Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother in law being pushy

58 replies

UpInSpace11 · 05/06/2022 23:11

Whilst at my in laws today, my mil started talking about our 3.5 year old ds staying over at their house soon. I explained that I would prefer he didn't just yet as I think he's a bit young and said that I'd worry about him. His sleep isn't always great and he can get quite disturbed with dreams and wants mummy/daddy in the night. I said that he hasn't even slept at my parents yet and they're only a mile up the road. My mil got really pushy and said that they wouldn't babysit unless ds can sleep at theirs. I thought this was a bit ott. They don't babysit that often but equally, they look after him one morning a week whilst we're at work and they take him on outings every so often. So they do see him enough.

I'm happy for ds to stay at grandparent's houses in the future when he's a little bit older or just a bit more settled with night time, etc.

She then looked at my DH and said that she couldn't wait to get rid of him when he was little. But I'm just not like that. Do I have to be the same as her?!

I'm really not being ungrateful for the offer of a sleepover for ds but I feel like I should be allowed to feel OK about it. AIBU?

OP posts:
prettylittlethingss · 06/06/2022 06:31

Don't let her if you don't feel comfortable. I also find it weird she's desperate to have him overnight.

NumberTheory · 06/06/2022 06:23

You could ask him if he wants to stay over without you. A night's disturbed sleep wouldn't be damaging, though it might take a few days to get back into the home routine after.

Like several other posters, I think it would probably be beneficial for your DC if you loosened up a bit. But I don't think that's the issue here. If my MiL, or any member of my family, tried to blackmail me into doing something with my DC that I wasn't comfortable with I would be shutting that down fast. That's an irresponsible thing to do to parents and indicates an entitlement and manipulative approach I would not want to encourage in any way.

I'd just say "We're not going to be blackmailed by you, PiL. You don't have to babysit, and we can find someone else for the weekday morning if you want to pile on the pressure. If you really think we would rush something with DS that we're not yet comfortable with in order to get a few hours of free babysitting you have no idea of how much we love him."

Liorae · 06/06/2022 00:44

In general daytime childcare is called just that - childcare, whether professional or by GOs. Babysitting, to me, has always meant evening/night.
This must be one of those weird Mumsnet definitions that nobody uses in the real world.

saraclara · 06/06/2022 00:36

MissyCooperismyShero · 06/06/2022 00:25

Um mil is the one with all the power here. She baby sits once a week so her ds and Dil can save money and go to work. Why are you advising that the op cuts off her nose to spite her face? To prove she can't be manipulated? Bollocks to that. The way to not be manipulated is to be confident in your decision. Not to flounce and cost yourself a fortune now and for years to come.

Except that OP has clarified to say that babysitting = evenings so that she and her DH can go out.

In general daytime childcare is called just that - childcare, whether professional or by GOs. Babysitting, to me, has always meant evening/night.

But both kinds of looking after the DGCs is much easier in the GP's home, so that they can potter about/get stuff done/sit on their own sofa, and not have to travel. MIL might have expressed it badly, but it's this element that's probably behind her suggesting the DGS sleep over.

MissyCooperismyShero · 06/06/2022 00:25

Peach777 · 05/06/2022 23:59

When she said she wouldn’t babysit I would have said ‘okay’. She’s made her bed, she can lie in it. No need to engage with her drama.

Um mil is the one with all the power here. She baby sits once a week so her ds and Dil can save money and go to work. Why are you advising that the op cuts off her nose to spite her face? To prove she can't be manipulated? Bollocks to that. The way to not be manipulated is to be confident in your decision. Not to flounce and cost yourself a fortune now and for years to come.

HiJenny35 · 06/06/2022 00:22

Just because some people feel the need to have a break from their children why do they assume all do. I don't need a break from my kids, neither does my partner. They are young for a short period of time and once that's over we will have years to ourselves. Your mother in law is entitled to remover her childminding at any point, to be honest if she's using that as a threat I wouldn't want to rely on her anyway and I'd make alternative arrangements. Don't ever be bullied into doing things you don't feel happy with. You know your child, if you feel you want to wait then do. Mine never slept over before 4 and even at 9 have slept out no more than 10 times. They still have a great relationship with grandparents. This need to have other people's children in your house overnight is just weird.

takeasadsongandmakeitbetter · 06/06/2022 00:19

Watch out she doesn't try to get him to ask... my mil got my son to ask and so we let him and when I collected the next day he told me he cried for me but they didn't call me. I was so angry! She told me he needs to get used to it! He is 4 now and occasionally stays over when he wants to but I'm still not overly comfortable as she is so manipulative and I don't trust her to call me if he is upset!!

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 06/06/2022 00:15

Janedoe82 · 05/06/2022 23:29

I would let him stay. This kind of thing can build and build and result in a big fall out. Your anxiety shouldn’t stop your son being able to stay with grandparents and develop a strong bond with them.

A fall out or otherwise is the MiL's choice. No one else's. This is about the best interests of a young child; interests which his mother is taking into account (and has pointed out valid reasons why) and his granny apparently isn't.

This is OP's and her DP's judgement call as parents, no one else's. It's for them to decide when the time is right to consider sleepovers, and MiL's current attitude would do nothing to convince me that this would be best for my child at the present time. Nor do people tend to take kindly to being coerced.

It's interesting just how many stories there are lately, on SM, MSM, and scenarios occurring in everyday life, where someone answers 'no' to a demand made by others and those others hear something entirely different.

No means no. There are a great many people who need to learn to accept this.

UpInSpace11 · 06/06/2022 00:15

worraliberty · 06/06/2022 00:08

What worries me is mil can be a bit hard at times and I'm not sure if she'd comfort him like we would.

I'm not sure I'd be happy with her babysitting every week then.

But I get it, there's something about wanting to know your child is happy away from you at night and right now, it doesn't seem like he's ready.

Perhaps tell her you'll review it in a few months or wait until he's asking to stay there?

That's exactly what I thought. I remember when I stayed at my grandparents house the first time and it's because I asked to stay there. I'm sure ds will ask to stay at some point when he's a little older. Like you say, maybe in a few months we'll review it.

OP posts:
takeasadsongandmakeitbetter · 06/06/2022 00:14

YANBU - your child - your decision
do not let MIL dictate or manipulate you- my MIL is the same and if I give her an inch she takes a mile. She really bossed me about with DS1 and I was not comfortable with a lot of things I ended up agreeing to.

My second baby is 11 weeks and she has been pressuring me to have him at hers without me! He's EBF and I'm not ready and she has been making all kinds of snide comments and talking about me to DH.

I would consider cutting the childcare too if she keeps pushing and have a more casual arrangement. We decided to stop regular childcare with my MIL because she kept using it against me and I hadn't wanted him with her in the first place!!

lisavanderpumpscloset · 06/06/2022 00:12

Not everyone does feel the same. I'm with you, I need to feel ok with it. So go with your gut and do what YOU and your DH feel is best. Nothing else matters

UpInSpace11 · 06/06/2022 00:11

I was fully prepared that people on here would say, well I let my child stay at grandparents at 6 months and that was fine. But surely, not everyone feels the same?
And as the parents, DH and I have to feel OK about it too. Someone else saying a 3.5 'should' stay over - why is it a 'should'?

OP posts:
MintJulia · 06/06/2022 00:11

Your child, your rules. As for her 'bargaining' I'd find external childcare that comes without conditions. You absolutely don't have to be like her. Her views and wants are irrelevant in this instance.

worraliberty · 06/06/2022 00:08

What worries me is mil can be a bit hard at times and I'm not sure if she'd comfort him like we would.

I'm not sure I'd be happy with her babysitting every week then.

But I get it, there's something about wanting to know your child is happy away from you at night and right now, it doesn't seem like he's ready.

Perhaps tell her you'll review it in a few months or wait until he's asking to stay there?

saraclara · 06/06/2022 00:05

To be fair, nightime babysitting is much easier for GPs if the child comes to them. They don't have to travel (and travel back home late at night) and they're in the comfort of their own home. And it seems they don't live that near to you.

So her 'demand' might not be about wanting your child to stay overnight for the sake of it, but just that travelling to you to babysit at night is becoming a bit of a pain. Not so much an ultimatum as 'it doesn't work for us babysitting this way, but would be fine if he comes to us'

UpInSpace11 · 06/06/2022 00:03

This isn't the first time she's been pushy. She once said they were going to get a bike baby seat for ds who was a year at the time. DH and I both said no as we're not keen because of safety (just our personal opinions). I explained our reasons to mil which she obviously didn't agree with and she called me a drip.

She later apologise for that one though.

OP posts:
humptydumptysatonawall · 06/06/2022 00:01

I'm all for leeway with GP's, but if she gets her way this time she'll know exactly what to do when there's another decision she doesn't like. Its okay for her to ask and be disappointed by your answer, however it's not fair that she's trying to force you in to it by other means.

If she doesn't want to provide childcare, then find somewhere else without discussion because it's clearly not what she wants really, it's just out of spite! Do you think she'll still be expecting your DC on her morning next week?

UpInSpace11 · 05/06/2022 23:59

So currently ds spends a couple of hours one morning a week with the inlaws. They collect him at 9.30, give him lunch and drop him at nursery for 12.30. What my mil meant by babysitting was if DH and I go out in the evening which is only very occasionally.

I just feel pressurised and I don't think that's fair. DH feels similarly. We're the parents so surely we have to feel comfortable.

Also ds is starting assessments for adhd so his behaviour can be very challenging and I think this sometimes disturbs his sleep. They are fine looking after him for a couple of hours during the day. That's part of his weekly routine and that's OK but he can go totally off the wall in a different environment. Over half term, we attempted one night away in a hotel. Ds was so fast and going crazy with excitement and DH ended up in his bed to calm him down. What worries me is mil can be a bit hard at times and I'm not sure if she'd comfort him like we would.

OP posts:
Peach777 · 05/06/2022 23:59

When she said she wouldn’t babysit I would have said ‘okay’. She’s made her bed, she can lie in it. No need to engage with her drama.

Eddiesferret · 05/06/2022 23:56

The usual suspects will pile in and say 'you don't have to part with your child ..blah blah blah.. but out in the real world where most of us have fairly normal relationships with extended family we realise that our kids do not 'belong' exclusively to the mother. Perhaps your partner would like his mother to have his child for the night. Perhaps your mother would like that special opportunity to bond over sleeping at granny's..

Sleep overs with GP are completely normal. All mine had had at least one by six months . I assumed (rightly) that as my mil and dm had raised 6 between them they might know what they were doing. And could almost certainly cope with a disturbed night !

It created a lovely bond and gave DH and I a break which is great for all couples once in a while.

worraliberty · 05/06/2022 23:54

YANBU, don't let him stay over until you and his dad think he's ready.

This is confusing though (although irrelevant I know)...

They don't babysit that often but equally, they look after him one morning a week whilst we're at work

Is that not babysitting?

WalkWithDignityAndPride · 05/06/2022 23:50

"If you couldn't wait to get rid of your son, why would I trust you with mine?"

WildCoasts · 05/06/2022 23:46

Her attempt to manipulate you with refusing to babysit would be the part that bothered me here. I'd call her bluff and find other care because that sort of thing really gets my back up.

You are his mother and you and DH get to decide when you are comfortable with him having overnights, if ever. She can have a good relationship with him during the day without needing overnights.

Africa2go · 05/06/2022 23:39

I think YABU - it's a bit hypocritical to accept the regular (presumably good) childcare on weekdays but overnight is different? How long has she been providing childcare? what would happen if he wanted mummy or daddy when he's there for morning childcare? Isn't it the same scenario (she just settles him)?

lisavanderpumpscloset · 05/06/2022 23:37

Absolutely not being U. You're the mother, you need to do what you know is right for your child. If MIL continues to be pushy about it, stop the weekly babysitting and make alternative arrangements

Swipe left for the next trending thread