Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husbands Burial Plot

311 replies

Bellysmackers · 05/06/2022 20:13

My first husband died in 2004. It was a very tragic accident whilst we were living overseas and we were both in our late 20s. His family never really bothered with me much afterwards. Never visited me etc. I always felt like they resented me for being the one who survived. Fast forward 10 years later I came home to find a gift on my doorstep from them that just said 'sorry' on it. A bit too little too late for me. I text pleasantries etc from time to time, but we had little contact. Then suddenly out of the blue recently, one family member got in touch via text being friendly, asking how I was etc. I fell for it (like an idiot), thinking there was genuine care there. BUT- she followed it with asking if I would consider signing over the ownership of my husbands grave to them as it would mean a lot and they feel this is the right thing to do as his immediate family. I have literally never even heard of this and would never consider it anyway ( and told her so) but can anybody think why they would want this? Has anyone heard of this before? And AIBU to say no??

OP posts:
MadameDragon · 07/06/2022 12:56

It’s very cruel to say the OP ‘moved on’. She didn’t, she got moved on by circumstances outside her control. She lost a planned future.
A friend died young and unexpectedly shortly after marriage. Her family were comforted that although she had missed out on a lot of her life, she had at least had one of life’s big experiences (deciding to commit to someone) before she died. They’ve never implied the marriage didn’t matter because it was only a few months long because they understood that it was the planned years ahead that counted.

Fraaahnces · 07/06/2022 10:00

Being remarried doesn’t erase OP’s past with her husband, no matter how long ago - or how long they were together. I suspect if the grave is signed over to “his immediate family” (🤯), I suspect THEY will erase OP’s history with her DH by changing the headstone, etc. Nope… They can buy their own.

echt · 07/06/2022 08:35

You have moved on - you have another husband and children

How I hate "moving on". Getting married again in no way implies a lack of love for the dead spouse. He is still her husband, she will always be his widow, always his next of kin.

If my child died young and I wasn’t able to have any ownership of where she was buried it would hurt beyond belief

If your child was married, you wouldn't get any say in it, you wouldn't be NoK.

ivykaty44 · 07/06/2022 08:25

They'll be able remove and have a new headstone put in. Probably they'll be able to have ashes interred.

which is disrespectful of the widow

Has there been any mention of offering money to reimburse the widow for the cost of the plot or do they just want it for free?

3luckystars · 07/06/2022 08:22

They are wealthy for a reason. They wouldn’t help you out with the cost of their sons funeral and now want a free grave because one of them is dying.

use your own gut feelings here. What would your husband want. Good luck.

JenniferBarkley · 07/06/2022 08:01

They want his burial plot to be owned by his family.

It is. It's owned by his wife.

Ordinarily a MIL proclaiming she's immediate family and the wife isn't gets short shrift on MN.

ChristmasCurry · 07/06/2022 08:00

After the way they have treated you, I would give them nothing.

Soontobe60 · 07/06/2022 06:42

I’m wondering why they are now asking for the ownership of the plot to be transferred to them? When your late DH died, I’m assuming that you organised his funeral and that it was paid out of his estate. You say you lived abroad at that time - was his funeral back here in the UK? You comment about the house you owned at the time being rented out and being trashed - but that’s not his family’s fault is it?
when my sister died very suddenly, her DP organised the funeral, which we as a family believed was as it should be. 15 years after, our father died and we wished to have his ashes interred with my sister - his eldest daughter. We didn’t realise that we’d need permission off her ex DP and it took some time to arrange this.
OP, without meaning to be hurtful, your late husband’s family are doing what most families would do. They want his burial plot to be owned by his family. They, like me, may not have realised at the time that burial plots actually belong to whomever arranged the burial. Be honest, what are your reasons for the, not wanting to take ownership? If you read back through your own posts, you write a lot about how awful his family were when he died etc which makes it sound like you are being spiteful. If my child died young and I wasn’t able to have any ownership of where she was buried it would hurt beyond belief.
You have moved on - you have another husband and children. His family cannot move on. His parents have lost their child, his siblings have lost their brother, his grandparents their grandchild. You need to do the honourable thing and hand over his burial plot to his family.

StopStartStop · 07/06/2022 06:29

"The average burial plot cost including the burial or interment fees as they are known is currently £1,986 but this varies hugely depending on location. For example, the cost of the burial plot alone can range from £500 to thousands of pounds if the cemetery is in London."
I searched it. I still think this is what they are after.

It seems very heartless to not give the parents the plot. They raised him, and it cannot be fair that connection by marriage can take that from them.
It seems extremely unreasonable of his family to make such a request. On marriage, a man 'leaves his parents' and becomes one with his wife. Thereafter, she is his next of kin.

echt · 07/06/2022 06:06

ivykaty44 · 07/06/2022 05:59

How will having ownership of the plot change anything for the parents?

it doesn’t stop them visiting the grave, laying flowers, sitting at the graveside

so what will change of ownership change for them as parents?

They'll be able remove and have a new headstone put in. Probably they'll be able to have ashes interred.

ivykaty44 · 07/06/2022 05:59

How will having ownership of the plot change anything for the parents?

it doesn’t stop them visiting the grave, laying flowers, sitting at the graveside

so what will change of ownership change for them as parents?

VirginiaWr · 07/06/2022 05:48

It seems very heartless to not give the parents the plot. They raised him, and it cannot be fair that connection by marriage can take that from them. How they treated OP was poor, but that is not a good enough reason to withhold this from them. Parental love is very different from spousal.

Tandora · 07/06/2022 04:15

Mummyoftwoo · 07/06/2022 00:16

That’s excessive!!!

OP, please don’t read into those people who tell you to ignore his family. That’s hurtful, they weren’t nice but not horrible enough not to give them the one piece left of their son. We are all mothers here and I can’t imagine ANYTHING worse then this happening to any of us.

Long story - my parents are originally from Iraq and during the war my 16 year old uncle and his whole class were taken by the army as Saddam Hussein was going through his routine human cleansing after the intifada threatened his regime. My mother and her siblings were all in their 20s so he was the youngest. Very ambitious young man and would go out of his way to take care of my pregnant mother while my dad was out seeking refuge to get my mother out.

When the news broke out that they were taken to a different city to all be shot alive and buried in mass graves my grandmother officially lost her life as my mum would describe it, ‘that’s the day I lost my youngest brother AND my mother’. Grief does unimaginable things, no one should bury their child. My grandmother locked herself in her room for 7 years, every day my mother would hear her whimpering, her loud wails still haunts my mother. It seems the heartbreak they saw their mother in has been more memorable to them as they now understand the pain after becoming parents themselves.

My grandmother eventually left her room after a fortune teller came to see her with the news that she believed my uncle was alive (though no remains nor ID were ever found there is no way he is still alive). She of course hang on to that hope but unfortunately she never was the mother they once knew. She turned into an angry women, very short tempered, extremely independent about everything and started blaming my grandfather for what had happened. Whenever she brings up her lost son she laughs loudly and starts day dreaming about how he will come and surprise her with flowers one day with his own wife and kids.

Please don’t take this as me making excuses for your husbands mother, however please forgive her for her shortcomings. Speak to her and ask her why she wants ownership and communicate to her that you didn’t appreciate the comment on immediate family. Tell her you were and still are extremely upset with the lack of support you got from them. The reason I mentioned my mothers story is because her own mother failed to provide her kids with the support they needed when she went through grief of losing a child. It is unimaginable and no one knows how they will react in a situation like this. We can talk and give our opinion however it means nothing as we could never understand such a pain. Just the thought of it makes me teary.

Though you will always remember and love your first husband remember the sacrifices we all make for our children and how much they mean to us. They are our backbone and that is literally where they grew to become the humans we birthed. This is what I personally would do especially since you had no children with him meaning you will have your own place of rest while your first husband can be joined by his remaining family.

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Mummyoftwoo · 07/06/2022 00:17

Sorry when I said excessive I meant to reply to someone else post.. oopsy

Mummyoftwoo · 07/06/2022 00:16

That’s excessive!!!

OP, please don’t read into those people who tell you to ignore his family. That’s hurtful, they weren’t nice but not horrible enough not to give them the one piece left of their son. We are all mothers here and I can’t imagine ANYTHING worse then this happening to any of us.

Long story - my parents are originally from Iraq and during the war my 16 year old uncle and his whole class were taken by the army as Saddam Hussein was going through his routine human cleansing after the intifada threatened his regime. My mother and her siblings were all in their 20s so he was the youngest. Very ambitious young man and would go out of his way to take care of my pregnant mother while my dad was out seeking refuge to get my mother out.

When the news broke out that they were taken to a different city to all be shot alive and buried in mass graves my grandmother officially lost her life as my mum would describe it, ‘that’s the day I lost my youngest brother AND my mother’. Grief does unimaginable things, no one should bury their child. My grandmother locked herself in her room for 7 years, every day my mother would hear her whimpering, her loud wails still haunts my mother. It seems the heartbreak they saw their mother in has been more memorable to them as they now understand the pain after becoming parents themselves.

My grandmother eventually left her room after a fortune teller came to see her with the news that she believed my uncle was alive (though no remains nor ID were ever found there is no way he is still alive). She of course hang on to that hope but unfortunately she never was the mother they once knew. She turned into an angry women, very short tempered, extremely independent about everything and started blaming my grandfather for what had happened. Whenever she brings up her lost son she laughs loudly and starts day dreaming about how he will come and surprise her with flowers one day with his own wife and kids.

Please don’t take this as me making excuses for your husbands mother, however please forgive her for her shortcomings. Speak to her and ask her why she wants ownership and communicate to her that you didn’t appreciate the comment on immediate family. Tell her you were and still are extremely upset with the lack of support you got from them. The reason I mentioned my mothers story is because her own mother failed to provide her kids with the support they needed when she went through grief of losing a child. It is unimaginable and no one knows how they will react in a situation like this. We can talk and give our opinion however it means nothing as we could never understand such a pain. Just the thought of it makes me teary.

Though you will always remember and love your first husband remember the sacrifices we all make for our children and how much they mean to us. They are our backbone and that is literally where they grew to become the humans we birthed. This is what I personally would do especially since you had no children with him meaning you will have your own place of rest while your first husband can be joined by his remaining family.

WildCoasts · 07/06/2022 00:04

I've been married 30+ years and am in my late 40s. If my husband had died in his 20s, there would always (forever) be this wondering about what might have been in our future, the children we might have had but didn't, how our lives would have unfolded. Just a few years of marriage don't make it less. Remarriage wouldn't change that. I imagine it is bittersweet to remarry, yet you need to move on and keep living.

One of the most hurtful things my ILs said to me after about 7 years of marriage (and three children) is that they were closer family than me and I came second. It's not the sort of thing you forget.

Op's experience of her first marriage and loss is hers, as is how she feels about it going forward. It can't be measured by someone else's judgement on the length of marriage and what that means in their mind.

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/06/2022 23:50

I'd sign it over. You've moved on. It's not possible for them to. He was their child. Spouses come and go, children don't.

JenniferBarkley · 06/06/2022 23:09

I can only assume that @Overthewine has never lost anyone tragically young.

I've been with my husband since we were 18. We're both still alive but the idea that you would have written that relationship off if one of us had died young is repugnant. My best friend died at 23, I can assure you that 13 years on my love for her is unchanged, even though I am of course and even though I have other friends I love dearly.

Love and grief are not finite.

ElegantlyTouched · 06/06/2022 22:03

If you sign it over you will regret it. He was your husband, you still have love for him, you chose each other. He is yours.

ivykaty44 · 06/06/2022 21:59

Overthewine

ive been on mn getting on 18 years now and I’ve seen some nasty comments, but yours sadly surpasses any previous nastiness 😢

Lizzieismagic · 06/06/2022 21:51

Imo ignore the messages. Especially since they didn't contribute to the funeral or give you his belongings. I am inclined to believe as someone posted they intend to change his headstone and omit you.

ivykaty44 · 06/06/2022 21:48

I wonder if they want ashes buried with your husband or change the head stone

thise are two things that could be done only if they owned the plot

neonjumper · 06/06/2022 21:43

I work in grief support in a client facing role and @Overthewine remark is totally devoid of any empathy and incredibly shocking, a view that lacks any understanding about the process of grief . It is an incredibly ill informed , callous remark that can only be designed to cause great harm .

Op I would suggest that you might want to access support from a grief and bereavement agency that can support you in the dilemma this request has brought up for you . A place where you can explore this in a non judgmental place .

TripleSeptic · 06/06/2022 21:16

YANBU I would be tempted to say that when they left you with so few of his personal effects, the funeral and the grave that you paid was the only physical testament that you had to mark your marriage, that it means more than a patch of earth and a piece of paper. It would be generous of you to allow them to be interred there. Their first thought 18 years ago was to loot your home, rather than put their arms around you as his widow. I know what my husband would have me do in this situation. What would your husband have said?

MinnieGirl · 06/06/2022 20:55

He chose you…. He didn’t choose his family.
Their behaviour sounds absolutely appalling.
Do they really think you would hand over your darling husbands grave to them?

I would contact the cemetery and make sure they are aware that only you have authority over the grave.
I would also tell the family very politely that your husband would be heartbroken by their nasty behaviour and not to contact you again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread