Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do you love The Royal Family?

288 replies

pedropony76 · 05/06/2022 18:39

I previously posted this on The Royal Family board but only received one response so wanted to post here for traffic.

For those that love The Queen & The Royal Family, can you actually explain why?

I often see MNetters saying ‘Oh I love The Queen, I love this member and that member’ but no one ever says why. I came across the video of Stacey Solomon saying she doesn’t get why the country is so obsessed with this family as it could be any one of us born into royalty and I totally agree.

For me, when I think of The Royal Family, I instantly think of colonialism and how many of the jewels on the Queen’s crown has been stolen from different countries. I understand not everyone thinks like this but why do some love the members of this establishment as if they’ve done anything to better your life? I’d love to hear people’s views. I’ve tried to have this conversation in real life but everyone I know couldn’t care less about The Royal Family so I’m none the wiser.

Here’s the Stacey Solomon clip for any who haven’t seen it before

OP posts:
Discovereads · 06/06/2022 06:53

FoiledByTheInsect · 06/06/2022 06:15

Queen not political? Have a look at the Privy Council, Orders in Council and closed decisions on invading other countries before trotting out that myth for the hundredth time.

The queen and the creepy medieval political traditions have for decades been used as political instruments (or she's manipulated the governments on both sides of the HoC, depending on your POV).

Interesting that people who've literally bought into a fairytale of Benevolent Queen, artfully woven since 1953 (complete with hologram in the jubilee carriage) are talking about conspiracy theories.

PA was only able to do what he did because he was "royal". Door opening for corrupt foreign deals etc.

I’m sorry but you are wrong and grossly mistaken about the Queen’s role. Since the Act of Union in 1707, Parliament has been our de facto ruler above the judiciary, executive, monarchy and church. And within Parliament, the democratically elected House of Commons is at the apex of power over the now advisory House of Lords. Decisions to “invade countries” have absolutely nothing to do with the Queen. The Prime Minister and his/her Cabinet retain the constitutional right to decide when and where to authorise military action. They don’t even have to put it to a Parliamentary vote although in more recent times they have done so.

As for the Privy Council it is how inter-departmental Government agreements are reached by ministers. Orders in council’ are personally approved by the Queen during meetings (albeit after ministers have reached an agreement to recommend approval beforehand). ‘Orders of council’ do not require the approval of the Queen – only by ministers in their role as privy counsellors.

However, the process for Orders in Council is that the lord president reads out the orders of the day, which are approved by the Queen. Although she can in principle refuse, approval is now merely regarded as a formality – much in the same way that royal assent is granted to acts of parliament. As in, the Queen de facto has no choice but to approve whatever the councillors decide just like she has no choice but has to approve acts of Parliament.

She has no political power and per our Constitution has to be politically neutral. The Queen doesn’t even have a vote in elections nor can she stand for election like we common people do due to this convention on political neutrality. She can take no blame or credit for any of the successive governments that have come and gone during her lifetime of service.

And it’s completely ridiculous in regards to Prince Andrew that you seriously think you have to be a royal to enable having sex with a 17yr old girl. This in a country where every year around 150 16-17yr old girls are married to men on average twenty years older than them and this is perfectly legal because of the parental consent loophole. And on the illegal side, girls under 18 make up 25% of all females trafficked for sex in the U.K. meaning literally thousands of girls under age 18 are being forced to have sex with adult men every day. Yes Prince Andrew is despicable, but to say he could only do what he did because he was royal is complete idiocy.

Blossomtoes · 06/06/2022 06:35

Discovereads · 05/06/2022 23:23

God save the Queen.
I do in fact love the Queen. We both like marmalade sandwiches. That’s a good enough reason for me. (Not going to say my real reasons why because the OP and others seem vested in mocking anyone and everyone who loves the Queen.)

It’s always the same on these threads. The bingo card goes:

Cap doffing
Forelock tugging
Bowing and scraping
Fawning
Inbred
Versailles
No place in a modern democracy (despite 12 other European modern democracies having monarchies)

It’s fashionable to be a republican these days, despite the obvious pleasure, evidenced so clearly over the last four days, that so many of us take in having a monarchy. No republic could replicate the joy, pride and sense of belonging displayed and articulated this weekend.

HistoricMoment · 06/06/2022 06:20

@10yearoldwisdom The pictures of her alone at Prince Phillips funeral made me cry and admire her more.
Do you also admire every lonely widow who had to bear the loss of her husband on her own during lockdown? Presumably not.
I think many people get attached to the RF because they give them an emotional focus, a bit like getting attached to personalities on Coronation Street etc. They are people whose lives you can follow, gossip about and admire from a safe distance, without all the messiness of real life relationships.

I'm a republican and don't spend much time thinking about the RF, but the fact they get so much public money when so many are struggling is a scandal that should start a revolution in my opinion. Their "service to the people" consists in shaking a few hands, talking a lot about various issues without actually doing anything about them, and smiling for the cameras in a soup kitchen or whatever. How about giving the state 10 million of their superfluous cash for the NHS, or children growing up in poverty? Now that would be a service to the people!

FoiledByTheInsect · 06/06/2022 06:15

Romeoalpha · 05/06/2022 23:19

Well, sorry to disappoint! I actually think we probably agree on more than we disagree on, and I am 100% with you re. electoral reform. But the royal family are not political so I don’t actually see how they are propping up the Tories? Sounds like a conspiracy theory to me, The Queen has worked alongside Labour governments and Tory ones alike.

Prince Andrew is a sicko of course, but there are lots of non-royal sickos too. It’s not really tied up with him being royal, it’s just that he’s a twat.

Queen not political? Have a look at the Privy Council, Orders in Council and closed decisions on invading other countries before trotting out that myth for the hundredth time.

The queen and the creepy medieval political traditions have for decades been used as political instruments (or she's manipulated the governments on both sides of the HoC, depending on your POV).

Interesting that people who've literally bought into a fairytale of Benevolent Queen, artfully woven since 1953 (complete with hologram in the jubilee carriage) are talking about conspiracy theories.

PA was only able to do what he did because he was "royal". Door opening for corrupt foreign deals etc.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 06/06/2022 05:08

I agree OP. I'm not a royalist in any shape or form. Having said that, I'm not a republican either. I'm pretty indifferent.
I accept some people love the theatre of it all, and that's fine. I'm sure some members of the royal family are lovely, and some not-so-lovely, just like society generally. That's the thing, they're just people! I don't get the bowing down to them; any more than I get the adulation of celebrities (that's odd too). But each to their own.
Apart from watching the Paddington Bear clip on YouTube (which was lovely) I largely ignored the Jubilee. But have no problem with other people celebrating.
If there was a referendum tomorrow on whether to keep the monarchy or not, I don't think I'd vote. I'm that indifferent...

Blossomtoes · 06/06/2022 05:04

MissTrip82 · 06/06/2022 01:05

It makes me feel sick to hear people describing the Queen as their ‘moral compass’.

How low can your standards be? My God.

As low as the PM perhaps. Compare and contrast the two.

lolanthe · 06/06/2022 03:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Is this a joke? Nothing in between those two extremes 🤔

I doubt Stacey Solomon (who a pp has kindly told me is a tv presenter) would make the shortlist for an elected head of state.

pedropony76 · 06/06/2022 02:55

Also I’m not sure why people are dragging Stacey Solomon? I don’t watch Loose Women or daytime TV. I actually saw the video on Twitter and linked the YT clip as it was a few mins longer. Just posted it because I saw it and agreed with her

OP posts:
pedropony76 · 06/06/2022 02:53

MissTrip82 · 06/06/2022 01:05

It makes me feel sick to hear people describing the Queen as their ‘moral compass’.

How low can your standards be? My God.

Exactly. I don’t get it either

OP posts:
pedropony76 · 06/06/2022 02:53

SleepSleepRaveAsleep · 06/06/2022 00:25

I don't and I'm so glad Stacey actually came out and said it. I don't get any of it, I don't get the fawning over them they are just people born into a family and I really don't get what people mean when they thank her "for all that you've done for us". What has she done??? She's never done a day's work (reading a speech someone else wrote and shaking hands isnt work) and she's lived a life of utter privilege 🤔. I think once the Queen dies it'd be a good time to get rid of the royal family. People are struggling to afford to live yet here we have these people telling us either how hard it is 🤣 or how we should save the environment, then goes home in their private helicopter lol.

Yes thank you! This is literally my point. I really don’t understand any of it and I don’t think The Queen has done a day’s work either. Some of the more recent comments saying that The Queen has done her duty for X amount of years. It’s her job? She didn’t just wake up one day and think ‘do you know what. I want to go to all these charity events, give speeches on the TV’ and all the other things that she does. The Royal Family is a massive institution that has advisors and the whole lot. It’s not like they’re just doing this out of the goodness of their own heart. She has a job and some may say she’s done it well but I don’t see how that makes her such an amazing person. Each to their own I guess

OP posts:
WakeMeUpWhenTheyHaveGone · 06/06/2022 02:11

Batshit.

Notaneffingcockerspaniel · 06/06/2022 02:07

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

MissTrip82 · 06/06/2022 01:05

It makes me feel sick to hear people describing the Queen as their ‘moral compass’.

How low can your standards be? My God.

SleepSleepRaveAsleep · 06/06/2022 00:25

I don't and I'm so glad Stacey actually came out and said it. I don't get any of it, I don't get the fawning over them they are just people born into a family and I really don't get what people mean when they thank her "for all that you've done for us". What has she done??? She's never done a day's work (reading a speech someone else wrote and shaking hands isnt work) and she's lived a life of utter privilege 🤔. I think once the Queen dies it'd be a good time to get rid of the royal family. People are struggling to afford to live yet here we have these people telling us either how hard it is 🤣 or how we should save the environment, then goes home in their private helicopter lol.

Thatswhyimacat · 06/06/2022 00:20

@TarasHarp55 yes I agree, hence my caveat about them knowing how to behave, of course I hardly think Macron or Trudeau are going to make a faux pas, but there is an underlying level of additional respect that I wouldn't expect someone like eg Macron to observe.

I agree it could all be better, I'm no massive royalist, but right now I'd take them over the government if I didn't really deep down believe in that pesky democracy.

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 00:15

Thatswhyimacat · 06/06/2022 00:12

I've got no dog in the fight but the Queen does seem to have a certain level of respect from leaders across the world. I would say it was just because most leaders, except ours, know how to behave, but even Donald Trump was nice to her.

Well they don't have much choice do they when she's presented to them. They're hardly going to embarrass themselves being rude to her. But it could be so much better.

Thatswhyimacat · 06/06/2022 00:12

I've got no dog in the fight but the Queen does seem to have a certain level of respect from leaders across the world. I would say it was just because most leaders, except ours, know how to behave, but even Donald Trump was nice to her.

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 00:08

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 00:00

Government contracts and deals could be done by a president, probably someone more accomplished too. Maybe someone who has the know how to strike a harder bargain.

What are you on about? The Queen/RF don’t do and have zero influence over government contracts and deals.

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 00:06

leotardrock · 05/06/2022 23:40

Crosser not corset!

Someone will be on in a second to tell us getting rid of the Royal Family will give us £350M per week to the NHS! 🙄

No it certainly wouldn't make a tap of difference. But what an outrage, to give all that money to one already super rich family.

Meanwhile we are going through the worst cost of living crisis we've ever known. It will literally be a case of eat or keep warm for some families. But as long as queenie's ok what the hell.

jimboandthejetset · 06/06/2022 00:00

It's interesting that people trot out "she does so much for our country" but no one says what she actually does.
Plus having a shit government is not a reason to be thankful for the queen or RF. I can blame Boris and the Tories for fucking up our country and for leading us to Brexit, as well as being a republican who thinks the RF are pointless in modern day society.

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 00:00

Government contracts and deals could be done by a president, probably someone more accomplished too. Maybe someone who has the know how to strike a harder bargain.

TarasHarp55 · 05/06/2022 23:57

leotardrock · 05/06/2022 23:49

Taras and yet the Queen is rolled out at the G8, she holds dinners at Buckingham Palace for visiting foreign dignitaries because she is so respected by other Foreign leaders!

She is used for obtaining Govt Contracts & Trade Deals, maybe not so much now but she most definitely was!

That doesn't impress me. There are plenty of places that would serve just as well. The queen has often hosted despots too. So nothing to admire about that.

1dayatatime · 05/06/2022 23:53

.

TarasHarp55 · 05/06/2022 23:52

Xtraincome · 05/06/2022 22:10

I have so little faith in elected leaders and government so have grown to like (some of) the Royal family more over the past 10 years. I think the Queen is like a living relic of our great history as a country and she is the one thing that seems to unite the country a little. We are such a painfully divided island I do dread the day there's no more royal family/Queen.

To a PP who said without the royal family people would still visit the estates/palaces- I'm not sure it would generate anywhere near the revenue you might think if there's no longer anyone on the throne, maybe?

It didn't do France any harm. Visitors to the Palace of Versailles dwarfs Buckingham Palace. Also royal palaces etc are quite low on the most visited places. Besides all that though tourism isn't a strong enough reason to keep a monarchy.

leotardrock · 05/06/2022 23:49

Taras and yet the Queen is rolled out at the G8, she holds dinners at Buckingham Palace for visiting foreign dignitaries because she is so respected by other Foreign leaders!

She is used for obtaining Govt Contracts & Trade Deals, maybe not so much now but she most definitely was!