Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husbands Burial Plot

311 replies

Bellysmackers · 05/06/2022 20:13

My first husband died in 2004. It was a very tragic accident whilst we were living overseas and we were both in our late 20s. His family never really bothered with me much afterwards. Never visited me etc. I always felt like they resented me for being the one who survived. Fast forward 10 years later I came home to find a gift on my doorstep from them that just said 'sorry' on it. A bit too little too late for me. I text pleasantries etc from time to time, but we had little contact. Then suddenly out of the blue recently, one family member got in touch via text being friendly, asking how I was etc. I fell for it (like an idiot), thinking there was genuine care there. BUT- she followed it with asking if I would consider signing over the ownership of my husbands grave to them as it would mean a lot and they feel this is the right thing to do as his immediate family. I have literally never even heard of this and would never consider it anyway ( and told her so) but can anybody think why they would want this? Has anyone heard of this before? And AIBU to say no??

OP posts:
echt · 08/06/2022 23:02

HappypusSadpus · 08/06/2022 23:00

So if they'd been together for 4 weeks, and got married in Vegas on a pissed-up whim, then he died 48hrs later, you'd think that was irrelevant?

Aye, ok.

If you can't see a short marriage in your 20's is really not all that significant in the grand scheme of things, regardless of the reason why it ended, then you may want to look at improving your critical thinking.

Or are you the type who thinks the boy you fancy at 17 can be your life altering 'one true love'? Give over.

I imagine OPs deceased ex partner would probably be pretty pissed that she's moved on with her life, but then wont give his parents the comfort of having control of his remains and burial plot.

Whatever.

It's none of your business.

HappypusSadpus · 08/06/2022 23:00

echt · 08/06/2022 22:45

You have also yet to answer how long you were actually together or indeed, married. Which I suspect is because it wasn't very long at all

Irrelevant.

Is that the kind of thing you'd say to someone who has miscarried/birthed a stillborn child/ had their child die in infancy? Thought not.

So if they'd been together for 4 weeks, and got married in Vegas on a pissed-up whim, then he died 48hrs later, you'd think that was irrelevant?

Aye, ok.

If you can't see a short marriage in your 20's is really not all that significant in the grand scheme of things, regardless of the reason why it ended, then you may want to look at improving your critical thinking.

Or are you the type who thinks the boy you fancy at 17 can be your life altering 'one true love'? Give over.

I imagine OPs deceased ex partner would probably be pretty pissed that she's moved on with her life, but then wont give his parents the comfort of having control of his remains and burial plot.

thenewduchessoflapland · 08/06/2022 22:59

How rude are her late DH's family?

They might as well have said "your not a blood relative and we've decided to punish you for not dying instead and then for moving on;we think it's a competition for who loved him more".

In order to have their ashes interred there they need to have the permission from the owner of the grave however if it's a single plot there can be an awful lot of red tape surrounding it.We're still trying to get my mum in laws ashes interred with her late parents and her elder sister as was her wishes but even though they all three are already buried there we've been hit with one issue after another;it's now been over 5 years.

CPL593H · 08/06/2022 22:56

Perhaps the late husband would have been less than thrilled by the behaviour of his family towards his grieving widow. Some dreadful, insensitive attitudes on this thread from people who I imagine would feel very differently had they been treated as badly as the OP describes.

HikingforScenery · 08/06/2022 22:51

vivainsomnia · 08/06/2022 13:54

It seems extremely unreasonable of his family to make such a request. On marriage, a man 'leaves his parents' and becomes one with his wife. Thereafter, she is his next of kin
A person never leaves their parents on marriage what a ridiculous thing to say. They will always remain their parents. A person can be a spouse and then stop being one.

I think it is sad you make it all about you OP. It's not a weakness to do what is morally right. Yes, they were not good to you. That doesn't mean you get to punish them because you have the power in your hand.

Do the right thing and let them take over. It won't change anything to your life, it will to them. Its a good example to set for your kids.

Why is handing it over to them “the right thing”?

echt · 08/06/2022 22:45

You have also yet to answer how long you were actually together or indeed, married. Which I suspect is because it wasn't very long at all

Irrelevant.

Is that the kind of thing you'd say to someone who has miscarried/birthed a stillborn child/ had their child die in infancy? Thought not.

HappypusSadpus · 08/06/2022 22:38

Bellysmackers · 07/06/2022 15:33

I have not "moved on". Simply married again.

I was my husbands next of kin at time of death and arranged his funeral as such.

I am not being spiteful, merely fulfilling my duties as his wife.

If his family wish for their ashes to be interred with him, o have never been anything but pleasant, regardless of their behaviour and they know I wouldnt be obstructive in this regard.

What irks me, as always, is their underhand and fake way of addressing this. I guess if they had been decent/honest about their reasoning for wanting ownership of the plot we could have discussed internment. As it stands- their history of complete disregard for me makes me less inclined to assist. I'm only human after all.

By the way you write about it, OP, I'm not surprised they've struggled to come across any other way.

Your reasoning behind keeping ownership of his remains and final resting place is in all honesty very hurtful.

You have also yet to answer how long you were actually together or indeed, married. Which I suspect is because it wasn't very long at all.

Tell them they can have it, if they agree to purchase another plot in return.

HappyGoLuckyLuLu · 08/06/2022 21:25

There is a weird analogy for the situation with a step-parent taking over all death & post-death arrangements over and above biological children from a previous marriage. It's another situation that could be argued from both sides & can absolutely suck. In this instance kids have been in the persons life for longer than the spouse. And I'm speaking as a daughter who had to go through a religious catholic funeral for my atheist dad all organised by my step-mum & they had been talking about divorce just 2 months before he died - killed on his motorbike - yet she is still playing grieving widow 11 yrs on. She scattered his ashes in a foreign country without letting me know ahead or seeing if I would've liked to be there. Does it suck - yes! But you sit back and take it because there is sweet f a you can do about any of it legally. Spouse has all the rights in this country here even if the person has kids.

StopStartStop · 08/06/2022 17:51

A person never leaves their parents on marriage what a ridiculous thing to say.
Genesis 2:24 instructs a man to leave his father and mother and cleave (be joined) to his wife.
@vivainsomnia Take it up with God.

ImAvingOops · 08/06/2022 17:18

They stole from you when your husband died and threatened to lie to the police about it. I'd be reminding them of that conversation when they are contacting you, asking for favours.

My feeling is they'd try to change the headstone or ban you from visiting. There's no advantage to you in signing it over, only potential grief. I don't think you owe them anything. At absolute best I'd say that I would leave it to their family in my will.

Badlifeday · 08/06/2022 17:02

I assume they want to die knowing their ashes can go there. If the OP owns the grave then she can say no to this up to the last minute - indeed she could agree for one parent to be placed there and refuse the other. They would not be allowed to have their names added to the headstone unless the Op requested it.
it is much easier (from their perspective) to know they have ownership of the grave.

vivainsomnia · 08/06/2022 13:54

It seems extremely unreasonable of his family to make such a request. On marriage, a man 'leaves his parents' and becomes one with his wife. Thereafter, she is his next of kin
A person never leaves their parents on marriage what a ridiculous thing to say. They will always remain their parents. A person can be a spouse and then stop being one.

I think it is sad you make it all about you OP. It's not a weakness to do what is morally right. Yes, they were not good to you. That doesn't mean you get to punish them because you have the power in your hand.

Do the right thing and let them take over. It won't change anything to your life, it will to them. Its a good example to set for your kids.

CharlotteUnaNatalieThompson · 08/06/2022 13:40

What a load of unkind bollocks being spouted to the OP on this thread.

So the OP has another husband now so the first no longer matters? Why is that reasonable yet to say that her DH's parents have another child so the loss of another one doesn't matter isn't?

OP in your shoes I would not transfer ownership either. You have been far more reasonable and gracious that many would be given how they've treated you. If they were genuinely sorry and their initial reaction had been due to grief they would have apologised genuinely without wanting something back. They have only apologised because they want something and are still dismissing you. No. That's not ok. And you are and always will be his next of kin

NamelessNancy · 07/06/2022 23:05

A few people have asked about what will happen after you're gone op. Will the plot pass to your second husband and/or children with him? I can see why this would be a valid issue for your first husband's family. Is there any scope for you to retain the plot in your lifetime and leave it to them in your will but in the meantime consider any request for internment of ashes?

blubberyboo · 07/06/2022 22:31

People on here are twats.
of course it is your legal and moral right to retain the plot. The only possible reason they could want it is to erase your name or any reference to him having a wife from the headstone. To do so is to actually disrespect their own son by dismissing his love for his wife.

if they merely wanted ashes to be buried there they could ask.
I would call out in no uncertain terms OP that he was your husband you loved each other and the plot will remain in your ownership

echt · 07/06/2022 22:21

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

No it isn't, and I have the views of a number of widows on this.

AppleKatie · 07/06/2022 22:14

Don’t be obtuse.

Notaneffingcockerspaniel · 07/06/2022 22:07

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Travis1 · 07/06/2022 21:47

Fuck me some of the cunty comments on this are mind blowing.

op I wouldn’t sign it over and I’d cut all
contact with them now. This must be dragging up a lot of old feelings for you 💓

StopStartStop · 07/06/2022 21:22

And by that I meant your first marriage. Just because your life has continued doesn't mean that the first marriage no longer matters.

StopStartStop · 07/06/2022 21:21

I have not "moved on". Simply married again.

Of course. You aren't required to stay single forever. It is cruel of your late husband's family to act as if your marriage is irrelevant.

💐

Tryingtokeepgoing · 07/06/2022 16:45

Bellysmackers · 07/06/2022 15:33

I have not "moved on". Simply married again.

I was my husbands next of kin at time of death and arranged his funeral as such.

I am not being spiteful, merely fulfilling my duties as his wife.

If his family wish for their ashes to be interred with him, o have never been anything but pleasant, regardless of their behaviour and they know I wouldnt be obstructive in this regard.

What irks me, as always, is their underhand and fake way of addressing this. I guess if they had been decent/honest about their reasoning for wanting ownership of the plot we could have discussed internment. As it stands- their history of complete disregard for me makes me less inclined to assist. I'm only human after all.

Posters who think that widows ‘move on’ cannot have experienced the loss of a spouse. Life goes on, of course it does…it has to. But the love for the spouse that died doesn’t just end because they’re gone…at least, not in my case. I’m fully behind your decision to retain control; if nothing else, you’ll out live his parents and so need to retain the control. Fortunately my husband had a good relationship with his parents, as do I still, so this is a non issue for us. But I also know he’d want me to retain ownership/control of his plot, not them. You’re doing nothing wrong x

Rosscameasdoody · 07/06/2022 16:33

VirginiaWr · 07/06/2022 05:48

It seems very heartless to not give the parents the plot. They raised him, and it cannot be fair that connection by marriage can take that from them. How they treated OP was poor, but that is not a good enough reason to withhold this from them. Parental love is very different from spousal.

Then why did they not contribute to the costs at the time if it means so much to them?

Bellysmackers · 07/06/2022 15:33

Soontobe60 · 07/06/2022 06:42

I’m wondering why they are now asking for the ownership of the plot to be transferred to them? When your late DH died, I’m assuming that you organised his funeral and that it was paid out of his estate. You say you lived abroad at that time - was his funeral back here in the UK? You comment about the house you owned at the time being rented out and being trashed - but that’s not his family’s fault is it?
when my sister died very suddenly, her DP organised the funeral, which we as a family believed was as it should be. 15 years after, our father died and we wished to have his ashes interred with my sister - his eldest daughter. We didn’t realise that we’d need permission off her ex DP and it took some time to arrange this.
OP, without meaning to be hurtful, your late husband’s family are doing what most families would do. They want his burial plot to be owned by his family. They, like me, may not have realised at the time that burial plots actually belong to whomever arranged the burial. Be honest, what are your reasons for the, not wanting to take ownership? If you read back through your own posts, you write a lot about how awful his family were when he died etc which makes it sound like you are being spiteful. If my child died young and I wasn’t able to have any ownership of where she was buried it would hurt beyond belief.
You have moved on - you have another husband and children. His family cannot move on. His parents have lost their child, his siblings have lost their brother, his grandparents their grandchild. You need to do the honourable thing and hand over his burial plot to his family.

I have not "moved on". Simply married again.

I was my husbands next of kin at time of death and arranged his funeral as such.

I am not being spiteful, merely fulfilling my duties as his wife.

If his family wish for their ashes to be interred with him, o have never been anything but pleasant, regardless of their behaviour and they know I wouldnt be obstructive in this regard.

What irks me, as always, is their underhand and fake way of addressing this. I guess if they had been decent/honest about their reasoning for wanting ownership of the plot we could have discussed internment. As it stands- their history of complete disregard for me makes me less inclined to assist. I'm only human after all.

OP posts:
JenniferBarkley · 07/06/2022 13:06

MadameDragon · 07/06/2022 12:56

It’s very cruel to say the OP ‘moved on’. She didn’t, she got moved on by circumstances outside her control. She lost a planned future.
A friend died young and unexpectedly shortly after marriage. Her family were comforted that although she had missed out on a lot of her life, she had at least had one of life’s big experiences (deciding to commit to someone) before she died. They’ve never implied the marriage didn’t matter because it was only a few months long because they understood that it was the planned years ahead that counted.

Exactly. An old neighbour of mine from my childhood died recently in her 30s, leaving a relatively new husband and a little baby. They used a wedding photo on her death notice, it would break your heart to look at her happy smile. I'm glad no one downplayed her husband's grief because they hadn't been married long - that's what's so bloody tragic about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread