Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that every child and young person…

237 replies

KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs · 05/06/2022 19:46

That got through the pandemic, followed the rules, stayed indoors for long periods of time, endured isolation, online learning, ping pongs in and out of school, slow vaccination roll-out…

Should get a medal.

Our kids are amazing and gone through so much but not one bit of recognition.

OP posts:
tigger1001 · 08/06/2022 09:52

ldontWanna · 06/06/2022 00:57

I'm not buying into the whole medal thing , but I find the attitudes of some posters baffling at best, and awful at worst. Almost sneery at children and a tone of "what do they have to be upset/depressed " about?

Yes a lot of children were ok.
A lot weren't though... some were stuck in abject poverty , some were stuck in abusive or chaotic households with no respite, some died, some were beaten, some were neglected ,some were taken into care , some that were already in care barely saw their parents/families for months on end, some kids developed mental health issues, or their previous issues escalated ,panic attacks,anxiety etc. , some didn't see one or both parents for months because it was too risky and many many more.

You don't have to give them a medal, but pretending it was all sunshine and rainbows and sleeping in and all hunky dory is fucking insulting.

Agree with this!

A medal isn't needed but funding into education and mental health support really is.

Home educating for many was abysmal. Not just because very little in the way of work and support was offered, but some parents were still working out the home, with zero childcare available. No time to help kids as they were working. Having to rely on the kids to grow up faster and take responsibility for younger ones. Any other years and I would have been worried that social services would have been at my door for leaving my 14 year old in charge of my 10 year old. But that's what we had to do to keep a roof over our heads.

Being told they were being "granny killers" if they met up with friends, even when it was allowed was of course going to play havoc with their mental well-being. Even more do when it's the governments own message.

It's actually really disheartening reading some of the comments on here, a parenting website, about children.

I think in the years to come we will see the true cost our children will pay for the pandemic.

Cornettoninja · 08/06/2022 09:24

It depends how in depth you’re looking at it @12Thorns .

I accept that some people will have enjoyed an enforced break from obligations and society, I know I would have but I worked outside the house through all the lockdowns. Even so I did see a personal benefit from being forced to stop other obligations. But that doesn’t take into account the disruption to education or economic effects which may not be the first thing a teenager or someone relatively shielded would notice but the effects are there to varying degrees.

What I got from lockdown is that modern society and working cultures are, in many cases, actively harmful and in desperate need of an adjustment of attitude. I see the effects in my own dd and that neither all or nothing is good for her but a balance.

I still don’t think children need putting on a pedestal for living through lockdowns. The ones who might be cheered by it don’t need it and the ones who really suffered are unlikely to be soothed by it - in fact I’d say it’s so far off the mark of what a traumatised child needs it’s offensive. I can’t imagine another scenario you’d congratulate someone for living through a trauma. What they need is stability and those who need it extra support. Not a medal or pat on the back.

TheKeatingFive · 08/06/2022 09:17

Well this thread is fucking depressing

Momicrone · 08/06/2022 08:17

12thorns, we have pages of people saying how much they enjoyed lockdown, glibly ignoring all the ones who suffered

12Thorns · 08/06/2022 07:40

BlueTitSmilingAtMe · 07/06/2022 23:41

I'm actually quite perturbed by the blunt refusal to recognise other people's difficulties that I see across the eight long pages of this thread and also by the blunt refusal to recognise how the stressors of the last couple years have impacted young people in quite particular ways.

I mean, it's not been good for anyone. But is this how we're going to be, when people express how it's been for them? Just say "fuck off, you didn't have it as bad as xyz"?

The thing is, it’s not true to say it’s not been good for anyone.

it’s been great for many people ,including many children. Just yesterday I heard a group of 15 year olds saying how much they wish we could have another lockdown

I certainly hugely preferred lock down living to normal life, although obviously I am sad about the reason it had to happen.

among friends and students, many suffered because of lockdown, many enjoyed it, and many were not particularly bothered either way

FMSucks · 08/06/2022 00:15

This thread is so sad. I cannot understand why grown ass adults on this thread are comparing themselves to children. You’re an adult ffs, you have no right to compare yourself to children, none. You have no idea of the long term effects this will have on them.

I agree with you OP. Whilst my children had me at home with them, were delighted with schooling online,, my youngest really struggled going back to school. He still hasn’t really recovered tbh. And I know my children had it easy compared to so many out there.

BlueTitSmilingAtMe · 07/06/2022 23:41

I'm actually quite perturbed by the blunt refusal to recognise other people's difficulties that I see across the eight long pages of this thread and also by the blunt refusal to recognise how the stressors of the last couple years have impacted young people in quite particular ways.

I mean, it's not been good for anyone. But is this how we're going to be, when people express how it's been for them? Just say "fuck off, you didn't have it as bad as xyz"?

Titsflyingsouth · 06/06/2022 17:24

I don't know about a medal. But I think policy makers definitely need to think more about the impact of the pandemic on kids and address the issues it's created.

Dept of Education seems to have gone back very quickly to a policy of 'let's assess the crap out of every year group', conveniently forgetting the huge gaps in learning.

Funding for CAMHS is ridiculously low.

For those kids who had no gardens and were cooped up in flats etc for 23 hours a day for several months - there must be physical health implications.

Kids social development has almost certainly taken a battering - my son is an only child and spent months without the company of another child. That's not natural and I do wonder about the long term impact on his social development.

There is longer- term fallout from this I do think the Government has basically forgetting about all of it now things have reopened.

JudgeE · 06/06/2022 17:21

I agree with you @ldontWanna. Is it really so hard for some people to hide a thread they think is silly or doesn't apply to them? If your teen enjoyed being in front of the TV all day, good for you.

If you spent your days having fun great. Other children had a really hard time and were locked in with their abusers, hidden from everyone. Others struggled mentally with it. Other's educations suffered.

If you can't see beyond your own experiences, don't bother commenting to those leaving rude comments to such an uncontroversial thread.

MarshaBradyo · 06/06/2022 17:10

You’re right IdontWanna

op a nice sentiment, but I’d choose that we did things differently instead

ldontWanna · 06/06/2022 17:07

Between April and September there were 285 reports by councils of child deaths and incidents of serious harm, which includes child sexual exploitation. This was a rise of more than a quarter on the same period the year before.

Damn snowflakes.Confused

And that's without considering the effect on children in care, children with significant SENDs and illnesses,children with severe mental health issues, children living in poverty, or being carers, or living in chaotic/neglectful/abusive households that were "ok".

ldontWanna · 06/06/2022 16:52

standoctor · 06/06/2022 16:01

"Our kids are amazing and gone through so much but not one bit of recognition."

What recognition do you want?

This is a joke and so typical of the weak snowflake mentality and self aggrandisement and self entitlement that so many people have these days.

When my grandfathers were 18 they were risking their lives in WW2.

One of them was a Lancaster bomber pilot. On his 19th birthday he was being chased by German fighters over Berlin.

My other grandfather at 18 was on destroyers. He was on a ship that was torpedoed and sunk he survived after being picked up by a nearby ship.

Your mollycoddled little darlings had to stay indoors and watch TV for a few while. Yea give them the Victoria Cross, a knighthood and the freedom of the city.

You think that deserved recognition. That is exactly the give every one a medal and a pat on the back for everything they do that has made a generation of people self absorbed narcissistic and unable to cope with any real problems that everyone has to face and go into meltdown.

You do realise you're talking about children here right? Children ffs. Some that were murdered in the pandemic. Mollycoddled little darlings indeed.

Whatever your issue is with OP or her (crap) idea or the concept of rewarding kids for what they have been through, the language you use around children, that didn't all had it sunshine and rainbows is disgusting.

SofiaSoFar · 06/06/2022 16:05

I honestly thought you'd sober up and then come back tail-between-legs, OP, not "RAGING" that most people disagree with your angle.

Quite bizarre.

standoctor · 06/06/2022 16:01

"Our kids are amazing and gone through so much but not one bit of recognition."

What recognition do you want?

This is a joke and so typical of the weak snowflake mentality and self aggrandisement and self entitlement that so many people have these days.

When my grandfathers were 18 they were risking their lives in WW2.

One of them was a Lancaster bomber pilot. On his 19th birthday he was being chased by German fighters over Berlin.

My other grandfather at 18 was on destroyers. He was on a ship that was torpedoed and sunk he survived after being picked up by a nearby ship.

Your mollycoddled little darlings had to stay indoors and watch TV for a few while. Yea give them the Victoria Cross, a knighthood and the freedom of the city.

You think that deserved recognition. That is exactly the give every one a medal and a pat on the back for everything they do that has made a generation of people self absorbed narcissistic and unable to cope with any real problems that everyone has to face and go into meltdown.

XenoBitch · 06/06/2022 15:38

Just clap for them. It worked for the NHS.

rainbowmilk · 06/06/2022 15:16

Agree @Cornettoninja. Appreciate that home schooling must’ve been awful (though my employer was very good about giving parents paid time off for it every week) but doing that was for the benefit of the child and part and parcel of being a parent. Why it deserved a cash sum and recognition from the state as a contribution to the nation was beyond me.

Cornettoninja · 06/06/2022 15:07

That’s bonkers @rainbowmilk. Raising your children during a disaster is just part of the job description surely?

it’s not remotely comparable to something like unpaid carers who (in theory) have the option to relinquish care to the state who would have to provide specialist care.

rainbowmilk · 06/06/2022 15:04

This thread reminds me of a work colleague who wrote to her MP asking for parents to all be given a one off payment from the government because they were the unsung heroes of COVID.

When pressed as to why parents were the heroes (or unsung, even, given that all anyone seemed to talk about was the effect on families), she just kept saying that parents suffered most and got no credit for their contribution to the nation. She also couldn’t explain why a cash payment would help redress that.

Hope she doesn’t see this thread and get ideas!

BlueTitSmilingAtMe · 06/06/2022 14:01

Mommabear20 · 06/06/2022 09:22

What about the people (like myself) who had to go to hospital appointments and inductions of labour, alone because of restrictions?
What about the people who couldn't visit loved ones in hospital or nursing homes?
What about the people living alone, who had no human contact for months on end?
What about the people that lost their jobs and businesses?
The pandemic has been hard on everyone!

Snowflakes. Dunno what they're moaning about when there's people in Russia dying in the war.

budgiegirl · 06/06/2022 12:48

obviously some children will suffer, and have suffered. As would be the case if the pandemic never happened

But it did happen, and so many children's mental health, who perhaps were coping before, has become much worse. The demands on mental health services has skyrocketed, and not because parents have told children that their mental health has suffered, but because, for some, it actually has.

FabFitFifties · 06/06/2022 12:25

MintyMoocow · 05/06/2022 20:05

How many teens do you lot know with social phobia now? We basically stunted their fucking lives for 2 years.
Bugger off with your “ Wah! we’re growed up and it was a bit diffy for us too!”

This. The impact for some children and teenagers has been horrendous. The struggle to access any sort of professional support for a child's emotional wellbeing is unbelievable in my area. I can't obviously share details, but I believe the general population would be very shocked to read referrals I have made, which haven't met thresholds. I can sit on the phone all day, whilst typing, and never get through to even make a referral. Some of my referrals by form, don't even get an acknowledgement to say unsuccessful. Those which are accepted, wait a minimum of a year to be seen. I am aware of some who are still waiting after 2 years. I also work with adults - never had a referral rejected, and waiting times are much shorter in my area - at least for triage and a plan of support. Social anxiety is a huge problem, for many children whose families did follow the rules, but many children suffered from the increased time spent in abusive, neglectful and violent households too. Yes I do know many adults have suffered horrendously too.

Confusion101 · 06/06/2022 12:10

@rainbowmilk obviously some children will suffer, and have suffered. As would be the case if the pandemic never happened. I think constantly telling children "oh your mental health has suffered" is not a narrative our children need to hear. And they do pick up on that! They will start to believe that and then the little resources that are available won't be going to the children who actually need it like your niece and daughter. Hope they both get the resources they need! 💕

NeedAHoliday2021 · 06/06/2022 12:02

I work in a hospital and all our children received a certificate and letter of thanks from our ceo. I’ve recognised how amazing my dc are and all they’ve been through and so have their schools. I’m not sure what a government medal for all children will achieve - it’s meaningless and the money could be better spent imo.

budgiegirl · 06/06/2022 12:01

I think that people are saying there'll be permanent mental health effects for children as a result of the pandemic is extremely worrying

Does that mean you think there won't be permanent mental health effects for some children? Because I thinks it's, at best, naive to think that there won't. Yes, many children can be taught resilience. But for some (although certainly a minority) the lockdown was a disaster in terms of mental health. My teenage niece suffered with her mental health terribly, still hasn't gone back to school, hardly comes out of her room, doesn't engage with anyone, stays up all night, sleeps all day, has talked about suicide. Her parents have tried everything they can think of, but are at the end of their tether. Access to mental health services is extremely difficult, due to the high demand. They've tried the GP, CAMHS, private councillors, private pschyciatrists, but waiting lists are extremely long, even if they can get on the waiting list on the first place.

My own daughter, although not as badly, has also suffered mental health problems, and is waiting for counselling.

So I actually find it quite offensive for anyone to say We have to get on with it!. Some children (and, of course, adults) can't.

rainbowmilk · 06/06/2022 11:59

There’s nothing to be gained from token gestures unless they’re backed up with societal changes. What use was clapping if the NHS continues to be underfunded? What use is a medal if the needs of schools and childrens mental health services continue to be ignored?

If we’re giving money to a specific group of people for trauma then it should be invested in the services that treat trauma, allowing those that have suffered most to receive prompt, good treatment.

I speak as someone with diagnosed trauma, who lived on their own for 2 years, saw nobody for vast stretches of that time, and was constantly being told how tough it is for families. I’m now paying a ridiculous amount of money for my own therapy. I don’t have any left to pay to the government for a nonsense medal scheme.