Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do you love The Royal Family?

288 replies

pedropony76 · 05/06/2022 18:39

I previously posted this on The Royal Family board but only received one response so wanted to post here for traffic.

For those that love The Queen & The Royal Family, can you actually explain why?

I often see MNetters saying ‘Oh I love The Queen, I love this member and that member’ but no one ever says why. I came across the video of Stacey Solomon saying she doesn’t get why the country is so obsessed with this family as it could be any one of us born into royalty and I totally agree.

For me, when I think of The Royal Family, I instantly think of colonialism and how many of the jewels on the Queen’s crown has been stolen from different countries. I understand not everyone thinks like this but why do some love the members of this establishment as if they’ve done anything to better your life? I’d love to hear people’s views. I’ve tried to have this conversation in real life but everyone I know couldn’t care less about The Royal Family so I’m none the wiser.

Here’s the Stacey Solomon clip for any who haven’t seen it before

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 06/06/2022 08:10

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 07:34

You do know that the Queen also pays income and capital gains taxes to the State on her private income? She volunteered to do this in 1992 and has done so since.

But that's tax out of OUR tax. There's a difference....We give her millions, she's giving a bit of it back. Nothing admirable about it.

Nobody ever admired me for paying tax.🙄

No, it isn’t tax on our tax. The RF is privately wealthy, they pay tax on income independent of the taxpayer. In any event, every public sector employee pays tax on our tax, shall we criticise them too?

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 08:08

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 08:02

Quite true, but why should we have to tolerate it from a member of the royal family....

The queen (who never puts a foot wrong) didn't care and gave him her blessing. 😣
Why so many people put this family on a pedestal never fails to amaze me.

Funny that stripping someone of all their royal titles and roles…basically giving them the sack is “a blessing”.

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 08:07

The biggest PR scoop ever has been convincing the masses that the wealthiest people in the country who own vast swathes of our land are somehow connected to our value or morality as a nation.

The Queen and RF are not the wealthiest people in the country. They don’t even make the top 250 wealthiest people of the U.K. Rich List.

Roussette · 06/06/2022 08:06

Curtsey to any of them? Not likely. Never ever.

I mean... come on.... is this what we are in the 21st century? Here's Zara looking like she's sat on the toilet

Why do you love The Royal Family?
Fairislefandango · 06/06/2022 08:04

I'm not a fan. I don't hate them, and I can't get myself that worked up about their cost and privilege. I just think the whole thing is an anachronism. I do find it really weird how much some people love them, in the same way that I am baffled by how invested people are in celebrities in general, and how they actually seem to feel they 'know' them.

'But how would you feel about president Boris?' is a total non-argument imo. Having a figurehead monarch doesn't really do anything to mitigate the effects of a poor government (as is very evident atm). Any country can end up with an arse of a leader.

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 08:02

Artwodeetoo · 06/06/2022 07:53

PA was only able to do what he did because he was "royal"

This applies to all men with an ounce of power or fame though. They're so used to people falling over themselves to spend time with them or being told how wonderful they are that they do feel entitled. I'm not excusing what he did of course, but it's not limited to him being a royal. It's epidemic amongst men, just look at how many MPs are being investigated, how many celebrities fell out of me too etc.

Quite true, but why should we have to tolerate it from a member of the royal family....

The queen (who never puts a foot wrong) didn't care and gave him her blessing. 😣
Why so many people put this family on a pedestal never fails to amaze me.

Roussette · 06/06/2022 08:00

I would love people to read this book. Its author is a respected person, formerly a member of the Privy Council, MP, Parliamentary Under Secretary of State etc.

I imagine a lot of Royalists won't read it because they would hate what it says.... the truth. An eye opener.

www.amazon.co.uk/What-Do-You-Royal-Family-ebook/dp/B07RN38QC5

Zebedee55 · 06/06/2022 07:57

The Monarch doesn't pay IHT, on personal or other wealth, nor do certain other members of the RF.

The Queen paid nothing when her mother died, and Charles won't pay anything when the Queen dies.

www.express.co.uk/news/royal/1508459/Royal-family-inheritance-tax-queen-evg

Herani · 06/06/2022 07:56

I respect the Queen as a person handsomely compensated for the role she does, but like all societies, we change. I think Prince Charles has it very right with regards to seriously trimming down to just the ‘senior’ royals, whose role is to simply act as figureheads there for hosting state visitors, highlighting charities and representatives. If we’re going to keep this anachronism, it needs to be streamlined to the essentials.

The Queen, as a person who was born into a role and has made the best of it, is still guilty of excess with regards to the grace and favour living of obscure family members and allowing the royal ‘business’ to try and avoid rules applied to other people (Scottish environmental/carbon tax implications - Google it).
I think titles should now be abolished as they are about division and placing one person, without merit, above another. We are a much more equal society now, thank goodness.

What on earth is ‘divine right’ in todays scientific world? And why should people curtesy to someone like Duchess Kate or Prince Edward? (Both probably lovely people, but again, just people doing a handsomely paid job).
We can’t change the division of wealth or sadly, land ownership, but we shouldn’t continue this remnant of a feudal system. The biggest PR scoop ever has been convincing the masses that the wealthiest people in the country who own vast swathes of our land are somehow connected to our value or morality as a nation.

balalake · 06/06/2022 07:53

I would not describe my feelings as love for the Royal Family. Mine is that given the choice between the history and tradition of the Monarchy and having the political process of an elected president, I'd choose the monarchy. I'd take away any formal or theoretical political role.

Roussette · 06/06/2022 07:53

Yes Prince Andrew is despicable, but to say he could only do what he did because he was royal is complete idiocy

Do you honestly think Jeffrey Epstein would've been schmoozing plain old Andrew Smith who lives in Bolton? PA was open to flattery by extremely wealthy men, and despots and dodgy dictators sucked up to him because he was Royal and could open doors. From then on came parties with young girls and the rest is history.

Artwodeetoo · 06/06/2022 07:53

PA was only able to do what he did because he was "royal"

This applies to all men with an ounce of power or fame though. They're so used to people falling over themselves to spend time with them or being told how wonderful they are that they do feel entitled. I'm not excusing what he did of course, but it's not limited to him being a royal. It's epidemic amongst men, just look at how many MPs are being investigated, how many celebrities fell out of me too etc.

Artwodeetoo · 06/06/2022 07:49

I wouldn't say I love the royal family, but I do like the Queen. I don't really get the narrative that she's never worked a day in her life though- she volunteered for the land army and actually genuinely got stuck in, she could have hidden away at home and been excused from it. She's had engagements practically every day, and no not insinuating this is hard manual labour but neither are all jobs. But having all of your time accounted for must be quite suffocating.

I wonder how much of it is because she's a woman, if it was a king I'm sure some would view it more as work. I'm not sure she should carry the burden of colonialism either really.

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 07:45

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 07:35

Why shouldn't the queen pay inheritance tax too. I find this grossly unfair.

The reason she isn’t paying inheritance tax on Prince Phillips estate is because no inheritance tax is due for married couples when one spouse dies. This applies to every married couple in the U.K.

She paid inheritance tax when her mother died. It’s been the case since 1973 that royals have to pay inheritance tax on their private assets.

What’s not taxable is the Crown Estate but that’s not the Queens wealth, it belongs to the State (and we the taxpayers) and is the source of the Sovereign Grant we pay her as reimbursement for her work as a ceremonial head of state.

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 07:37

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 07:34

You do know that the Queen also pays income and capital gains taxes to the State on her private income? She volunteered to do this in 1992 and has done so since.

But that's tax out of OUR tax. There's a difference....We give her millions, she's giving a bit of it back. Nothing admirable about it.

Nobody ever admired me for paying tax.🙄

No, this is tax on her private wealth and is not anything to do with the public funds from the Sovereign Grant that we give her.

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 07:35

Why shouldn't the queen pay inheritance tax too. I find this grossly unfair.

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 07:34

You do know that the Queen also pays income and capital gains taxes to the State on her private income? She volunteered to do this in 1992 and has done so since.

But that's tax out of OUR tax. There's a difference....We give her millions, she's giving a bit of it back. Nothing admirable about it.

Nobody ever admired me for paying tax.🙄

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 07:28

LateAF · 06/06/2022 07:17

@Discovereads And I haven’t even touched on the Americas. What do you think happened to the natives? No military force used? It was worse than what’s happening in Ukraine- systematic force and genocide. Your attempts to minimise colonialism and British Invasion of the empire territories are offensive and inexcusable.

However, having seen your previous posts defending Prince Andrew, I won’t engage with you further.

You have misunderstood or I have misunderstood what you meant by “at its beginning colonialism…”. English Colonialism literally began with families of refugees from England colonising North America (Plymouth being the first successful colony founded by England outside the U.K.). It was from this initial beginning that everything else devolved in regard to English colonialism. Of course colonies were later founded and expanded by military force in later years, I never said otherwise. I don’t think it’s minimising to point out that at its beginning colonialism wasn’t about invading and taking over foreign kingdoms. Much of what is evil in the world starts out seeming to be reasonable and relatively harmless.

Also, I did not defend Prince Andrew, I said he was despicable but it’s idiocy to think a U.K. 16/17yr old girl is only in danger from a royal wanting to have sex with them when thousands of girls in this age bracket are being married off or trafficked and forced to have sex with adult men daily in this country. Surely you can see that the poster I was responding to was minimising the extent of sexual abuse of girls under 18 by saying Prince Andrew was only able to do that because he was royal. It ignores all the other girls similarly sexually assaulted and abused by the thousands of nonroyal men in this country.

LateAF · 06/06/2022 07:17

LateAF · 06/06/2022 07:11

Your ignorance is staggering and offensive. Militarily force was used to invade Nigeria and Ghana just to name two. Thousands of men, women and children killed by British infantry. The Caribbean colonies were built and colonised on the back of British slavery. What the fuck are you talking about with a few ships of religious refugees?! You’re embarrassing yourself.

@Discovereads And I haven’t even touched on the Americas. What do you think happened to the natives? No military force used? It was worse than what’s happening in Ukraine- systematic force and genocide. Your attempts to minimise colonialism and British Invasion of the empire territories are offensive and inexcusable.

However, having seen your previous posts defending Prince Andrew, I won’t engage with you further.

restedbutexhausted · 06/06/2022 07:16

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 07:05

The word colonialism lessens the impact of what colonialism actually entailed, but colonialism at its beginning looked like the present Russian invasion of Ukraine.

Sure it did. A few ships carrying families of religious refugees landing on the shore looks exactly like tanks and soldiers invading under cover of shelling and mortar bombardment.

This thought should have remained in your head. Staggeringly ignorant.

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 07:14

LateAF · 06/06/2022 07:11

Your ignorance is staggering and offensive. Militarily force was used to invade Nigeria and Ghana just to name two. Thousands of men, women and children killed by British infantry. The Caribbean colonies were built and colonised on the back of British slavery. What the fuck are you talking about with a few ships of religious refugees?! You’re embarrassing yourself.

I’m taking about the beginning of colonialism. You’re referring to the apex of colonialism that occurred over 200yrs after its beginning.

LateAF · 06/06/2022 07:11

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 07:05

The word colonialism lessens the impact of what colonialism actually entailed, but colonialism at its beginning looked like the present Russian invasion of Ukraine.

Sure it did. A few ships carrying families of religious refugees landing on the shore looks exactly like tanks and soldiers invading under cover of shelling and mortar bombardment.

Your ignorance is staggering and offensive. Militarily force was used to invade Nigeria and Ghana just to name two. Thousands of men, women and children killed by British infantry. The Caribbean colonies were built and colonised on the back of British slavery. What the fuck are you talking about with a few ships of religious refugees?! You’re embarrassing yourself.

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 07:05

The word colonialism lessens the impact of what colonialism actually entailed, but colonialism at its beginning looked like the present Russian invasion of Ukraine.

Sure it did. A few ships carrying families of religious refugees landing on the shore looks exactly like tanks and soldiers invading under cover of shelling and mortar bombardment.

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 07:01

How about giving the state 10 million of their superfluous cash for the NHS, or children growing up in poverty? Now that would be a service to the people!

As a matter of fact, the Guardian reported that as of ten years ago, the Queen has done more for charity than any other monarch raising over £1.4billion for hundreds of charities. www.theguardian.com/voluntary-sector-network/2012/jun/11/queen-charitable-support

You do know that the Queen also pays income and capital gains taxes to the State on her private income? She volunteered to do this in 1992 and has done so since.

LateAF · 06/06/2022 07:00

DuvetHugger · 05/06/2022 23:00

To be fair, I don't think Stacey has done much to deserve her wealth either.

I'm fond if the Royal family, I'd love to know more about how they live day to day and also love the pomp and ceremony and rituals. But no, I don't love them.

No, no more than a banker who went to private school and had all the contacts to forge an easy career in banking. Stacey made the most of the options available to her from the circumstances she was born into. That’s the way capitalist society works- so in that sense, while she might not subjectively “deserve” her wealth, she has objectively “earned” it. Just like all the other high paying careers such as bankers, city lawyers, actors etc.

The monarchy neither earn or deserve the wealth. Their lot, constitutional and political position and soft power is given to them by virtue of birthright alone, and we the public have no say. Their position has no place in modern politics and society and I can’t believe people are defending it.

To me the queen represents nepotism at its peak level, stolen wealth, and colonialism. The word colonialism lessens the impact of what colonialism actually entailed, but colonialism at its beginning looked like the present Russian invasion of Ukraine. None of the countries voluntarily gave their land, power, culture, historic artefacts, jewels and wealth voluntarily to the British Empire. Countless lives were lost, tribes wiped out, possessions stolen, families displaced - and the queen in her reign presided over the Empire and still to this day wears those stolen jewels, while those stolen artefacts are on display or lie unused in the basements of our London museums.

To this day we see the negative impact of colonialism - windrush, conflicts such as in Nigeria where the north and south are culturally and tribally distinct and should never have been lumped together as one country. I can never celebrate an old woman who represents an institution that caused so much pain around the world and reigned over and made Empire-related decisions. Beyond the nepotism that Stacey Solomon called out, the whole institution is sinister and I will never celebrate it.