Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel guilty but not know how to help my sister.

60 replies

PumpkinPie2016 · 05/06/2022 19:26

I'll try to keep this brief but it may be long!

My sister is married and has two children. At present, neither her nor her husband work. They get benefits. My sister has not worked really since she left school. She has started jobs but always quits them. She has started two recently- neither lasted more than a week.

Unfortunately, over the years, she has relied on our parents, me and other family members to "lend" money which is then never returned. There are always various excuses as to why it can't be returned. In recent months, our parents have supported her to the tune of around 2k 😳 they are ok financially but not wealthy enough to sustain that! I had started saying no to providing more money as it was becoming constant and expensive!

I helped out recently by sending a supermarket shop. Earlier this weekend, we had a family gathering and my sister asked for help for a taxi fare - I agreed to help as it would be quite an expensive fare, I didn't want her to miss out and I could afford to help. I gave her £65. Taxi cost £45 so she would have had the remaining money left. I know our parents also gave £20.

Except I have now had messages asking for more money for gas/electricity. I have said no and suggested she ring and ask for temporary credit.

I feel awful 😥 I obviously love my sister but I cannot keep funding someone else. I am comfortably off but not rich and have my own bills to pay. Unfortunately, once you say yes to one request, more and more is asked for until you say no.

I honestly don't know what to do to help her🙄 the obvious solution is for them to get jobs but neither seems able to stick at anything.

Not even sure why I am posting-just feeling frustrated and low this evening 😕 that said, if anyone has any suggestions for helping her that would be welcome.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NamechangeFML · 06/06/2022 06:00

My DM is shocking with money. I was working p/t making buttons and every weekend -can i have XX for food/electric? Never ever was repaid.
( i had a job since 14 and she would take wages off me too)
always cash for fags though....
eventually i went NC after she took my last £50 and went camping. I had to call a family member sobbing to then help ME
3 years passed and we spoke again-but she never did ask me for cash again.

Pickabearanybear · 06/06/2022 04:31

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Marty13 · 06/06/2022 04:05

Yeah, I helped my brother before but he was doing things to earn money and improve his situation. He never paid me back (I expected that when I decided to give him the money) but he has changed his situation and hasn't asked me for money in years, despite living month by month.

I think helping someone who is helping themselves is very different to enabling someone who just wants to keep the status quo.

But I also appreciate it's hard to say no to family. I'd recommand not loaning your sister anymore money but I know I'd be the first to break that rule.

Can you talk to her about her situation ? "Dear Sis, over the years I have loaned you X monies and you haven't paid me back any of it. I want to help you but I can't keep doing that. I'd love to help you in other ways though, do you want to talk about jobs and what's been going on on that front for you ? "

lifecanbehardattimes · 06/06/2022 03:14

IncompleteSenten · 05/06/2022 19:45

Message her saying sorry sis but you currently owe me £X. I just can't afford to keep giving you money. Please dont ask me again. If you want help job hunting, let me know.

Perfect

lifecanbehardattimes · 06/06/2022 03:13

You are enabling her!

Why would she get a taxi when she can't afford it? And then you gave he extra too!

Iflyaway · 06/06/2022 02:10

None of them work but he drives a BMW!

Drug dealing comes to mind.....

SlatsandFlaps · 06/06/2022 01:50

@Sarahcoggles That's a massive assumption you've made there! £50 a week?! It depends massively on how much you smoke. I quit a year ago but I only smoked between 1-3 cigarettes per day so a pack of 20 lasted me at least a week.

10HailMarys · 06/06/2022 01:04

If a family member was struggling to find a job, or had a job that didn't pay enough to make ends meet, or couldn't get a role that could fit around childcare or whatever, I would happily lend/give whatever help I could afford. I currently help my mum out with money now and again, although she never asks.

But this is clearly not the case with your sister and her husband, as they have had jobs which they leave after a week or so.

If people choose not to work, that's up to them as far as I'm concerned. I don't personally have an issue with someone claiming benefits rather than working - but if that is the choice they've made, then it's up to them to manage on that low budget. It's not up to family to prop them up. My brother was once unemployed for two years, pretty much by choice, when he was younger, but he never, ever asked anyone for money, not once. He lived in terrible conditions, in my opinion, but he accepted that he'd made his bed and therefore had to lie in it.

I think you just need to be really clear with your sister. 'Sorry, but I can't help you. I've helped you out with money many times before but it can't go on. You and BIL have made a choice not to work, which is totally up to you, but I can't help you finance that choice. Happy to help you get support with budgeting, or with finding you and/or BIL work that you can stick with, but please don't ask me for money again.'

Sarahcoggles · 06/06/2022 00:34

PumpkinPie2016 · 05/06/2022 19:40

@MoreShit123 in a way🙄 she doesn't smoke but her husband does.

I just find it perplexing that two adults seem to think it perfectly acceptable to ask others to fund them.

I promise I am not a horrible person and I don't mind helping anyone to a point but it's become ridiculous!

Smoking costs about £50 a week doesn't it? And she asks you for money?

caringcarer · 05/06/2022 23:15

Your parents and you are enabling them to fail at life and be a burden. Offer money only for a taxi so they can attend events. Don't offer anything else. You should also speak to your parents and suggest they stop enabling your sister and bil to not work. If he gave up smoking he could put that money towards utility bills. If you and patents stopped enabling them then one of them would have to get a job. That is the only way they will climb put of poverty.

InChocolateWeTrust · 05/06/2022 22:09

I thought you were v unlikely to be able to live of benefits and not work nowadays - the Tories can't be as evil as everyone claims

Where you have a couple of kids, you can get various elements that add up, although it can be capped and it's not loads, which is probably why they are constantly needing more from OP

Wishihadanalgorithm · 05/06/2022 22:06

Your sister and her husband are adults. It’s about time they took responsibility for their own decisions. Tough love is needed from everyone. Once the family bank dries up they will have to figure out how to fund themselves.

I speak from experience with a sister who sounds like yours. Once we all got sick of bailing her out (to the tune of thousands) she went NC with us. It was strangely peaceful.

Your parents should realise they are only enabling your DS and not solving the problem. Can imagine it must be tough to say no though.

Natty13 · 05/06/2022 22:05

the obvious solution is for them to get jobs but neither seems able to stick at anything.

I am really shocked that you don't understand that that the reason. The jobs "don't stick" is because everyone keeps funding them.

If you and everyone else stopped giving them money all the time they would have to stick at a job wouldn't they?

Ferngreen · 05/06/2022 21:58

I thought you were v unlikely to be able to live of benefits and not work nowadays - the Tories can't be as evil as everyone claimsConfused

Newestname002 · 05/06/2022 21:54

@PumpkinPie2016

Got a message about an hour after saying it's OK, sorted it.

So they can do it ... except check they've not "sorted it" by scrounging off your parents again. 🌹

Doginthewindow · 05/06/2022 21:42

Op get your parents to do the same.

PumpkinPie2016 · 05/06/2022 21:39

Sorry just catching up with the thread. Thank you for all of your replies - it's a relief to know that others can understand why I am infuriated! I am sorry some of you have similar relatives!

Someone asked their ages - they are both early 30s so not kids!

I have said no, I cannot afford it, to the request I received tonight. I sent a link to a citizens advice page which explains how to get temporary credit for utilities. Got a message about an hour after saying it's OK, sorted it. Not sure how but that's not for me to worry about.

Someone upthread said their sister or friend was like this and every message was a request for money which is exactly how I feel.

Going forward, I am just going to say 'sorry, I can't' and rinse and repeat.

I am happy to help them job hunt/budget etc but not to continue funding their lives.

OP posts:
Doginthewindow · 05/06/2022 21:13

PassThePringles · 05/06/2022 21:00

Sorry DogInTheWindow, I thought I'd replied to you directly :)

I agree with you completely. It is absolutely worth a try, especially if op acts as she is serious this time. Sadly I think this has been going on for such a long time, they only know sob stories. But it’s up to them then.

Newestname002 · 05/06/2022 21:01

@PumpkinPie2016

I'm afraid your sister and her husband are idle spongers. Why would they go to all the trouble of getting jobs, sticking to them in order even if they don't like them, to pay their bills if you and your parents will just hand cash out to them?

Have you or your parents ever added up how much you've given them over the years? Try it, then add your going rate of tax and NI to that and work out how long you'd have to work in your job to get that money. And they are getting it - regularly - for free. Plus they're on benefits.

You are not being horrible to say no firmly and keep saying no. Anything else is just encouraging them to leave things as they are get bailed out by family for the rest of their lives...

Perhaps refer them to Citizens Advice or one of the debt management agencies - but let them do this themselves. They need to adult up and accept responsibility for their own lives, just as you are. 🌹

PassThePringles · 05/06/2022 21:00

Sorry DogInTheWindow, I thought I'd replied to you directly :)

PassThePringles · 05/06/2022 20:59

I think OP has realised from the replies that she needs to toughen her approach abit. (I hope so anyway!) but you're right, it could go that way.

Her sob story holds no ground though as there is work out there, especially in things like Housekeeping which can be only four hours a day while the dc are at school (or the BIL would be home with them)... If she gets an attitude towards OP, it'd be biting the hand that feeds her, so to speak, so she'd be burning bridges which will either show OP how ungrateful she is or OP will get a break from bailing the couple out for a while, while she cools off... Maybe that'd be a win/win situation actually...

It's worth a try anyway imo. It helped me help my friend who was stressed and unorganised (not going through her money but going through her daily routine, breaking it down etc so see what we could fix.)

Doginthewindow · 05/06/2022 20:46

PassThePringles · 05/06/2022 20:41

I'd ask her if she wanted to have a coffee and figure out how she can budget her money better. If she's comfortable with it, find out what their incomings are and where every pound of her outgoings are going to. Is she buying the high end brands? Paying for Sky? How much is getting smoked away etc. Let her see in black and white where her money is going and where can she save here and there.
You never needed to worry about being called horrible etc, you've done more than enough for them.

It will only end with a sob story and op getting the blame.

Herejustforthisone · 05/06/2022 20:46

How old are they?

Quitelikeit · 05/06/2022 20:43

sadly you cannot change their approach to life or money. Luckily you are not responsible for their actions and nor should you feel guilty.

i think it’s highly likely that they are getting more from your parents than you know about.

if you all keep bailing her out then you hamper her ambition to get up and go to work as she really doesn’t need to if you all subsidise her

Herejustforthisone · 05/06/2022 20:42

They’re pathetic and they need to grow up. Everyone needs to stop enabling them and giving their own hard-earned money over to two lazy fuckers who are big enough and stupid enough to support themselves, but who can’t be arsed and would rather some other mugs do it.