Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking DH if we can take out mortgage at 55

166 replies

EnglishDutch · 05/06/2022 14:39

I want to move to be near to my recently bereaved 85 yo dad (I live an hour away from him). Lovely dream house has come up for sale over the road from him. Ideal in many respects. But it's a big stretch for us as it's offers over 450k (likely to go for 500k +). Our current house (no mortgage) is worth minimum 180k and we have 190k in savings. So would most likely need to take out a mortgage. We are both 55. Likely to inherit about 250k in next few years (my dad says).
OH flatly refuses to take out a mortgage. AIBU to ask him?
My dad said yesterday he would give me my inheritance early but then changed his mind as it would be unfair to my 2 brothers (I agree).

OP posts:
Bednobsbroomsticks · 05/06/2022 17:42

I'd go for it but maybe find a cheaper house

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 05/06/2022 17:41

But the option here isn't "take on a mortgage and use all your savings" vs "nothing". They could move and buy a cheaper house if they wanted to - it's not all or nothing

They would not be using all their savings. They would be investing them in a property which - barring some unexpected national financial catastrophe (which would likely wipe out other forms of savings too) - will gain in value. When they eventually sell the new house, they can repay off any remaining mortgage. They are not reliant on an inheritance.

Property typically outperforms most other forms of savings. Equities (shares) are even better but also higher risk. Yes, in an ideal world, you would have a mixture of both, but putting it all in property is hardly reckless, looking at the performance of property over the last century. It's actually a bigger risk to leave it in savings that are unlikely to outperform inflation.

Yes, the OP could buy a smaller house. But she wants a larger one. And - contrary to many posts on here - there is nothing reckless or foolish about making this sort of investment at 55.

IJoinedJustForThisThread · 05/06/2022 17:36

You mentioned that you had previously bought a house abroad. Do you still own that house? Could you sell it and put the money towards a new house closer to your dad?

DrDinosaur · 05/06/2022 17:36

You are unreasonable asking this on mumsnet, as most people here seem to think everyone over 60 is physically and mentally enfeebled. It sounds as though you have plenty of income to repay a mortgage, even if you will need to get it over a shorter period.
Nobody can predict the future, but if inflation remains high, you may end up much better off by borrowing now, if the value of the property rises and the real value of cash savings falls.

Greatoutdoors · 05/06/2022 17:33

This seems really illogical to me. You’d be moving to be nearer your dad but you are relying on his inheritance to pay the mortgage off. When your dad is gone, will you still want the house and area?

PortalooSunset · 05/06/2022 17:32

You say your dad doesn't have a big social network - would moving him nearer to you help or is he not wanting to leave the family home?
Could you live with him for a bit so dh gets used to the area?

MMMarmite · 05/06/2022 17:31

Plus if things went wrong you could always sell the house again, you won't end up with no equity at all.

MMMarmite · 05/06/2022 17:31

I think you should move, it sounds like it would improve your quality of life, and your salary means you could pay off the mortgage pretty quickly, particularly if you made an effort to cut your expenses for a while.

What is your partner's specific objection?

Another option is to ask for a loan off of your dad, and pay that back over the next few years. Would that worry your partner less? A loan rather than early inheritence might feel fairer with the other siblings.

Schoolchoicesucks · 05/06/2022 17:28

Beaucoup · 05/06/2022 15:47

You are suggesting -

  1. at the age of 55
  2. to wipe out your life’s savings
  3. And also wipe out your entire equity
  4. to take on a mortgage
  5. which relies on potential inheritance which is barely a guarantee given old age and sickness on the part of the parent?
if my spouse suggested this with any degree of seriousness we would need to be parting ways.

Of course it's not wiping out their equity, it's transferring that equity into a different property.

They are not relying on an inheritance to pay off the mortgage- they earn £120k a year which they would use to pay it off.

The possible inheritance is a side thing that may bolster their finances when it comes, if it isn't used for care home fees.

OP, a £150k mortgage on your salaries is affordable. Have you asked your husband specifically about this now, with a view to offering on this particular property? If there was a different property for sale that wouldn't require a mortgage would he be up for the move? How is the £180k of savings invested and would it be possible/sensible to use that as deposit or is it tied up? (And if it is in cash and you're not planning to use it for buying a property, do consider how much you are losing in inflation and consider investing some of it elsewhere - in pensions if you're not maxxing those out).

I agree that the frequent visits will take their toll on you - a move closer to your dad (or him to you) seem sensible. And closer to your dh's work would also seem sensible. But perhaps this isn't the right property and perhaps you do want to let some time pass since your bereavement before making any major decisions.

Will your dad visit and stay with you for a week or two at a time? If you mainly wfh can you visit and stay with him to reduce the travel but maximise spending time together?

coffeecupsandfairylights · 05/06/2022 17:27

OP is 55, not 95. I feel sad for everyone in their 50s who decides they are too old to follow their dreams because of a fear of ill-health.

But the option here isn't "take on a mortgage and use all your savings" vs "nothing". They could move and buy a cheaper house if they wanted to - it's not all or nothing.

A 55 year old woman in the UK has a life expectancy of 31 years. Some older people experience ill-health, but many are healthy and active into their 70s and 80s. Three-quarters of 80 year olds still live independently.

There's a big difference between being fit and well enough to travel and do sports/hobbies, and being able to commit to a full-time working week. On the same level, living independently just means you still live in your own home - most eighty year olds will be receiving some form of care, either paid or from family members.

The OP and her DH need life assurance and critical illness cover, just like anyone else with a mortgage. They do not need to start preparing themselves for the grave

It's not "preparing yourself for the grave" to decide that you don't want the commitment of a mortgage well into your sixties 🙄

ThreeonaHill · 05/06/2022 17:22

Pinkdelight3 · 05/06/2022 17:19

OP is 55, not 95. I feel sad for everyone in their 50s who decides they are too old to follow their dreams because of a fear of ill-health.

I think the 'dream house' element is misleading. This isn't really about following dreams. This is about moving opposite an 85yo dad. If living there was their dream, on those salaries and as it's closer to work etc, they could have moved there at any point in the last two decades if it really was their dream. And the ill-health element is in people's minds because the DM has passed and the DF may well decline in health, and these things are at the crux of the move. She's not talking about going travelling or making a longed for career move or somesuch dream which I'm sure people would be more supportive about. This is a sudden reaction to a sad situation and people, including her DH, are rightly urging caution.

I feel sad for people who think having everything they own tied up in a house bigger than they need is a dream 😆

It's not that 55 is too old to follow your dreams, it's that if you saddle yourself with a large mortgage and spend all your savings at this stage in your life, you options for "dreams" are significantly reduced.

I doubt whether OP's DH sees this house a s a dream anyway.

Kennykenkencat · 05/06/2022 17:21

if you don’t use every bit of your savings, (keep around 6 months in savings or have at least a buffer)
What would you need to borrow and what would the yearly mortgage payments be like if interest rates rose eg 2%

Then compare how much commute costs and fuel costs you and Dh would save over a year.

Whilst initially the immediate answer is don’t do it. When you look at it as purely a financial transaction it might be worth your while or at least not going to cost that much different than you are spending atm

The extra money for the 3 return train tickets each week to go into London

You doing 120 mile round trips twice per week, even if your car does 40 mpg that is an extra 6 gallons of fuel per week
Add the depreciation and extra repair costs of putting an extra 12000miles per year on your car could be an extra £100-200 per month.
If I were to guess I think you are spending in drinks and drabs and deprecating value of your car about £550-650 per month.

Whilst your Dh wants to save money, living where you do could be looked at as an expensive option.

On a personal level though is your life where you live happy. Have you good friends and a sense of belonging.
I ask because I do think that after a traumatic event I can see the need to want to comfort your father and want him to be ok and for you to be around family and to grieve. But the idea of selling up and moving I think comes from maybe a dissatisfaction with where you currently live

Pinkdelight3 · 05/06/2022 17:19

OP is 55, not 95. I feel sad for everyone in their 50s who decides they are too old to follow their dreams because of a fear of ill-health.

I think the 'dream house' element is misleading. This isn't really about following dreams. This is about moving opposite an 85yo dad. If living there was their dream, on those salaries and as it's closer to work etc, they could have moved there at any point in the last two decades if it really was their dream. And the ill-health element is in people's minds because the DM has passed and the DF may well decline in health, and these things are at the crux of the move. She's not talking about going travelling or making a longed for career move or somesuch dream which I'm sure people would be more supportive about. This is a sudden reaction to a sad situation and people, including her DH, are rightly urging caution.

WilsonMilson · 05/06/2022 17:16

You’d be absolutely mad to saddle yourselves with a perhaps £200k mortgage at 55, leaving you with zero savings. Unless you’ve got a magnificent pension pot you haven’t mentioned, it would be batshit. Are you planning to work until you’re 80?

BattenburgDonkey · 05/06/2022 17:15

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow it’s not preparing for the grave, but if health problems do present then being able to take early retirement or go part time without panicking about mortgage repayments is a huge positive.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 05/06/2022 17:14

Villagewaspbyke · 05/06/2022 17:04

Yeah agreed! 55 is not old! And you can get mortgages up to 70 - in fact there’s no upper age limit in some cases.

But just because you can do something, doesn't mean you should.

I've read SO many threads on here from people in their sixties who are suddenly really struggling with full-time work, despite loving it just 4-5 years earlier. Lots of people are looking to cut down their working hours in their fifties and sixties - they're planning for retirement or at least semi-retirement, not for new homes and mortgage commitments.

So, I really don't blame the DH for not wanting to take on a brand new mortgage at 55. I would personally at least want the option to go part-time in my sixties, without the worry of a new mortgage hanging around my neck, especially if taking on that mortgage would also mean wiping out all my savings on top.

Pinkdelight3 · 05/06/2022 17:13

You say you're worried about him being lonely but also that he refuses to move. So he's not worried about being lonely and your siblings aren't worried about it either, nor is your DH. Again, it's the woman who goes through all the worry and all the upheaval, expense and stress you're proposing, when your DF himself doesn't even want to consider moving. Honestly, I'd take some time to get perspective, and don't even do all those motorways trips unless you really have the time and inclination. Maybe he needs to see how he copes for himself in order to realise it's him who needs to move. Or maybe he'll be absolutely fine and no one will need to move. Or six months to a year down the line, you might find an ideal house well within your budget that's much closer but not over the road.

In essence, there's no need to go off the deep end, going from a 180K mortgage free house to a 500k+ mortgaged house, from an hour away to over the road, and making yourself the sole solution to your dad's situation while causing new problems for yourself and DH. Right now, your issue is your grief. Sit with that, work through it, and let the rest fall into place when you're less emotionally-motivated.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 05/06/2022 17:10

ElenaSt · 05/06/2022 16:40

Don't do it! You are now hitting the age where health problems may start to occur and the idea of taking out a mortgage is really daft.

OP is 55, not 95. I feel sad for everyone in their 50s who decides they are too old to follow their dreams because of a fear of ill-health. A 55 year old woman in the UK has a life expectancy of 31 years. Some older people experience ill-health, but many are healthy and active into their 70s and 80s. Three-quarters of 80 year olds still live independently.

The OP and her DH need life assurance and critical illness cover, just like anyone else with a mortgage. They do not need to start preparing themselves for the grave.

Goodskin46 · 05/06/2022 17:09

My dad would love me to be nearer. My husband thinks that my dad could buy half the house (ie co-own it), then it would be included in the entire estate when he dies

This sounds sensible.

Goodskin46 · 05/06/2022 17:07

DirtyteaCup · 05/06/2022 16:01

A 12 year only mortgage is a killer. We are 55 and have just remortgaged with the maximum term allowed on 12 years (to 67). We have massive equity and very generous pension but 67 was a but off for anything except a very small mortgage

I'm very intersted to hear this, has it changed in recent years ? My BIL (actually they are not married) is 58 I think their mortage is until he is 70. Also SMIL ( she is 63- I think) has another 15 years.

EnglishDutch · 05/06/2022 17:06

dustandroses · 05/06/2022 16:51

Clearly you are grieving and it may take a while before you come to a decision. A few things come to mind.

How long do you envisage visiting twice a week, is it just while he settles?
Does your dad actually want you living that close long term?
Do you want to become your dads carer by default, how would this affect yours and DH's future plans as he becomes more dependant?
Is it the house you've seen or being close to your dad that's driving the move?

Finally if you are going to take on this role then I don't see how it can be unfair to receive your inheritance early to enable you to do it. You are not on an equal footing with your brothers if you are providing support and care and changing your lifestyle to support your dad and they are not.

The offer could also be made to your brothers do they want early inheritance to enable them to move closer to dad and provide care and support?

Hi dustandroses,
I envisage visits to my dad getting more, not less, frequent.

I don't particularly want to be a carer by default. But one of my brothers is unable to do it due to mental health issues, and the other has just taken a job in Norway. I am unable to switch off my caring mode; I helped care for my mum as she died and I now worry about my dad getting isolated. He does not have the wide social network that my mum had.
My dad would love me to be nearer. My husband thinks that my dad could buy half the house (ie co-own it), then it would be included in the entire estate when he dies. This would be do-able but my dad thinks it's messy. Also if we did this, I would prefer to have the discussion / offer that opportunity to my brothers so that things are transparent.

It's being closer, firstly, and the house, secondly. I have wanted to move that way for a long time to be closer to my parents. My husband has resisted for reasons too long and complicated to bore you with here!

OP posts:
Villagewaspbyke · 05/06/2022 17:04

Alltheleavesaregreen1 · 05/06/2022 16:40

Am I missing something? This wouldn’t be a big mortgage, it could be cleared in 10 years and most people I know have terms that take them right up to retirement age before they are repaid (me included). They are both working so I’m going to hazard a guess that they will make the repayments from salary? This is a weird thread.

Yeah agreed! 55 is not old! And you can get mortgages up to 70 - in fact there’s no upper age limit in some cases.

floppybit · 05/06/2022 17:01

I seem to be in the minority here but I think what you are proposing is completely reasonable and I would do it

Villagewaspbyke · 05/06/2022 17:01

I don’t think that unreasonable at all op. Sounds like a lovely property and any mortgage would be affordable. If you dh won’t go along with it though that’s his choice

Panjandrum123 · 05/06/2022 16:59

worraliberty · 05/06/2022 14:43

Perhaps I'm missing something but if he flatly refuses, what's the point in asking him?

Also, I wouldn't start mentally spending your inheritance now incase your dad needs care or private medical treatment.

This ☝️- we know mum intended to leave money to us and the grandchildren. She changed her mind once the doctor said she’d live into her nineties. Then she started on about spending it all (there’s a history with her, not least around money), obviously her choice to do so. Sadly she is now 90 and has dementia so it’s likely it will all be going on her care home fees.