Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do you love The Royal Family?

288 replies

pedropony76 · 05/06/2022 18:39

I previously posted this on The Royal Family board but only received one response so wanted to post here for traffic.

For those that love The Queen & The Royal Family, can you actually explain why?

I often see MNetters saying ‘Oh I love The Queen, I love this member and that member’ but no one ever says why. I came across the video of Stacey Solomon saying she doesn’t get why the country is so obsessed with this family as it could be any one of us born into royalty and I totally agree.

For me, when I think of The Royal Family, I instantly think of colonialism and how many of the jewels on the Queen’s crown has been stolen from different countries. I understand not everyone thinks like this but why do some love the members of this establishment as if they’ve done anything to better your life? I’d love to hear people’s views. I’ve tried to have this conversation in real life but everyone I know couldn’t care less about The Royal Family so I’m none the wiser.

Here’s the Stacey Solomon clip for any who haven’t seen it before

OP posts:
Roussette · 06/06/2022 08:43

The Queen is the largest land owner in the world.

www.businessinsider.com/worlds-biggest-landowners-2011-3#1-queen-elizabeth-ii-15

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 08:42

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 08:34

That's as may be, but all that does is highlight how enormously wealthy she is. Wealth hoarded through the centuries through theft from the people. The queen didn't "volunteer" tax for the good of the country either. There was an ulterior motive.

Dont be silly, paying income and capital gains tax doesn’t highlight enormous wealth as we all pay those taxes, or at least anyone making more than£12,500 per a year does. Hardly have to be rolling in money to pay income taxes. And the Queen isn’t even on the U.K. Rich List. She’s not that rich.

Oh, an “ulterior motive” is there? That just highlights your bias and prejudice. She can’t win with you can she? She does good for the country and to you that is proof she is bad.

Roussette · 06/06/2022 08:41

Blossomtoes · 06/06/2022 08:39

how enormously wealthy she is.

She’s not though. She barely makes the rich list these days and Sunak’s net worth is double hers.

If you are talking the Sunday Times Rich List, which is pure guesswork.... of course she doesn't! It's all shrouded in mystery

Roussette · 06/06/2022 08:40

they also are happy for their financial reports to be published and subject to the same scrutiny as any other public spending ie audit etc; really opaque that

Should we be grateful for that? Your post implies we should.

OF COURSE their financial reports should be published!

Blossomtoes · 06/06/2022 08:39

how enormously wealthy she is.

She’s not though. She barely makes the rich list these days and Sunak’s net worth is double hers.

Roussette · 06/06/2022 08:39

You haven't read the book then. OK.

Artwodeetoo · 06/06/2022 08:39

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 08:34

That's as may be, but all that does is highlight how enormously wealthy she is. Wealth hoarded through the centuries through theft from the people. The queen didn't "volunteer" tax for the good of the country either. There was an ulterior motive.

An ulterior motive, take your tin foil hat off. If she hadn't volunteered to pay tax its not like it would have affected her really is it? They also are happy for their financial reports to be published and subject to the same scrutiny as any other public spending ie audit etc; really opaque that.

www.royal.uk/royal-finances-0

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 08:37

Roussette · 06/06/2022 08:27

So you know the worth of the coastal areas the Monarchy owns, the sea beds, Regent St in London, retail parks, shopping centres, farms in Texas, the list is endless. To pick it apart and work out who owns what is impossible. How do you distinguish between the Crown's wealth and personal wealth. Much of this comes from conquests and of course colonialism.

She is the largest legal land owner in the world and you think you know all that worth? The estimate is between £16bn and £18bn, or more.

We are spoon fed what the Monarchy want us to know. I urge you to read the book I linked to. It will become clearer if you do.

No it’s not impossible to pick apart what is the Crown Estate (which is actually owned by us not the Queen) vs what the Queen actually privately owns. There are numerous webpages hosted by the Government with every asset listed and annual financial statements.

She is not the largest legal land owner in the world because that is the Catholic Church. The land value you are listing is not hers as she doesn’t own the land within the Crown Estate, we do (or rather the Government does). And we (the Government) get all the money from it, she doesnt. She only gets an allowance we pay her from the Crown Estate income as reimbursement for her ceremonial duties and work.

Im not going to read a book that is based on a lie that the Queen owns the Crown Estate, when by law she is not the owner at all.

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/06/2022 08:35

I’m not a royalist and I think the obsession with royalty in general is a negative force in our society (although I can see the argument for having a constitutional monarchy(.

But I do have masses of respect for the Queen as a person: her work ethic, fortitude, service and courage are pretty hard not to admire.

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 08:34

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 08:27

No it’s not “out of our tax”. You’re quite simply wrong. The Queen voluntarily pays income and capital gains tax on her private wealth. These tax payments are not from the sovereign grant we give her which come from the Crown Estate. And while the Crown Estate does belong to the State/we taxpayers, technically not even that money comes from our tax. The Crown Estates income is almost all business and rent income.

That's as may be, but all that does is highlight how enormously wealthy she is. Wealth hoarded through the centuries through theft from the people. The queen didn't "volunteer" tax for the good of the country either. There was an ulterior motive.

Roussette · 06/06/2022 08:33

You do know that the Queen also pays income and capital gains taxes to the State on her private income? She volunteered to do this in 1992 and has done so since

Only when she was forced to because of public opinion. She didn't choose to. The RF are not stupid, they know when they're not onto a winner and make adjustments to shut us all up

orwellwasright · 06/06/2022 08:31

I love how they perpetuate an ingrained class structure with all power and privilege being held by the wealthy.

I love how when they go on holiday they're carried around on special fancy armchairs by black people.

I love how they advise everyone of the dangers of climate change whilst having loads of kids and travelling on private planes.

I love how they hang out with paedophiles.

So much really.

QuizzlyBear · 06/06/2022 08:30

I mean come on, for fuck's sake. If that panel of angry badgers is the best we have to offer women in this country, then I'm more ashamed of that than anything else in our collective history.

I find it deeply disturbing that you apparently find the cast of Loose Women more offensive than our country's history of colonisation, slavery and the systemic oppression of women. Just wow.

HistoricMoment · 06/06/2022 08:30

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 07:01

How about giving the state 10 million of their superfluous cash for the NHS, or children growing up in poverty? Now that would be a service to the people!

As a matter of fact, the Guardian reported that as of ten years ago, the Queen has done more for charity than any other monarch raising over £1.4billion for hundreds of charities. www.theguardian.com/voluntary-sector-network/2012/jun/11/queen-charitable-support

You do know that the Queen also pays income and capital gains taxes to the State on her private income? She volunteered to do this in 1992 and has done so since.

That £1.4 billion isn't her own money though! It's other people's money she helped raise with her charitable work. No one knows how much she privately donates, though occasional donations make the news. I'm sure it's just a fraction of her wealth though.

Roussette · 06/06/2022 08:27

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 08:18

No they are not “totally opaque”. Their finances are published on the internet for all to see. Unlike most of the people actually on the Rich List.

So you know the worth of the coastal areas the Monarchy owns, the sea beds, Regent St in London, retail parks, shopping centres, farms in Texas, the list is endless. To pick it apart and work out who owns what is impossible. How do you distinguish between the Crown's wealth and personal wealth. Much of this comes from conquests and of course colonialism.

She is the largest legal land owner in the world and you think you know all that worth? The estimate is between £16bn and £18bn, or more.

We are spoon fed what the Monarchy want us to know. I urge you to read the book I linked to. It will become clearer if you do.

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 08:27

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 08:22

Of course it's out of our tax. We aren't talking of their private wealth. I'm talking about her annual income which is from the taxpayer. Why would I criticise pubic sector employees. I made the point because someone mentioned the queen paying tax as if it's admirable. It's from what we give her, fact.

No it’s not “out of our tax”. You’re quite simply wrong. The Queen voluntarily pays income and capital gains tax on her private wealth. These tax payments are not from the sovereign grant we give her which come from the Crown Estate. And while the Crown Estate does belong to the State/we taxpayers, technically not even that money comes from our tax. The Crown Estates income is almost all business and rent income.

Blossomtoes · 06/06/2022 08:25

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 08:22

Of course it's out of our tax. We aren't talking of their private wealth. I'm talking about her annual income which is from the taxpayer. Why would I criticise pubic sector employees. I made the point because someone mentioned the queen paying tax as if it's admirable. It's from what we give her, fact.

And also from her private income. Fact.

If you’re going to criticise the taxation source of one public servant, surely you have to criticise them all? Unless, of course, you don’t believe in consistency.

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 08:23

Zebedee55 · 06/06/2022 07:57

The Monarch doesn't pay IHT, on personal or other wealth, nor do certain other members of the RF.

The Queen paid nothing when her mother died, and Charles won't pay anything when the Queen dies.

www.express.co.uk/news/royal/1508459/Royal-family-inheritance-tax-queen-evg

The RF do in fact pay IHT. The only exemption special to the RF is that bequests between sovereigns are exempt of IHT. Might want to read what you linked. It’s not a blanket exception for the entire RF applying to all inheritance.

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 08:22

Blossomtoes · 06/06/2022 08:10

No, it isn’t tax on our tax. The RF is privately wealthy, they pay tax on income independent of the taxpayer. In any event, every public sector employee pays tax on our tax, shall we criticise them too?

Of course it's out of our tax. We aren't talking of their private wealth. I'm talking about her annual income which is from the taxpayer. Why would I criticise pubic sector employees. I made the point because someone mentioned the queen paying tax as if it's admirable. It's from what we give her, fact.

Roussette · 06/06/2022 08:18

Blossom Of course I know that. I am talking about PA and JE. Their relationship was based on money and royalty.
I know that is not always the case. In this instance, it was because he was Royal and 'useful'.

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 08:18

Roussette · 06/06/2022 08:10

Because their finances are totally opaque. That's why.

No they are not “totally opaque”. Their finances are published on the internet for all to see. Unlike most of the people actually on the Rich List.

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 08:16

Roussette · 06/06/2022 07:53

Yes Prince Andrew is despicable, but to say he could only do what he did because he was royal is complete idiocy

Do you honestly think Jeffrey Epstein would've been schmoozing plain old Andrew Smith who lives in Bolton? PA was open to flattery by extremely wealthy men, and despots and dodgy dictators sucked up to him because he was Royal and could open doors. From then on came parties with young girls and the rest is history.

That’s not exactly correct. All the sucking up happened because Prince Andrew was working as a Special Trade Representative. Anyone in that position would have been a target. No one was sucking up to him when he was flying helicopters for example.

Blossomtoes · 06/06/2022 08:14

Roussette · 06/06/2022 07:53

Yes Prince Andrew is despicable, but to say he could only do what he did because he was royal is complete idiocy

Do you honestly think Jeffrey Epstein would've been schmoozing plain old Andrew Smith who lives in Bolton? PA was open to flattery by extremely wealthy men, and despots and dodgy dictators sucked up to him because he was Royal and could open doors. From then on came parties with young girls and the rest is history.

Rousette, men don’t have be rich and powerful to abuse young girls. The Rotherham perverts were shopkeepers and taxi drivers.

Artwodeetoo · 06/06/2022 08:11

TarasHarp55 · 06/06/2022 08:02

Quite true, but why should we have to tolerate it from a member of the royal family....

The queen (who never puts a foot wrong) didn't care and gave him her blessing. 😣
Why so many people put this family on a pedestal never fails to amaze me.

I don't think people are tolerating it are they? Hes rightly been stripped of all of his Royal titles and duties, with family I think people would be surprised how many parents don't just abandon their children completely after stuff like this. I don't think that means she wasn't bothered about it. I'm sure many are convinced they would but who knows. The case against him wasn't really about whether he had sex with her (of course he did I don't believe she would lie), but about whether he knew she was trafficked. She was of legal age here, again not saying that makes it okay, but it means legally he wouldn't be brought to task for that. Unless there happened to be written correspondence (highly unlikely) where he was told she was trafficked he wouldn't have been found guilty. Actually a pay out was a good outcome for her as well, she sadly never would have got 'justice' if he had been questioned anyway.

Roussette · 06/06/2022 08:10

Discovereads · 06/06/2022 08:07

The biggest PR scoop ever has been convincing the masses that the wealthiest people in the country who own vast swathes of our land are somehow connected to our value or morality as a nation.

The Queen and RF are not the wealthiest people in the country. They don’t even make the top 250 wealthiest people of the U.K. Rich List.

Because their finances are totally opaque. That's why.