Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to leave dog in shower for one day?

164 replies

showerdog · 05/06/2022 20:14

Elderly dog has back issues, can't be left unsupervised not in a crate because he will jump on and off furniture and risks hurting himself. He is not destructive and never has been, but his crate is broken. Can I leave him in a large, walk in shower for one day whilst I'm at work? He sleeps in the shower in the summer when it's shut, only difference is the door will be shut. He will obviously have his usual blanket and water. AIBU? I can't think of another safe place in my open plan house. Even the toilet is a risk as he will try and sit on it or jump on it.

OP posts:
Theluggage15 · 05/06/2022 23:17

Do you struggle with reading comprehension Chardonnay like a lot of the posters on this thread? It’s recovering from a serious back injury.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/06/2022 23:13

Age doesn’t automatically bring knowledge.

Experience does.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/06/2022 23:12

The degree of cruelty to dogs is what is shocking.

Sticking a dog in a cage for hours, with no room to move and nothing to do, and no company, instead of training it is what's irresponsible.

Safety reasons my poodle, it's all done for the sake of convenience of the owner.

FreetheKhalo · 05/06/2022 23:09

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/06/2022 20:47

I've had dogs for probably longer than you have been alive.

I've never stuck a dog in a cage.

Patronising.

Age doesn’t automatically bring knowledge.

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/06/2022 23:06

Redbone · 05/06/2022 22:21

Why did you get a dog if you crate him for most of the day? You are being extremely cruel.

Why join a forum if you can't be arsed to read the full thread or at least the OP's posts.

She's made it clear he's crated for a few hours in a morning, some days of the week, because he has an injury that takes a LONG time to heal from.

TrifleFunny · 05/06/2022 23:04

Rosscameasdoody · 05/06/2022 20:45

FFS read the post. It’s a small dog (9lb) and not left in the crate all day - 4 hours max. And it’s a safety issue - for the good of the dog, not the owner.

I agree, the level of comprehension on this site is shocking.

OP, not ideal but if you don't have any other option then it will have to be OK. Leave him a few treats to find and a bit of food smeared somewhere safe to lick off.

tillyandmilly · 05/06/2022 23:03

Agree

youkiddingme · 05/06/2022 23:03

I once fell awkwardly in the shower and somehow twisted the glass as I fell against it. The thing exploded. I found myself surrounded by thousands of pieces of glass. It was the safety kind, so fortunately not sharp shards, but it was a hell of a shock and a nightmare to clear up. So, I've voted no.

tillyandmilly · 05/06/2022 23:02

I have never crated - I used a playpen in one section of my kitchen - for my puppy - I could not bear to put the puppy in a locked cage with hardly any room!

Obviouspretzel · 05/06/2022 22:56

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 05/06/2022 21:37

Stick you with a bowl of water in a crate for 4 hours, see how you like it

Make me walk about with no clothes on all day, see if I like it. Make me eat a dried pigs ear, see if I like it. Make me shit outside on the floor, see if I like it.

I wouldn't like it. Because I'm not a dog.

Confusedashell2 · 05/06/2022 22:47

Crate training is not cruel. It may not suit all dogs if not introduced in the right way, but it's not cruel.
Our dogs sleep in crates at night and if we go out during the day, and actually even when we are at home they will often choose to go and sleep/sit in there for a while.
When done properly, a dog sees a crate, not as a cage/prison, but as their safe space where they can go for some peace from the other pets/kid, etc.

With respect to the OP, I would worry about your dog slipping on the surface especially after spinal surgery, otherwise I think it would've been okay as a one time solution. Your 2nd option sounds much better though. Hope ddog recovery continues well.

FirewomanSam · 05/06/2022 22:37

@AmberLynn1536 fair play to you, not many people on MN apologise when they’ve made an ill-judged comment and I am always impressed when people do. Good on you for recognising that it was unnecessarily harsh and apologising for it.

@Redbone read the posts. OP doesn’t routinely crate the dog, he needs to be crated for his own safety due to back injuries. Like a human being put on bed rest.

@ChardonnaysBeastlyCat I don’t have kids but as far as I’m aware, young kids are often left in cots overnight while their parents sleep in another room. Is that not the case?

FWIW I’m ambivalent about crates for dogs. I sometimes go on a primarily American forum for dog owners though and ‘crate training’ is REALLY pushed on there, to the point that you’re almost made to feel like a bad owner if you don’t do it. And then on the other hand there are countries where crating your dog is actually illegal. I had a crate for mine when he was a very young puppy and we found it helpful for night time and getting him to settle down for naps (much like a child’s cot) but I never really liked the idea of daytime crating while we were out, so we puppy-proofed our living room instead and he just roams freely in there. But if a vet told me he needed to be crated for a while or risk seriously injuring himself then I would probably get the crate out again. Most dog owners really are just trying to do the best for their dogs.

Teenagehorrorbag · 05/06/2022 22:32

My cat broke a hip years ago, and I was told to keep him in a cage for 6 weeks. It's very common for such injuries. I felt awful and we compromised on shutting him in the bathroom when I was at work.

You are not being cruel, you're making the best of a bad situation and doing what you have to. I'm sure the shower is fine.

XelaM · 05/06/2022 22:26

Do people not understand that the dog is recovering from serious surgery which means he MUST be crated?!?

Honestly, I absolutely detest dogs being caged, but if they are recovering from surgery- it's actually necessary. It's like bed-rest for humans. It's miserable, but sometimes necessary to recover.

Redbone · 05/06/2022 22:21

Why did you get a dog if you crate him for most of the day? You are being extremely cruel.

Teder · 05/06/2022 22:21

It’s not cruel for a dog to be in a crate to heal from an illness, injury or surgery. It’s more cruel to allow a dog who doesn’t understand ‘the need to ‘rest to do whatever they want.

I don’t crate mine but I restricted with a playpen post surgery upon vets suggestion. I didn’t want him busting open stitches and getting an infection. A few days of playpen time (as well as obviously a lot of time out of the playpen) meant he healed quickly.

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 05/06/2022 22:20

I don't know what people imagine the dog to feel? He's probably had the crate all his life and sees it like OP is his mum putting him in his cot. He'll have a nice kip. I doubt the dog feels like a prisoner. Why are pp making it sound like guantanamo?

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/06/2022 22:11

Dog trainer/behaviour consultant here..

The risk you have is leaving him in a new location may cause distress, only you can decide if that is likely and whether its avoidable, and whether if distressed he will throw himself around or just stay still in one place.

If the shower/bathroom is the safest place you have, then it is.. as long as he has room to move around, choose warm or cool surface, has access to water and its within his threshold for being alone, I can't see how that's an issue.

For the raving lunatics blarting on about crate training..

Crating can be extremely useful for dogs who need to be pretty much immobilised for rehab, as in the case of spinal injuries.

Where we'd be able to keep a human in bed or in a brace and tell them not to move, we just can't do that with a dog so crate or a small pen depending on the dog, is the answer.

All dogs should be crate trained - by that I mean all dogs should be introduced to a crate, conditioned using positive reinforcement to feel relaxed and comfortable in a crate, and again conditioned via positive reinforcement to feel relaxed about being left short periods in a crate.

If you do not do this, then when your dog needs crate rest to rehab from injury, when they need to go to the vets and stay there during the day or overnight, when they need to travel in a crate (and you may say you won't need most of those but the chances are, your dog WILL experience at least one of those things in their life), they will not be prepared and it will cause them distress.

Like literally anything, crates can of course be misused - people often refer to 'crate training' to mean 'shut the dog in a crate and ignore it crying' - thats not how it should be done or needs to be done.

erinaceus · 05/06/2022 22:01

This does not sound like a great idea. I would brainstorm for alternatives -- work from home? Call in sick? Ask on your local FB group if anyone can lend you a crate for the morning? Emergency dog sitter? Dog-proof one room?

DolphinaPD · 05/06/2022 22:01

MrszClaus · 05/06/2022 20:18

I think Y may BU, shutting them in the shower might be a bit stressful for them (especially if normally they only snooze in there on occasion with the door open). Is the shower big enough for them to stretch and move and walk about? Will they be close to their mess if they have an accident?

Can you not get a replacement crate if they are crate trained?

Why are you applying this they bollocks to a dog?

LauraNicolaides · 05/06/2022 22:01

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 05/06/2022 21:37

Stick you with a bowl of water in a crate for 4 hours, see how you like it

I love this ridiculous logic Grin

I mean, I guess we should all stop walking our dogs too. "Let someone put a collar on your neck, drag you round the neighbourhood until you shit under a bush, and take you home for a tin of Pedigree Chum, see how you like it."

MrsRuggles · 05/06/2022 22:00

showerdog · 05/06/2022 21:02

FWIW, I'm going to leave him in the bathroom and block off the toilet. My friend is now bringing over a play pen I'm going to use to block the toilet off with.

Also, up until now, his crate was non-negotiable. Even leaving him in the kitchen or bathroom wasn't a possibility. He's only recently been cleared to jump up again, ie, putting his paws up against a surface. The last few weeks, anytime he's not been fully supervised, he's been crated. If I wanted to pee, he got crated. He was crated at night, apart from when we'd get up to let him out. Spinal disc injuries are not something you can play around with. It's been absolutely miserable but it's the only way for him to heal properly, bar putting him to sleep, which I don't want to do as he's seven and his breed lives for double that!

You're totally doing the right thing. There's a lot here who don't get the necessity for restricting movement after injury. I had a cat who had a knee tendon replaced, he had to stay in a crate for several weeks, At first I thought it was going to be terrible for him but he was OK. Sometimes we have to do the responsible thing and you're doing it.

Thehawki · 05/06/2022 21:58

@Sarah3587 did you not read that OPs dog only started being in the crate due to a ruptured disc in its spine?

Has no one ever heard of humans being put on bed rest or told only light duties? This is the situation OPs dog is in right now so OP is doing the right thing keeping her dog safe in a crate. The crate she normally uses is broken and will be replaced tomorrow evening. The only safe option OP can think of currently is a large ish shower so the dog won’t be jumping up on anything and hurting it’s back more. The kitchen is off limits due to wires, the hallway presumably bc of stairs.

The dog will be left for four hours. It will sleep and then OP will be back home to give enrichment. Op will then replace the broken crate. The dog will be moved into the kitchen at a later date when it is finished and the dog gets the all clear for it. She’s just looking after her dog! Crikey everyone is so worked up over nothing.

Pasithea · 05/06/2022 21:58

Don’t leave him on a potentially slippy floor. Especially if he is recovering. Oh and crates unless for rehab and recovery are the work of the devil.

BadNomad · 05/06/2022 21:58

I think people are misunderstanding the situation. If I understand right, he is only being crated while he recovers from a back injury? And only when unsupervised? I've had to do this too. Cage rest. Like when they're staying at the vets. It's not cruel. It's necessary. I don't like the idea of the shower, though. Even only for one day. Can you ask a friend or neighbour to look after him instead?

Swipe left for the next trending thread