Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girl in boyish clothes = YES, boy in clothes that are even the tiniest bit feminine = NO!

104 replies

GrahameSylvia · 05/06/2022 19:37

Does anyone else think its a bit unreasonable that when dressing young kids (babies, toddlers, and perhaps also a bit older), a lot of people now seem to think that dressing girls in slightly more boyish clothes (blue, dinosaur print, stuff with 'strong girl' etc printed on it) is great, progressive, cool etc. But that if you put your baby or toddler boy in one item that is even the slightest bit feminine, even when paired with other boy-ish stuff (I'm talking blue dungarees with a tiger on them and a vest that has gone a tiny bit peach colored in the wash) people instantly assume they are a girl and / or are made quite uncomfortable and ask why your kid is dressed as a girl??

I'd say we dress our one year old somewhere between 'standard boy' and what we think of as neutral - not that this should matter. There is plenty of blue, brown green in his wardrobe, though also some yellow, brighter prints and the occasional bit of dark purple or fawn. But anytime he has the slightly 'girlier' things on everyone calls him she. We've also had a couple of instances of relatives (not always older ones) being uncomfortable or mocking him / us when he's been dressed in supposedly 'girly' things e.g. a red cardigan, a bonnet with earflaps instead of a beanie, dungarees printed with sweetcorns.

Since then I've started to look round and noticed that even in our relatively progressive, affluent bit of the world some girls are dressed very femininely, but plenty are dressed in stuff that is boyish or neutral and everyone still assumes they are girls. But every boy is wearing camouflage, sludge colours and vehicle prints. The same extends to toys, plenty of girl toddlers being encouraged to play with lego and cars and get muddy, but parents at our local affluent play cafe actively discouraging boys from picking up dolls or dollhouses - despite the fact that most of these girls will grow up to own cars and drive and the boys will own houses and have babies.

So why do all these progressive folks feel it is okay and positive for girls to be 'boyish' but still seem to be (consciously or unconsciously) very against their little boys being the slightest bit feminine?

Has anyone else seen the same / seen different / think its unreasonable to condition little boys to be against anything 'soft', 'feminine' or 'caring'? Doesn't feminism / progress cut both ways?

OP posts:
Sumtimesiamgreen · 05/06/2022 19:48

What is your point? You have not said anything that is not common knowledge?

bridgetreilly · 05/06/2022 19:48

Hello, and welcome to our sexist world. The answer to your question is because boy is better. Girls can be a bit boyish because that’s better, but boys shouldn’t be girly because that’s worse. See also baby names: it’s cool to call a girl Jack or James, but horrific to call you boy Jane or Jemima.

HotPenguin · 05/06/2022 19:45

Yes but it's because of misogyny - the female role is seen as "lesser" so boys are discouraged from doing "feminine" activities. Many of the traditional feminine roles (childcare, housekeeping etc) are poorly paid whereas traditional male jobs (computer programmer, physicist, builder) are well paid so there is a sort of logic to it - but at the end of the day we need all roles so ought to value all of them.

Perfect28 · 05/06/2022 19:41

Yes it's complete horse shit and my son has several pink things. I literally do not give a hoot what anyone thinks because it's all absolute nonsense.

Swipe left for the next trending thread