Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husbands Burial Plot

311 replies

Bellysmackers · 05/06/2022 20:13

My first husband died in 2004. It was a very tragic accident whilst we were living overseas and we were both in our late 20s. His family never really bothered with me much afterwards. Never visited me etc. I always felt like they resented me for being the one who survived. Fast forward 10 years later I came home to find a gift on my doorstep from them that just said 'sorry' on it. A bit too little too late for me. I text pleasantries etc from time to time, but we had little contact. Then suddenly out of the blue recently, one family member got in touch via text being friendly, asking how I was etc. I fell for it (like an idiot), thinking there was genuine care there. BUT- she followed it with asking if I would consider signing over the ownership of my husbands grave to them as it would mean a lot and they feel this is the right thing to do as his immediate family. I have literally never even heard of this and would never consider it anyway ( and told her so) but can anybody think why they would want this? Has anyone heard of this before? And AIBU to say no??

OP posts:
Tiani4 · 06/06/2022 17:12

@Bellysmackers
I agree with @TheFlubQueen and other PPs who are more sensitive to the fact he was your husband, you are his widow and it was a tragic loss for you, one that changed your life forever.

You don't have to make irreversible decisions and I wouldn't.

You can feel for his parents in their loss of their son, the same way they ought feel for you. I suspect they hold some underlying grievance or blame towards you to ask to take over ownership of his grave and burial plot from his widow. It's really not on to suddenly contact you 10 years later and try by stealth to erase you as any part of "his immediate family". You were his most immediate family.

So, don't make a decision, don't engage. Let them contact you direct with details of what they were planning to do. I'd be tempted to contact the cemetery and state that no one is to make changes to your late husbands headstone, grave or burial plot except you as the legal owner of your Kate husbands resting place, and to ask that it is flagged on their files.

Then you have all the time in the world to consider and oversee any detailed genuine requests that you can choose if are appropriate/ what your darling Late husband would have wanted.

There's no hurry for this as you presently have insufficient information to even know what any decision might result in.

Overthewine · 06/06/2022 17:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Overthewine · 06/06/2022 17:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 06/06/2022 16:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

My husband died young, albeit not in his 20s. He was 47. We had no children, but fortunately I still have a good relationship with his parents, and we meet up every few months to catch up, and on his birthday to remember. His ashes are interred in the cemetery, and I own the plot. They’d not dream of asking for it, but likewise their are no circumstances on earth in which I’d relinquish that final link to him - he was my soulmate, and just because he’s died doesn’t mean I’ve stopped loving him. Yes, life has moved on…I haven’t remarried, but it’s conceivable I could, after all I might live another 50 years. But, my ashes will be interred with his, in a plot I chose because I knew he’d have loved it, with a gravestone saying what I know he’d like, and space for my name when the time comes. I’ll outlive his parents, much as the OP will outlive her PIL, so she should retain control…what happens when they die?

justfiveminutes · 06/06/2022 12:40

Maybe there is a compromise op. One where you don't dismiss their request but do tell them that you are not ready to make any big decisions yet.

It is a shame that they didn't support you when you needed them. You do describe them as manipulative and underhand, and maybe they are, but I also know that grief affects people differently and I have felt rage (misplaced, not fair), despair and utter abject hatred for pretty much everyone. I have retreated and didn't have capacity to support anyone else. You will always love and grieve for your first husband but presumably still find happiness in life and have things to look forward to. Maybe they do not. Saying that you are not ready to think about it yet is a halfway ground.

Highwind · 06/06/2022 12:03

The logic by some on here of “he was their person first/longer” absolutely baffles me.

When a child dies before a parent, the parent will always have been in the deceased’s life longer than the will spouse have…. But in the UK, the spouse trumps all other relationships, as it should.

When he made the choice to marry OP, he knowingly and legally superseded any relationship before, including the one he shared with his parents. By getting married he chose OP to be his new immediate family and enshrined that in Law. By getting married he overturned any Will that he may have had drawn up beforehand.
By getting married, he chose OP, the person he must have trusted the most to have his best interests at heart, to be the one to make any decision on behalf of himself and his estate…. should he be unable to.

If he didn’t want OP to act as a spouse with all the legal responsibilities and expectations that it entails then he wouldn’t have married her, she would have been a girlfriend… but never a spouse. His age and the length of the marriage are inconsequential to the legally binding role of a spouse.
Those were his wishes. Why should his wishes not matter now or not be honoured?

OP, I am only in my 30’s, only been married a few years…. But if god-forbid anything happened to my husband even now, it would be a cold day in hell before I let anyone go against my dead husband’s wishes.

Your husband entrusted you to act for his best interests. Do what you will.

mustlovegin · 06/06/2022 11:31

but that marriage is over- you marry until "death do us part"

I would say this is a difficult concept to process.

Anyhow, who knows what happens after death, etc? How do you know the OP would not rather 'be' with her first husband and not the second when in 'heaven' etc. It's not so simple and the OP doesn't sound ready to make any permanent decision ATM

lifeturnsonadime · 06/06/2022 11:20

OP I'm sorry for your loss.

Do people on here really think that if young widows remarry then their love for their first husband is somehow diminished?

I just really don't understand the train of thought.

Regarding the burial plot and its ownership I think you are being entirely reasonable not to hand over ownership. If they have been underhand in the past then it is quite possible that they will erase mention of you on the headstone. The fact that you have remarried is irrelevant to your love for your first husband. You shouldn't have to remain single for eternity after a tragic loss in order to 'earn' the right for the love of your first husband to be acknowledged.

Perhaps write to your SIL to explain your feelings and to say that it is not an objection to your PILs ashes being interned it's just that you are his wife and you feel that you would be being disloyal to your DH to hand the title over.

It is a difficult situation and I think some of the comments on here have been very unkind.

RedHelenB · 06/06/2022 10:55

Darbs76 · 05/06/2022 21:09

I’d assume they want to be buried with their son. As you’re remarried and in another country it’s probably fair enough of them to assume you might do that. I think it’s an entirely reasonable request and I don’t know why you wouldn’t say yes to be honest.

This. Sounds like they've not been nice to you at all since their son's death, but as you've moved on I don't see being "tit for tat" would make anyone feel any better, including yourself. Yes, he married you but other than sex he'll have shard an intimate relationship with them fir far longer than your marriage, I can understand why they see themselves as immediate family.

BogRollBOGOF · 06/06/2022 10:47

The real issue is trust. If his family had maintained a cordial, respectful relationship then it would be much easier for OP to consider their request.

As they don't consider OP as the family of her husband, there is a risk that she could be erased from any mention on the headstone which would be incredibly hurtful.

Visiting a grave is not policed so OP's ownership is not a hinderence to that. Allowing their ashes to be interred if permissible by site rules would be a kind gesture, but I would not transfer ownership of what happens to be a valuable asset, both financially but more importantly an emotional asset to people that couldn't acknowledge the validity of my relationship and grief, and were untrustworthy.

Bellysmackers · 06/06/2022 10:25

TheFlubQueen · 06/06/2022 09:40

@Bellysmackers I'd be really wary about all of this.

I've had two siblings die and both times the graves became a bit of an unhealthy focus for my DPs.

The first sister died in what sounds like circumstances similar to your DH. It was obviously really horrible but my DM in particular created a lot of drama around the grave - one example of many was that there was a storm and some flowers she'd put there blew away but she immediately flew into a rage and said they'd been stolen. She only checked and found them later after she'd upset everyone else. Stuff like this was really hard to live with, I was a teenager and I moved out as soon as I could.

Nobody got asked for their input into the funeral arrangements, and definitely not my sibling's long term partner.

With my second sibling we were all older, she'd been ill for a long time and sibling had kids and a husband. I had to explain to my DM that she couldn't jump in hire an undertaker under the circumstances. Then she agreed with my BIL that DSis would be interred in my other sibling's grave. But then that got used to create conflict as well.

My parents - without having a discussion with my sister's immediate family about the wording or anything else - went ahead and ordered a headstone, which my sister's kids were upset about. Then they complained they had to pay for the headstone, and also started muttering about it being handy for BIL that he could use "their" plot, which still had plenty of space for them. If they'd actually spoken to my sister's kids and husband about the wording and who was paying I'm sure it would have been sorted out, but they wanted to control everything.

If your former in laws have form for behaving inconsiderately then I'd be absolutely loathe to hand over ownership in case they then cause you further hurt. The fact that they've gone about this in quite an underhand and manipulative way would be ringing alarm bells, when they could have - for example - written to you and explained what it was they wanted to do with the grave and ask for a discussion on how it could happen. Losing a child must be awful but losing a husband is terrible too, and they're still not treating you in an honest and respectful way. I think you're right not to hand it over to them.

TheFlubQueen I think your post is closest to how I feel. I'm not a vindictive person, nor would I have any issue with internment. I think what upsets me most, is that even after all these years they still can't just be honest and respectful. They have always been underhand and manipulative and now I understandably have an element of paranoia where they are concerned 😟

OP posts:
Bellysmackers · 06/06/2022 10:16

JenniferBarkley · 06/06/2022 02:00

I'm very sorry for your loss.

Please don't feel you need to hand the plot over. He was your husband. You didn't leave him, you didn't divorce him, he died. I think some on this thread and your in-laws are forgetting that you are his immediate family. Their grief is of course awful, but so is yours - you expected to grow old with your husband and had your future snatched away from you. Your remarriage doesn't change that.

I think you're right to tell them you're open to discussions so that if they want their ashes buried there you can facilitate that. It would be the kind thing to do. But I would worry they would change the head stone if they could.

Some of the posts on this thread are awful and I imagine pretty difficult for OP to read.

Some of the posts are difficult for me to read on here, but I threw it out there and so I have to take the rough with the smooth and I appreciate not everyone will be with my train of thought on the subject

OP posts:
LookItsMeAgain · 06/06/2022 10:15

Burial plots are becoming increasingly expensive and I wouldn't be in the slightest bit surprised if they want to use the plot in future years to have their ashes interred there.

I'd be very blunt and ask them straight out "Why do you want this? Until you tell me, I'm doing nothing about it either way"

I'd also agree with the suggestion that if they say anything to you about their plans for the plot, you will need time to consider it and you will get back to them about it.

See what they say.

mustlovegin · 06/06/2022 10:01

I sense that you are not ready to do this yet OP (and may never be).

Perhaps ask what they intend to do with it (they may not tell the truth, obviously) and tell them that you may consider it in the future but that you will initiate contact (to avoid them pressuring you)

growandhope · 06/06/2022 10:01

@Abraxan Surely they were rude and nasty when they took his personal possessions without letting the OP have any say, and threatening her with the police if she objected?

There is still no rude and nasty there, they wanted his stuff, he was their person for a lot longer than OPs. Maybe they didn't like her, they want their own back and he died at such a young age, I think it is all completely understandable.

HelloBarkness · 06/06/2022 10:00

Derailing slightly but

If a parent is bereaved and has another baby, do people think the new baby is a replacement for the dead child and thus everything is fine now? Of course not, but people can't seem to realise the same applies to a widow.

They do think this. And vocalise it. To your face. When we found out my unborn baby was ill and we'd lose him one of the first things a lot of people said was "at least you can have another" (spoiler alert, the "another" died too).

OP, I think they're probably considering where they will go in death and want to be in with their son.

I can't imagine not having control of my babies remains, I had them cremated because I couldn't bear the thought of them being not at home. And I want them to go in with me/be scattered when I am when I die. I can't explain it, but the idea of not being with them in death makes me feel ill.

I'd be open to seeing what the ILs intentions were, but honest about not wanting to sign anything over.

Ikeptgoing · 06/06/2022 09:57

What do you want to do OP?
He was your husband who you loved very much, you were his NOK and he died tragically. This talk from his birth family as being his 'only immediate family' is rather insulting as he chose you to make a life with and to make his wife.

I'd be inclined to say "No Thank-you, he was my husband and I loved him very much. I have no plans to make any irreversible decisions about his grave nor burial plot at this point."

Then if they have a reason (eg "we want our ashes to be buried with our son" you can consider that and discuss it and agree to what is acceptable to you based on what you believe your late husband's wishes would have been. (Ie "when the time comes I can assure you I would sympathetically view your wish to bury your ashes as parents in same plot as my husband, but with my oversight on what happens to his headstone or what additional plaques may be put there"

Waspie · 06/06/2022 09:53

If their ashes are buried with your first husband would the family not wish to change/update the headstone to reflect the additional occupants? Would you allow this?

Abraxan · 06/06/2022 09:47

growandhope · 06/06/2022 09:36

maybe looking at it from the other side I wouldn't call them rude and nasty like an above poster. They lost their child/sibling and probably don't rate you in all honesty, how long were you with him? It is life it happens but they still see him as theirs. Surely that is understandable too. A mother never lets her child go. Meet them halfway at least. What would he have wanted?

Surely they were rude and nasty when they took his personal possessions without letting the OP have any say, and threatening her with the police if she objected?

That type of behaviour should not be put down to grief. Many bereaved people can behave perfectly well even at the worst of times, especially to their child's spouse.

Ariela · 06/06/2022 09:45

Just leave it to them in your will (assuming you had no children between you who would have an interest).
And tell them that you've done that.
Job done.

TheFlubQueen · 06/06/2022 09:40

@Bellysmackers I'd be really wary about all of this.

I've had two siblings die and both times the graves became a bit of an unhealthy focus for my DPs.

The first sister died in what sounds like circumstances similar to your DH. It was obviously really horrible but my DM in particular created a lot of drama around the grave - one example of many was that there was a storm and some flowers she'd put there blew away but she immediately flew into a rage and said they'd been stolen. She only checked and found them later after she'd upset everyone else. Stuff like this was really hard to live with, I was a teenager and I moved out as soon as I could.

Nobody got asked for their input into the funeral arrangements, and definitely not my sibling's long term partner.

With my second sibling we were all older, she'd been ill for a long time and sibling had kids and a husband. I had to explain to my DM that she couldn't jump in hire an undertaker under the circumstances. Then she agreed with my BIL that DSis would be interred in my other sibling's grave. But then that got used to create conflict as well.

My parents - without having a discussion with my sister's immediate family about the wording or anything else - went ahead and ordered a headstone, which my sister's kids were upset about. Then they complained they had to pay for the headstone, and also started muttering about it being handy for BIL that he could use "their" plot, which still had plenty of space for them. If they'd actually spoken to my sister's kids and husband about the wording and who was paying I'm sure it would have been sorted out, but they wanted to control everything.

If your former in laws have form for behaving inconsiderately then I'd be absolutely loathe to hand over ownership in case they then cause you further hurt. The fact that they've gone about this in quite an underhand and manipulative way would be ringing alarm bells, when they could have - for example - written to you and explained what it was they wanted to do with the grave and ask for a discussion on how it could happen. Losing a child must be awful but losing a husband is terrible too, and they're still not treating you in an honest and respectful way. I think you're right not to hand it over to them.

growandhope · 06/06/2022 09:36

maybe looking at it from the other side I wouldn't call them rude and nasty like an above poster. They lost their child/sibling and probably don't rate you in all honesty, how long were you with him? It is life it happens but they still see him as theirs. Surely that is understandable too. A mother never lets her child go. Meet them halfway at least. What would he have wanted?

SarahProblem · 06/06/2022 09:30

Say no. You owe them nothing.

Abraxan · 06/06/2022 09:29

Maves · 06/06/2022 00:40

Think the right thing is to give them the deeds. You've re married he's not your husband anymore. He is their son.

Don't be ridiculous. He remains her first husband and will remain a special part of her life/memories. Being married a second time doesn't diminish what they once had.

Or is the op only entitled to remember her first husband if she commits herself to a life of sitting in back headscarves mourning him at his graveside forever more?

Whilst his parents will forever remain his parents, equally he will still remain the OP's first husband.

cottagegardenflower · 06/06/2022 09:24

I would inform them you will allow internment and possibly an amendment to the headstone?