Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking DH if we can take out mortgage at 55

166 replies

EnglishDutch · 05/06/2022 14:39

I want to move to be near to my recently bereaved 85 yo dad (I live an hour away from him). Lovely dream house has come up for sale over the road from him. Ideal in many respects. But it's a big stretch for us as it's offers over 450k (likely to go for 500k +). Our current house (no mortgage) is worth minimum 180k and we have 190k in savings. So would most likely need to take out a mortgage. We are both 55. Likely to inherit about 250k in next few years (my dad says).
OH flatly refuses to take out a mortgage. AIBU to ask him?
My dad said yesterday he would give me my inheritance early but then changed his mind as it would be unfair to my 2 brothers (I agree).

OP posts:
MigsandTiggs · 05/06/2022 16:54

Everyone is concentrating on your combined salaries, but it's disposable income that you ought to be looking at. You will be able to get a 12 year mortgage but rates are rising at the same time that a housing crash is predicted. You will be wiping out your savings but moiving is expensive and the new house might require repairs etc. How will you cover emergency expenses without savings? When all your equity is tied up in a house, are you prepared to dip into your pension funds if necessary? I suggest you create an outgoings spreadsheet and see an independent financial adviser before proceeding. If the answer is positive, your husband might then come on board. Personally, I wouldn't do it as it's too risky having all your eggs in one basket at 55.

Zilla1 · 05/06/2022 16:53

HNRTT but if the sums work then could the sums work if your DF has liquid assets but is squeamish about a gift to loan you the £80k to £130k formally secured against the house so it doesn't disadvantage your DBs but you still move to his benefit?

dustandroses · 05/06/2022 16:51

Clearly you are grieving and it may take a while before you come to a decision. A few things come to mind.

How long do you envisage visiting twice a week, is it just while he settles?
Does your dad actually want you living that close long term?
Do you want to become your dads carer by default, how would this affect yours and DH's future plans as he becomes more dependant?
Is it the house you've seen or being close to your dad that's driving the move?

Finally if you are going to take on this role then I don't see how it can be unfair to receive your inheritance early to enable you to do it. You are not on an equal footing with your brothers if you are providing support and care and changing your lifestyle to support your dad and they are not.

The offer could also be made to your brothers do they want early inheritance to enable them to move closer to dad and provide care and support?

Alltheleavesaregreen1 · 05/06/2022 16:50

Don't do it! You are now hitting the age where health problems may start to occur and the idea of taking out a mortgage is really daft.

is everyone here 50+ and living in a low cost housing area where they became mortgage free at 40 or something? Because in my world, 50 somethings work full time and most won’t retire til close to 70. I work with lots of people of all ages and it’s really not common for people in their 50s to give up work due to ill health.

JulesJules · 05/06/2022 16:46

I'm surprised that most posters are advising aginst tbh. I would do it - nicer house, very close to your Dad, saving on your trips to see him, much easier commute for your DH. You can easily afford the repayments without having to rely on possible future inheritance. Enormous (from my perspective) work bonus can pay off big chunk of mortgage or replenish savings.

Curlygirl06 · 05/06/2022 16:46

EnglishDutch · 05/06/2022 16:38

Hi
Some sensible, compassionate and understanding posts on here! Thank you all. It is difficult when you're dealing with loss, and maybe (as lots have pointed out) not the time to make big life-changing decisions.

🌺

When my mum died my dad sold their house and moved within 9 months. He's often said he wished he hadn't done it, so perhaps leave it for at least a year before you decide?

Alltheleavesaregreen1 · 05/06/2022 16:44

That is the age when many people are looking to be done with mortgages, not to take another one on.

ha! Most banks are lending with terme ending up to age 70 with few questions asked. The majority of people who are under 40 now will not be mortgage free by 55 and many won’t even be able to buy in the first place. If it gets too much, they could sell but I can’t see how a loan that’s less than their combined annual salaries (by contrast, mine is 4.5 x salary) is a crazy idea that someone would have to be nuts to consider.

ElenaSt · 05/06/2022 16:40

Don't do it! You are now hitting the age where health problems may start to occur and the idea of taking out a mortgage is really daft.

Alltheleavesaregreen1 · 05/06/2022 16:40

Am I missing something? This wouldn’t be a big mortgage, it could be cleared in 10 years and most people I know have terms that take them right up to retirement age before they are repaid (me included). They are both working so I’m going to hazard a guess that they will make the repayments from salary? This is a weird thread.

SpidersAreShitheads · 05/06/2022 16:40

OP, my mum and my stepdad and me, DP and DC are about to sell both homes and purchase a bigger property where we’re going to be building an annexe. It’s a huge and scary undertaking but something that we all want.

for various reasons, my mum will have to take out a small £60k mortgage. She’s over 70 yrs old and currently mortgage free. I can’t take the mortgage out in my name as it’s a two-step move with her property being sold first. I’ll be paying the mortgage but the debt is in my mum’s name (if she had to, she could comfortably afford the repayments herself but that’s not the plan).

It was my mum’s idea to get a mortgage in her name. It means she’ll have us close to her which is what she very much wants. And I have two disabled DC so it will be helpful for me too.

I don’t think you’re bonkers to consider it. It sounds like your overall quality of life would improve in many ways and property values always rise in the long term so it’s a good investment for your future. I would do it, if I were in your shoes.

EnglishDutch · 05/06/2022 16:38

Hi
Some sensible, compassionate and understanding posts on here! Thank you all. It is difficult when you're dealing with loss, and maybe (as lots have pointed out) not the time to make big life-changing decisions.

🌺

OP posts:
ChateauxNeufDePoop · 05/06/2022 16:38

Topseyt123 · 05/06/2022 16:29

I'm very sorry to hear that you have lost your mum so recently. Losing a parent is very hard. It forces you to realise that life is short and to face your own and your Dad's mortality.

However, I think this is clouding your better judgement here, so I am on team DH. I'm afraid I would not agree to another mortgage at age 55. You've managed to become mortgage free, which presumably is now making life much more comfortable financially, even though your salaries are good. You need to stay that way and build up your savings and pensions much further.

I understand why you feel the need to move. We lost my Dad just over a year ago and the result is that my now widowed elderly mother lives alone, a three hour drive away from us. She also has her own health issues.

Moving house has to make financial sense too. What you are proposing doesn't. It sounds as though you could afford to buy a different house outright near to your Dad. Surely that would make more sense financially if you feel you really must move.

Sorry, but I do feel that your DH is right to put the brakes on this. Mortgage free status adds to your financial security and isn't something to be given up lightly, especially at 55. That is the age when many people are looking to be done with mortgages, not to take another one on. He is probably also happy as he is, even though he has indicated that he may consider a move if no mortgage was involved. Again, that seems sensible to me.

Look for a cheaper house that will need no mortgage. If that doesn't work out then maybe take on a short term rental near to your Dad so that you can take your time to get a feel for how things look likely to go. Don't just plunge straight into an expensive house purchase. It could end up being an expensive mistake.

This, sorry OP but your DH is right and whats even more worrying is your main engagement with pro-posters. It's a really dumb idea.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 05/06/2022 16:38

Agree with all the PPs saying not to rely on the inheritance to repay the mortgage. But much of the rest of the advice is barking. You're not 'losing' your equity in your current property, as some have said - you're investing it in a new property. Yes, that comes with risk, because you will be heavily invested in property, but you might have 40 or more years of life ahead of you, including a decade or more of working. You don't have to give up on your dreams at 55, FFS.

SausagePourHomme · 05/06/2022 16:37

Stuffin · 05/06/2022 16:35

Taking on mortgage would mean they would need to keep working.

A lot of people mortgage free at that age are thinking about early retirement or going part time etc.

It's something both of them need to be on board with as it will mean taking on a big debt.

not everyone wants to stop working at 55. I definitely don't.

if it's between being retired living in the wrong house in the wrong place VS working and having a nice lifestyle or close to loved ones, I know what I'd chose

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 05/06/2022 16:35

Mummadeze · 05/06/2022 16:30

I would do it as you are both still working and will end up with a much more valuable property. I don’t see the issue.

Speculation.

Stuffin · 05/06/2022 16:35

SausagePourHomme · 05/06/2022 16:29

to read this thread you'd think people have one foot in the coffin at 55..you could be working another 20 years. I don't think it's beyond the realms of possibility to buy a bigger property.

Taking on mortgage would mean they would need to keep working.

A lot of people mortgage free at that age are thinking about early retirement or going part time etc.

It's something both of them need to be on board with as it will mean taking on a big debt.

Mally100 · 05/06/2022 16:34

Madness to put 190k into a debt.

IVbumble · 05/06/2022 16:31

Go for it OP & if your Dad does want to help you out it's ok to accept that help particularly if you end up providing the care that your father needs.

Not sure why everyone seems to think your Dad has not got long to go - he could have another 15 yrs. Your mortgage might be paid off by then.

Mummadeze · 05/06/2022 16:30

I would do it as you are both still working and will end up with a much more valuable property. I don’t see the issue.

EnglishDutch · 05/06/2022 16:30

badhappening · 05/06/2022 16:20

It's very doable on your combined salaries.

Your DH not having to commute 3 days a week and you saving on huge fuel bills and travelling time would be a huge bonus.

The 2 questions I would have are:

How secure are your jobs?
How certain are you that your DF will leave you £250k?

Your DF could get dementia and leave it to the donkeys sanctuary.
Another factor is that wills can and are changed all the time, particularly when families are in each other's pockets and there are big fall-outs.

badhappening - Jobs are fairly secure. They depend on us, how hard we work but we've done them for 20 odd years so can't see anything awful happening. Unexpected events like covid did not affect our jobs either.
Re my dad leaving me 250k, he and my mother (recently deceased) worked out their will in a lot of detail including funding for care homes. Their estate is currently being valued as part of the probate process and is over £1m apparently. This is to be shared between me and 2 brothers.

OP posts:
SausagePourHomme · 05/06/2022 16:29

to read this thread you'd think people have one foot in the coffin at 55..you could be working another 20 years. I don't think it's beyond the realms of possibility to buy a bigger property.

Topseyt123 · 05/06/2022 16:29

I'm very sorry to hear that you have lost your mum so recently. Losing a parent is very hard. It forces you to realise that life is short and to face your own and your Dad's mortality.

However, I think this is clouding your better judgement here, so I am on team DH. I'm afraid I would not agree to another mortgage at age 55. You've managed to become mortgage free, which presumably is now making life much more comfortable financially, even though your salaries are good. You need to stay that way and build up your savings and pensions much further.

I understand why you feel the need to move. We lost my Dad just over a year ago and the result is that my now widowed elderly mother lives alone, a three hour drive away from us. She also has her own health issues.

Moving house has to make financial sense too. What you are proposing doesn't. It sounds as though you could afford to buy a different house outright near to your Dad. Surely that would make more sense financially if you feel you really must move.

Sorry, but I do feel that your DH is right to put the brakes on this. Mortgage free status adds to your financial security and isn't something to be given up lightly, especially at 55. That is the age when many people are looking to be done with mortgages, not to take another one on. He is probably also happy as he is, even though he has indicated that he may consider a move if no mortgage was involved. Again, that seems sensible to me.

Look for a cheaper house that will need no mortgage. If that doesn't work out then maybe take on a short term rental near to your Dad so that you can take your time to get a feel for how things look likely to go. Don't just plunge straight into an expensive house purchase. It could end up being an expensive mistake.

Soontobe60 · 05/06/2022 16:28

Have you actually done a mortgage calculation? Dont forget you’d need £15K stamp duty before you even factor in other moving costs.
A 10 year mortgage will cost you IRO £1500 pm. Plus you’d have no savings left.
Your DF would be very unwise to give you any substantial money at his age. Should he require care, it could be seen as deprivation of assets.

cocktailclub · 05/06/2022 16:26

Could you take out an interest only mortgage for the additional funds. If you inherit, pay it off. If not plan to downsize in 10 years.

Maddison12 · 05/06/2022 16:25

She doesn't need to rely on a 'potential inheritance' as they would have a large deposit and jointly earn 120k. Can't see what people are finding so ludicrous about it myself.

OP only you know if you'd be able to get your DH on board with this. You say it's your dream house so got to be worth looking into further. You're not exactly a low earner and you only live once.