Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that every child and young person…

237 replies

KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs · 05/06/2022 19:46

That got through the pandemic, followed the rules, stayed indoors for long periods of time, endured isolation, online learning, ping pongs in and out of school, slow vaccination roll-out…

Should get a medal.

Our kids are amazing and gone through so much but not one bit of recognition.

OP posts:
ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 06/06/2022 11:43

😂😂😂 wtf

Confusion101 · 06/06/2022 11:42

I think that people are saying there'll be permanent mental health effects for children as a result of the pandemic is extremely worrying. Poor family backgrounds and bad family situations aside (as of course those children have had more to deal with), children should be taught coping mechanisms and resilience, and I actually think most did learn a lot of resilience over the past few years. It was a shit 2 years but if it is leaving the average child with an "average family" with permanent mental health issues then how will they ever deal with anything outside of the norm. Change (for better or worse) happens all the time, it cannot be escaped! We have to get on with it!

BanditBluey · 06/06/2022 11:02

Why only children and young people? What about the women who were pregnant during the first lockdown, before vaccines were available, who had to go to all medical appointments alone, weren't allowed a partner to stay after birth. No visitors once baby born apart from on the doorstep. Do you know how lonely that was? What about those who were elderly or lived alone and weren't allowed to mix households (before bubbles) so were alone for months. Everyone had their own difficult times and "deserve a medal" for different reasons

Cornettoninja · 06/06/2022 10:33

cottagegardenflower · 06/06/2022 09:48

Don't be silly. Everyone (bar the PM and his staff) deserve a medal for getting through the pandemic. Nurses and doctors who put their lives on the line, care staff who stayed away from their families for weeks, mothers trying to do the work of teachers and their own jobs from home, teachers trying to control a zoom classroom, shopworkers carrying on supplying us with food despite the risks to their own health and, not least, families who lost loved ones.

Basically anyone who had the option to walk away and didn’t. I don’t think children fall into that category - this happened to them.

I find it vaguely insulting to suggest they should receive accolades and thanks for a situation they had no/few personal choices in.

Cornettoninja · 06/06/2022 10:30

@druto

You can disagree though

thanks Grin

I do to some extent, but because this thread specifically is about the effects of the pandemic on children which (imho) blurs lines and conflates issues. There are unique issues whose causes are attributable to the pandemic and perhaps in some cases are based on pre-existing foundations.

All are undeniably issues, but I believe it does a disservice to each subset of problems to imply their roots are in an event that took place after they were previously recognised. Issues specifically arising from the pandemic have an implication they can be resolved as the pandemic subsides and allows previous standards to resume which I don’t agree with. These are problems that will continue to exist and are vulnerable to other exacerbations, ones we don’t know will happen yet.

lifeturnsonadime · 06/06/2022 09:50

Agree with all who say that YABVU for a number of reasons.

Money would be better spent on ensuring that ALL children are educated in this country pandemic or not. Did you know that there is a significant number of children that there is no suitable school for in this country? Many of them autistic, These children, I have two of them, have been on a quasi lockdown for years with no peer group because of education and sen funding cuts and lack of appropriate schools.

I'm not trying to say that lockdown wasn't hard for children but I really don't think that some people realise how awful the situation is for some children with SEN in this country and a period of online learning and enforced home education is a drop in the ocean compared with what many children in this country have to cope with.

Mental health and other support services also need to improve.

cottagegardenflower · 06/06/2022 09:48

Don't be silly. Everyone (bar the PM and his staff) deserve a medal for getting through the pandemic. Nurses and doctors who put their lives on the line, care staff who stayed away from their families for weeks, mothers trying to do the work of teachers and their own jobs from home, teachers trying to control a zoom classroom, shopworkers carrying on supplying us with food despite the risks to their own health and, not least, families who lost loved ones.

corblimeym8 · 06/06/2022 09:39

Mommabear20 · 06/06/2022 09:22

What about the people (like myself) who had to go to hospital appointments and inductions of labour, alone because of restrictions?
What about the people who couldn't visit loved ones in hospital or nursing homes?
What about the people living alone, who had no human contact for months on end?
What about the people that lost their jobs and businesses?
The pandemic has been hard on everyone!

So what's your problem with the op then? You said it's been hard on everyone, does op have to list every single person in the world - also you didn't mention Ukraine.

druto · 06/06/2022 09:35

course it has been awful for some children, just as it has been awful for some adults as well, and they were the ones who had to worry about homeschooling, paying the bills etc.

I don't understand the narrative that if a parent who struggled through the pandemic eg worried about finances, loses a job or is stressed juggling homeschooling or covid health implications or bereavement etc somehow their dc are insulated from this?

druto · 06/06/2022 09:28

@Cornettoninja I think you have misunderstood my posts. I'm fully aware that mental health issues, poverty & eating disorders etc existed before the pandemic however my point was the pandemic has made it worse. I don't think there are any issues that are solely being blamed on covid with regards to children?

Of course energy was an issue before the war just like our economic woes are tied to 08, Brexit & not just the war/covid.

My other point was challenging the point that children won't be paying for it forever. Yes, pensions & the NHS have been kicked down the road. The pandemic has exacerbated it though hence the global drop in birth rates & in the UK a mass exodus of over 50s workers, not to mention the huge boom in house prices. You can disagree though.

Mommabear20 · 06/06/2022 09:22

What about the people (like myself) who had to go to hospital appointments and inductions of labour, alone because of restrictions?
What about the people who couldn't visit loved ones in hospital or nursing homes?
What about the people living alone, who had no human contact for months on end?
What about the people that lost their jobs and businesses?
The pandemic has been hard on everyone!

NohoHank · 06/06/2022 09:08

What a bizarre thread...

ldontWanna · 06/06/2022 09:01

I agree with PP's that the medal would be pointless. Similar to clapping for the NHS,but at least that was free.

What we need is proper funding and support put into services (education,mental health, SS, sure start centres, youth centres etc). It happened,it sucked and some children where severely damaged in many ways. We need to help and support them , not pretend it didn't happen or hand them a medal. That's equally useless. Not expect the to perform and behave as Covid isn't a thing anymore (and the effects of it are gone or insignificant)because the government decided it isn't.

Moithered · 06/06/2022 09:00

KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs · 06/06/2022 08:58

@Moithered no

Ok thanks, it was rather unclear

KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs · 06/06/2022 08:58

@Moithered no

OP posts:
Momicrone · 06/06/2022 08:57

Not all kids 'had an absolute blast', some kids had a terrible time. Mental health issues have sky rocketed. It's a bit glib and lacking in compassion to say 'my kids loved it' so everyone else should feel the same

Moithered · 06/06/2022 08:56

KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs · 06/06/2022 07:49

So I did have a large glass last night but I’m still RAGING that of all fuck wit places this platform is still full of sneers and dumbwit whataboutery. What do you mean what did our children do?

We could forever compare our kids
lives in comparison to others - that’s not what recognition is about. And why is it bad to recognise that for our children and young people these last 2 years have been insanely challenging? That what we asked them to do was really really hard.

And for those people whose kids had long
lie ins with butterflies and walks in the woods - fantastic I’m pleased for you and I’m pleased for your kids and I still say thankyou to them. For many kids it wasn't like that and no one has bothered to say well done or thankyou or even acknowledge that - and that makes me really sad.

And judging by this board they’re not going to get any thanks either.

I feel for the younger generation, I think they have been amazing. Medal, proper services, catch up support - throw it at them because they deserve it.

Are you 12 by any chance?

Cornettoninja · 06/06/2022 08:41

@KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs I don’t follow your arguments at all.

Actually thanking children implies that they somehow collectively decided to follow restrictions with a comprehensive understanding of what that meant in reality. It’s also implies that children have a responsibility to do the same again off their own backs should the conditions require it.

ensuring that services and support are available to those who need it is something we owe them as the ones tasked as their protectors in society (and have been failing at since before the pandemic by all accounts) but no thanks should be involved from any party. It’s not something that should be begged for or require x-factor style justification.

you’re conflating two issues and coming up with a skewed scenario whereby offering all children thanks and acknowledgement somehow makes a difference. It doesn’t - actions speak louder than words imo.

Anapurna222478063 · 06/06/2022 08:31

Imagine if it was a guaranteed right that every child had access to proper music, open spaces, swimming and public art. Imagine if every child had access to high quality nursery, school and wrap-around care.

Anapurna222478063 · 06/06/2022 08:29

No. I think a medal is a daft idea.

I do think we need to invest massively in mental health services, totally overhaul education funding and the support and facilities kids have access to, and generally recognise that prevention is better than cure. Probably a bit more expensive than a medal.

Cornettoninja · 06/06/2022 08:29

@druto

@Cornettoninja so what issues are being wrongly attributed to the pandemic?

I was specifically addressing your post below, but in general it happens quite a lot that existing issues are highlighted or exacerbated during various crises and then somehow become marketed as a result of a crisis that nobody saw coming.

Have a look and see how far back urgent warnings of an energy crisis existed (insulate Britain had a good point and even they got serious about it at a fairly late stage retrospectively) which is now apparently a result of the war in Ukraine. Yes it didn’t help, but this was already an issue.

Everyone had a tough time and no one is denying that some children struggled but they won't pay for it forever.

Really? what age will state pension be in 10 yrs time? free at the point of care NHS in 10 years? higher taxes because we are facing a huge population demographic shift?

State pensions - these have been allowed to drift along for decades with no change in entitlement age despite changes in life expectancy and population age distribution and are unpopular when they do happen. Although I concede that it’s been managed terribly with shifting goalposts affecting those with the least time and resources to cushion themselves. These have been a time bomb for a long, long time. Probably more so for younger working age adults right now since the burden of age distribution should lessen somewhat for their children.

NHS - again, I personally can recall a couple of decades of conversation about privatisation (which has already happened in various guises) and conversations about funding.

Population demographics and taxes - tie into both above issues and again have been a well entrenched subject of concern and discussion. Immigration is part of the solution but as a country there is a push back against it. Taxes aren’t inherently a bad thing, mismanaged ones are.

Listing those issues alongside ones created by the pandemic without acknowledging their history pushes them into the category of ‘things we had no control over and couldn’t have possibly foreseen/averted’ and that’s just not true.

Are they difficulties facing generations? Yes. Are they rooted in the pandemic? No.

onlythreenow · 06/06/2022 08:24

Thinking back to myself as a child/teen I would have thought I was in Heaven at being locked down and not having to attend school.

YABU and ridiculous OP. Of course it has been awful for some children, just as it has been awful for some adults as well, and they were the ones who had to worry about homeschooling, paying the bills etc.

Glitternails1 · 06/06/2022 08:08

@KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs They need therapy, not medals. Especially teens. The lockdowns have stunted their emotional growth. So many have social anxiety, general anxiety, depression etc. So many act really young for their age because they haven’t socialised with their peers.

Badqueen · 06/06/2022 08:05

Who is that you want to say thank you? And exactly who to? What form would this take? An awards ceremony? A piece in the media? Money given to everyone between the ages of 2 and 20? Why would the country spend millions on giving out medals? Because it would cost millions. Would every child get one, even those who didn't follow the rules at all? There were loads of those where i live. Medals don't just materialise out of thin air. That money could be spent on education.

You seem to be really angry about it and i am not really sure why. What would this recognition look like, and what difference would it make to your life?

The idea that they should be recognised because they made sacrifices for the older generation is absurd. That's part of living in a civilized society. Young people are no more important than older people. Older people don't need to be "grateful" to young people for following the rules. Everyone was supposed to, regardless of age.

Perhaps elderly people, like my grandmother, who were confined to their homes, who aren't tech savvy and who became incredibly isolated as a result should get a medal. We missed every one of the last special occasions in the last year of her life because of lockdown. At least teenagers could still socialise online.

Madamecastafiore · 06/06/2022 08:02

No, my kids had an absolute blast they seriously don't deserve a medal.