her that he feels since his sister was born that Lizzy and her family don't care about him as much and are always doing things with his sister and not him. This upset Olivia.

Olivia and Paul don't really get on so she decided to send a message to Lizzy directly just asking if they could talk about it. The message was polite but to the point.

Lizzy replied saying that she is sorry he feels that way but her daughter will always be number one to both her and her family (her parents, grandparents, siblings etc..) and that if there are any issues with their child, Olivia should take it up with Paul. She also added that it was none of Olivia's business how much or what Lizzy does with her own daughter and she won't be made to feel like she has to justify it. The message was also polite but obviously Lizzy wasn't happy.

Who's unreasonable?

(Flipped a coin for the vote so don't read anything into that)

YABU - Olivia shouldn't have sent the message in the first place.

YANBU - Lizzy's reply was cruel.

OP posts:
autienotnaughty · 07/06/2022 21:31

GoldPig · 07/06/2022 06:55

I don’t understand why everyone’s berating Olivia for contacting Lizzy. Surely if the relationship is more amicable than with Paul it’s more likely to get a positive result, especially as it’s mother to mother where the concern raised is much more likely to be understood?

Lizzy has confirmed what Olivia’s son has observed - the daughter is favoured over him by both Lizzy and her family. Even extra effort from Paul isn’t going to undo that deflating fact.

I grew up in a blended family and it’s a fact of life that impacts on your sense of worth - you find balance in the attention you get elsewhere.

Totally agree

aSofaNearYou · 07/06/2022 21:31

@Tandora Yes, he feels that way, and there's no evidence that there's actually anything behind that besides him missing out on some days out. Kids very frequently say they feel unloved for materialistic reasons.

You have no idea what Olivia actually said to Lizzie, you're predisposed to say that Lizzie's response is "a problem" to you. Olivia's message could be "a problem" to others.

whumpthereitis · 07/06/2022 21:04

Tandora · 07/06/2022 20:38

Really ? I read it differently .
OP’s list says:

he feels since his sister was born that Lizzy and her family don't care about him as much and are always doing things with his sister and not him

Lizzie’s reply was that her child will always be number 1 and refused to even have a conversation with Olivia about it?

To me that says it’s about much more than one day at grandparents, and Lizzie’s response would be a serious issue for me in itself.

The OP explicitly mentioned two examples that concerned the stepmother’s parents. Yes, her parents will naturally do more with their granddaughter. The stepmother will naturally do more with her daughter who she has full time and is responsible for. The son’s father is the one responsible for him, and he is after all there to be with his father, not have the stepmother pretend to be his actual mother. Again, ‘treated differently’ is not synonymous with ‘treated badly’.

No shit captain obvious, to all of those points.

I hope you don’t seriously work with vulnerable children, or indeed the vulnerable at all. The last thing people requiring help need is to have words put into their mouth by someone who thinks they have special insight based on information they’ve dreamed up.

Tandora · 07/06/2022 20:38

aSofaNearYou · 07/06/2022 20:16

I’m not talking about the grandparents, that was just one example of how he is left out. I’m talking about the broader situation of how he is treated differently at his 50% home to his half sibling.

There's nothing to back this up though, no actual reason to think DSS is upset about more than missing out on day's out.

Really ? I read it differently .
OP’s list says:

he feels since his sister was born that Lizzy and her family don't care about him as much and are always doing things with his sister and not him

Lizzie’s reply was that her child will always be number 1 and refused to even have a conversation with Olivia about it?

To me that says it’s about much more than one day at grandparents, and Lizzie’s response would be a serious issue for me in itself.

aSofaNearYou · 07/06/2022 20:16

I’m not talking about the grandparents, that was just one example of how he is left out. I’m talking about the broader situation of how he is treated differently at his 50% home to his half sibling.

There's nothing to back this up though, no actual reason to think DSS is upset about more than missing out on day's out.

whumpthereitis · 07/06/2022 19:53

Tandora · 07/06/2022 19:04

I’m not talking about the grandparents, that was just one example of how he is left out. I’m talking about the broader situation of how he is treated differently at his 50% home to his half sibling.

I imagine he is treated differently, as he’s 10 and she’s 3. You mean how he’s abused and neglected, presumably, which OP hasn’t even claimed him to be.

You appear to be building you own narrative here.

StridTheKiller · 07/06/2022 19:19

All Pauls are total wankers, without exception.

Tandora · 07/06/2022 19:04

whumpthereitis · 07/06/2022 17:20

‘Caregivers in his home’ - except they’re not in his home. They’re his stepmother’s parents. They also treat him kindly. On this occasion they wanted a day out with their 3 year old granddaughter at an age appropriate activity. The boy was quite safe with his father and stepmother. In your world this is clearly unreasonable and a cruelty inflicted, but for most people it really isn’t. It’s also not something a 10 year old would generally fail to comprehend.

There is nothing in this particular situation that even hints at abuse. ‘Treated differently’ is not interchangeable with ‘treated abusively’, which is just as well really, otherwise every parent that gives a teenager more leeway than a 7 year old would be fucked.

Also, it’s ‘worked’, so past tense. I mentioned it because your advice was ludicrous in relation to using this event alone as justification for changing their agreement.

I’m not talking about the grandparents, that was just one example of how he is left out. I’m talking about the broader situation of how he is treated differently at his 50% home to his half sibling.

whumpthereitis · 07/06/2022 17:20

Tandora · 07/06/2022 16:49

It’s not about the kid’s feelings of eg “I feel like I want some chocolate cake”, “I feel like wearing the dinosaur shoulder”. this is about whether a child feels cared for / valued/ treated as a person of equal worth by his caregivers in his home.

Emotional neglect in childhood is a form of abuse and has profoundly harmful and permanent psychological effects. There’s no telling a child who doesn’t feel loved / valued that they need to “manage their feelings”, they won’t be “pandered to”, they are being irrational/ unreasonable. That is a profoundly harmful attitude.
(This differential treatment is clearly not a construct of the child’s mind /
projection either; Lizzie has apparently acknowledged herself that the differential treatment is real).

There is no way that I would want my children spending 50% of their time in a blended family setting where they weren’t treated with equal love and priority as the other children in the household. I would do everything in my power to protect my children from that.

you work in a legal office- good for you. I work in research on violence and abuse against children and impacts on emotional well-being and development.

‘Caregivers in his home’ - except they’re not in his home. They’re his stepmother’s parents. They also treat him kindly. On this occasion they wanted a day out with their 3 year old granddaughter at an age appropriate activity. The boy was quite safe with his father and stepmother. In your world this is clearly unreasonable and a cruelty inflicted, but for most people it really isn’t. It’s also not something a 10 year old would generally fail to comprehend.

There is nothing in this particular situation that even hints at abuse. ‘Treated differently’ is not interchangeable with ‘treated abusively’, which is just as well really, otherwise every parent that gives a teenager more leeway than a 7 year old would be fucked.

Also, it’s ‘worked’, so past tense. I mentioned it because your advice was ludicrous in relation to using this event alone as justification for changing their agreement.

Tandora · 07/06/2022 16:49

*dinosaur shoes

Tandora · 07/06/2022 16:49

whumpthereitis · 07/06/2022 14:40

Okay, so based solely on the kids feelings? Because kids aren’t prone to irrational/unreasonable feelings, ever? If a kid feels something, he must therefore be right, and pandered to? Bollocks. What he needs to be taught is to manage his feelings. No one is treating him unkindly because he has a different relationship to his stepmother’s parents in comparison to his half sister. OP even said they include him, just not every time. He’s 10 years old, he’s capable of understanding that.

I worked in a legal office. If anyone came in and presented this alone as justification for altering a custody agreement that has up until this point worked well, the reaction would be a rolling of eyes and a ‘fucking seriously?’ amongst ourselves.

It’s not about the kid’s feelings of eg “I feel like I want some chocolate cake”, “I feel like wearing the dinosaur shoulder”. this is about whether a child feels cared for / valued/ treated as a person of equal worth by his caregivers in his home.

Emotional neglect in childhood is a form of abuse and has profoundly harmful and permanent psychological effects. There’s no telling a child who doesn’t feel loved / valued that they need to “manage their feelings”, they won’t be “pandered to”, they are being irrational/ unreasonable. That is a profoundly harmful attitude.
(This differential treatment is clearly not a construct of the child’s mind /
projection either; Lizzie has apparently acknowledged herself that the differential treatment is real).

There is no way that I would want my children spending 50% of their time in a blended family setting where they weren’t treated with equal love and priority as the other children in the household. I would do everything in my power to protect my children from that.

you work in a legal office- good for you. I work in research on violence and abuse against children and impacts on emotional well-being and development.

SemperIdem · 07/06/2022 15:00

@Tandora

That is not a reason to alter a custody arrangement, let’s be realistic.

thing47 · 07/06/2022 14:59

Even more annoying than the attempt at impartially is the "which of these two women is to blame" and total lack of accountability/responsibility of the father who is involved for creating two children and not stepping up

So true @WeBuiltCisCityOnSexistRoles. I reckon OP is Paul! Looking for excuses for his rubbish parenting of his 2 DCs…

whumpthereitis · 07/06/2022 14:40

Tandora · 07/06/2022 13:17

Revisiting the custody agreement? Based on what? That he doesn’t get to go out with his stepmother’s parents when they’re spending time with his sister?

No , based on the fact that he does not feel equally cared for / valued in the blended family home. That’s a awful situation for a child to grow up in.

Contrary to popular opinion on this thread, Im better the OP is Lizzie.

Okay, so based solely on the kids feelings? Because kids aren’t prone to irrational/unreasonable feelings, ever? If a kid feels something, he must therefore be right, and pandered to? Bollocks. What he needs to be taught is to manage his feelings. No one is treating him unkindly because he has a different relationship to his stepmother’s parents in comparison to his half sister. OP even said they include him, just not every time. He’s 10 years old, he’s capable of understanding that.

I worked in a legal office. If anyone came in and presented this alone as justification for altering a custody agreement that has up until this point worked well, the reaction would be a rolling of eyes and a ‘fucking seriously?’ amongst ourselves.

EatYourVegetables · 07/06/2022 13:54

Why do men so often have it so easy?

funinthesun19 · 07/06/2022 13:46

Instead, he got one on one time with his father and stepmother independently of his sister.

It’s like dss having time with his father isn’t quite so important when Lizzy and her DD are out and about doing something. I’m sure in her next breath, Olivia will be wishing her son could have some time alone with his dad, but only when Lizzy and dd are locked in at home.

WiddlinDiddlin · 07/06/2022 13:44

Mm.. so based on that update and those ages..

Paul needs to up his game to make it clear to his son that the younger childs GP's are doing 'baby' stuff that he won't enjoy and to make sure they do fun stuff together too.

I suspect its more of a 'child B is getting a treat whereas child A is doing boring normal stuff' type issue than the GP's themselves.

I still think it is pretty heartless of the GP's to form a relationship and bond with the older child and then ditch him when the new one comes along, that is still on them... (if that is what occurred!)

But over all it is Pauls job to manage that, manage his sons expectations and ensure equality between his children.

SemperIdem · 07/06/2022 13:25

Olivia is totally unreasonable. Do she and her family include the younger sibling? No.

Tandora · 07/06/2022 13:17

*betting

Tandora · 07/06/2022 13:17

Revisiting the custody agreement? Based on what? That he doesn’t get to go out with his stepmother’s parents when they’re spending time with his sister?

No , based on the fact that he does not feel equally cared for / valued in the blended family home. That’s a awful situation for a child to grow up in.

Contrary to popular opinion on this thread, Im better the OP is Lizzie.

whumpthereitis · 07/06/2022 11:56

I think Lizzie was way more reasonable than she could have been, and probably more reasonable than she felt like being. She wasn’t rude imo, she was assertive, and shut that shit down. Olivia has no business dictating to Lizzie’s family. They have no obligation to the DSS just because their daughter married his father. He’s not their grandchild, yet they’ve welcomed him and treated him with kindness. They haven’t even dropped him, they still take him out! He just doesn’t get to go on every occasion. Instead, he got one on one time with his father and stepmother independently of his sister.

Of course they’re going to have a greater bond with their biological grandchild. DSS may have his feelings and be entitled to them, but that doesn’t mean he’s entitled to have them pandered to. Instead of teaching him that he should get his way, his parents would be better served in (kindly) teaching him to manage his expectations. His relationship with his stepmother’s parents is different to the one they have with his sister, it’s more harmful to pretend this isn’t the case than pay lip service to the idea that the relationship is the same.

Olivia needs to accept this too, and not overstep. All she’ll do is make a pleasant relationship acrimonious. Revisiting the custody agreement? Based on what? That he doesn’t get to go out with his stepmother’s parents when they’re spending time with his sister?

WeBuiltCisCityOnSexistRoles · 07/06/2022 10:32

God I hate these vague, trying to be impartial threads. They are almost as annoying as reverses.

I am betting you are Olivia and aren't replying/explaining fully as you are realising from this thread that your DH is stepping up to be a responsible parent so you feel you have to do it. Even more annoying than the attempt at impartially is the "which of these two women is to blame" and total lack of accountability/responsibility of the father who is involved for creating two children and not stepping up. Why does the DC not feel able to confide in him? If she has confided in him, why hasn't he addressed it?

Just explain the situation properly! You have an issue in your life that you want advice/support on. Explain and MNers will help! A "secret" AIBU thread won't help and annoys people like me You want to know if your perspective is unreasonable or not, surely, so explain your perspective! You also can have no full insight to Lizzy's perspective despite the brief texts, so you can't "present her side" here.

Come on, just say who you are and what's going on and you will get better advice, including more help on how to deal with the father of these children!

funinthesun19 · 07/06/2022 10:17

I also think that clearly Lizzy and her parents are not always going to want to find activities and outings that are suitable for both a ten-year-old and a toddler.

I agree. Their focus is rightly on giving their 3 year old daughter/granddaughter opportunities that are centred around her.

Just a hunch, but I bet Paul isn’t finding activities and outings that are suitable for both a ten year old and a toddler and I bet Olivia isn’t pulling her face at him.

ManateeFair · 07/06/2022 09:44

User2392 · 07/06/2022 06:22

But as I say, without knowing details like how well the older child knows the GP's, how much time he spends with his father and Lizzy, how much time the GP's have, how old everyone else... its hard to say if they are being reasonable or not

Olivia's son is 10 and Lizzy's daughter is 3.

He stays with Lizzy and Paul 50% of the time. The grandparents in question are retired.

Wait, Olivia’s son is 10 and Lizzy’s daughter is only 3? I had assumed they were similar ages.

In that case I think Olivia is being even more unreasonable. It is pretty normal for a three-year-old to require more attention and fuss than a ten-year-old in general. I also think that clearly Lizzy and her parents are not always going to want to find activities and outings that are suitable for both a ten-year-old and a toddler.

I strongly suspect Olivia’s son would have some jealousy issues with his little sister even if they weren’t a blended family. It’s pretty normal.

qpmz · 07/06/2022 09:32

You can prioritise your own child without it being detrimental to your stepchild.