Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother in law being pushy

58 replies

UpInSpace11 · 05/06/2022 23:11

Whilst at my in laws today, my mil started talking about our 3.5 year old ds staying over at their house soon. I explained that I would prefer he didn't just yet as I think he's a bit young and said that I'd worry about him. His sleep isn't always great and he can get quite disturbed with dreams and wants mummy/daddy in the night. I said that he hasn't even slept at my parents yet and they're only a mile up the road. My mil got really pushy and said that they wouldn't babysit unless ds can sleep at theirs. I thought this was a bit ott. They don't babysit that often but equally, they look after him one morning a week whilst we're at work and they take him on outings every so often. So they do see him enough.

I'm happy for ds to stay at grandparent's houses in the future when he's a little bit older or just a bit more settled with night time, etc.

She then looked at my DH and said that she couldn't wait to get rid of him when he was little. But I'm just not like that. Do I have to be the same as her?!

I'm really not being ungrateful for the offer of a sleepover for ds but I feel like I should be allowed to feel OK about it. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KylieCharlene · 06/06/2022 09:38

I'd not be bullied into allowing my child to sleep there. You're not comfortable with it and you'd spend the night being an anxious mess- therefore it's not happening.
Tbh I'd not be comfortable at all leaving him with them after the crazy suggestion of the bike seat (but probably that's just me).

elfycat · 06/06/2022 09:32

I don't understand the sleepover thing with young children. I'm 50 and I never slept over with a family members. We did have my cousin to stay for a few days in the summer holidays after she reached 10+ years but that's because she was more similar in age to me and my 2 sisters, than her own siblings (5 year gap in their family, in which we were all born) and we would 'play' in a different way.

I have had my parents overnight care for my children when they were toddlers - I was taking an OU degree and there was an optional residential weekend revision course run by the tutors - this happened on 3 courses. But apart from that I see no reason to have a 'night off' from being a parent - certainly not because someone else wants to play happy families with my DDs. Now they are older I'm happy to let them sleepover and go on residential trips etc, so it's not PFB. But in general I like my DC and want them at home with me as part of our family life.

Your MIL should not be putting pressure on you at all. She's pushing your boundaries. When a 3.5yo pushes boundaries it's to learn about the world and how they fit. When an adult does it they're being an abusive twat. That alone would make me set my own boundaries - and all childcare would be off.

Toomuch2019 · 06/06/2022 09:27

OP @UpInSpace11 could you clarify what element of babysitting that your MIL is refusing to do without overnights

I had read it just as evenings rather than the daytime element?

FigTreeInEurope · 06/06/2022 09:16

She sounds toxic, I'd be reluctant to hand my kid over to her at all

LuaDipa · 06/06/2022 09:14

LuaDipa · 06/06/2022 09:08

This is what the dgm has said, not op. The ‘threats’ are coming from her. In my opinion holding babysitting over op is unreasonable and op is only making other arrangements as requested.

Also very interesting that the mil is being ‘naughty’ while the op would be ‘cruel’ to do the same.

The mil is being utterly horrid knowing that they likely rely on her for support. It’s not about withdrawing contact, I’m sure they will still visit and spend time with her but I would not be comfortable depending on anyone who could behave like that to get their own way.

LuaDipa · 06/06/2022 09:08

Holly60 · 06/06/2022 08:51

As much as I don't think OP is unreasonable, I really don't like that so many posters are suggesting OP says she will end the babysitting.

I totally get that her MIL has attempted to manipulate them by saying no more babysitting, but I think we all know she doesn't really mean it. Suggesting OP threatens to stop them having her DS seems a bit hypocritical because it is clearly manipulative too. The implication is - we will stop access to DS unless you start to toe the line.

I always think this is so cruel. MIL is being naughty by trying to manipulate the situation but of course she isn't really going to refuse to babysit - OP doesn't need to make counter-threats. She can just say ' I understand you are keen to have him but I'm not ready yet'. And repeat.

I hate the veiled threat that parents hold all the power over grandparents because ultimately they can just stop access to grandchildren if they want to. We all know that's true - it's not fair to actually threaten it if a grandparent is seen to step out of line.

This is what the dgm has said, not op. The ‘threats’ are coming from her. In my opinion holding babysitting over op is unreasonable and op is only making other arrangements as requested.

mogtheexcellent · 06/06/2022 08:57

Dd is nearly 8 and has never stayed alone at PILs. Their other grandchildren do regulalry. Im married to the son so i guess it makes a difference.

Dd has stayed a few times at my parents. The difference is she has her own room there and is used to sleeping on it from birth. We live 10 mins from in laws but 4 hrs from my parents. Dh and i agree we love having DD home. MIL tried to insist when DD was 3 but i shut her down (she accused me of poisoning DD when she was 10 days old amogst other things so i keep a firm boundary).

Staying over at inlaws is not a right.

Holly60 · 06/06/2022 08:51

LuaDipa · 06/06/2022 08:24

My mil got really pushy and said that they wouldn't babysit unless ds can sleep at theirs.

Awful behaviour. I would just say that’s a shame but we understand. I’ll give nursery a call and put him in for the full day instead of him coming to you.

As much as I don't think OP is unreasonable, I really don't like that so many posters are suggesting OP says she will end the babysitting.

I totally get that her MIL has attempted to manipulate them by saying no more babysitting, but I think we all know she doesn't really mean it. Suggesting OP threatens to stop them having her DS seems a bit hypocritical because it is clearly manipulative too. The implication is - we will stop access to DS unless you start to toe the line.

I always think this is so cruel. MIL is being naughty by trying to manipulate the situation but of course she isn't really going to refuse to babysit - OP doesn't need to make counter-threats. She can just say ' I understand you are keen to have him but I'm not ready yet'. And repeat.

I hate the veiled threat that parents hold all the power over grandparents because ultimately they can just stop access to grandchildren if they want to. We all know that's true - it's not fair to actually threaten it if a grandparent is seen to step out of line.

WildCoasts · 06/06/2022 08:50

UpInSpace11 · 06/06/2022 00:11

I was fully prepared that people on here would say, well I let my child stay at grandparents at 6 months and that was fine. But surely, not everyone feels the same?
And as the parents, DH and I have to feel OK about it too. Someone else saying a 3.5 'should' stay over - why is it a 'should'?

Mine certainly never did at that age. I was still breastfeeding at night then anyway, so not even an option. I have never had a single overnight with my grandparents in my life.

There isn't a wrong or right here. It sounds like both you and DH don't want the overnights so say no until you are comfortable.

Freddiefox · 06/06/2022 08:46

What my mil meant by babysitting was if DH and I go out in the evening which is only very occasionally.

how far are they from you? Are you coming home late? And then they have to travel home. My mum was a bit funny about this and preferred to care for them at her house because of the added time it took her to get home.

dworky · 06/06/2022 08:41

She's proven herself controlling and unsuitable for sole childcare, hasn't she?

LuaDipa · 06/06/2022 08:31

Eddiesferret · 05/06/2022 23:56

The usual suspects will pile in and say 'you don't have to part with your child ..blah blah blah.. but out in the real world where most of us have fairly normal relationships with extended family we realise that our kids do not 'belong' exclusively to the mother. Perhaps your partner would like his mother to have his child for the night. Perhaps your mother would like that special opportunity to bond over sleeping at granny's..

Sleep overs with GP are completely normal. All mine had had at least one by six months . I assumed (rightly) that as my mil and dm had raised 6 between them they might know what they were doing. And could almost certainly cope with a disturbed night !

It created a lovely bond and gave DH and I a break which is great for all couples once in a while.

I trust my dm and mil completely with the kids and they have a wonderful relationship but I didn’t feel the need to palm them off on them overnight at only 6 months old. And funnily enough they weren’t so desperate for an overnight stay that they tried to blackmail me into allowing it. Your normal is exactly that - your normal. It isn’t mine.

LuaDipa · 06/06/2022 08:24

My mil got really pushy and said that they wouldn't babysit unless ds can sleep at theirs.

Awful behaviour. I would just say that’s a shame but we understand. I’ll give nursery a call and put him in for the full day instead of him coming to you.

stuntbubbles · 06/06/2022 08:16

but out in the real world where most of us have fairly normal relationships with extended family we realise that our kids do not 'belong' exclusively to the mother. Perhaps your partner would like his mother to have his child for the night. Perhaps your mother would like that special opportunity to bond over sleeping at granny's.

Sleep overs with GP are completely normal. All mine had had at least one by six months .
This is all so breathtakingly rude, narrow-minded and mean-spirited. You can have “normal” relationships with extended family without sleepovers. It can be just as normal not to sleepover at grandparents as not: what about EBF babies, how are they sleeping over at six months? Kids that simply don’t sleep? Family that don’t live in the same area? Or older grandparents: my 75yo single father certainly doesn’t want to deal with a wakeful baby or my 3.5yo overnight, but they have a normal, loving, bonded relationship.

There’s no “real world normal”: you’ve seemingly decided your way is the de facto correct way and everyone who does it differently is a Mumsnet figment, but the OP is a real, normal person who just isn’t ready for her kid to stay over somewhere. Also very normal.

Thehop · 06/06/2022 08:12

Don’t let her blackmail you.

my kids never slept out until they asked, they were around 7/8 when that happened. Otherwise they’re just being forced surely? Wasn’t okay with me and it’s perfectly okay for it not to be okay with you too!

Ilikecheeseontoast · 06/06/2022 08:09

Not unreasonable at all. My 5 year old has never slept anywhere but with us yet his sister did from being about 3.5. Each child is different and you know yours best. MIL sounds like a nightmare. Stand your ground.

Toomuch2019 · 06/06/2022 07:58

YANBU to not want him to stay over. It's your choice as a parent

However

YABU to expect evening babysitting if they've made it clear that they would rather have him at theirs. As previous posters have said many people prefer to do evenings at their own home to be on their own sofas and avoiding late evening travel.

If you don't want your DS to stay there suggest you pay for a babysitter to cover evenings our for you and DH.

FWIW though it feels a bit precious if you being like this given your child is now 3.5, and a shame for your child who would most likely love the novelty of it

ChimChimeny · 06/06/2022 07:39

wait until he's asking to stay there?

I wouldn't tell her that because she'll start on your DS, "you want to.come and stay at grandma's don't you" and so on

Beautifulmonster87 · 06/06/2022 07:00

Do what is best for you and him and don’t feel guilty!
My mum and MIL have never looked after my 3.5 year old at all. Only my sister has over night about 4 times because he’s close to her and enjoys it. I would trust my mum but my son has never done it and she hasn’t offered! She would stay here and babysit if we went out but only for the evening not over night. As for my MIL, she’s too clumsy and falls over her own feet so NO WAY!!

If you won’t relax, there’s no benefit for you!

ememem84 · 06/06/2022 06:52

I think ds did his first sleepover at dparents when he was 4. Until then I didn’t want him to do it. They have the dc one day a week but for me night times were different. Nothing to do with them not being able to cope. It was all about me not wanting to be away from them overnight.

ds stayed over on a random Friday. DH and I and dd stayed home. I didn’t want to go out or anything. Just in case.

dparents recently had both dc (ds 4 and dd2.5) while DH and I went to a wedding. The dc came with us then dparents picked them up from the venue and had a sleepover.

if you’re not happy with it yet then you’re not happy with it. So leave it. And maybe when he’s older you will be.

PinkSyCo · 06/06/2022 06:45

UpInSpace11 · 05/06/2022 23:59

So currently ds spends a couple of hours one morning a week with the inlaws. They collect him at 9.30, give him lunch and drop him at nursery for 12.30. What my mil meant by babysitting was if DH and I go out in the evening which is only very occasionally.

I just feel pressurised and I don't think that's fair. DH feels similarly. We're the parents so surely we have to feel comfortable.

Also ds is starting assessments for adhd so his behaviour can be very challenging and I think this sometimes disturbs his sleep. They are fine looking after him for a couple of hours during the day. That's part of his weekly routine and that's OK but he can go totally off the wall in a different environment. Over half term, we attempted one night away in a hotel. Ds was so fast and going crazy with excitement and DH ended up in his bed to calm him down. What worries me is mil can be a bit hard at times and I'm not sure if she'd comfort him like we would.

Why are you leaving your child in the care of someone who is hard on him. Put your hand in your pocket and pay for proper childcare if this is the case.

girlmom21 · 06/06/2022 06:40

They don't babysit that often but equally, they look after him one morning a week whilst we're at work

That's a lot of babysitting but I'd be taking her at her word and making alternative arrangements.

Reallyreallyborednow · 06/06/2022 06:39

it’s the refusing to take no for an answer that would annoy me.

fair enough to ask, but to start on the blackmail and calling names because you don’t want to- i don’t get why some GP’s are so obsessed with o/n stays.

mine just weren’t comfortable staying overnight when they were tiny. Mil would constantly tell them about when they came to stay, and the bedroom they’d sleep in, and how much her other grandchildren loved to stay (they had no say in it 😂)

i hated staying with people as a child. My mum swears I loved it but different rules, strange food etc always used to freak me out.

WooNoodle · 06/06/2022 06:36

I'd just say "We're not going to be blackmailed by you, PiL. You don't have to babysit, and we can find someone else for the weekday morning if you want to pile on the pressure. If you really think we would rush something with DS that we're not yet comfortable with in order to get a few hours of free babysitting you have no idea of how much we love him."

I would say something more like "ok I understand, we won't ask you to babysit until we're all ready for him to sleep over, thank you for all the baby sitting you've done so far, he's really enjoyed it".

WooNoodle · 06/06/2022 06:33

Thing is maybe it's easier for them to babysit if he stays over. So I'd just not ask them to babysit.