Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking DH if we can take out mortgage at 55

166 replies

EnglishDutch · 05/06/2022 14:39

I want to move to be near to my recently bereaved 85 yo dad (I live an hour away from him). Lovely dream house has come up for sale over the road from him. Ideal in many respects. But it's a big stretch for us as it's offers over 450k (likely to go for 500k +). Our current house (no mortgage) is worth minimum 180k and we have 190k in savings. So would most likely need to take out a mortgage. We are both 55. Likely to inherit about 250k in next few years (my dad says).
OH flatly refuses to take out a mortgage. AIBU to ask him?
My dad said yesterday he would give me my inheritance early but then changed his mind as it would be unfair to my 2 brothers (I agree).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mellicauli · 05/06/2022 23:03

Your Dad should move near you, not the other way round.

Arrivederla · 05/06/2022 22:44

coffeecupsandfairylights · 05/06/2022 18:31

That sucks @Arrivederla :(

It was similar for my dad. He was absolutely fine until developed sight issues in his late fifties and found the idea of working for another decade with a degenerative condition quite scary. His sight is still okay but he can no longer drive at night (a necessity for his previous job) and he would struggle to work full-time now.

He's still fit/healthy enough to do things like travel and continue with his hobbies, but that's very different to having to stick with full-time work because of financial commitments.

Thank you for your kind comment, coffeecups - I appreciate it.
You just never know what is round the next corner. 😕

Pinkcadillac · 05/06/2022 20:50

I would do it too. It is affordable and you will be happier and have a better quality of life.
It will be a good investment too. What return are you getting on your current savings?

towelsa · 05/06/2022 20:35

I would do it if you prefer the house/area generally and can see yourself staying there long term (regardless of your dad). If so try and sell the positives to your partner.
It's definitely affordable for you and not that much of a risk based on your income.
We will have more than £150k to pay off at 55 with a lower annual salary. I wish we didn't but equally we live in an area we want to be in. If we really wanted to we could theoretically sell up and move. Our bigger house has gone up in value MUCH more than the smaller more affordable property we were in before so if we downsized now we'd be in a better position financially despite paying mortgage payments and stamp duty.

AnneElliott · 05/06/2022 19:48

Does it mean you or your DH can't retire as planned? That's the only reservation I'd have. You have large savings and a high income which means repayments aren't a problem and I assume you could downsize later if you wanted to release the equity?

Crazylazydayz · 05/06/2022 19:22

@EnglishDutch

I am sorry for your loss, it is always hard to lose a parent. As pp have advised you need to wait 12 months before making a big decision.

However, during the 12 months you can get your financial affairs in order. You and your DH can also have open conversations about your future.

  1. Keep a record of income and expenditure, how much you save each month.
  2. Research your pension options, how much income do you need in retirement. Are you both entitled to full state pension? When do you plan to retire, do you plan to phase retirement by reducing hours, if so when. Will you take lump sums or higher pension? How does taking your pension early impact on your monthly pension income.
  3. Work out how much your commuting costs, not just fares but time. Do the same for your trips to your Dad.
  4. Look at properties near your Dad I.e. no more than 15minute drive. Keep the price range realistic. Research the area etc.
  5. Work out savings on both commuting costs and time. The difference could pay a small mortgage.
  6. There is a reason you haven’t moved nearer to your Dad before. Particularly as you like the area. On the figures quoted you could have afforded to move some time ago. It would have shortened your husbands commute. What are those reasons? Why are they not as valid now? Where do you want to retire too?
  7. You need to be honest with your DH and this could be a crunch point in your relationship. From what you have said your DH isn’t going to move no matter how much you want to.
  8. Do not factor your potential inheritance into your calculations. Having your Dad around is worth more than any inheritance.
I’m sorry if some of the questions are challenging at this difficult time but you need to work through the options to reach the right decision.

Best of luck

BunsyGirl · 05/06/2022 18:49

So you put £120k of your savings towards the house, which leaves you with a mortgage of approx £1k per month over 20 years. You will still have a savings pot of £70k. If your joint income is £6k you can easily afford £1k payments and pay extra off as well.

dianthus101 · 05/06/2022 18:38

coffeecupsandfairylights · 05/06/2022 18:34

Sounds like a lot of hassle to me, lol.

It's clear this thread is pretty fairly divided, but at the end of the day, OP's DH is in the camp of not wanting a new mortgage in his 50's, so OP is going to have to come to terms with that and come to a compromise somewhere.

Maybe OP wouldn't mind the hassle.

dianthus101 · 05/06/2022 18:36

I'd want more than a "couple thousand" in the bank for emergencies in my mid-fifties.

Why? Are you in your fifties or just speculating?

thesugarbumfairy · 05/06/2022 18:35

On the face of it, I don't really see why its an issue or out of your budget, but I do understand why your DH would be reluctant to wipe out your savings. (although you need to take any inheritance out of the plan completely - that may or may not happen so there is no point considering it. ) You wouldn't need a massive mortgage going by what you've written, and on what you earn its easily payable before official retirement age. You're only 55. However, if your DH doesn't want to, then I think that its fair enough. I think you have to compromise if you really want to move to be nearer your dad, and find somewhere a bit less nice.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 05/06/2022 18:34

dianthus101 · 05/06/2022 18:28

I've read SO many threads on here from people in their sixties who are suddenly really struggling with full-time work, despite loving it just 4-5 years earlier. Lots of people are looking to cut down their working hours in their fifties and sixties - they're planning for retirement or at least semi-retirement, not for new homes and mortgage commitments.

They won't have to work forever just because they've taken out a larger mortgage for a bigger house. If they want to retire in five years time and do not have money from another source to pay off the mortgage (e.g. inheritance), they can just downsize. The house will probably have gone up in value and they won't lose money from doing that.

Sounds like a lot of hassle to me, lol.

It's clear this thread is pretty fairly divided, but at the end of the day, OP's DH is in the camp of not wanting a new mortgage in his 50's, so OP is going to have to come to terms with that and come to a compromise somewhere.

dianthus101 · 05/06/2022 18:33

Indigoo03 · 05/06/2022 18:29

Looking at the maths, it is reasonable, assume price 500k , mortgage at 320 ( putting old house proceeds in)....this is without dipping into savings. Guess it is DPs reason for no mortgage......

Why wouldn't they dip into the substantial savings?

coffeecupsandfairylights · 05/06/2022 18:32

dianthus101 · 05/06/2022 18:29

But the point is, if you put all your savings into your property, you can't access it in an emergency.

They can keep back a couple of thousand for emergencies.

I'd want more than a "couple thousand" in the bank for emergencies in my mid-fifties.

And before you say, yes, I know lots of people have no savings, but I would never get rid of all my cash savings by choice.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 05/06/2022 18:31

Arrivederla · 05/06/2022 18:22

A very good point. I am not too far off retirement and have always felt fairly comfortable with the prospect of working until I am 66. Unfortunately, I've recently developed totally unexpected health issues and am now struggling with the idea of continuing for another 4 years (fairly stressful job). 😕

That sucks @Arrivederla :(

It was similar for my dad. He was absolutely fine until developed sight issues in his late fifties and found the idea of working for another decade with a degenerative condition quite scary. His sight is still okay but he can no longer drive at night (a necessity for his previous job) and he would struggle to work full-time now.

He's still fit/healthy enough to do things like travel and continue with his hobbies, but that's very different to having to stick with full-time work because of financial commitments.

dianthus101 · 05/06/2022 18:29

But the point is, if you put all your savings into your property, you can't access it in an emergency.

They can keep back a couple of thousand for emergencies.

Indigoo03 · 05/06/2022 18:29

Looking at the maths, it is reasonable, assume price 500k , mortgage at 320 ( putting old house proceeds in)....this is without dipping into savings. Guess it is DPs reason for no mortgage......

dianthus101 · 05/06/2022 18:28

I've read SO many threads on here from people in their sixties who are suddenly really struggling with full-time work, despite loving it just 4-5 years earlier. Lots of people are looking to cut down their working hours in their fifties and sixties - they're planning for retirement or at least semi-retirement, not for new homes and mortgage commitments.

They won't have to work forever just because they've taken out a larger mortgage for a bigger house. If they want to retire in five years time and do not have money from another source to pay off the mortgage (e.g. inheritance), they can just downsize. The house will probably have gone up in value and they won't lose money from doing that.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 05/06/2022 18:28

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 05/06/2022 17:41

But the option here isn't "take on a mortgage and use all your savings" vs "nothing". They could move and buy a cheaper house if they wanted to - it's not all or nothing

They would not be using all their savings. They would be investing them in a property which - barring some unexpected national financial catastrophe (which would likely wipe out other forms of savings too) - will gain in value. When they eventually sell the new house, they can repay off any remaining mortgage. They are not reliant on an inheritance.

Property typically outperforms most other forms of savings. Equities (shares) are even better but also higher risk. Yes, in an ideal world, you would have a mixture of both, but putting it all in property is hardly reckless, looking at the performance of property over the last century. It's actually a bigger risk to leave it in savings that are unlikely to outperform inflation.

Yes, the OP could buy a smaller house. But she wants a larger one. And - contrary to many posts on here - there is nothing reckless or foolish about making this sort of investment at 55.

But the point is, if you put all your savings into your property, you can't access it in an emergency.

I would never put ALL my savings into property - I would always want a decent amount in easy to access bank accounts so that it was there to use immediately if I needed it.

OP might want a larger house, but her DH doesn't so she's going to have to compromise somewhere.

Arrivederla · 05/06/2022 18:22

coffeecupsandfairylights · 05/06/2022 15:46

I wouldn't put all my savings into property in my mid-fifties.

No, you're not old at 55, but you're still closer to retirement than not, and there are many threads from people on here who managed full-time work just fine in their fifties, then found themselves really struggling 5-7 years later and needing to drop to part-time or take early retirement.

That would be too big of a risk for me.

A very good point. I am not too far off retirement and have always felt fairly comfortable with the prospect of working until I am 66. Unfortunately, I've recently developed totally unexpected health issues and am now struggling with the idea of continuing for another 4 years (fairly stressful job). 😕

dianthus101 · 05/06/2022 18:21

I'm not sure why some posters think it's a daft idea. A mortgage will be perfectly affordable on your joint salary. It's worth discussing with your DH although if he doesn't want to take on the debt that's understandable too. You may need to think of a compromise.

CucumberSandw1chesCake · 05/06/2022 18:17

I am sorry for your loss

There is a saying, not to make any drastic changes for a year after a bereavement

Do you need to set up certain things for your DF ?
Examples
Power of attorney
Order delivery of regular medication from the pharmacy
Cleaner once a week
Gardener
A social activity
Online food shop
Can your sibling phone/email/Skype once a week

Driving to visit once a week is fine for a few months & see how it goes

Moving is a dramatic step & too soon ?

Volterra · 05/06/2022 18:09

I’m so sorry for your loss 💐I lost my Dad in January unexpectedly, 4 days after I told him we would be moving up this year having tried the previous couple of years.

We are going ahead as it is financially advantageous, we decided to move 2.5 years ago and and I really want to be close to my Stepmother and transport links for my DC. Also my DH will be able to retire quicker. There’s also a massive sense of wanting to go home.

It has been massively stressful and my physical health is suffering really badly. My advice is take some time to grieve, it’s very early days yet.

BunsyGirl · 05/06/2022 18:06

£150k mortgage doesn’t sound particularly large on your joint income. I should point out that my mortgage is £475k so it seems small to me! I I don’t think about the size of my mortgage. I look at the amount of equity we have. Approx £550-£600k in our case. You would have a sizeable sum of equity and could sell and buy something cheaper if necessary. We have paid £100k off our mortgage in the last five years (original mortgage was £575k). Our joint income is a bit more but we’ve had school fees on top. I you set your mind to it you could pay £150k off is less than ten years.

altiara · 05/06/2022 17:56

I think financially it’s doable and there’s the possibility to pay off a mortgage sooner with inheritance or with pension lump sum.

BUT…
1- imagine your dad is no longer living in the house opposite, would this still be an area/road you want to move to?
2- in maybe 5-10 years time, would you want to move again? Downsize?

I think you need to consider
-where you both want to live for the rest of your lives and
-if one of you had to give up work for health reasons (not necessarily you if your parents are living long lives) how you pay off the mortgage and again, where would you want to be living.

SwedishEdith · 05/06/2022 17:53

What are your husband's retirement plans and will this mean he has to keep working for longer? Does he actually want to live over the road from your dad? (And what does he do that gives annual bonuses of £40k?).

Swipe left for the next trending thread