Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husbands Burial Plot

311 replies

Bellysmackers · 05/06/2022 20:13

My first husband died in 2004. It was a very tragic accident whilst we were living overseas and we were both in our late 20s. His family never really bothered with me much afterwards. Never visited me etc. I always felt like they resented me for being the one who survived. Fast forward 10 years later I came home to find a gift on my doorstep from them that just said 'sorry' on it. A bit too little too late for me. I text pleasantries etc from time to time, but we had little contact. Then suddenly out of the blue recently, one family member got in touch via text being friendly, asking how I was etc. I fell for it (like an idiot), thinking there was genuine care there. BUT- she followed it with asking if I would consider signing over the ownership of my husbands grave to them as it would mean a lot and they feel this is the right thing to do as his immediate family. I have literally never even heard of this and would never consider it anyway ( and told her so) but can anybody think why they would want this? Has anyone heard of this before? And AIBU to say no??

OP posts:
Mally100 · 11/06/2022 08:57

So sorry for your loss op. Extend the offer to his parents if they wish his ashes to be with him, but other than that you owe these people absolutely nothing. No guilt, no understanding, not even a second thought. Had your late dh been alive you most probably would be together so you were always his immediate family. And that's who you will always also be to him. They didn't accept you back then, and still don't now. So you owe them absolutely zero.

sammylady37 · 11/06/2022 08:48

StopStartStop · 10/06/2022 14:04

My point is that it's a very well known concept, to leave your parents and go to your marriage partner.

It's also quite well known in law, what with being each other's next of kin and all that.

So there, there, dear. No-one assumes you (or anyone else) believe in God.

Well, yes, it’s a well known concept. I didn’t raise any issue with the point you made, but instead with the manner in which you made it, referencing a text and a belief system that are utterly meaningless to many. You could have made your point without those irrelevancies.

NellePorter · 11/06/2022 08:16

@SabrinaSabrina2022 have you read all of the OP's posts?!

Bittersweetmammaries · 11/06/2022 07:22

SabrinaSabrina2022 · 10/06/2022 06:42

There are some deluded people in this world. NO pain is worse than a parent losing a child. Lose your child when they are a young adult then judge. No the grief is not equal and it can never be, How dare anyone marry again yet hold onto the grave rights from 17 years ago out of anger and bitterness. I find these comments shameful. You sleep next to another man every night. You did not stay single bereft in grief which many many women did when they lost their men in the war. You moved on and that is a good thing to have happened. They never will he is dead forever. They might not have been as nice to you as you would have liked but holding the ownership of their dead son as payback is far worse than grieving parents not being as nice as they could have been.

I don’t think she’s holding on to the rights out of anger and bitterness. His grave is the only thing she has left of him. Show some compassion.

StopStartStop · 10/06/2022 14:04

sammylady37 · 10/06/2022 08:00

Oh ffs. Not everyone believes in a God or pays any heed to what’s written in the bible.

My point is that it's a very well known concept, to leave your parents and go to your marriage partner.

It's also quite well known in law, what with being each other's next of kin and all that.

So there, there, dear. No-one assumes you (or anyone else) believe in God.

peachgreen · 10/06/2022 08:37

The ignorance shown on this thread is astonishing, although I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised, really. Losing your spouse young is so unimaginable that people can’t really put themselves in that position until they’ve experienced it.

My late husband will always be my husband. I will never move on, or love him any less than I do now. Even if I met someone else, I would still consider myself to be his wife, and I would still love him just as much. That’s the duality of grieving your spouse. Thankfully the law recognises this.

And FWIW, my FIL has lost both his spouse at a young age, and his adult son (who he loved dearly). He says that losing his wife had the bigger impact on his life and was, in many ways, “harder”. That doesn’t make it a universal rule, of course - but grief is not a competition, and blanket statements like “losing a child is the worst possible pain” are neither accurate nor helpful.

sammylady37 · 10/06/2022 08:02

Changerazelea · 09/06/2022 12:37

OP just to say please don't lose faith in humanity based on the dreadful responses you have had on this thread. Some of them beyond cruel.

You have every right to keep hold of your late husband's plot and you should definitely do so based on your experience of his family.

Wishing you some peace with this situation and hope you can manage to draw a line under this with them.

OP I second this post. Some posters here have been awfully cruel and hurtful, whatever their motivation is, it’s not coming from a good place. I hope you can disregard their venom and not take it to heart.

sammylady37 · 10/06/2022 08:00

StopStartStop · 08/06/2022 17:51

A person never leaves their parents on marriage what a ridiculous thing to say.
Genesis 2:24 instructs a man to leave his father and mother and cleave (be joined) to his wife.
@vivainsomnia Take it up with God.

Oh ffs. Not everyone believes in a God or pays any heed to what’s written in the bible.

ivykaty44 · 10/06/2022 07:53

How dare anyone marry again yet hold onto the grave rights from 17 years ago out of anger and bitterness.

how would grave ownership help? And it’s grave ownership they didn’t want to pay for 17 years ago

everyone can visit the grave, lay flowers, sit etc

as for woman in the war not remarrying… there weren’t enough men at the end of either wars and why there were so many spinsters in some generations

Zonder · 10/06/2022 07:49

No it's not. And their pain doesn't take away his wife's pain. And it doesn't explain why they want to own his grave. It won't bring him back or mean they can visit any more often.

echt · 10/06/2022 07:32

NO pain is worse than a parent losing a child

Grief is not a competition.

StopStartStop · 10/06/2022 07:25

@SabrinaSabrina2022
holding the ownership of their dead son

No person is 'owned', alive or dead.

SabrinaSabrina2022 · 10/06/2022 06:42

There are some deluded people in this world. NO pain is worse than a parent losing a child. Lose your child when they are a young adult then judge. No the grief is not equal and it can never be, How dare anyone marry again yet hold onto the grave rights from 17 years ago out of anger and bitterness. I find these comments shameful. You sleep next to another man every night. You did not stay single bereft in grief which many many women did when they lost their men in the war. You moved on and that is a good thing to have happened. They never will he is dead forever. They might not have been as nice to you as you would have liked but holding the ownership of their dead son as payback is far worse than grieving parents not being as nice as they could have been.

Bellysmackers · 09/06/2022 19:31

Changerazelea · 09/06/2022 12:37

OP just to say please don't lose faith in humanity based on the dreadful responses you have had on this thread. Some of them beyond cruel.

You have every right to keep hold of your late husband's plot and you should definitely do so based on your experience of his family.

Wishing you some peace with this situation and hope you can manage to draw a line under this with them.

Thankyou X

OP posts:
Changerazelea · 09/06/2022 12:37

OP just to say please don't lose faith in humanity based on the dreadful responses you have had on this thread. Some of them beyond cruel.

You have every right to keep hold of your late husband's plot and you should definitely do so based on your experience of his family.

Wishing you some peace with this situation and hope you can manage to draw a line under this with them.

startfresh · 09/06/2022 10:44

Please don't hand over the plot. For the single reason, if they own it and change the headstone (likely) they may erase you. Even if they include you, it may be as a footnote and it certainly wouldn't be YOUR chosen headstone.

Definitely be accommodating and, as you're happy to, allow them to have their ashes buried there if they wish, however don't lose your ownership of his headstone. They need to let him continue to RIP.

timeisnotaline · 09/06/2022 10:23

HappypusSadpus · 08/06/2022 23:05

Vows are until death do us part. OP is no longer married to him, and as such is no longer his wife. She's someone else's wife.

After the management of his estate she pretty much became nul and void in terms of anything to do with him, other than ownership of the burial plot. Because upon death they are no longer married 🤷🏼‍♀️

I would love you to tell this to my grandpa in person, that his marriage of 60 years didn’t count anymore because his wife had died. Her grave was precious to him, as the grave of his wife. Not his former wife. The graves of our loved ones are precious because they are dead. The op owns this one and I personally wouldn’t hand it over to the family that didn’t love him enough to contribute to his funeral costs or to not be very unkind to his grieving widow. You reap what you sow.

Meraas · 09/06/2022 07:57

You paid for the funeral, therefore you own the burial plot.

It’s as simple as that.

People who ignore a grieving widow and remove her belongings (as your husband’s belongings became yours), and then taunt her that they will deny all knowledge to the police, don’t deserve consideration.

echt · 09/06/2022 07:30

Badlifeday · 09/06/2022 06:40

To be fair, in my experience people say that kind of thing all the time when you have a miscarriage.

I was asking the poster what they would say in those circumstances.

JenniferBarkley · 09/06/2022 07:19

@HappypusSadpus have you ever been married? I can only assume not. If you have, how long after the wedding was it before you felt that you actually were your spouse's closest family and next of kin?

For me it was the day of the wedding, because that's the whole point of the wedding ceremony, both legally and emotionally (and spiritually for those who are religious).

I've never lost a spouse, but I can assure you my late father is still my dad, and my late best friend is still my best friend.

Badlifeday · 09/06/2022 06:40

echt · 08/06/2022 22:45

You have also yet to answer how long you were actually together or indeed, married. Which I suspect is because it wasn't very long at all

Irrelevant.

Is that the kind of thing you'd say to someone who has miscarried/birthed a stillborn child/ had their child die in infancy? Thought not.

To be fair, in my experience people say that kind of thing all the time when you have a miscarriage.

echt · 08/06/2022 23:13

HappypusSadpus · 08/06/2022 23:06

Oddly enough unless you're the OP it's equally none of yours, either.

Did you think long and hard to come up with that answer? Or just realised there wasn't much of a valid response. Because you're talking bubbles.

I'm not the one prying for information from the OP. You are.

echt · 08/06/2022 23:12

HappypusSadpus · 08/06/2022 23:05

Vows are until death do us part. OP is no longer married to him, and as such is no longer his wife. She's someone else's wife.

After the management of his estate she pretty much became nul and void in terms of anything to do with him, other than ownership of the burial plot. Because upon death they are no longer married 🤷🏼‍♀️

Ahem.

The "til death us do part bit is religion, not law. I am still my late DH's wife and would remain so even if I married again. If any aspect of my late DH's estate came up, even years later, I would be the person in charge of it.

The law distinguishes between the first and any other marriages, that's why all Wills become void on subsequent marriages and have to be re-written. Because the the woman is still the wife of her first husband.

HappypusSadpus · 08/06/2022 23:06

echt · 08/06/2022 23:02

Whatever.

It's none of your business.

Oddly enough unless you're the OP it's equally none of yours, either.

Did you think long and hard to come up with that answer? Or just realised there wasn't much of a valid response. Because you're talking bubbles.

HappypusSadpus · 08/06/2022 23:05

JenniferBarkley · 07/06/2022 08:01

They want his burial plot to be owned by his family.

It is. It's owned by his wife.

Ordinarily a MIL proclaiming she's immediate family and the wife isn't gets short shrift on MN.

Vows are until death do us part. OP is no longer married to him, and as such is no longer his wife. She's someone else's wife.

After the management of his estate she pretty much became nul and void in terms of anything to do with him, other than ownership of the burial plot. Because upon death they are no longer married 🤷🏼‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread