Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel guilty but not know how to help my sister.

60 replies

PumpkinPie2016 · 05/06/2022 19:26

I'll try to keep this brief but it may be long!

My sister is married and has two children. At present, neither her nor her husband work. They get benefits. My sister has not worked really since she left school. She has started jobs but always quits them. She has started two recently- neither lasted more than a week.

Unfortunately, over the years, she has relied on our parents, me and other family members to "lend" money which is then never returned. There are always various excuses as to why it can't be returned. In recent months, our parents have supported her to the tune of around 2k 😳 they are ok financially but not wealthy enough to sustain that! I had started saying no to providing more money as it was becoming constant and expensive!

I helped out recently by sending a supermarket shop. Earlier this weekend, we had a family gathering and my sister asked for help for a taxi fare - I agreed to help as it would be quite an expensive fare, I didn't want her to miss out and I could afford to help. I gave her £65. Taxi cost £45 so she would have had the remaining money left. I know our parents also gave £20.

Except I have now had messages asking for more money for gas/electricity. I have said no and suggested she ring and ask for temporary credit.

I feel awful 😥 I obviously love my sister but I cannot keep funding someone else. I am comfortably off but not rich and have my own bills to pay. Unfortunately, once you say yes to one request, more and more is asked for until you say no.

I honestly don't know what to do to help her🙄 the obvious solution is for them to get jobs but neither seems able to stick at anything.

Not even sure why I am posting-just feeling frustrated and low this evening 😕 that said, if anyone has any suggestions for helping her that would be welcome.

OP posts:
Speakuptomakeyourselfheard · 05/06/2022 20:41

I don't know how you can feel sorry for them OP, I'd be ashamed of them, because they're basically too lazy to get off their backsides and earn their own money, and as everyone else has pointed out, you and your parents enabling them hasn't done them any favours whatsoever!! Tell them that you're done lending, and they need to get jobs and if they don't like the jobs they get, then they need to stick with them until they've found something else, not just quit and expect others to bail them out.

PassThePringles · 05/06/2022 20:41

I'd ask her if she wanted to have a coffee and figure out how she can budget her money better. If she's comfortable with it, find out what their incomings are and where every pound of her outgoings are going to. Is she buying the high end brands? Paying for Sky? How much is getting smoked away etc. Let her see in black and white where her money is going and where can she save here and there.
You never needed to worry about being called horrible etc, you've done more than enough for them.

BilboBagBin · 05/06/2022 20:41

For a few people, traditional ‘work’ is not really for them for a variety of reasons. Maybe your sister needs to try something like a side hustle doing something she enjoys that she can slowly build up into a long term business as her confidence grows,

Therunecaster · 05/06/2022 20:35

My DP has a brother like this. He and his horrible wife have fleeced his PILs for 10s of thousands over the years. They owe DP 5 thousand and cut him off when he asked that they start paying it back. I can't stand them. Their adult kids have turned out to be equally grabby. None of them work but he drives a BMW!

Cactuslove · 05/06/2022 20:34

They've become dependent on you all so there's no urgency to find a job. But if they are on benefits I'm surprised they're not asked to go to the job centre etc? I've recently found myself on benefits only £100 pm but all helps- his is after separation and I have two young kids. I work 24 hours in a professional job. My brother gave me £1000 for my birthday and stocked my fridge. The most amazing gift. But I can't bring myself to touch his money! In a years time once they're working if you decide to help them out a bit it's a gift and should be seen like it. But I do agree with you find it hard to understand how they just ask others for money. I feel embarrassed that my brother even felt the need to help me out.

Hothammock · 05/06/2022 20:33

I have similar in my family. They ask because they have learned it works and everyone seems to accept it as of it's a normal way of life. You will never help grown Adults out of this pattern of behaviour unless you change your own part in it.
So you will be doing the right thing to say sorry you can't lend anymore until she has managed to repay what has already borrowed.
From experience, you will need a thick skin the first few times and then it will become easier.

hiredandsqueak · 05/06/2022 20:32

Honestly just stop saying yes to any request. I did the same with dsis because every text I received was a request for money. Once I stopped saying yes she never contacted me any more. Yes it's sad we aren't in contact but she obviously didn't want to know me for anything more than what I could give her.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 05/06/2022 20:30

My sister is the queen of coming out then saying she has forgotten her purse. We will be having words about it next time we go anywhere together. You just have to say no.

Georgeskitchen · 05/06/2022 20:30

Agree with above pps, you and yoir parents need to stop enabling them. They are taking the piss big time

Doginthewindow · 05/06/2022 20:26

You are not doing their children any favours either. They are crap role models and need to step up sooner rather than later. What on earth are you thinking by enabling them this way..wake up!

Mariposista · 05/06/2022 20:23

Sorry, but if your sister has not worked since she left school, she should not have had children. Where does she think the money comes from to put food on their table and clothes on their back? The money fairy? The bank of mum and dad?

PumpkinPie2016 · 05/06/2022 20:22

No MH/learning difficulties which prevent them from working.

I do think part of the issue is that she/they have become used to being bailed out by everyone else. As I say, I do love her but she is very good at giving a sob story about why she needs this money.

I wonder if they would benefit from something like early help but I don't know how to access that in a non-professional capacity.

OP posts:
LookItsMeAgain · 05/06/2022 20:16

I think you might need to be cruel to be kind - give her an itemised breakdown of how much money you've spent (just you) and maybe ask your mum/dad to do the same and say that the only way that you've been able to provide her with this money is because you have a job and you stay in that job.
Perhaps ask her to put a budget together based on what she gets by way of benefits and show her how to economise.
There's a saying about teaching a man to fish (can't think of it right now) but I think if you show her how to budget rather than keep giving her handouts, she'll do better in the long run.

drpet49 · 05/06/2022 20:15

“Simple, you and your parents stop enabling her. She won't learn to budget while she thinks she's got it made scrounging off you. You're a mug if you lend her any more. Unless she lives in the middle of nowhere with no buses, wtf were you doing paying 45quid for a taxi???”

^This

Doginthewindow · 05/06/2022 20:12

You are not helping them. Are they planning on living like this when they are old? Agree with your parents to stop being doormats all of you. It’s absolutely ridiculous.

Basketet · 05/06/2022 20:11

I'm surprised the Jobcentre hasn't got them both into part time employment even... regardless of how many times your Dsis quits. As pp has already asked, do they have poor MH and or learning difficulties?

TheHaka · 05/06/2022 20:09

Ask if she needs help to budget.

YarnHoarder · 05/06/2022 20:08

Ignore what you're parents are doing to an extent, they can obviously do what they want with their money - I know you're not trying to stop them etc but know it can feel frustrating. Definitely stop supporting them quiet so much, benefits are crap to have to live on but it sounds like there's issues with their budgeting if they're regularly having to rely on others.

If it was my sister I'd have drawn the line ages ago but we have a relationship where this is easy. Next time she asks, ask when you're going to get paid back for the taxi fare? It's basically turned into you gifting her money every time she asks when it should be a loan. Every time she asks, asks for the last to be repaid first. It'll help set some boundaries and for them to realise they have a finite income and need to make adjustments to live within that or increase that income.

InChocolateWeTrust · 05/06/2022 20:02

Do they have any reasons why they might be struggling to work (mental health? Learning difficulties?)

In terms of how you can help, I do think you have to cut them off.

But maybe also try and encourage them towards some stepping stones towards work? For people who've never held down a job it's a big step to go from nothing to employment. They might need to start with a bit of education or volunteering to build better habits before adding the responsibility that paid employment brings. It's a long game and they likely need a lot of help.

bridgetreilly · 05/06/2022 20:00

Honestly, the kindest thing here is to stop. They will never change unless they have to. If they know they can always rely on other people to pay, there is no motivation for them to work and to budget properly.

PumpkinPie2016 · 05/06/2022 19:58

@FoiledByTheInsect unfortunately, we do live in villages with very limited public transport so they genuinely had to get a taxi.

Thank you for all of the replies so far. I know that ultimately, you are all right.

OP posts:
HotPenguin · 05/06/2022 19:57

Yadnbu in fact your parents are being actively unhelpful by giving all that money. What will she do you when your parents retire/pass away? She needs to get her shit together and start working and the longer she leaves it the harder it will be.

MoreShit123 · 05/06/2022 19:57

I doubt anyone on here is going to think you're a horrible person OP. They both need to get a bit of self respect and grow the fuck up x

FoiledByTheInsect · 05/06/2022 19:52

Simple, you and your parents stop enabling her. She won't learn to budget while she thinks she's got it made scrounging off you. You're a mug if you lend her any more. Unless she lives in the middle of nowhere with no buses, wtf were you doing paying 45quid for a taxi???

Ignore all texts, social media rants etc., and just keep asking "how's the job search going" on repeat till she gets the message.

IncompleteSenten · 05/06/2022 19:45

Message her saying sorry sis but you currently owe me £X. I just can't afford to keep giving you money. Please dont ask me again. If you want help job hunting, let me know.