Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the stigmatisation of borderline personality disorder is awful

219 replies

PonderingBPD · 05/06/2022 16:29

Most people with BPD have experienced alot of trauma, typically during childhood, hence the disorder which has alot of parallels to complex PTSD. It's not something people choose to have and is actually soul destroying to live with.

Why are people with the condition spoken of and thought of so negatively? It's essentially victim blaming.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Dinneronmybfpillow · 05/06/2022 18:23

I also hate when people pretend BPD is bipolar to avoid stigma. This only adds stigma to bipolar and confuses the symptoms. They're completely different illnesses.

On the flip side, it also serves to further the stigma against BPD. We've seen it on this thread already, multiple people offering differential diagnoses as a more palatable option for the OP.

Anon1717 · 05/06/2022 18:20

I dated someone with BPD for 18 months and he refused to go to therapy or actually treat it. Instead I ended up paying for months or therapy and being prescribed diazepam. One of his exes had him arrested four times for abuse and he still saw himself as the victim.

Not everyone with BPD is like that, but there's a big difference between those who seek treatment and those who don't.

I also hate when people pretend BPD is bipolar to avoid stigma. This only adds stigma to bipolar and confuses the symptoms. They're completely different illnesses.

Adventurine · 05/06/2022 18:16

I honestly think the "borderline" part leaves most people to think it's either mild or within the persons power to control/reverse it. As if it's not a full blown mental health issue, only that the person is at risk of becoming that way. Like borderline type 2 diabetic. Borderline obese. Borderline alcoholism. It makes it sound like an optional state which is totally reversible, which then makes it seem as though the person with BPD is wilfully being unpredictable and offensive to people if they're having bad days. Which in turn is why a lot of people seem to find BPD sufferers to be attention seekers and too much hard work. I think that the terminology paints a false picture.

Vivi0 · 05/06/2022 18:13

I can’t agree with this.

I’ve seen this argument used time and again to shut down people who have been raised by a BPD parent when talking about their experiences and associated trauma. I know that BPD does not look the same in every individual, but many people have endured abusive childhoods at the hands of their BPD parent.

I’ve seen people told they need to “have more empathy” towards their BPD parent. In what other situation would any victim be told to empathise more with their abuser.

So whilst I acknowledge that a BPD diagnosis comes with stigma, I don’t think it is “awful”.

LicoricePizza · 05/06/2022 18:12

PonderingBPD · 05/06/2022 16:42

As you might have guessed I (strongly suspect) have BPD.

My husband has aspergers. He's a wonderful person however some of his behaviours can be very difficult to live with indeed. He can have meltdowns and shut downs. He stonewalls (not intentionally, it's a defence mechanism)

If I have an episode then I'm clearly being manipulative and/or abusive.

If my husband has one, he can't help it he's autistic.

Yet there is no stigma attached to autism. Autism isn't something people are made to feel ashamed of(which im thankful for as i have an ASD son). Telling somebody you have autism isn't going to result in them making a snap decision that you're probably abusive.

Likewise bipolar, bipolar is a perfectly acceptable disorder to have (not for the sufferer, obviously, I'm sure it's horrid to live with) but for society. You'll likely be met with sympathy if you have bipolar, depression, panic attacks.

Society is even moving away from the stigmatisation of schizophrenia now which is brilliant.

But not borderline, borderlines = scumbags (in many peoples minds)

I totally agree with you on this. Have been reading on this subject as family members recently diagnosed with ASD throwing into question other family members myself included.

Autsim spectrum contains many neuro cognitive features shared by people with BPD & bipolar.

These are neurologically fixed differences in brain, & neural cognitive development.

They mean that certain behaviours, beliefs, ways of feeling & behaving are governed by these & cannot be changed, nor in fact should they be as the person is not able to change them.

Pple with ASD are taught (now, rightly) to not try to be NT, when their abilities & differences along the spectrum are valid & should be equally accepted & seen as valid in the remit of human behaviour.

There is much less stigma now & judgement therefore for ASD. Yet when there are so many similar shared elements neurologically such as executive function differences, theory of mind, emotional dysregulation & behavioural management difficulties in both BPD & autism, one condition remains far more stigmatised & judged negatively than the other.

Far more women have been & continue to be diagnosed with BPD when many may in fact be suffering with undiagnosed ASD.

Part of the gender inequality prevalent still in health & mental health sadly still evident today.

I am hoping that with the advancements in autism & awareness of how it can present & affect women, this will change the way mental health, “disorders”, and “pathological personality” labels may ultimately change.

Why no empathy for people struggling with often times very similar difficulties.

notmyusualusername2022 · 05/06/2022 18:12

Bonheurdupasse · 05/06/2022 16:31

The condition in isolation doesn't need to be stigmatised, however if the behaviours arising from it are harmful to other people they shouldn't have to shy away from calling the behaviours out.

This.

I'm a regular poster, but have namechanged for this.

My father had BPD. My DM endured years of domestic violence at his hands and he also abused me and my three siblings. One of my siblings died as a result of his abuse.

This was a long time ago (I'm now in my 40s) but at the time the view of professionals was that he was "mad not bad" and that this excused his behaviour. It didn't make things any easier for us, his victims.

I don't believe that everyone with BPD is like this, however the ones that are need to be called out for it and not excused because they "can't help it".

Awalkintime · 05/06/2022 18:08

No stigma from me I don't consider it a correct label.

namechange9765 · 05/06/2022 18:03

Not to invalidate what you're saying about BPD - I agree that it should not be stigmatised - but if you haven't already, I would highly recommend also researching dissociative disorders. I have recently been diagnosed with DDNOS (sort of a milder form of dissociative identity disorder). It's much more common than people used to realise, and it took me a very long time to realise due to stigma/ misinformation. DDNOS symptoms have a huge overlap with BPD - I can relate to a lot of the experiences you are describing. Now that I am getting the right treatment, and learning the right techniques from my own research, I am really healing, compared to frustratingly slow progress in the previous ten years. Worth looking into, just in case.

The CTAD clinic videos on youtube are a very reliable resource to start at.

SchoolThing · 05/06/2022 18:03

Nidan2Sandan · 05/06/2022 17:49

I deal with a lot of BPD people in my line of work, dealing with antisocial behaviour.

Sadly, they are usually the perpetrator and usually young women.

Recent examples would be a 22yo single Mum who decided the old man across the street gave her a dirty look. He denies he ever did, and certainly hes been housed by us since the 80s with no issues previously, but never say never. Anyway, the young lady has taken to making his life a living hell. Shouts abuse at him in the street, purposefully blocks his driveway with wheelie bins, throws dirty nappies on his lawn, has even called the police to make false allegations. Her excuse is that she has BPD and her mental health means she csnt control herself when she feels wronged.

The next example is an older woman, mid 40s. Making her neighbours life hell as she thinks they're showing off and I quote "making me look like a cheap fucking cunt" because they bought a new car and showed it to the other neighbours.

So, from my experience it's hard because BPD folk can seem to elaborate and escalate innocent incidents in their head and then try to justify their behaviour with the MH BPD excuse. My answer is always that having BPD is no excuse for being antisocial and bullying.

Dealing with antisocial behaviour would give you a rather narrow view of the world.

Plenty of people with BPD who don’t behave like the two in your post.

You could just as easily exchange the BPD with “depressed” or “autistic” or “adhd” and come up with a similarly absurd finding.

maddening · 05/06/2022 18:01

Based on experiences I guess, living/ working/ dealing with someone who is emotionally volatile is hard. And that is on top of dealing with "your own shit" which most people do have going on on some level or another.

PonderingBPD · 05/06/2022 18:01

CorneliusVetch · 05/06/2022 17:53

Thank you for sharing. This sounds incredibly difficult to live with. What is clear is that you have a very big degree of insight and commitment to manage your symptoms, which is fantastic and you should be very proud of that. I’m sorry that you have had such a difficult childhood and that you have to live with this very distressing condition as a result. I wish I had advice, but I don’t I’m afraid - I just want to wish you the best because you sound like you are very brave and very considerate of those you love.

Thank you so much 💓

OP posts:
TreacheryPepper · 05/06/2022 18:01

I have BPD. I was diagnosed sixteen years ago. I'm high-functioning these days bit I was very ill for a decade. To be honest I don't think I've faced an descrimination as a result of my diagnosis. No more so than someone with any other form of mental illness, any way.

WhoWants2Know · 05/06/2022 18:00

I definitely can't agree that there's no stigma attached to Autism or Autistic Spectrum Disorders.

PonderingBPD · 05/06/2022 17:57

StridTheKiller · 05/06/2022 17:51

I have BPD. Unmedicated I am bad and have been truly awful, a total nightmare, especially Then years of self medicating with drink. Then finally diagnosed and medicated. I'm very happy, well and balanced now.

What medication are you on if you don't mind me asking?

OP posts:
dreamingbohemian · 05/06/2022 17:56

OP no one can diagnose you over the internet but reading through all the things you have listed, it doesn't strike me as that different from someone suffering from depression and PTSD. If you were abandoned as a child then of course you will have a fear of abandonment, this is a natural response to that trauma, I would think?

The black and white thinking for example -- this is very common when dealing with depression and trauma, I personally was like this until my MH improved, it was the improvement that allowed me to see the 'grey'

When I was unwell I thought that was just how I was, and in fact when I was initially referred for psychiatric treatment it was for investigation of BPD (this was in the US many years ago). Luckily I was referred to a great doctor who walked through all the traumas of my life and helped me see that I was reacting to those, and that there were ways to get better.

I don't want to project my experience on you but maybe it is worth exploring a bit more the possibility that you don't have BPD?

PonderingBPD · 05/06/2022 17:56

Nidan2Sandan · 05/06/2022 17:49

I deal with a lot of BPD people in my line of work, dealing with antisocial behaviour.

Sadly, they are usually the perpetrator and usually young women.

Recent examples would be a 22yo single Mum who decided the old man across the street gave her a dirty look. He denies he ever did, and certainly hes been housed by us since the 80s with no issues previously, but never say never. Anyway, the young lady has taken to making his life a living hell. Shouts abuse at him in the street, purposefully blocks his driveway with wheelie bins, throws dirty nappies on his lawn, has even called the police to make false allegations. Her excuse is that she has BPD and her mental health means she csnt control herself when she feels wronged.

The next example is an older woman, mid 40s. Making her neighbours life hell as she thinks they're showing off and I quote "making me look like a cheap fucking cunt" because they bought a new car and showed it to the other neighbours.

So, from my experience it's hard because BPD folk can seem to elaborate and escalate innocent incidents in their head and then try to justify their behaviour with the MH BPD excuse. My answer is always that having BPD is no excuse for being antisocial and bullying.

I would never, ever behave like that. My anger is always targeted inwards.

I've never had an issue with neighbours and have had no dealings with the police in my adult life (admittedly I was a little shit when I was a child, shoplifting, but that came from poverty more than any premeditated intention to do something bad)

I'm more likely to be picked on, than pick on somebody.

OP posts:
CorneliusVetch · 05/06/2022 17:53

PonderingBPD · 05/06/2022 17:29

Sure, I don't mind.

So I don't handle stress well and get upset / angry easily. I have alot of self loathing and don't feel good enough for anybody, or anything really. Things that most people can just brush off tend to really hurt me, such as a stranger being rude in a supermarket for example - most people will just roll their eyes but for me I have quite a deep emotional response to it and can be reduced to tears.

When I have an episode I tend to retreat into myself, shut myself away, rather than screaming and shouting at people. The anger is always directed inwards.

I have a huge fear of abandonment which stems from (quite literally) being abandoned as a child, that manifests itself as me putting up with things other people wouldn't dream of, such is the fear of being alone. I stayed in a violent relationship (not DH) for 6 years because the fear of being alone was worse than the physical beatings.

I'm prone to depressive episodes and suicidal ideation, although I don't openly speak about the latter because I'm aware people would see it as being manipulative.

I have strong impulses to self harm which I manage with techniques I learned from my DBT workbook.

Black and white thinking and splitting - somebody is either all good or all bad. If somebody does something to upset me then I can only see them through that lense for a period of time. I lack the ability to look at the bigger picture. There's no grey area which is frustrating as hell because we all know life isn't black and white.

Similarly if somebody has done something bad to me, but later on they're kind or do something good, the bad is all forgotten and they're a great person (even if the bad is something that has caused me significant harm) there's no grey area.

I'm a huge people pleaser and tie myself in knots trying to make people like me as I feel as though I need external validation. I have cripplingly low self esteem.

My husband would tell you that the hardest part of living with me is never knowing what mood I'm going to be in from one day to the next, which I acknowledge must be trstinf so I do my best to mitigate any effect this has on him (and my DC) by removing myself from the situation if I feel angry or overwhelmed.

Thank you for sharing. This sounds incredibly difficult to live with. What is clear is that you have a very big degree of insight and commitment to manage your symptoms, which is fantastic and you should be very proud of that. I’m sorry that you have had such a difficult childhood and that you have to live with this very distressing condition as a result. I wish I had advice, but I don’t I’m afraid - I just want to wish you the best because you sound like you are very brave and very considerate of those you love.

StridTheKiller · 05/06/2022 17:51

I have BPD. Unmedicated I am bad and have been truly awful, a total nightmare, especially Then years of self medicating with drink. Then finally diagnosed and medicated. I'm very happy, well and balanced now.

Nidan2Sandan · 05/06/2022 17:49

I deal with a lot of BPD people in my line of work, dealing with antisocial behaviour.

Sadly, they are usually the perpetrator and usually young women.

Recent examples would be a 22yo single Mum who decided the old man across the street gave her a dirty look. He denies he ever did, and certainly hes been housed by us since the 80s with no issues previously, but never say never. Anyway, the young lady has taken to making his life a living hell. Shouts abuse at him in the street, purposefully blocks his driveway with wheelie bins, throws dirty nappies on his lawn, has even called the police to make false allegations. Her excuse is that she has BPD and her mental health means she csnt control herself when she feels wronged.

The next example is an older woman, mid 40s. Making her neighbours life hell as she thinks they're showing off and I quote "making me look like a cheap fucking cunt" because they bought a new car and showed it to the other neighbours.

So, from my experience it's hard because BPD folk can seem to elaborate and escalate innocent incidents in their head and then try to justify their behaviour with the MH BPD excuse. My answer is always that having BPD is no excuse for being antisocial and bullying.

PonderingBPD · 05/06/2022 17:49

picklemewalnuts · 05/06/2022 17:45

I'm going to leap in with both feet and risk being disablist and prejudiced against people with autism now...

I suspect the reason you find your own mental health hard to manage may be because you are married to a man with autism.

How are your relationships outside the home? Some people with autism find it hard to be a supportive partner because their own diagnosis means that may not come naturally- and may not be easily learned.

You may need a level of support he isn't able to offer, and you will perceive that as rejection. That's very hard.

I have no issues with friendships, I've had the same couple of friends for around 15 years. There isn't the ups and downs with them, that there is with DH, or my mother.

It's the close interpersonal relationships I struggle with, but then I'm quite an isolated person in general so don't have a wide sphere to reference from.

It can certainly be difficult having a relationship with DH as he doesn't have much affective empathy, whereas I feel everything ten fold.

OP posts:
PonderingBPD · 05/06/2022 17:45

Andromachehadabadday · 05/06/2022 17:36

Ok so my mum had bpd and my son has autism.

I think you are wrong that’s there’s no stigma attached to autistic behaviours. In fact I think autism is usually the excuse given for lots of poor behaviour, even when it’s not autism. Lots of ‘self diagnosed’ abusive people around. I know it’s hard to get an adult diagnosis but lots of people don’t even try and just keep hurting the people around them and expect it to accepted. And lots of people oblige and agree with them.

I do agree there is some stigma attached to BPD. My mum had the childhood trauma (her brother died from SIDS at 3 months) along with an emotionally abusive father.

My mum died last year, really out of the blue. I can’t even talk to a counsellor properly about her because it would make her sound awful. And she wasn’t she was sick and in the 80s there was no support. My mum loved me and my sibling so much. I loved her and feel like my life is over. But my childhood held a lot of abuse. Mum was sectioned once. At a facility so poor she escaped. Her and my dad split up she moved us around and he couldn’t find us. When he did, they got back together because dad felt we (the kids) needed the support.

But he couldn’t do it all. Things still impacted us. Like the time I had a friend over after school and got home to mum having pulled the entire contents of my wardrobe out and dumping it in my bed because it wasn’t in the order she wanted. Then told me I couldn’t do anything until I cleared it up so she sat downstairs grilling my friend because she needed to know everything I did and who I spoke to. Dad was at work.

Alot of the things she did were for attention, like I couldn’t go out without her causing drama and me having to come home. The first time she met my first proper boyfriend she stood and screamed that he was obviously far too old for me. He was 4 months older than me. There was melt downs and self harming when I wouldn’t just roll over and accept her behaviour as I got older. I was a good teen. Good grades. Never in trouble. Because I knew not to cause anymore but at 15-17 I didn’t know how to handle her, but when I stood up for myself she would lose it and threaten to Kill herself and say how much I must hate her, until I broke down and accepted whatever she wanted.

I decided not to go to uni, as she wouldn’t let me live away. I started working full time, saved up bought a house at 19 and left. I now know that that caused lots of problems and dad shielded me from how bad it was. As did my older brother, who moved out soon after.

Around the time I got pregnant she did finally accept the diagnosis and get counselling and took her meds. She was so much better and the best Nana I could ask for, for my children. But my childhood was traumatic. I haven’t even mentioned 1% here.

as a result I entered an abusive marriage at 20, that I finally got out of in my 30s. I didn’t even realise how bad it was until I was over 30. I detach very easily. I can compartmentalise to a point where I don’t deal with things. Stress builds up and it’s made me sick. I am independent to an extreme. To a point, I don’t have complete adult relationships. I live my Dp, but I refuse to be dependent financially or emotionally on him. I don’t believe, he really loves me. I don’t let him see my vulnerable. Friends don’t know me as well as they think. They don’t know about my childhood, or how I am not coping with mums death. I pushed them all away. My kids are the centre of everything and I have lived my life making sure they don’t live how I did. Dd is 18 and I think I have done a good job, though obviously make my own mistakes. I am determined they never feel beholden to me but completely supported by me. That they feel the priority.

So while I wouldn’t outwardly stigmatise BPD, I would never be involved with someone who had it. I would leave someone diagnosed with it.

I have been diagnosed with ptsd, due to my childhood and struggle every day. Especially now she had died.

I adored my mum. We had a much better relationship in the last half of my life. But that doesn’t erase what I went through.

My own opinion is that regardless of why someone acts how they do, regardless of the diagnosis if you are abusing someone, they should leave. Even if it’s temporary while the other person gets it’s under control. I see why people stay when the other person is working really hard. But my advice would be to leave, at least until they can show they can manage their behaviour and stop the abuse.

Yes, my mum was a victim of her dad. A victim of her mums breakdown when her brother died. But then I ended up being a victim of it too. I have the right to not want to a victim of others peoples trauma anymore.

I also don’t believe bpd is stigmatised anymore that other conditions.

Thank you for sharing this, and I'm really sorry that you had such a difficult childhood.

I don't blame you for feeling the way you do, after everything you saw and went through. Its only natural you would want to avoid anybody associated to the condition which had such an impact on your life.

I don't want to silence people speaking from a place of personal experience. BPD or not, nobody should be abused and the diagnosis isn't an excuse.

OP posts:
picklemewalnuts · 05/06/2022 17:45

I'm going to leap in with both feet and risk being disablist and prejudiced against people with autism now...

I suspect the reason you find your own mental health hard to manage may be because you are married to a man with autism.

How are your relationships outside the home? Some people with autism find it hard to be a supportive partner because their own diagnosis means that may not come naturally- and may not be easily learned.

You may need a level of support he isn't able to offer, and you will perceive that as rejection. That's very hard.

SchoolThing · 05/06/2022 17:44

@Andromachehadabadday

What a terrible time you have had.

I hope that one day you can trust your therapist enough to talk through some of this. 🌸

cornflakedreams · 05/06/2022 17:38

It is not coincidental that the BPD label is disproportionately applied to female victims of trauma.

The number of developed countries that even accept it as a valid diagnosis is small. The evidence base used to justify it in the UK and US is shocking, and rejected by professionals in those countries too.

It is our century's "hysteria" .

PonderingBPD · 05/06/2022 17:37

User3568975431146 · 05/06/2022 17:35

I would strongly dispute that behavioural characteristics of borderline personality disorder and anything at all like cptsd!

They are very, very similar.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread