Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husbands Burial Plot

311 replies

Bellysmackers · 05/06/2022 20:13

My first husband died in 2004. It was a very tragic accident whilst we were living overseas and we were both in our late 20s. His family never really bothered with me much afterwards. Never visited me etc. I always felt like they resented me for being the one who survived. Fast forward 10 years later I came home to find a gift on my doorstep from them that just said 'sorry' on it. A bit too little too late for me. I text pleasantries etc from time to time, but we had little contact. Then suddenly out of the blue recently, one family member got in touch via text being friendly, asking how I was etc. I fell for it (like an idiot), thinking there was genuine care there. BUT- she followed it with asking if I would consider signing over the ownership of my husbands grave to them as it would mean a lot and they feel this is the right thing to do as his immediate family. I have literally never even heard of this and would never consider it anyway ( and told her so) but can anybody think why they would want this? Has anyone heard of this before? And AIBU to say no??

OP posts:
Summerfun54321 · 05/06/2022 22:35

What would your DH have wanted? I would give over the plot to his family, it will mean a lot to them.

Strawberriesaregreat · 05/06/2022 22:34

Just had a thought that perhaps if your first husbands headstone has loving wife etc or mentioning word husband that as you have remarried that they are planning to change it? Would they go that far? Would they have the money to do that?

StoneofDestiny · 05/06/2022 22:31

I'd say no - simply because they sound devious and untrustworthy. If they come back later about wanting the parents ashes put in - consider that when it happens. It seems odd and suspect to me.

Strawberriesaregreat · 05/06/2022 22:31

It might be that they are planning to ask the cemetery whether some family members could be buried on top in the same plot? There is a tendency to do this now as some places are running out of spaces. Either way seeing as you have received little in the way of support I would go with a strong refusal.

Sswhinesthebest · 05/06/2022 22:30

saraclara · 05/06/2022 21:51

Do you visit the grave regularly?

I know that you've said that they've behaved horribly, but I do kind of get how the immediate family's loss is different from a spouse's. Especially when the DS was so young. You have someone new filling the gap in your life. They never will.

I'm trying to imagine how I'd feel in their situation. Of course I'd want my DCs' partners to be happy again and find someone else. But it leaves something like a grave in a kind of limbo. I don't know (thanks goodness) but I can imagine that their attchment to it ten years on, might be greater than yours.

But I'd have the conversation. Even if you don't trust them. Say no, it's not something that you're considering, but is there anything that they'd like your permission to do with it.

I agree with this.

Porcupineintherough · 05/06/2022 22:30

Fraaahnces · 05/06/2022 22:21

But they claim that they are his immediate family… implying that she is not. As his wife, she is absolutely his immediate family. I’d say no or demand his immediate effects returned.

Yes but it's complicated isn't it? The OP was his wife, now she is someone else's. She may still have love for him but her life has (quite rightly) moved on. She now loves someone else and has a new family.

LuaDipa · 05/06/2022 22:28

Onwards22 · 05/06/2022 22:17

What an awful post.

She was his wife. That doesn’t change just because she has remarried.

How is it awful?

What legal benefits does owning a grave have vs not owning it?

What legal benefit does it have for his other family?

We lost my ddad many years ago now. My dm never remarried but she has moved on in her own way. She would be devastated if my ddad’s family sprung this on her. Obviously they wouldn’t because they are decent people and recognise the place that my dm had in his life.

I’d like to say my siblings and I do our bit with the grave but we really don’t. It doesn’t mean we miss him any less but we only really visit at Christmas. It’s my dm that cleans the headstone and ensures there are fresh flowers. She also arranges the annual memorial service. She’s a different person now than when she was married and has a completely new life but she has never forgotten my ddad.

pantsville · 05/06/2022 22:25

Sarah3587 · 05/06/2022 21:40

Some People react oddly after they lose their child. He was your first husband and it sounds like you’ve moved on remarried and have a new life now. I would hand over their sons grave. Imagine if this were your child’s grave.

I agree with this

Maytodecember · 05/06/2022 22:23

They could want their ashes buried with him or it is possible to have another body put in the same grave, I think.
As you were his wife you are his legal next of kin. If one of his parents died they could scatter ashes on the grave, I don’t think permission is needed for that, but cannot inter anything without your permission.
A difficult decision as of course they did lose their son, but you lost your husband.

Fraaahnces · 05/06/2022 22:21

But they claim that they are his immediate family… implying that she is not. As his wife, she is absolutely his immediate family. I’d say no or demand his immediate effects returned.

Onwards22 · 05/06/2022 22:17

What an awful post.

She was his wife. That doesn’t change just because she has remarried.

How is it awful?

What legal benefits does owning a grave have vs not owning it?

Tandora · 05/06/2022 22:15

Darbs76 · 05/06/2022 21:09

I’d assume they want to be buried with their son. As you’re remarried and in another country it’s probably fair enough of them to assume you might do that. I think it’s an entirely reasonable request and I don’t know why you wouldn’t say yes to be honest.

I agree with this. OP you are a parent. Please try to imagine if thIs were your DC. You have a new husband and children now, let them be buried with their son, and have ownership of their ashes.
sorry for your loss.
xxx

Sylfia · 05/06/2022 22:12

I'd let them have it - I'd rather think of the grave being tended by any family into the future than left in your sole possession. If you're not planning to be buried there, and he has no children, it's nicer to think of him being with parents. Doesn't mean you love him any less.

Porcupineintherough · 05/06/2022 22:12

Ownership.of a plot is not necessarily "in perpetuity" my grandmother's was for 50 years. Now if we don't rent it again it will be recycled for another occupant, with the headstone removed. Maybe they just want the security of knowing its safe? My mum is giving up her mum's grave as she doesn't want it to go untended once she's too old to visit (it's hundreds of miles away). She doesn't feel that her mum is "there" but would hate anyone to see an untended grave and think no one cared for her. Grief can be quite complex .

Teenagehorrorbag · 05/06/2022 22:06

I didn't know anyone owned graves as such? Unless they are double plots or something....

My siblings and I recently contacted the church where my mother is buried and asked if we could have the headstone moved as it was out of line with others. They didn't ask for any proof of relationship or deeds etc. We arranged for a stonemason to do the work and we could have been anyone. My father is presumably the 'owner' but he had other stuff going on and we didn't involve him; nobody asked for any ID.

I would ask them what exactly it is they want to do that they can't do without your 'permission'? Seems very odd!

LuaDipa · 05/06/2022 22:04

Onwards22 · 05/06/2022 21:50

I personally would just give them ownership.

It’s probably something they want to do before they’re too old and I can’t see how you owning it benefits you in any way.

What an awful post.

She was his wife. That doesn’t change just because she has remarried.

I’m sure his family has also changed. There may have been marriages, grandchildren, even great grandchildren. That doesn’t mean their grief is less valid or they miss him any less. Why is this different for the op?

JudgeJ · 05/06/2022 22:03

Bellysmackers · 05/06/2022 21:05

I would 💯 have no issue whatsoever with interment of his parents ashes with him. Maybe I need to let them know, should this be their wish?

Are they aware that it's a single plot so they can't be buried there? If they want their ashes in there they don't need to own the plot, they will simply need your consent and I'm sure that you should be able to amend the ownership to reflect this, the condition being that they can make no changes.

Fenella123 · 05/06/2022 22:02

You don't trust them, for very sound reasons. So say no.

Feel free to say that you're happy to consider letting their ashes be buried in the plot ... though, TBH, as they behaved poorly, I'd be tempted not even to say this. Let them gather the courage to ask, if they're that keen. If they can't ask politely without pissing you off, you don't need the upset.

Rosscameasdoody · 05/06/2022 21:54

User89174648495 · 05/06/2022 21:49

You sound like you are being controlling over their son’s grave because you don’t like them. Is this punishment for their behaviour?

Have you got children, if so, are they with this man?

What can you think of that they would do that you don’t want them to? Why don’t you be the bigger person and be open and ask them what they are hoping for?

Grief is awful for everyone but the kind thing to do is to be open to compromise.

Her husbands family abandoned her when she most needed their support. They weren’t kind to her at the worst time of her life, so why should she be kind to them now ? And it might be their sons’ grave but he was also her husband. It sounds as though they have no empathy or understanding beyond their own grief and are only in touch because they want something.

ArcheryAnnie · 05/06/2022 21:53

I think that's a bit unfair, @User89174648495 . You could just as easily say they are trying to be controlling over her husband's grave. And it's not "controlling" to want to know more information before handing over ownership of something so emotional and precious, especially to people who have previously treated you unkindly, as these people have been to the OP.

saraclara · 05/06/2022 21:51

Do you visit the grave regularly?

I know that you've said that they've behaved horribly, but I do kind of get how the immediate family's loss is different from a spouse's. Especially when the DS was so young. You have someone new filling the gap in your life. They never will.

I'm trying to imagine how I'd feel in their situation. Of course I'd want my DCs' partners to be happy again and find someone else. But it leaves something like a grave in a kind of limbo. I don't know (thanks goodness) but I can imagine that their attchment to it ten years on, might be greater than yours.

But I'd have the conversation. Even if you don't trust them. Say no, it's not something that you're considering, but is there anything that they'd like your permission to do with it.

CandyLeBonBon · 05/06/2022 21:51

Onwards22 · 05/06/2022 21:50

I personally would just give them ownership.

It’s probably something they want to do before they’re too old and I can’t see how you owning it benefits you in any way.

Wow!

Onwards22 · 05/06/2022 21:50

I personally would just give them ownership.

It’s probably something they want to do before they’re too old and I can’t see how you owning it benefits you in any way.

Rosscameasdoody · 05/06/2022 21:50

As a widow myself I would find it really insulting. They are not your late husbands’ ‘immediate’ family, you are. It doesn’t matter what their reasoning for leaving you to your own devices after you were widowed - it was wrong and they know it. You would have been vulnerable and in need of support through the most difficult experience of your life, and they abandoned you. And the only reason they are in touch now is because they want this of you. It obviously means a great deal more to you than to them, so I would say no and have nothing more to do with them.

User89174648495 · 05/06/2022 21:49

You sound like you are being controlling over their son’s grave because you don’t like them. Is this punishment for their behaviour?

Have you got children, if so, are they with this man?

What can you think of that they would do that you don’t want them to? Why don’t you be the bigger person and be open and ask them what they are hoping for?

Grief is awful for everyone but the kind thing to do is to be open to compromise.