Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that every child and young person…

237 replies

KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs · 05/06/2022 19:46

That got through the pandemic, followed the rules, stayed indoors for long periods of time, endured isolation, online learning, ping pongs in and out of school, slow vaccination roll-out…

Should get a medal.

Our kids are amazing and gone through so much but not one bit of recognition.

OP posts:
FlissyPaps · 11/06/2022 21:09

This country is fucked. We are truly fucked.

What are you proactively and constructively doing in order to be less “fucked” in your local community OP?

rainbowmilk · 11/06/2022 20:48

Christ, I heard nothing but “what about the children????” during the pandemic. It was the chief focus of so, so many people and groups. MN as you’d expect was awash with UsForThem publicity. I really feel sometimes like I live on a different planet to some!

12Thorns · 11/06/2022 20:43

Since this thread started, purely out of interest, I have asked several hundred children if they would be pleased or displeased to hear lockdown was returning tomorrow.

approx 80% voted pleased, many saying it was the best time of their lives - the main reason being getting up later, more time at home, more family time, less disruption to learning compared to being in classrooms, more relaxed lifestyle, less pressure overall etc

I know lockdown learning suited many children, but I did think it would be around a third who preferred it, not this overwhelming majority

Poppinjay · 11/06/2022 18:46

FFS! Get a grip.

There are thousands of children across the country who have been denied education, mental health services and friendship due to the appalling attitude our LAs have to meeting their special educational needs. This is their whole childhoods. Lockdown actually brough relief for some in the form of access to online education when education was previously being withheld and the chance to attend school with smaller groups in more closely supervised environments that meant they could cope.

I've seen and heard recognition of the effect the pandemic has had on children all over MN and other media throughout the lockdowns and since. We are all aware that it has been shit for some children. It has been shit for the majority of the population. It has been worse for some of the elderly who are still scared to leave their homes.

The average child in this country is a lot less fucked than most in terms of what they have been through and what they can expect from life.

KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs · 11/06/2022 18:28

I’ve read this thread back again aghast at how many on here have dismissed our children's experiences.

Maybe I could have expressed it better than a medal but it does not takeaway,
no matter what a crap idea an actual medal
might be, the ease that so many on this thread have dismissed, negated and diminished what our children did. I do not
share this sentiment at all. Our kids have been amazing. And this thread has made me so sad.

Theres a thread on Twitter today from Frankie Boyle just now who has expressed it so much better than me. And that is that the bandwidth of conversations through the pandemic has not included children.

’In a reversal of natural order of things, during the pandemic, we asked our children to sacrifice friendship, education and fresh air to protect the old. Where is the recognition? Where is the payback?’

And he goes on to talk about just ‘how invisible / ignored the unprecedented experience our children have had is…’

And that’s US lot here on mumsnet of all places, rendering our children’s experiences invisible, ignored and diminished.

This country is fucked. We are truly fucked.

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 08/06/2022 18:01

Jourdain11 · 08/06/2022 15:43

I'm kind of assuming that it's a figurative medal rather than an actual, physical medal!!

What would that look like though?

Isn’t there also the danger of telling children that are actually relatively unscathed by the pandemic, that actually no, you’ve been through something much bigger than you thought you had and casting the whole thing in a new light and damaging them retrospectively?

I can point to the pandemic almost exclusively for some things that my daughter struggles with now (she’s a sensitive soul at the best of times), I’m not sure that rewriting history and our ‘this is just how it is at the moment and that’s disappointing but it’ll get better’ approach to lockdowns/restrictions wouldn’t do more harm than good. She’s made great progress, does she really need to be knocked back that her view of how we told her everything would be ok (and it was) was wrong and actually she’s some sort of victim?

They’ll draw their own conclusions with the benefit of retrospect and documented history, I don’t think we need to interfere with their current perceptions by and large.

ldontWanna · 08/06/2022 17:35

KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs · 08/06/2022 12:40

This thread is so depressing, no
actually it’s sad, bone wearying sad.

The medal is a symbol of recognition for our children and yes I accept
that for most kids that would be naff.

But what I don’t get is all those people on here who are so supposed to recognising our children? What is so WRONG with a symbol, any symbol, about saying to our children and young people ‘we see you’, that what they did was extraordinary, once in 100-years and that this will be generationally impactful. Where have we said collectively - thankyou?

But what I find so sad is how this is even a debate on this freaking platform of all places where you’d think there would be the loudest advocacy?

For all those that are comparing our children’s experiences with Ukraine, or the WW2 generation, or with their own adult experiences - just what? And calling our kids snowflakes? What?

To not recognise, protect and invest in future generations is a terrible indictment of where our priorities are as a country. This country is fucked.

I personally don't want a symbol. Not another wishy washy,pointless,performative ,pretend we care.

What I want is adequate support,help,intervention,prevention and services , all across the board for all children, particularly the children damaged by the pandemic.

I don't want symbols, I want action, and funding, and for children to fucking be a priority and not just data.

TambourineOfRepentance · 08/06/2022 17:13

Teder · 08/06/2022 14:00

Children who have suffered don’t need ‘recognition’. That’s what makes the “country fucked”. Those children who suffered need appropriate services and support and the government should be funding it, not giving a medal to every child. Recognition my arse. I’m sure we can do better than that for those who suffered actual trauma or even those who struggled a bit but still are very worthy of decent support. Fund and organise services better rather than a tokenistic virtual signalling piece of crap medial for every Tom, Dick and Harry.

This! What would be useful is properly investing in mental health support, or educational support for those who have fallen far behind.

What has no use at all is constantly reiterating to classrooms of children that "You've had such a tough time". This helps no one. It doesn't help those who have been badly affected and it doesn't help those who have been (understandably) bored and lonely while locked down but have readjusted well enough.

Jourdain11 · 08/06/2022 15:43

I'm kind of assuming that it's a figurative medal rather than an actual, physical medal!!

rainbowmilk · 08/06/2022 15:12

It's not a legal requirement when joining mumsnet that you must unconditionally support any and all policies or ideas that prioritise children and parents over all else. Mumsnet isn't a religion.

I just believe that the best way for society to recover from a pandemic which affected everyone in different ways, is for funding to be directed to those who need the help. Those who'd like their child/mum/gran/next door neighbour etc. to be given a medal are free to buy one out of their own money. I do not support money that could go to help the most vulnerable (including but not exclusively children) going towards purchasing medals which help nobody.

xogossipgirlxo · 08/06/2022 14:23

Wow, I can't believe this thread is for real.

Cornettoninja · 08/06/2022 14:19

I think, with the help of this thread, I’ve put my finger on why I don’t like the idea of a medal or other ambiguous recognition of lockdown for children.

We issue medals or ‘honours’ when there’s nothing left for anyone else to add. Someone has achieved something brilliant or done something extraordinary outside expectations of them and their peers.

Issuing medals and recognitions with thanks implies we’re done and there’s nothing else to be provided. I’m not done, this is a part of our lives for the foreseeable and still evolving for lots of people all who have needs that can and should be provided for.

Teder · 08/06/2022 14:00

KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs · 08/06/2022 12:40

This thread is so depressing, no
actually it’s sad, bone wearying sad.

The medal is a symbol of recognition for our children and yes I accept
that for most kids that would be naff.

But what I don’t get is all those people on here who are so supposed to recognising our children? What is so WRONG with a symbol, any symbol, about saying to our children and young people ‘we see you’, that what they did was extraordinary, once in 100-years and that this will be generationally impactful. Where have we said collectively - thankyou?

But what I find so sad is how this is even a debate on this freaking platform of all places where you’d think there would be the loudest advocacy?

For all those that are comparing our children’s experiences with Ukraine, or the WW2 generation, or with their own adult experiences - just what? And calling our kids snowflakes? What?

To not recognise, protect and invest in future generations is a terrible indictment of where our priorities are as a country. This country is fucked.

Children who have suffered don’t need ‘recognition’. That’s what makes the “country fucked”. Those children who suffered need appropriate services and support and the government should be funding it, not giving a medal to every child. Recognition my arse. I’m sure we can do better than that for those who suffered actual trauma or even those who struggled a bit but still are very worthy of decent support. Fund and organise services better rather than a tokenistic virtual signalling piece of crap medial for every Tom, Dick and Harry.

Excited101 · 08/06/2022 13:48

Ridiculous suggestion. The kids had no control about what they ‘sacrificed’, they had to just get on with it! Most people muddled along and made the best of it, people of all ages. Any simpering martyrdom and suggestions of kids having ‘done it all for others’ is what will be leading towards them feeling like they should need a medal rather than just cracking on, and getting back to normal with whatever support they may need- as ever.

There are many, many I feel sorry for from the pandemic but kids as a whole is not it, and a meaningless medal is not the way to offer any recognition.

Cornettoninja · 08/06/2022 13:35

noblegiraffe · 08/06/2022 13:33

Going on about how kids should be given a medal when what they, - desperately in some circumstances- need is proper funding seems to be rather overlooking their actual needs in favour of virtue-signalling gestures.

I care about kids so I gave them a medal when many are going hungry or can’t access mental health services or social services or don’t have a qualified teacher and are in a dangerous school building…. Priorities? Hmm

Put succinctly - this.

noblegiraffe · 08/06/2022 13:33

Going on about how kids should be given a medal when what they, - desperately in some circumstances- need is proper funding seems to be rather overlooking their actual needs in favour of virtue-signalling gestures.

I care about kids so I gave them a medal when many are going hungry or can’t access mental health services or social services or don’t have a qualified teacher and are in a dangerous school building…. Priorities? Hmm

grapewines · 08/06/2022 13:27

lickenchugget · 08/06/2022 13:22

Also yabvvvvvvu for the phrase ‘we see you’,

God, yes.

Give your kids a medal if you want, OP.

lickenchugget · 08/06/2022 13:22

Also yabvvvvvvu for the phrase ‘we see you’,

Cornettoninja · 08/06/2022 13:21

But what I don’t get is all those people on here who are so supposed to recognising our children? What is so WRONG with a symbol, any symbol, about saying to our children and young people ‘we see you’, that what they did was extraordinary, once in 100-years and that this will be generationally impactful

because it’s a meaningless, empty gesture that doesn’t actually recognise or achieve anything, certainly not the support needed on a societal level for children. At best it’s a soother for adults who feel guilt over the unavoidable and can make themselves feel better.

from the point of view of a child who does need support a ‘we see you’ means absolutely nothing and is of no tangible benefit to them.

By all means give an example of something similar so we can get an idea of what it is you’re trying to communicate because I’m struggling to come up with a comparison to make sense of what you’re advocating.

I recall a similar idea floated in the first lockdown to have a ‘clap’ for school children similar to the NHS one. Never took off afaik, I suspect largely because it just doesn’t make any sense. Either from the child’s pov or the adults.

But what I find so sad is how this is even a debate on this freaking platform of all places where you’d think there would be the loudest advocacy?

A debate means two sides. That’s exactly what you’ve got. I think you wanted a total agreement with you.

SniggleSnarf · 08/06/2022 13:20

I'll chip in for your kids medal, OP.

Will there be a ceremony?

lickenchugget · 08/06/2022 13:12

Yabu, it goes kids good to be resilient, far too many haven’t been taught this skill. The thanks and rewards should
come from their own parent and families, who would be tasked with giving a medal?

Trafficjamlog · 08/06/2022 13:07

mine don’t need a medal. They would have preferred to go to school and see their friends but then got on with lockdown and have pretty much forgotten about it and picked up where they left off.

MarshaBradyo · 08/06/2022 12:46

KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs · 08/06/2022 12:40

This thread is so depressing, no
actually it’s sad, bone wearying sad.

The medal is a symbol of recognition for our children and yes I accept
that for most kids that would be naff.

But what I don’t get is all those people on here who are so supposed to recognising our children? What is so WRONG with a symbol, any symbol, about saying to our children and young people ‘we see you’, that what they did was extraordinary, once in 100-years and that this will be generationally impactful. Where have we said collectively - thankyou?

But what I find so sad is how this is even a debate on this freaking platform of all places where you’d think there would be the loudest advocacy?

For all those that are comparing our children’s experiences with Ukraine, or the WW2 generation, or with their own adult experiences - just what? And calling our kids snowflakes? What?

To not recognise, protect and invest in future generations is a terrible indictment of where our priorities are as a country. This country is fucked.

Op I hear you. It’s a tough read.

On other threads posters get annoyed when they are told to think of people worse off. But children are to expect the Ukraine / WW2 argument. That’s how low some expectations are. Too depressing, but hopefully not indicative of how everyone feels, bar this thread.

12Thorns · 08/06/2022 12:46

Because our children have not done anything noteworthy or praiseworthy, or made any particular sacrifice for anyone but themselves. That’s the point. There is nothing literally nothing to thank it praise them for. They area very privileged cohort who were mildly inconvenienced for a short time for their own good

KnowButNeedU2TellMeAsItIs · 08/06/2022 12:40

This thread is so depressing, no
actually it’s sad, bone wearying sad.

The medal is a symbol of recognition for our children and yes I accept
that for most kids that would be naff.

But what I don’t get is all those people on here who are so supposed to recognising our children? What is so WRONG with a symbol, any symbol, about saying to our children and young people ‘we see you’, that what they did was extraordinary, once in 100-years and that this will be generationally impactful. Where have we said collectively - thankyou?

But what I find so sad is how this is even a debate on this freaking platform of all places where you’d think there would be the loudest advocacy?

For all those that are comparing our children’s experiences with Ukraine, or the WW2 generation, or with their own adult experiences - just what? And calling our kids snowflakes? What?

To not recognise, protect and invest in future generations is a terrible indictment of where our priorities are as a country. This country is fucked.

OP posts: