Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do you love The Royal Family?

288 replies

pedropony76 · 05/06/2022 18:39

I previously posted this on The Royal Family board but only received one response so wanted to post here for traffic.

For those that love The Queen & The Royal Family, can you actually explain why?

I often see MNetters saying ‘Oh I love The Queen, I love this member and that member’ but no one ever says why. I came across the video of Stacey Solomon saying she doesn’t get why the country is so obsessed with this family as it could be any one of us born into royalty and I totally agree.

For me, when I think of The Royal Family, I instantly think of colonialism and how many of the jewels on the Queen’s crown has been stolen from different countries. I understand not everyone thinks like this but why do some love the members of this establishment as if they’ve done anything to better your life? I’d love to hear people’s views. I’ve tried to have this conversation in real life but everyone I know couldn’t care less about The Royal Family so I’m none the wiser.

Here’s the Stacey Solomon clip for any who haven’t seen it before

OP posts:
Justkeeppedaling · 05/06/2022 23:00

it seems the entire British (or English, rather) system is built on this type of inherited lordships, money, estates, positions and so on

You were right with British.

MosaicBlues · 05/06/2022 22:55

I don’t think we could find someone to elect who would have done as good a job as the Queen does at being head of state and an ambassador of this country. She impresses everyone who meets her in person and the continuity is reassuring for me. I am going to feel so very sorry for her family when she dies. Poor Prince Charles - a) I think they’re genuinely close now and b) no one can follow that.

FoiledByTheInsect · 05/06/2022 22:54

The sentiment is all very well but we’d be no richer, we’d be just as unequal, but we’d have lost something that made us a little bit unique, a little bit special, and overall I think a force for good.

I can't believe a Corbynite just said that. Of all the good things about Britain you cite the Nonce family as a little bit special .... Epstein and the 0 mm the queen distanced herself... Just wtf. Perhaps unique in our enabling of sex offenders and crime. A force for good, wtaf, guys I'll leave you all to it because this is unbelievable.

darisdet · 05/06/2022 22:50

FoiledByTheInsect · 05/06/2022 22:42

27,457 threads later and still people trotting out the same old myths .. we do not have a democracy. We have an imitation of one with a govt that got 44 percent of the vote and 22 million votes wasted. Until fptp is replaced by a fairer pr/av system, millions of voters will continue to have nobody to vote for, the Tories will continue to benefit from their massive over representation and will keep serving their own interests, and only their own interests, by forging unholy alliances with whoever will give them the most in return/keep them in power including the RF and their "special relationship" with the PM. You are being held hostage to what you call tradition and stability but it is in reality corrupt and undemocratic and undermining social unity.

I remember you from one of the republican threads! I wouldn't disagree with electoral reform, but as I said on a recent thread it's not going to benefit the Conservatives so it's not on the cards for them. If we got a lab/lib coalition it might be a different story, but we can only hope!

Foolosophy · 05/06/2022 22:48

As an outsider I find it very odd for Brits to be debating the point of the royal family. At least someone is keeping an eye on them, and they have their purpose.
However, it seems the entire British (or English, rather) system is built on this type of inherited lordships, money, estates, positions and so on, and those people are subjected to none of the scrutiny. I would find it much more useful for the system as a whole to get rid of that lot.
I mean, ‘house of lords’ for christ’s sake, if ever there was an anachronism..!

FoiledByTheInsect · 05/06/2022 22:42

27,457 threads later and still people trotting out the same old myths .. we do not have a democracy. We have an imitation of one with a govt that got 44 percent of the vote and 22 million votes wasted. Until fptp is replaced by a fairer pr/av system, millions of voters will continue to have nobody to vote for, the Tories will continue to benefit from their massive over representation and will keep serving their own interests, and only their own interests, by forging unholy alliances with whoever will give them the most in return/keep them in power including the RF and their "special relationship" with the PM. You are being held hostage to what you call tradition and stability but it is in reality corrupt and undemocratic and undermining social unity.

Haydugee · 05/06/2022 22:35

I think the Queen personally is amazing. She is such a strong woman and I find her devotion to this country and sense of duty humbling. In 70 years she has not really put a foot wrong. In an era of Trump, Biden, Boris etc I am even more truly grateful for our Queen.

More generally in this country, the royal family is above politics and I believe a truly unifying force for good. I have been at charity events and hospital wards during a royal visit and the pleasure and excitement it causes is huge. It also ensures maximum publicity. Have you seen how many charities each individual royal is a patron of? Have you seen how many public duties are carried out by the working royals - one single Head of State could never scrape the surface of so many visits.

On the World stage, our monarchy is a source of interest. Foreign heads of state want to meet our royals and stay in our palaces. Every time I have lived abroad, from France to Russia to Hong Kong to Australia - I have always been asked if I have met the Queen. Tourists also flock here because they love the living history and pageantry.

England has had a monarch for over 1000 years, I love the connection with the past.

Romeoalpha · 05/06/2022 22:30

FoiledByTheInsect · 05/06/2022 22:06

Romeoalpha Seriously. National identity??? I am absolutely ashamed to be British and automatically associated with those people and a country too backwards to even think it's necessary to update its political system.

Well it’s sad you feel that way, although I do understand. I am also ashamed to be British at times, believe me, I am a die-hard lefty, I voted for Jeremy Corbyn!

I just think that the Royals are a total red herring / straw man when it comes to bringing meaningful change to the UK. You can go after symbols, as with the recent tearing down statues but where would it get us?

The sentiment is all very well but we’d be no richer, we’d be just as unequal, but we’d have lost something that made us a little bit unique, a little bit special, and overall I think a force for good.

There is no denying that the Royals are working in the best interests of our country. They live in luxury- but they pay for it with their lives. A gilded cage. I wouldn’t give up my freedom for their life. I truly do believe it is a life or service. So as long as they are willing to do it, I am happy for them to continue. I actually think the way the monarchy will ultimately end will be with a string of abdications and nobody wanting the job.

leotardrock · 05/06/2022 22:27

Romeo I agree with you wholeheartedly!

Democracy yes so important but it doesn't seem to be serving us very well at the moment does it?

We have a Prime Minister who has broken the Law, that no one seems to have the balls to get rid off!

We had a referendum that has split society down the middle, Scotland didn't want BEXIT but are having to lump it, same Northern Island!

It wasn't the Queen who chucked £37 Billion on test & trace was it!

Chewchewbacca · 05/06/2022 22:22

MintJulia what do you mean .. ? Can you give examples of how she handles such things? Not noticed! Thnks

JudgeJ · 05/06/2022 22:15

DemBonesDemBones · 05/06/2022 19:07

Well I like the Queen better than I like Stacey Solomon 🤷‍♀️

At least I've heard of the Queen! Who's the other woman?

Romeoalpha · 05/06/2022 22:14

The Queen isn’t even on the UK Rich list, She probably doesn't even make the top 500.

All the talk of redistribution of wealth is misguided if directed solely at the Queen. Yes redistribution of wealth needs to happen, but it is a POLITICAL problem. You’re not going to be any better off by ‘sacking’ the Royal family.

Blame the Tories for the poverty and increasing inequality. Blame Boris and his band of selfish and immoral chancers.

Xtraincome · 05/06/2022 22:10

I have so little faith in elected leaders and government so have grown to like (some of) the Royal family more over the past 10 years. I think the Queen is like a living relic of our great history as a country and she is the one thing that seems to unite the country a little. We are such a painfully divided island I do dread the day there's no more royal family/Queen.

To a PP who said without the royal family people would still visit the estates/palaces- I'm not sure it would generate anywhere near the revenue you might think if there's no longer anyone on the throne, maybe?

MasterBeth · 05/06/2022 22:06

I love Queen Stacey.

FoiledByTheInsect · 05/06/2022 22:06

Romeoalpha Seriously. National identity??? I am absolutely ashamed to be British and automatically associated with those people and a country too backwards to even think it's necessary to update its political system.

FoiledByTheInsect · 05/06/2022 22:01

Florenz · 05/06/2022 21:34

How much money do we pay to politicians and in return we get? And people want to replace the Queen with yet another politician?

The concept of an impartial referee-type president, Ireland or Italy style, really isn't rocket science nor is it that hard to implement. They step in to uphold the constitution if necessary. The advantage of having a constitution is that a country actually knows what it stands for so has a chance - in theory if not always in practice - of upholding those values.

Unlike the UK which has no clue about what it stands for except what the BBC and the RF propaganda machine tell it to stand for.

BBC "Look, plebs, 70 years of devoted service"

Plebs "Ooh doesn't she look good for her age oh yes we must be such a strong and stable democracy"

Romeoalpha · 05/06/2022 22:00

I don’t ‘love’ the Royal family. However, I think we are better off keeping them, at least for now, for the following reasons:

  • Democracy is imperfect. I support it, but like capitalism it has its downsides - you know what they say about the people who pursue power being the least suitable to wield it? Just look at the bunch of tossers and chancers we have chosen for ourselves recently. At least the royals give us something better to aspire to.

  • And yes, I know historically they are a dubious lot, and that the institution can be seen to represent the class system and inequality. But we can’t change the past sadly, and in the here and now I think they do rather a good job of raising awareness of important causes and serving the public.

  • And YES, I know they are supported by taxpayers money. But think about the money we send off to google, facebook, amazon, etc every day - disgustingly rich corporations who avoid paying taxes and who co tribute little to nothing to the culture and success of our nation. I can’t get that exercised about some of my taxes going to the royal family, but the amount I end up unwillingly giving to monopolistic corporations makes me feel ill.

*Finally, I think they are an important part of our national identity and reminder of our history. I definitely think there is work to be done to modernise the monarchy, a bit of ‘rebranding’ is you like to move away from associations of empire etc. But we shouldn’t ‘cancel’ history we should remember and learn from it. Alongside the transient short-termist world of politics I think keeping in touch with the long view is v.important.

StoneofDestiny · 05/06/2022 21:58

I don't love the Queen or her family. The whole institution of monarchy is an affront to democracy.
Chronic injustice having a family elevated above all others, destined to live in extraordinary privilege with jobs guaranteed for life. Appalling, that they have abundance of palaces, most lying empty for most of the year, when so many have no roof over their head.
As for the Queen being a model of duty, service and moral values etc etc. Not a bit of it. She had to be forced to pay taxes. Forced!
We have to pay to keep her family in the manner they expect, but she never wanted to contribute to societies essentials without being made to.
She tolerated her racist, misogynistic arrogant husband and equally openly supports her son who has just paid £12 million to shut down a case of child abuse! Flaunted her support for all to see.
As for hard working - gawd help us if that's the definition of hard work. No serious hard graft, stress by over demands in your time, no threat of redundancy, no threat of relocation or wage cut. In fact, no worry about childcare, feeding your children, educating them or their future employment. No worry about housekeeping, heating costs, clothing budget, cleaning, transport or home security. All taken care of.

jimboandthejetset · 05/06/2022 21:34

@Overthewine well wasn't that a lovely way to describe some of the British population? Do you honestly think it's just "thugs who watch daytime TV" who don't understand the point of the monarchy? Is just not getting it an education thing?
I'm highly educated, I don't watch daytime TV, and I certainly don't understand the adulation they get.
But on the other hand, if no one cares what she says, why has she been slated for it?
As someone else has pointed out, there is an irony to people talking about SS earning her money as someone who started in reality TV when the RF and the queen are the biggest and by far the richest reality TV stars out there...

Florenz · 05/06/2022 21:34

How much money do we pay to politicians and in return we get? And people want to replace the Queen with yet another politician?

RepublicOfNarnia · 05/06/2022 21:31

Will her death or funeral be a public holiday? Or even Charles' coronation be a public holiday?

Hawkins001 · 05/06/2022 21:23

10yearoldwisdom · 05/06/2022 21:02

I disagree with the concept of monarchy and aristocracy. It rewards and protects those of us with the greediest and most cut throat ancestors, rather than those of us who work the hardest or provide the most key functions of society.

However.

I have grown to respect and be grateful for the Queen. She was an amazing role model and leader during the pandemic. The pictures of her alone at Prince Phillips funeral made me cry and admire her more. Comparing her leadership with the government, and Boris, in particular is a stark and depressing thing to do. She also reminds me of my Grandma who died recently which gives me a real soft spot for her. I’ll be genuinely sad when she dies.

I think Harry and William speaking out about their loss and the impact on their mental health has also been helpful.

Prince Andrew should be cut off and cast out. Dreadful man.

I don’t think public money should be spent on propping the institution up and I am all for a massive redistribution of wealth. The gaping chasm between rich and poor at the moment is shameful.

With regards to the redistribution of wealth, let's say everyone gets a set amout, how long before we are at similar levels again, as some.will spend, some save, some invest and rebuild wealth, then what ? Keep redistributing ?

Overthewine · 05/06/2022 21:21

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

pedropony76 · 05/06/2022 21:10

I know I must sound like I’m being purposely obtuse here and I promise I’m not.

But I really don’t understand this The pictures of her alone at Prince Phillips funeral made me cry and admire her more
The Queen is a regular human like you and me. She’s not a God. Just a human who was randomly born into this life. What is there to cry about and admire? I seriously just don’t get it.

Tbh I’ve accepted that I’ll never really understand why people are so moved by The Queen/TRF or are so invested in them because I just see them as regular people. I don’t look at them as kind/generous people or people who represent anything. I just look at them as people who do a specific type of job and nothing more than that really. Thank you for all of the comments as it’s definitely giving me a deeper understanding of what others think

OP posts:
Sparklingbrook · 05/06/2022 21:08

I don't know why everyone is so bothered about what SS thinks, she's on a lunchtime chat show (which nobody on MN confesses to watch) where the panel chat and give their opinions, so she gave hers...